Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

Letter to the Committee Saying Why Brain Rejuvenation Should Not Be Allowed - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Dear members, While there exists a general consensus of the benefits of medical transplant towards saving lives and giving persons a second chance in life, it becomes very necessary that advancements in the medical field towards replacement of body organs be examined keenly with a view to determine the issues surrounding such a process…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.8% of users find it useful
Letter to the Committee Saying Why Brain Rejuvenation Should Not Be Allowed
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Letter to the Committee Saying Why Brain Rejuvenation Should Not Be Allowed"

Download file to see previous pages Within the context of brain transplant, a person is only identical to the later person if the later person has the entire body as the earlier person, subsequently, brain rejuvenation results to memory duplication whereby a person’s memory can be used by several other persons. Prior to the suggested “brain rejuvenation” procedure on Nick, Dr. Mathews performed a “brain transplant” operation on Julia North and subsequently the members of the committee agreed that Julia North’s life was saved. Perhaps we may need to understand a few basics and events that led to this case. Before this operation, Julia North was a young woman run over by a car in efforts to save the life of a child who wandered onto the tracks. Mary Frances who was the child’s mother had stroke while watching the events unfold. The two victims were brought to this facility where Dr. Mathews performed his ‘Brain transplant’ operation which the committee approved and agreed that saved Julia’s life. It is also important to note that at the time of accident, the survivor, Julia North’s body was dying and the brain was okay and Dr. Mathews transferred her brain into another body. The committee further agreed that it was Julia’s life that was saved since the survivor had memories of Julia based on the being Julia. While arriving at this conclusion, this committee must have been guided by the sophisticated memory account that provides that when a person is numerically identical to a later person if and only if the person has memories of being earlier person that is so caused in the right way. My objection for this matter rests with Cohen’s views on this matter. Julia North had one up until the time of accident, and another body after the operation. This implies that one person had two bodies. Therefore a person cannot be simply identified with a human body and therefore something must be wrong with the view that the committee had adopted on this case as it implies that if a similar operation were to be carried out on brain transplant, then afterwards this person would be a person with new body since the person with that body has a memory of having a similar case as Julia if caused in the ‘right way.’ Right in this scenario has a particular meaning of interest, and must satisfy three conditions; if a subject experiences some event, this experience leaves a trace in the brain of the event and this trace that has been left is later responsible for content of a memory, then in this way we can say that the memory is caused in the right way. Dear members, we are faced with another problem of a new technique called ‘Brain rejuvenation’ yet to be performed on Nick. While adopting earlier propositions to defend approving Julia’s case we are also suggesting that the same logic as earlier proposed would be applicable and as such the committee is justified in saying that Nick would be the survivor of the operation , and I quote, “Nick would be the survivor of the brain rejuvenation procedure because the survivor would have the memories of being Nick and there would be more than one person of being Nick.” But dear members, Nick cannot be more than one person and this do not seems right. Using the same procedure as advanced in this new ‘brain rejuvenation’ process, the committee has argued that saving Nick’s life will be accomplished by replacing his brain with a duplicated brain from someone else and as such his survival are justified on the premise that the same bodies would be of this new person, say Alex and that Nick would then have Alex’s memories and they remember them in the right way. Premised on the duplication theory, when someone ...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Letter to the Committee Saying Why Brain Rejuvenation Should Not Be Essay”, n.d.)
Letter to the Committee Saying Why Brain Rejuvenation Should Not Be Essay. Retrieved from
(Letter to the Committee Saying Why Brain Rejuvenation Should Not Be Essay)
Letter to the Committee Saying Why Brain Rejuvenation Should Not Be Essay.
“Letter to the Committee Saying Why Brain Rejuvenation Should Not Be Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Letter to the Committee Saying Why Brain Rejuvenation Should Not Be Allowed

An Analysis of the Differences in Brain Processes of Males and Females during Language Tasks

Such is the case with the development of cognitive functions and language skills. While the brain may have complexities that we simply haven’t even yet scratched the surface of, seemingly every day there are advancements in our knowledge of brain functions.

MRI’s and various cognitive function tests have shown that males and females use different parts of their brains while performing the exact same language tasks; the biological basis for this is due to the organizing effects of testosterone and estrogen. Females have long been known to be slightly ahead of males as far as language skills at younger ages, but this could also be attributed to the fact that overall females develop earlier than males and reach...
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Lennox-Gastaut Syndrome as a Childhood Brain Disorder

In 70 A.D literature, in the Gospel according to Mark (9:14-29), Jesus was said to have cast out an evil spirit from a man with such condition. The man’s father said to Jesus that his son is possessed by a spirit who caused him a loss of speech. Furthermore, the father said that whenever the spirit has his son, it throws him to the ground where he later on foams on the mouth and becomes immovable (Beaumanoir, 1982).
These were the implicit notions regarding what people now know properly as epilepsy. There are many kinds of epilepsy, but to the layman, the image of a person who is having an epileptic seizure cries out, falls to the floor-at most time without consciousness, does not have control over his movements, drool...
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

