Compare and Contrast the Ideologies and Aims of VILLA and CARRANZA - Essay Example

• Villa
• Villa often opposes dictators during his time and revolted against the current regime twice. He strongly believed in his ways and that Mexicans should be free from the oppression of people in power and injustice.

IDEOLOGIES:

• Carranza
• Carranza joined the revolution due to high ambitions; he collaborated with Francisco Madero who was the brains of the revolution in 1910. As quoted by Christopher online, “Carranza was not a true believer in reform and he felt that a firmer hand (preferably his) was needed to rule Mexico.” (Minster About.com Guide)
• Villa
• Villa’s charisma provided him the support of the lower class and was often more of a hero to them than a rebel. The people supported much of his cause however awkward his methods may be.

AIMS:

• Carranza
• Carranza was more into the politics of the matter. One of his major reasons for joining the revolution was his plans of attaining power for himself. After Madero got assassinated by Huerta, another uprising came; this time led by Carranza himself. He was supported by Villa and Obregon on this one.
• Villa
• Villa’s radical aims were by no means visibly clear. Villa spoke unclearly of creating mutual colonies for his ex-comrades.
• He yielded to Venustiano Carranza’s Plan.

IMPACT:

• Villa
• Villa led his army to win countless battles with his bravery. With his great charisma, he was able to gather an army of 3000 in just a month. He led them the last time against American Troops, after attacks on Columbus and New Mexico, before he was awarded pardon in 1920.

• Carranza
• Carranza, on the latter part of the second uprising, was sided by the United States. Villa went to the mountains during this time and was considered a fugitive of the New Mexican government. Little was changed during Carranza’s reign.

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION:

• End Event:
• Jennifer Rosenberg added in her online article that; “Villa retired from revolutionary life in 1920 but had only a short retirement for he was gunned down in his car on July 20, 1923.” (Rosenberg About.com Guide)
• After Obregon drove him off of power in Mexico, Carranza was gunned by Rodolfo Herrera in his sleep together with his top supporters in 1920. As Christopher Minster quoted it, “Herrera was put on trial by Obregon, but it was clear that no one missed Carranza: Herrera was acquitted.” (Minster About.com Guide)

CONCLUSION:

• I believed that Villa played the most vital role in the revolution. The man could have done a lot for his country if only he got rid of his pride and reckless behavior that also led him to many failures.