Nobody downloaded yet

The three stages of a trial and the presentation of evidence - Essay Example

Comments (1) Cite this document
Summary
This research aims to present the background against which the three-stage trial process is set. It is this background that necessitates the presentation of evidence in a way that it is tested and thus assists the tribunal of fact as far as humanly and reasonably possible to arrive at an honest conclusion…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98% of users find it useful
The three stages of a trial and the presentation of evidence
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The three stages of a trial and the presentation of evidence"

Download file to see previous pages Before analyzing the three-stage process of the criminal trial it is necessary to present the background against which the three-stage trial process is set. It is this background that necessitates the presentation of evidence in a way that it is tested and thus assists the tribunal of fact as far as humanly and reasonably possible to arrive at an honest conclusion. The background foundations for the criminal trial also ensures that the defendant’s right to a fair trial is protected and that he or she has an opportunity to counter the evidence presented against him or her. The foundation for the three-stage trial process in the presentation of evidence is grounded in Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights. The right to a fair trial as enunciated in Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights provides the defendant with an inalienable right to confront the witnesses against him at the trial. This is also known as the right to not only confront one’s accusers but the right for one’s accusers to confront the accused person.6 In this regard, at the stage of the trial where the prosecution presents its case, evidence is presented substantiating the allegations against the accused through the direct examination of witnesses for the prosecution.7 At the close of the prosecution’s case, the defendant who has the inalienable right to remain silent may make a submission of no case to answer.8 The right to remain silent is not specifically mentioned in the European Convention on Human rights but has been interpreted by the courts to be a necessary part of the right to a fair trial as provided for in Article 6 of the Convention. In fact it was held in Murray v UK that: the right to remain silent under police questioning and the privilege against...
From the research it can be comprehended that the trial itself is concerned with the presentation of evidence relevant to the legal and factual issues before the court. The evidence is either presented or debated throughout the trial pursuant to the laws and rules regulating the presentation and admissibility of evidence. Quite often evidence is relevant but inadmissible and unfortunately, in balancing the scales of justice for both victims and defendants and protecting the accused right to a fair trial, the best evidence may not be presented in the courts. However, it is this balancing exercise that requires that as far as possible, the best evidence is presented and at the end of the day, regardless of the outcome, it is supported by the evidence that was legally and fully presented in the course of the trial. If both sides merely traded evidence that was not subject to cross-examination the tribunal of fact would only be getting one side of the story and thus an incomplete version of events. Therefore, examination-in-chief, cross-examination and re-examination facilitate that telling of a complete version so that a tribunal of fact is in possession of the best available and admissible evidence. The strength of the evidence will be tested and scrutinized during cross-examination. The authenticity of the scrutiny and tests during cross-examination will be tested during re-examination. ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The three stages of a trial and the presentation of evidence Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1393472-law-of-evidence
(The Three Stages of a Trial and the Presentation of Evidence Essay)
https://studentshare.org/law/1393472-law-of-evidence.
“The Three Stages of a Trial and the Presentation of Evidence Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1393472-law-of-evidence.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (1)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
nh
nhahn added comment 5 months ago
Student rated this paper as
I never thought 3750 words essay could be written in such a free manner. I loved the style of this essay. Will definitely use it for my own work!

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The three stages of a trial and the presentation of evidence

Stages of criminal trial

...? Sentencing Stage in Criminal Trial Once discovery has been done where the prosecuting and defense attorneys have gone over documents, they come back to the court room where the judge ask if they have any extra information they want to bring to light. If not the judge sends the jury to mitigate a guilty or non guilty verdict. A case was chosen from Los Angeles of a drunken driver. According to Fisher (2011), the driver had killed an elderly man. In the case chosen, he had no jury as he pleaded "no contest to one count of vehicular manslaughter", which means he admitted that he killed the man without the intention of doing so. The choice of this paper is in the case of a admitting a guilty verdict and the...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Oral presentation/principle of evidence

... s Presentation This is an application on behalf of Elizabeth and Fiona, defendants in the proceedings. The application is for the exclusion of the following evidence: 1) Confession statements of Elizabeth and Fiona (“Exhibits 1 and 2”); 2) Exclusion of the Elizabeth’s statements in relation to Fiona’s culpability for the offence; and 3) Exclusion of evidence of the defendants’ previous convictions (“Exhibits 3 and 4”). Elizabeth and Fiona stand accused of burglary and I shall address the exclusion of evidence in relation to each defendant respectively. 2. Submissions on behalf of Elizabeth. Elizabeth makes her application on various grounds, which are helpfully outlined in the skeleton argument filed on her behalf. Firstly... , the...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Clinical evidence and presentation

