Compare and contrast the ideologies and aims of VILLA and CARRANZA and their impact on the Mexican Revolution ( 1910-17) - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Though he was a killer, a bandit, and a revolutionary leader, many remember him as a folk hero.” (Rosenberg Guide). Villa was…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.5% of users find it useful
Compare and contrast the ideologies and aims of VILLA and CARRANZA and their impact on the Mexican Revolution ( 1910-17)
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Compare and contrast the ideologies and aims of VILLA and CARRANZA and their impact on the Mexican Revolution ( 1910-17)"

VILLA and CARRANZA: A contrast and comparison of their impact on the Mexican Revolution (1910 - 1917) INTRODUCTION: As Jennifer Rosenberg described, “Pancho Villa was a Mexican revolutionary leader who advocated for the poor and wanted agrarian reform. Though he was a killer, a bandit, and a revolutionary leader, many remember him as a folk hero.” (Rosenberg Guide). Villa was considered a hero by some and a villain by others. He believed in brute force and was sadistic with his ways oftentimes. But he always gave back to the poor.
Carranza was intelligent and stubborn, Minster of quoted that, “He was not the sort to inspire great loyalty, and his success in the revolution was mainly due to his ability to portray himself as a wise, stern patriarch who was the nations best hope for peace.” (Minster Guide)
Villa often opposes dictators during his time and revolted against the current regime twice. He strongly believed in his ways and that Mexicans should be free from oppression of people in power and injustice.
Carranza joined the revolution due to high ambitions; he collaborated with Francisco Madero who was the brains of the revolution in 1910. As quoted by Christopher online, “Carranza was not a true believer in reform and he felt that a firmer hand (preferably his) was needed to rule Mexico.” (Minster Guide)
Villa’s charisma provided him the support of the lower class and was often more of a hero to them than a rebel. The people supported much of his cause however awkward his methods maybe.
Carranza was more into the politics of the matter. One of his major reasons for joining the revolution was his plans of attaining power for himself. After Madero got assassinated by Huerta, another uprising came; this time led by Carranza himself. He was supported by Villa and Obregon on this one.
Villa’s radical aims were by no means visibly clear. Villa spoke unclearly of creating mutual colonies for his ex-comrades.
He yielded to Venustiano Carranza’s Plan.
Villa led his army to winning countless battles with his bravery. With his great charisma he was able to gather an army of 3000 in just a month time. He led them the last time against American Troops, after attacks on Columbus and New Mexico, before he was awarded pardon in 1920.
Carranza, on the latter part of the second uprising, was sided by the United States. Villa went to the mountains during this time and was considered a fugitive of the New Mexican government. Little was changed during Carranza’s reign.
End Event:
Jennifer Rosenberg added in her online article that; “Villa retired from revolutionary life in 1920 but had only a short retirement for he was gunned down in his car on July 20, 1923.”(Rosenberg Guide)
After Obregon drove him off of power in Mexico, Carranza was gunned by Rodolfo Herrera in his sleep together with his top supporters in 1920. As Christopher Minster quoted it, “Herrera was put on trial by Obregon, but it was clear that no one missed Carranza: Herrera was acquitted.” (Minster Guide)
I personally believed that Villa played the most vital roles in the revolution. The man could have done a lot for his country if only he got rid of his pride and reckless behavior that also led him to many failures.
Minster, Christopher. “Biography of Venustian Carranza”. Latin American History. Web. 20 November 2009.
Rosenberg, Jennifer. “Biography of Pancho Villa”. Latin American History.
Web. 20 November 2009. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Compare and contrast the ideologies and aims of VILLA and CARRANZA and Essay”, n.d.)
Compare and contrast the ideologies and aims of VILLA and CARRANZA and Essay. Retrieved from
(Compare and Contrast the Ideologies and Aims of VILLA and CARRANZA and Essay)
Compare and Contrast the Ideologies and Aims of VILLA and CARRANZA and Essay.
“Compare and Contrast the Ideologies and Aims of VILLA and CARRANZA and Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Compare and contrast the ideologies and aims of VILLA and CARRANZA and their impact on the Mexican Revolution ( 1910-17)

Compare / contrast

...her wishes. In Ashputtle there is no lesson of forgiveness but instead the stepsisters are avenged by two turtle doves, who peck out their eyes and blind the stepsisters. Charles Perrault’s Cinderella which was the original and earliest written Cinderella story starts with an introduction through the use of very noble words such as “nobleman, proudest and haughtiest” (Perrault). These words give a very royal feel intended for the French court. This start clearly shows that it is not aimed to capture the readers emotionally as the readers don’t feel any emotional attachment with this royal introduction. While in contrast in Jakob and Wilhelm’s Ashputtle the beginning is much more captivating and the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Compare & contrast

...Comparison and Contrast between two close friends Introduction My two closest friends are John and George. We have been friends since third grade and have to this day, served as one another’s support system for as long as we have known each other. George is very athletic while John is the geek in the group. The latter has interests in computers and knowledge in general, while the former plays football and recently made it to be the school’s first team as a quarter back. We are currently in the same school though different classes but share every opportunity in between the lessons and available free time to chat and share jokes. Personality From the above brief description, my two friends have very distinct personalities....
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Compare and contrast political ideologies, such as Liberalism and Conservatism

