StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Way Our Lives Should Be Governed: Sandel and Nagel - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
"The Way Our Lives Should Be Governed: Sandel and Nagel" paper states that though Nagel and Sandel’s ideas are overlapping at some points, however, Nagel has a realization as to whether the society and individual shall be distinct from each other or rather they should be a reflection of each other…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.8% of users find it useful
The Way Our Lives Should Be Governed: Sandel and Nagel
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Way Our Lives Should Be Governed: Sandel and Nagel"

The concept of self and society is one of the most critical aspects of the philosophy and underlying debate that attempt to present a balanced and historical analysis of the way our lives should be governed. Sandel’s ideas on self and society reflect the basic philosophical ideologies of liberalism and how one should be self governed. He is however, well aware of the practical difficulties that Americans are facing specially his recognition of the fact that Americans are losing the control over the very forces that tend to govern their lives. Nagel however considers the changing views about the way we conduct our public lives have radically changed over the period of time. For example, “Because of the way life is, this results in real damage to the condition of the public sphere: Many people cannot take that kind of exposure, and many are discredited or tarnished in ways that have nothing to do with their real qualifications or achievements.” (Nagel) This conception of society therefore clearly reflect the manner in which the relation between the society and the individual has blurred. Nagel therefore offers a very raidcal explantion of our relationship with the society in which our private information and self does not matter most and as such society’s collective thinking is shaped by the forces that are probably outside the society itself. This conception therefore may be coincinding with what Sandel mention that Americans are losing control over the forces that control their own lives. Sandel’s ideas however seems to be more influenced by the basic ideas of Kant and Mill and he largely distinguish between the two to provide an explanation of the self and the society. From Kantian perspective he sees the liberation of individual as something which is beyond any moral or customs. He mentions it very vividly in following manner: “The liberal ethic derives most of its moral force from the appeal of the self image that animates it………….. liberal self is installed as soveriegn, cast as the author of only obligations that constrain”. (Sandel) Accordingly, Sandel view liberal self as someone who is not essentially related with the society but rather he is someone who is free from any constraints and his relations with the society are free from any type of obligations other than the one that he has set for himself. This position is quite related with the Kantian views of self which are mostly based on the metaphysical views of an individual regardless of the any binding from the society. Kantian view of self is also based on the multiplicity of an individual wherein self is comprised of the spirit, the soul and the physical body itself. It is our physical self through which we are being recognized by our society as the individual having certain chracterstics. Thus self perception according to Kant is based on the presentation of the actuality. Sandel further, eloborate on this in following manner: “we must respect the diginity of all persons but beyond this, we owe only what we agree to owe” This quote further clarify the Sandel’s views on the relationships of an individual to the society and the overall extent of the relationship between the two. This concept of self is radically different from that of the Nagel who view this as : ” While we should insist on the protection of individual rights of personal freedom, I believe we should not insist on confrontation in the public space over different attitudes about the conduct of personal life. To the extent possible, and the extent compatible with the protection of private rights, it would be better if these battles for the soul of the culture were avoided, and no collective response required. Best would be a regime of private freedom combined with public or collective neutrality.” (Nagel). This quote indicate Nagel’s view point regarding how a person or an individual shall interact with the society and a collective neutrality shall be observed when conflict between self and society emerge. The conduct of personal life shall not interfere or rather dominate the collective thinking of the society itself. Nagel however, also view this debate between the self and the society as two different aspects which should not interact with each other. This also means that the personal as well as public domains of people should be separate and one shall not interfere with that of the other. Nagel therefore in a sense provide a clear understanding of how our collective behavior shall be shaped in the society and how society shall behave or respond to the individual. This means that the society shall not attempt to transgress its limits whereas self shall also keep itself into within certain limits so as to provide a proper balance between the two. What is fundamentally different between the two approaches of the writers is not the actual role of individual in a society but rather how an individual and society shall interact with each other. Sandel believes that self shall be liberated from the chains of the society wherein Nagel provides a much practical insight into how the public and private life has been blurred and there is now probably less difference between the personal values and the self and the society. He maintains that in a society where public and private domains of individuals do not hold much, individual shall may not held the key. Nagel further clarifies this in following manner: “If in the name of liberty one tries to institute a free-for-all, the result will be a revival of the forces of repression, a decline of social peace and perhaps eventually of generally accepted norms of toleration. “ This position is quite explicit on how the relationship between the society and self shall be proposed. In my opinion, Nagel’s view is much realistic considering the new social forces that emerged as a result of post-industrialism in America. The new forces and increasing emphasis on negation of self is what new society is all about. Though Nagel and Sandel’s ideas are over-lapping at some points however, Nagel has a realization as to whether the society and individual shall be distinct from each other or rather they should be reflection of each other. Nagel therefore superior in considering the fact that there are limits to the self as well as the society and both shall not transgress into the boundary of another beyond a certain point. Sandel’s analysis however lacking this and view self as an independent and liberated self with no boundaries. Works Cited 1. Nagel, Thomas. CONCEALMENT AND EXPOSURE. 1998. 17 March 2010 . 2. Sandel, Michael J. Democracy's Discontent: America in Search of a Public Philosophy. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1996. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Self & Society (Philosophy) Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words, n.d.)
Self & Society (Philosophy) Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1734867-self-society-philosophy
(Self & Society (Philosophy) Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
Self & Society (Philosophy) Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1734867-self-society-philosophy.
“Self & Society (Philosophy) Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1734867-self-society-philosophy.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Way Our Lives Should Be Governed: Sandel and Nagel

