• Home
  • Subjects
  • Literature
  • Information to Those Who Would Remove to America and Traits of Indian Character by Benjamin Franklin and Washington Irving

Information to Those Who Would Remove to America and Traits of Indian Character by Benjamin Franklin and Washington Irving - Essay Example

Benjamin Franklin and Washington Irving represent two of the great intellectuals of American history. Separated by a generation, Franklin and Irving both published letters – titled “Information to Those Who Would Remove to America” and “Traits of Indian Character”, respectively – which differently portrayed the American public. …
Download full paper
File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.6% of users find it useful
Information to Those Who Would Remove to America and Traits of Indian Character by Benjamin Franklin and Washington Irving

Extract of sample Information to Those Who Would Remove to America and Traits of Indian Character by Benjamin Franklin and Washington Irving

Download file to see previous pages In these letters, Franklin generally spoke to the modest and hard-working nature of Americans, while Irving spoke to the imperialist and naïve nature of Americans toward Native Americans. Their letters contained very different themes and messages, but within these letters can be parsed out fundamentally different views of American culture and heritage. Where Franklin generally praises the American sense of equal opportunity, especially as opposed to the lack of equal opportunity in Europe, Irving rather eloquently criticizes the lack of equality and opportunity afforded to Indians, by Americans. Although these two great Americans views are separated by a generation, their messages are essentially timeless, for the emphasis that they place on certain virtues of character.
Benjamin Franklin’s letter is written expressly to Europeans who are interested in moving to America. He writes to them because he believes that they have a mistaken view of what life in America is truly like. It appears to Franklin that many Europeans believe Americans to be very wealthy and in want of talented businessmen, scientists, artisans, and tradespeople to pay for their work. Europeans also appear to generally believe that, as “Strangers of Birth”, they will be greatly appreciated and respected, upon relocating to America, since they will be considered fellow countrymen. Franklin criticizes the speculation that Americans will reward emigrating Europeans with paid travel, free land, slaves, farm tools, and cattle, calling these notions “wild imaginations”. According to Franklin, America is not a land of great riches, nor is it a land of little wealth; instead, he writes, “a general happy mediocrity … prevails”. This mediocrity prevails, in part, because most people are farmers, craftsmen, or merchants, who cannot neither afford to live idly nor to spend money on luxurious things. The middle-class character of the economy is further increased, because the few geniuses who are born in America usually relocate to Europe where their great talents can gain them greater rewards (greater than Americans can afford). Knowledge of literature or mathematics was, during this time, greatly appreciated and wanted in America. However, Franklin notes that nine universities were already running and staffed by capable professors. Since America will soon be producing its own industry of academics, Franklin argues that even well-respected academics won’t be in such high demand that they are afforded great wealth. Even worse are the prospects for workers trained in civil office or the bureaucracy of government, since America has too little wealth for large or superfluous government. With the wars being at an end, military officers have similarly-bleak prospects of finding good work. Central to Franklin’s characterization of Americans is their attitude toward other people, “[not] what is he? But, what can he do?” Here, Franklin expresses a view of America than diverges significantly from the view of America espoused by Irving; where Franklin portrays the Americans as exceptionally concerned with personal ability over personal heritage, Irving will portray Americans as exceptionally concerned with personal heritage over personal ability (discussed below). It is Franklin’s opinion that, although Europeans place emphasis on the quality of a person’s birth (i.e., his or her national heritage), Americans have little regard for a person’s national roots. In fact, Franklin’s choice of words seem to indicate American disdain for those who do not engage in productive labor, writing that Americans value a family-history of labor, rather than a history of ...Download file to see next pagesRead more
StudentShare Professional Writing Service is the right decision for you! Only from $14,99/page for a 100% unique and relevant paper. Enter your email, choose essay type and get your personal 20% discount
on on expert writing!
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Information to Those Who Would Remove to America and Traits of Indian Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1459139-information-to-those-who-would-remove-to-america-and-traits-of-indian-character-by-benjamin-franklin-and-washington-irving
(Information to Those Who Would Remove to America and Traits of Indian Essay)
“Information to Those Who Would Remove to America and Traits of Indian Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1459139-information-to-those-who-would-remove-to-america-and-traits-of-indian-character-by-benjamin-franklin-and-washington-irving.
  • Cited: 0 times
kameronbreitenb added comment 2 months ago
Student rated this paper as
Helpful paper! Used it to finish an assignment for a literature course. It was easy as ABC, for the first time in my life.
Click to create a comment or rate a document

