Nobody downloaded yet

Letter to the Committee Saying Why Brain Rejuvenation Should Not Be Allowed - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Dear members, While there exists a general consensus of the benefits of medical transplant towards saving lives and giving persons a second chance in life, it becomes very necessary that advancements in the medical field towards replacement of body organs be examined keenly with a view to determine the issues surrounding such a process…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.5% of users find it useful
Letter to the Committee Saying Why Brain Rejuvenation Should Not Be Allowed
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Letter to the Committee Saying Why Brain Rejuvenation Should Not Be Allowed"

Download file to see previous pages Within the context of brain transplant, a person is only identical to the later person if the later person has the entire body as the earlier person, subsequently, brain rejuvenation results to memory duplication whereby a person’s memory can be used by several other persons. Prior to the suggested “brain rejuvenation” procedure on Nick, Dr. Mathews performed a “brain transplant” operation on Julia North and subsequently the members of the committee agreed that Julia North’s life was saved. Perhaps we may need to understand a few basics and events that led to this case. Before this operation, Julia North was a young woman run over by a car in efforts to save the life of a child who wandered onto the tracks. Mary Frances who was the child’s mother had stroke while watching the events unfold. The two victims were brought to this facility where Dr. Mathews performed his ‘Brain transplant’ operation which the committee approved and agreed that saved Julia’s life. It is also important to note that at the time of accident, the survivor, Julia North’s body was dying and the brain was okay and Dr. Mathews transferred her brain into another body. The committee further agreed that it was Julia’s life that was saved since the survivor had memories of Julia based on the being Julia. While arriving at this conclusion, this committee must have been guided by the sophisticated memory account that provides that when a person is numerically identical to a later person if and only if the person has memories of being earlier person that is so caused in the right way. My objection for this matter rests with Cohen’s views on this matter. Julia North had one up until the time of accident, and another body after the operation. This implies that one person had two bodies. Therefore a person cannot be simply identified with a human body and therefore something must be wrong with the view that the committee had adopted on this case as it implies that if a similar operation were to be carried out on brain transplant, then afterwards this person would be a person with new body since the person with that body has a memory of having a similar case as Julia if caused in the ‘right way.’ Right in this scenario has a particular meaning of interest, and must satisfy three conditions; if a subject experiences some event, this experience leaves a trace in the brain of the event and this trace that has been left is later responsible for content of a memory, then in this way we can say that the memory is caused in the right way. Dear members, we are faced with another problem of a new technique called ‘Brain rejuvenation’ yet to be performed on Nick. While adopting earlier propositions to defend approving Julia’s case we are also suggesting that the same logic as earlier proposed would be applicable and as such the committee is justified in saying that Nick would be the survivor of the operation , and I quote, “Nick would be the survivor of the brain rejuvenation procedure because the survivor would have the memories of being Nick and there would be more than one person of being Nick.” But dear members, Nick cannot be more than one person and this do not seems right. Using the same procedure as advanced in this new ‘brain rejuvenation’ process, the committee has argued that saving Nick’s life will be accomplished by replacing his brain with a duplicated brain from someone else and as such his survival are justified on the premise that the same bodies would be of this new person, say Alex and that Nick would then have Alex’s memories and they remember them in the right way. Premised on the duplication theory, when someone ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Letter to the Committee Saying Why Brain Rejuvenation Should Not Be Essay”, n.d.)
Letter to the Committee Saying Why Brain Rejuvenation Should Not Be Essay. Retrieved from
(Letter to the Committee Saying Why Brain Rejuvenation Should Not Be Essay)
Letter to the Committee Saying Why Brain Rejuvenation Should Not Be Essay.
“Letter to the Committee Saying Why Brain Rejuvenation Should Not Be Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Letter to the Committee Saying Why Brain Rejuvenation Should Not Be Allowed

Audit Committee

...of an organizations functions as well as dangers along with, between other belongings, allows external auditor to offer a standing information lying on Audit doings furthermore to present contribution in favor of the committee’s consideration (BPP, 2011). Question 2: Audit and Corporative Governance, explain the role of Internal Auditors. Answer: Governance is the expression worn to explain the function of people assigned by means of regulation, control, along with path of a unit. Depending on the authority, diverse body might contain liability pro corporate governance: Board of Directors Audit Committee Other supervisory committees Benefits of Good Corporate Governance...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Auditing Committee

...of audit committees has resulted in mixed findings. Some researchers concluded that audit committees are ineffective (Crawford, 1987; Jones, 1986). However, others suggest that having an audit committee prevented false representation of financial statements, reduced inconsistent accounting policies, and made a strong control mechanism on the external auditor (Kunitake, 1983; DeFond and Jiambalvo, 1991; McMullen, 1996). Collier (1996) in a study undertaken in UK concluded that there is limited evidence in the effectiveness of audit committees. Literature has suggested many factors that generally impact the effectiveness of audit committees. The three...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Federal open market committee