Clinical Supervision Importance in Practices Nursing

hellip; Work is one of the most fundamental aspects of our lives.... Nevertheless, we often pay little attention to the work we do, our suitability to it, to critical relationships inherent in it or to the manner in which our very essence is by it challenged....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Sigmund Freuds Analysis Applied to Adolf Hitler

This would be the way that Hitler would deal with the discomfort of the repressed memories of Palgrave.... nbsp; The unconscious is where our id resides, and also a place where bad memories are repressed.... These hysterical symptoms then become a way for the unconscious to release these memories and trauma....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Orphan Brands Issues

armite, our main example of a orphan brand is "a dark brown-colored savory spread made from the yeast that is a by-product of the brewing industry.... According to the definition on given by WordSpy (2008, pg.... 1) an orphan brand is "A once-famous brand name that remains on sale but is no longer popular"....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

Legal Issues in Consumer Protection

So, if we agree that we have advertently or inadvertently involved ourselves in one business transaction or the other, there have been at least one or two instances in our lives when we have felt that we as consumers have been given an unfair deal by the providers/salesman and the deal has not been concluded in the manner it should have been; in other words, our rights as customers have been infringed.... This definition and example might seem a little far fetched at the moment, but surprisingly both are in a way applicable in our day to day lives....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

The role of sexuality in Victorian society applied to A. S. Byatts Possession

Although the novel tells a fictional tale of two literary scholars tracking down evidence of a love affair between two Victorian era poets, episodes dedicated to the poets themselves reveal a great deal of information regarding the way of life of women during this period in history....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Bailing Out Corporate America

Americans do not hope to have just enough, they hope to have everything they can get but they expect to get it by working hard, doing a good job, and being successful (sandel, 2009) anything else is considered theft.... ?? This is a dream that European upper classes might have some difficulty in interpreting and now many of our own are having trouble hanging on to....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

The Story of Every Human Being Is Dramatic and Tragic

We have energies during the early years of our lives (Blase & Blase, 2000), but they deplete with the passage of time, and then, we need to have motivation in order to get through our lives' later sections.... I was a student once, and I am now a manager who is attempting to make the same difference in others' lives as somebody did in mine.... In this way, we have to give ourselves the utmost level of exposure so that we can grow....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Sigmund Freuds Analysis Applied to Adolf Hitler

These hysterical symptoms then become a way for the unconscious to release these memories and trauma.... "Sigmund Freud's Analysis Applied to Adolf Hitler" paper states that Freud's theory would help explain why Hitler became the man that he became.... His id was what ruled - Hitler blamed the Jews for the ills of the world, and he pursued a course of action that was not condoned by society....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us