Nobody downloaded yet

Frankfurts notion of Second Order Volition - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
This essay is an attempt to analyseFrankfurt’s notion of a second order volition in the light of its impact on the freedom of will and action. Harry G. Frankfurt is an American philosopher and a retired professor of philosophy at Princeton University…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.9% of users find it useful
Frankfurts notion of Second Order Volition
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Frankfurts notion of Second Order Volition"

Download file to see previous pages Frankfurt’s essay opens with his views on the concept of “person”. When his contemporaries seek to define a person as merely a body with states of consciousness, Frankfurt begs to differ. He states that a person is not just the singular form of ‘people’. It does not merely refer to the members of certain biological species with a set of specific physical and mental characteristics that are supposed to be uniquely human. Humans are not the only creatures with desires, motives and choices. But it is the capacity of reflective self-evaluation and a desire to be different from what they are that makes the persons a class apart from the other living beings.The primary feature that differentiates a person from other creatures is his structure of will. To define “will”, one needs to first understand the concept of first order desire. A first order desire is simply a desire for something or a desire to do or not to do one thing or another. For example, a desire to smoke a cigarette or to watch a movie or to read a book is a first order desire. ...
Therefore, a desire which determines the behaviour of a person at a critical moment and leads him to action in the presence of other conflicting desires is termed as will. (Frankfurt, 1971, pp. 4-5) To define “free will”, Frankfurt introduces another type of desires- second order desires. A second order desire refers to a desire about a first order desire or a desire to have or not to have a first order desire. Or in other words, a second order desire is a manifestation of the uniquely human ability of reflection on one’s first order desires. For example, a habitual smoker may have a desire to smoke but a smoker who is trying to quit may want “not to have a desire to smoke”. The latter is a case of second order desire.It is these second order desires that are regarded as a mark of ‘personhood’. (Frankfurt, 1971, p. 3) Second order desires which refer to effective first order desires are termed as second order volitions. In simpler terms, when a person wants a second order desire to be his will, it becomes a second order volition. To illustrate the concept better, we may take the example of a psychologist dealing with a drug addict patient. To understand his patient better, he may want to have the desire for drugs (second order desire). But he does not want his desire to be effective (to actually take drugs). The doctor thus demonstrates a second order desire but no second order volition. It is not second order desire but second order volition that is essential to being a person and this leads us to the definition of free will and freedom of action.((Frankfurt, 1971, p. 5) Free will is a situation wherein a person’s second order volition determines his behaviour. The definition of “freedom of will” ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Frankfurts notion of Second Order Volition Essay”, n.d.)
Frankfurts notion of Second Order Volition Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1490899-frankfurts-notion-of-second-order-volition
(Frankfurts Notion of Second Order Volition Essay)
Frankfurts Notion of Second Order Volition Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1490899-frankfurts-notion-of-second-order-volition.
“Frankfurts Notion of Second Order Volition Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1490899-frankfurts-notion-of-second-order-volition.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Frankfurts notion of Second Order Volition

The notion of Peace

...Philosophy Introduction Peace refers to a or a period of harmony characterized by the absence of violent clashes. Normally referred to as the lack of hostility, peace also portrays the presence of healthy established interpersonal or global relationships. It portrays achievement in matters of social or economic well being, the establishment of fairness, and a working political order that caters for the true interests of everybody. International relations teach that peace means the absence of war or conflict, together with the existence of cultural and economic understanding. This paper will evaluate Dr. Abigail Forsythe’s argument. Question 1: Conclusion of Dr. Abigail Forsythe’s argument In summarizing Dr. Abigail...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Frankfurts Distinction between Bullshitting and Lying

.... In order to make a knowledgeable claim, one is supposed to be aware of possible counterclaims and the associated ways to dispel them. If one makes a claim because of a plausible reason it becomes bullshit. Deception can also be termed as giving correct information. For instance, yesterday on TV, the assistance finance minister promised to save Hortis Bank (Frankfurt, 2005, p. 12). The hearer can make inference to that while knowing it wrong. The difference between bullshit, deception and lies is of significance from the perspective of mechanism design. Different means can give undesirable incentives for different forms of dishonesty. For example a financial advisor, who advises his client on investment...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Notion Of Houses