The Importance of the Letter of Credit

...Understanding The Importance of the Letter of Credit And Why It Is Considered the Lifeblood of International Trade I. Introduction International business transactions involve a lot of complex situations that may pose problems on the part of the sellers and buyers. Since parties in international transactions often do not see each other face to face, this situation can lead to confusions especially in terms of payments. As payments are very important in any commercial transaction, letters of credits for an important part of international transactions and is considered as the lifeblood of international trade. Compared to other types of payment systems, the letters of credit are relatively safe as it is course through banks. One of the most...
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Katherines Letter

... roommate was out partying and the door was locked so nobody could enter without knocking or breaking the door down. I told myself that it was just my imagination and that I should get back to work. As I sat down on my study table, I noticed something underneath my laptop… it was Katherine’s letter! I stared at the letter in disbelief not knowing what to do. I was about to put the letter back into the trash when I felt someone whispered in my ear. I couldn’t make out what it was saying but I felt the hair on nape rising. Suddenly, my laptop came to life on its own. The screen flickered and an eerie light filled the room. Scared out of my wits, I grabbed my cellular phone and tried to call one of my friends but I could not get a signal...
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Death Penalty Should Not Be Allowed

... Death Penalty Should Not Be Allowed Article 5 of the United Nations’ Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) prohibits the subjection of any individual to punishment that is cruel, inhuman or degrading (United Nations 1). The office further makes it clear that the universal declaration of human rights is a document drafted by representatives from different legal and cultural backgrounds. Civilized humanity thus views the universal declaration of human rights as the gold standard in terms of how humans should relate with each other. Therefore, if the UDHR lays down universally agreed standards on which humans should treat each other, does the death penalty has a place in the 21st century? Is capital punishment a contravention...
12 Pages (3000 words) Term Paper

Lens and Artifact from Letter from Birmingham Jail and Antigone

... decision to disown one of his brothers Polyneices and yet his other brother Eteocles is given a decent burial. According to her this is unjust. For this reason the two decides to engage in civil disobedience. This is expressed when MLK responds to the whites critics in form of a letter and informs them that he is not sorry for the kind of civil unrest taking place in Birmingham but he argues that the White rulers had not given them any option (Martin Luther King 457). On the other hand Antigone also confesses to breaking the highest law against King Creole but she says that it is unjust to dishonor his brother. She pleads that she be given the chance to bury his brother. This paper is going to analyze several instances civil disobedience...
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper

Enhancing Drugs: Why Should They Be Allowed in Sports

... Performance Enhancing Drugs: Why Should They Be Allowed in Sports? Introduction The topic of the performance enhancement drugsin sports is one that has elicited mixed opinions from various quotas. The main motivation is that the drugs have been argued to have both negative and positive impacts both on the athletes and on the game itself. Currently, the performance enhancement drugs are banned and cannot be used in any sport (Anabolic Steroid Abuse, 4). Those who engage or partake of these drugs and those found to have taken the drugs are usually banned from the sport. The use of the performance enhancing drugs is associated with several benefits. Some of these benefits include improved strength as well as performance. This research...
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Letter about GMOs and The Issue of Their Safety

The Internet has come to provide us with a wealth of scientific, layman, and very rigorously vetted information regarding GMOs and the arguments of both sides of the debate. The bottom line is that GMO safety to human health and ecology is not something that has been conclusively proven. Judging from the worldwide furor, moreover, it seems that there are significant negative health effects that can be likened to a ticking time bomb associated with GMO use. Will we wait for the mass onset of diseases like cancer and other serious ailments that ultimately will be traced to GMOs, before we act? What will happen to your brands and to your company when the bomb explodes? I am writing to strongly urge you to reconsider your current prac...
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Letter from Birmingham Jail by Martin Luther King

... Researched Personal Argument: “Letter from Birmingham Jail” Introduction The legendary Martin Luther King wrote “the letter from Birmingham jail” in response to the clergy men’s publication which opposed his civil movement. Despite King’s letter receiving overwhelming support from the country people, it also received a few criticisms on some parts by other writers. Unlawful and untimely demonstrations are the core issues that some writers confront against King’s anti racism movements. Refutation According to Reider Para 2 he states that some weeks before King was arrested and taken to Birmingham jail, most of the “Blacks” as compared to the “Whites” had turned against him. The writer explains that King was discouraged by the fact...
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Letter of Advice and Interpersonal Communication

Even though communication has a significant role in the building of relationships, a regular individual is likely to encounter many obstacles that will prevent effective communication. Communication problems lead to difficulties in conveying messages to for example workmates, friends, and even family. Having an emotion that is contrary to an earlier experience is a barrier to effectiveness in the interpersonal relationships between couples in a relationship. In case one does not do away with this negative emotion, it continues to influence the way one talks and the feeling can be uttered when one least expects. These emotions might be as a result of situations like the previous that had shown up earlier. One will not be able consc...
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Letter to the Committee Saying Why Brain Rejuvenation Should Not Be Allowed for FREE!

Contact Us