...Liberalism and Conservatism Political and social ideologies in the U.S. are varied ranging from far left to far right. The two sides have a contentious relationship which has grown even more heated during the last decade. In the left corner wearing blue trunks are the liberals and in the opposite corner are conservatives donning red. During less contentious times political philosophies are not as noticeable but contentious issues or events cause a reemergence of these deep-held feelings. Actions by the government during the Bush administration coupled with the election of the first black president have provoked an emotional response by persons on the left who want change and persons on the right who are resistant to...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Compare and Contrast ideologies

... Topic: Compare and Contrast Ideologies The political structure of a is determined by dominant ideology ingrained in its system. Organization, institution and state often conform to principles and social practices that shaped their political thoughts, behaviors, economic relations and cultural norms (Fred, 1978). Social interaction is cultivated by how power or authority is wielded through integration or adaptation of legitimate laws in democratic regime or by rules imposed by monarchical leaders to its constituents (Fred, 1978). Postmodern political structure however gave rise to the necessity of democratizing the process by encouraging peoples’ participation in governance and in community-based decision-makings to bring about... the...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper

Compare & contrast fill up the gap in our education system and in the workplace Education is very important Ways should be found to get people interested in education Education is one of the most important things in the world today; in fact, it is considered a basic human right by most international organizations. In this paper, we shall look at two articles with different approaches to education and we shall compare these approaches to each other. In this paper, we shall compare the different approaches that these two authors have suggested as a remedy for filling up the gaps in education both in the workplace and at school. We shall look at the following: an approach to education, failures in the education system, and...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Compare & contrast

...habit. For example, a person may decide that starting today; they will never smoke, and then stick to their decision. Secondly, a person may break a bad habit by tapering off, which highly bases on harm reduction. Bad habits result in harm, so one may choose to reduce the harm by reducing the number of times they engage in the bad habit. A person will start cutting back on the bad habit, like gradually rolling back the bad habit until it finally disappears completely. For example, a smoker used to five cigarettes daily may decide to smoke only two, then one, and finally quit smoking. The two ways present different conditions, so one may choose depending on how well they can cope. Comparing the two, abstinence may be...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Compare & Contrast

..., and utilize male sexual energy as a distraction for what is taking place behind the scenes. Furthermore, the representation of class is one in which the viewer comes to the realization that the moneyed aristocracy/bureaucracy is the only mechanism through which the average societal stakeholder can hope to get ahead. As a direct result of this realization and portrayal, the protagonists of the film find it necessary to ingratiate themselves with these individuals as a means of pursuing this dream. Interestingly, the second film that will be discussed within this comparison and contrast, “All about My Mother”, represents a differential between those individuals that live within the provinces and those that live within...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Compare & contrast

...from the readers. In Chang’s writings, the author does not use sound devices. Thirdly, the use of sensory details and figurative language is another aspect of writing style that can be used to compare and contrast two or more authors. In general, both writers employ literally devices that appeal to the senses of the reader. Both writers extensively use similes in their writings. In Chang’s Lust Caution, examples of similes used include: “…through the glass doors like a sea dragon” (Chang, 28), “what sounded like Hindi upstairs” (Chang, 28) and “a nose squalled like a lion’s muzzle” (Chang, 30) among others. In Hsun’s Medicine, some of the similes used include “the man’s eyes shone…. like a famished...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

The Mexican Revolution of 1910

.... and Hall Linda B. Tangled Destinies: Latin America and the United States. Albuquerque: Univ. of New Mexico Press, 1999. Print. de Fuentes, Fernando, Dir. Lets Go with Pancho Villa, 1936. Film. Estrada, Luis, Dir. Herods Law, 1999. Film. Fernández, Emilio, Dir. María Candelaria, 1944. Film. Gonzales, Michael J. The Mexican Revolution, 1910 - 1940. Albuquerque, NM: Univ. of New Mexico Pr, 2002. Print. McCaa, Robert. “Missing Millions: The Demographic Costs of the Mexican Revolution.” Mexican Studies 19, 2:2003. 367-400. Print. Madero, Francisco. The Plan of San Luis Potosi, November 20, 1910....
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Compare Contrast

...Thomas Friedman’s Generation Q and Rob Fishman’s Generation of Generation Q The similarities These generations both talk about the impacts of technology on the millennial generation and particularly the use of computers by a majority of the global population which has enhanced the world interconnectedness (Fishman Web). For instance, the two generations focus on the use of social media like Facebook, YouTube, and MySpace. The two generations are both termed as “Quiet,” because the focus of its members is on the computerized technology that they use in their interactions. Secondly, both generations are stuck in the use of technological advancements to solve the societal injustices and problems. They both argue that the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Compare and contrast the ideologies and aims of VILLA and CARRANZA and their impact on the Mexican Revolution ( 1910-17) for FREE!

Contact Us