...Notion Of Houses We all have temporary passions, things that seem important for a short time, and as we grow older and expand our experiences, we realize how transient many of these passions can be. My father is certainly more enduring than temporary passions; indeed, his example and his words remain indelibly etched in my mind and my soul no matter how much time passes. He often notes to me that “it is better to build human houses than to build houses with empty people.” This essay will explain my interpretation of my father's proffered wisdom, and how this folksy quotation affects my overarching values, passions, and commitments. More particularly, this essay will discuss education as my most important value,...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Wilson and Kelling:A Broader Notion of Public Order

...Wilson and Kelling: A Broader Notion of Public Order That issues involving policing and public order are important is hardly worthy; on the other hand, there has been a tremendous amount written about the mechanisms, both theoretical and practical, for putting the most effective and the most efficient type of police force on the street. The publication of an article in 1982, by two academics, argued that police have been too reactive to fulfill their functions in the most efficient manner possible, that public order encompasses much more than a rigid attention paid to crime rates, and that investing police officers with a greater amount of discretion would contribute...
8 Pages(2000 words)Book Report/Review

Frankl's Notion of Life

...FRANKL'S NOTION OF LIFE In life, many people expect great things to happen in them. Many people view life as a gift with full of happiness. But lifeseems to have its own course. In reality, life is full of trials and hardships. It is a ubiquitous reality that man suffers almost in a daily basis. Pain and suffering are inevitable parts of human life. With this reality, man begins to question: How can life have meaning Can man find meaning in suffering For Frankl, it does not matter what man expects from life rather what life expects from man. This would mean that the meaning of life does not come from the situations that life gives but it comes from how man responds to each and every situation. Life will surely give joy...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Compare marx's notion of liberation with mill's notion of liberty

...are “progressive” and consequently seeking to better themselves as well as society. To accomplish this requires an acceptance of three inviolable areas of liberty: the inward domain of consciousness; freedom to pursue one’s own tastes; an ability of individuals to unite. Once again, however, his caveat for each of these is always that they do no harm to others. [Intro Para 12] Lastly, the title Mill gives to his essay is not On Government or On the Individual but On Liberty. This is so self-evident that it may be overlooked, but it is crucial to his analysis: Liberty is the driving force behind human endeavor and the always beguiling, if unreachable, notion of human perfectibility. Mill is thus squarely in the...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Social Psychology Notion

.... Hence, altruism and empathy serve as social helping, while diffusion of responsibility and pluralistic ignorance leave negative impact on helping attitude and project and promote selfishness within the social establishment. Q 2: (Answer): Every social set up looks for the prevalence of peace, order and discipline within its jurisdiction and scope. Thus, disorder and mayhem are discouraged at larger scale by devise and articulating of specific set of norms, mores, values, customs, conventions, traditions and statutes of law, conformity and following of which is highly recommended by an overwhelming majority of society. The main reason behind such compliance and conformity includes the protection of the one’s personal rights... or...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Second Order Crossover Loudspeaker

...Introduction Loudspeakers are the commonly used electrical devices that are used to increase the volume of sound. Loudspeakers are responsible for transforming the electrical signals into sound that are coming from devices such as broadcasting devices (radio), TV systems or electronic music related appliances. Loudspeakers use both electric and mechanical principles to convert an electrical signal. Mostly the speakers we use in our daily life works on the principle of audio cross-over. As the project topic suggests that we will be discussing the second order cross-over loudspeaker, loudspeakers are classified into different orders on the basis of filter order. Before...
9 Pages(2250 words)Lab Report

Political Order

...Effective Theories for Political Order Development Introduction Political order refers to ever changing political situations and systems prevailing in a society. The changes in the society are mainly due to the presence of various tensions and existing political theories with distinctions. The diverse contemporary and traditional political theories assist in forming a state with legitimacy, justice and humanity for the enrichment of political situations and the creation of ideal political order (Wissenburg, 2012). In this regard, a German philosopher named Friedrich Nietzsche reflected views about Christian morality, human equality and perfectionism. As per the political principle of...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

D2: SECOND ORDER SYSTEM RESPONSE - SYSTEM DYNAMICS

...Second Order System Response - System Dynamics Introduction The main purpose of this report is to analyse diverse cases of harmonic response of the second-order rectilinear dynamic systems. Whilst harmonic response theoretically takes into consideration of the steady state vibrations, the dynamic parameters extracted from the corresponding analysing of harmonic response can be employed to approximate the transient behaviour. Harmonic response permits the steady state response of the dynamic systems to the underlying harmonic excitation to be determined devoid of solving the system equations. The response of systems to diverse disturbances is one of the fields of study...
5 Pages(1250 words)Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Frankfurts notion of Second Order Volition for FREE!

Contact Us