...? Federal Open Market Committee of the of the Federal Open Market Committee Introduction The Federal Open Market Committee plays a key role in setting the rates of interest on loans etc. that are available with banks and other lending institutions. In fact if we consider carefully, monetary and fiscal policy are the two ways in which the money supply and interest rates within an economy are controlled. This has impact on the rates of inflation, employment, job creation, productivity and a whole lot of other factors that form part of our financial and economic well being and affect the National Statistics and state of the economy. In this assignment we are going to take on the role of the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Congressinal committee hearing simulation accepted within the three years. Three years too will make authorities have manageable number to vet for work visa programs. Subsequently, amendment should be done to enable renewal of the visas if the period that they are meant to be functional elapses. This would ensure that the most needed workforce is retained depending on the prevailing work needs of the United States. Extension of visa life spans would indirectly influence the general work and life balance of the United States work force. This is necessitated by the fact that adequate workforce increases chances of the workers qualifying for leave days from their employers. Leave on its part rejuvenates the workers and desired effectiveness...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

U.S committee system

...20 May 2008 The Committee System in the US Congress The structure of the US congress can be attributed to the type of work which it carries out. Due to the volume of work and the complexity of the processes, deregulation has become essential and the most distinctive characteristics of the congressional committee system. Breaking down the workload and responsibilities among different committees enable them to focus on specific duties thereby enhancing the whole congress’ efficiency: “Within assigned subject areas, committees and subcommittees gather information; compare and evaluate legislative alternatives; identify problems and propose solutions to them; select,...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Split Brain (Brain Area Functions) and they can also feel it. The reason for this is that the connection between the two hemispheres is lost and information cannot be relayed from the right hemisphere to the left hemisphere which is principally responsible for language. It also proved the fact that “spatial tasks” are performed at a more optimal level by the right hemisphere. This was seen when the patients were asked to collected colored objects. They could perform this activity in a better way with the left hand. An intriguing aspect seen in these patients is that the two hemispheres function as two brains (Greenstein et al 2000). I think split brain surgery should only be performed as a last resort when all other...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay


...Psychology What are two kinds of evidence that consciousness depends on a functioning brain? To start with, damage to the alerting areas of the brain, the brain stem and the midbrain, most likely can result to loss of consciousness. The first evidence is that consciousness cannot exist without the cortex working accordingly. Without this part, it would not be possible to comprehend speech, plan, move, solve problems, or express emotions. All these are aspects of consciousness. Second evidence is the brain stem. The hypothalamus is responsible for the sleep cycle; therefore, the suprachiasmatic nucleus controls the preoptic nucleus that induces sleep. By inhibiting the...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Committee Memo

...John Carlisle, President Cc: Richard Bartocelli, Vice President, Department of Research and Development Chair of New Product Committee Date: October 24, 2012 Subject: Status of Lexivia Project This is to update you regarding the latest status of Lexivia project. In the last monthly meeting, held on October 3, two major facts came to light that might delay the project. William Song, our outside patent attorney had informed that the drug composition of Lexivia and its potential use as heart medication was revealed in an article written by one of the company’s scientists in Journal of Experimental Pharmacology in April 2009 issue. Article was written before patent application was filed. The issue needs to be investigated...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Analyzing mills saying

...wants. For Mill, he is likened to a pig. It is known that a pig does nothing but eat, sleep and relieves itself from the heat by swimming in the mud or worse, in its own dirt and it is satisfied with such kind of life. Therefore, the philosopher argues that he would rather be an unhappy human being than an animal which acts in such a manner but is still satisfied about itself. For the second person, he might be dissatisfied and unhappy but considers himself of higher morality than the former. This contradicts the philosophy of Bentham who says that a person is moral when his actions bring him happiness. Similarly, Mill believes that it is better to be a dissatisfied wise man than a satisfied fool. It is assumed that he...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Qatar Olympic Committee

...Qatar Olympic Committee (QOC) Assignment Introduction The Qatar Olympic Committee (QOC) is charged with the responsibility of administrating and supervising the sports federations and institutions in Qatar. The need for the establishment of the QOC was as a result of the continued participation of the Qatar national teams in various regional, continental and international competitions. In addition, during the mid 1970’s, there was great diversification of the sport activities in Qatar (, 2014). This necessitated the establishment of a body that would manage and supervise the various sport activities. QOC provides opportunities for members of the community to participate in sport and...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Letter to the Committee Saying Why Brain Rejuvenation Should Not Be Allowed for FREE!

Contact Us