...Clinical Evidence: Psoriasis Management Daivonex To many psoriasis sufferers, the disease is a very inconvenient disease to live with. And even if it is a non-contagious disease, it still causes patients embarrassment and job stress because of the appearance of their skin. It currently affects about 2-3 percent of the world population affecting all races, both sexes and all age groups, from babies to the elderly population (National Psoriasis Foundation, 2008). Its cause has yet to be fully established, and many scientists credit both genetics and the environment as possible contributors to this disease. Psoriasis is a long-term condition, often re-surfacing after years of remission. It is often treated depending on...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Stages of a Criminal Trial

...will be admissible during the trial ("Criminal law stages," 2011). During the O.J. Simpson pre-trial hearings, in addition to issues of admissibility, the trial was moved from Santa Monica to Downtown Los Angeles. Following these stages, the criminal proceedings move to the main trial stage. This stage is the heart of the criminal case and involves the prosecution calling witnesses and then allowing the defense to cross-examine them. The defense then is ability to present their case. The trial is bookended by opening and closing statements. Following the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

The stages of a criminal trial

...The Sentencing Stage of a Criminal Trial Stages of a Criminal Trial: Sentencing A person who is found guilty or pleads guilty in a court of law faces sentencing. A judge determines the appropriate punishment from the guilty depending on the intensity or nature of the crime. Maximum sentences are usually states in the statutes which illegalize a criminal act. The sentencing stage comes after the trial stage and is before the appeal stage (Larry, 2010). If a defendant is guilty of a felony and is facing substantial prison time, the judge in the case waits until he / she hears from the defense and the...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Stages of a criminal trial

...the first step of determining whether the trial should happen before a jury or a judge. The attorneys involved in the persecution gives details of the issues that surround the case to the court. He will further explain the point in which the prosecution plans to prove. The defense further gives their opening statements. In this case, the team will be trying to prove that the defendant is innocent. The opening of statement stage is only valid if other steps of the trial are successful (Felman, 2002). These stages include presentation of evidence to the court. There then follows cross examination of this evidence and...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Three stages of Emerging Markets in a financial crisis

...Stages of Financial Crisis Insert Introduction The Economies in an early stage of economic development recently opened up to the flow of services, goods and capital from the rest of the world. This would resemble countries like the United States which are considered advanced, but with some important differences. There are three stages of emerging markets in a financial crisis that this paper analyses. The first stage: Initiation of financial crisis Unlike in advanced countries economies where crises are triggered by a number of factors, financial crisis develops along two reasons in emerging markets: it can either be mismanagement of financial liberalization and globalization or severe fiscal imbalances. Mismanagement of financial... ...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Computer Forensics: Computers as Trial Evidence

...Due to the growth in electronic technology, there is an evolution of e-evidence that prosecutors and law enforcement officers use to accuse a person before a judicial authority. Electronic communications have made an impact on the manner in which the business men conduct their affairs, and how friends and families communicate with each other. Over 90% of adults use electronic communication on a daily basis (Nilsson, 2010). On this note, electronic evidence are always used in courts. The use of this evidence is always governed by the Federal Laws of Evidence (Ensminger, 2012). These laws establish the criteria upon which a judge or a magistrate should use...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Evidence week three

...to reexamine the presented data Question: How do expectant mothers diagnosed with diabetes relate to nurses and how do they perceive reporting their blood sugar levels to their healthcare givers within the first 6 months? (Eadara et al., 2010). The question is both qualitative and quantitative. It will use a mixed research design to enable a proper analysis of data and/or information and uncover the real facts underlying GDM and Preeclampsia (Eadara et al., 2010). Using a mixed design will also allow me to reference data appropriately and eventually derive knowledge that can contribute to the growth of evidence-based knowledge in nursing. Fall and injury prevention agency database This is a great...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Circumstantial Evidence Within The Casey Anthony Trial

...Circumstantial Evidence within the Casey Anthony Trial Grade (November 6, Casey Anthony Trialis one of the cases where Circumstantial Evidence featured prominently, owing to the fact that the crime was committed under circumstances where no witness would be available, since it was well choreographed way before it occurred (Paradis, 2011). Nevertheless, the jury did not find the merit in the Circumstantial Evidence that was presented, rather opting to continue digging for more and more evidence, and the more they tried to dig, the more elusive the evidence became. Despite the jury’s position that the Circumstantial Evidence did not merit proving the case of intended murder of Caylee beyond reasonable doubt, it is evident... that the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The three stages of a trial and the presentation of evidence for FREE!

Contact Us