MORE SAMPLES OF TOPIC: "Information to Those Who Would Remove to America and Traits of Indian Character by Benjamin Franklin and Washington Irving"

Benjamin Franklin

...Benjamin Franklin One of the pillars of American history who had been instrumental in contributing various works in an array of endeavors is Benjamin Franklin. He was born on the 17th of January of 1706 in Boston, Massachusetts (Vinci, par.1). He came from a large family with 13 siblings and grew up in Milk Street in a cramped household. Due to financial instability, the family could not afford sending Benjamin to school and opted to make him an apprentice to his brother’s employment as a printer. Unfortunate travails with his brother in the printing shop provided the impetus for Benjamin’s running away in 1723 en route...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper
Read More…

Benjamin Franklin

...No: Benjamin Franklin Franklin was born in Boston, New England and received basic education in literature from the grammar schools. Franklin led dynamic life for his nation to follow in future. He played a great part in independence of the America and promoting nationalism in American people. Franklin proved mastery in science, public services and great insight about business. He was the founder of American philosophical society. He knew the importance of book reading for an ordinary American. Benjamin made a plan to construct subscription library in Philadelphia. Benjamin laid emphasis on moral...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Read More…

Benjamin Franklin

...Character Profile Template Introductory Information Character’s Benjamin Franklin. Birth–Death Years January 17, 1706 – April 17, 1790. Picture of Character: Find a digital photo of the individual and paste it here. Most Noted For Benjamin Franklin was known as the Founding Father of United States. He has expertise in a large number of different areas. He was a leading politician, author, scientist, postmaster, political theorist, musician, statesman, inventor, diplomat, civic activist and satirist. Character Profile Report Biographical Information: Include life...
4 Pages(1000 words)Assignment
Read More…

Benjamin Franklin

...Benjamin Franklin’s Remarks Concerning the Savages of North America Civility, politeness, and decorum are concepts that are considered applicable to‘civilization’. And the term ‘civilization’ is only used in context wherein there is so-called ‘order’, ‘system’, ‘cities’, ‘education’, ‘government’, etc. However, Benjamin Franklin, in his address Remarks Concerning the Savages of North America, argued that people of the so-called civilized world greatly misunderstood other cultures, especially those that exist within the confines of the wilderness like Native Americans. It is a common belief that people living outside...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Read More…

Benjamin Franklin

...on the behalf of white men and definitely not slaves. Because the British government was running short of work force, they required to recruit African American Soldiers to fight on representing the crown, and promising them for the exchange of Liberty in return. As a result of threatening catastrophe, the Royal governor of Virginia, Lord Dunmore, issued a declaration that promised liberty to the slaves and servants who were willing to join his Loyalist Ethiopian Regiment. References Top of Form Clark, R. W. (2004). Benjamin Franklin: A biography. Edison, NJ: Castle Books.Bottom of Form Isaacson, Walter. (2004). Benjamin Frankline: An American Life. NY:...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
Read More…

Benjamin Franklin

...Benjamin Franklin Benjamin Franklin is one of the most well-known historical figures worldwide; but not only because his portrait is on the $100 bill, but because he was a great person who achieved unbelievable success in multiple spheres, including politics and science and was one of the Founding Fathers of the United States. Franklin was one of those prominent self made men, as he gained his position in society on his own, developing his talents by hard working. Benjamin Franklin was born in Boston on January 17, 1706. He was born in a working class family and had always been proud of...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper
Read More…
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Information to Those Who Would Remove to America and Traits of Indian Character by Benjamin Franklin and Washington Irving for FREE!

Contact Us