Nobody downloaded yet

Judges Should not Be Granted the Liberty to Make Laws - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The author discusses a statement that judges should not be in the position of the deciding cases in such a way that they are seen to be making lawmaking law is the function of Parliament only. The author states that Judges should not be granted the liberty to make laws. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.6% of users find it useful
Judges Should not Be Granted the Liberty to Make Laws
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Judges Should not Be Granted the Liberty to Make Laws"

Download file to see previous pages The Legislature is the prime law-making body and it is called the Congress in the United States. It is divided into two houses---The Senate and the House of Representatives. The Congress passes bills and transforms them into acts and laws, approves or disproves of the appointments made by the President, it declares wars and also gives its consent on treaties.
The Executive branch is the one that ensures the execution of laws passed by the Legislature. In the United States, the President is the head of the Executive organ of the Government and performs numerous functions. The most important ones among those functions are, that he is the Commander-in-Chief, he makes appointments in association with the recommendations of the Legislature, he can veto bills and laws; besides ensuring the proper implementations and execution of laws.
The Judiciary is the body of the government that undertakes the job of administering justice and taking charge of the criminal and civil offenses in the country. In the United States, the Supreme Court is the apex court, which also serves as the highest court of appeal. The other federal courts exercise their functions in accordance with their position in the hierarchal set-up. The Judiciary also interprets laws for the country. In addition to this, it also performs the functions of Judicial Review, which means, it undertakes the task of declaring a bill/act or law unconstitutional if it goes against the Constitution of the United States.
The Constitution of the United States also has a system of Checks and Balances, wherein each organ of the Government is granted autonomy, as well as, responsibility. In other words, one organ of the government can check the other organ, in case it goes beyond its sphere of activity or conducts proceedings in a manner that is outside its power. ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(Judges Should not Be Granted the Liberty to Make Laws Essay, n.d.)
Judges Should not Be Granted the Liberty to Make Laws Essay. Retrieved from
(Judges Should Not Be Granted the Liberty to Make Laws Essay)
Judges Should Not Be Granted the Liberty to Make Laws Essay.
“Judges Should Not Be Granted the Liberty to Make Laws Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Judges Should not Be Granted the Liberty to Make Laws


..., a libertarian argues that liberty should be natural and is an unchallengeable right. Liberty and equality can coexist coherently in a constitutional government through formulation of a framework that checks the two principles. A right involves responsibility, duties or commitment on other parties concerning the right holder, whereas, liberty reflects on freedom or permission for the right owner. Liberty and rights have an inverted relationship; liberty grants an individual the free will of engaging in any activity when there is no obstacle that may act as a limitation. Conversely, a right acts as a barrier to one’s...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Do Judges Make the Law or Find it a particular case is undisputable. Therefore, judges are supposed to find any existing law that is relevant to a case at hand and apply it to make legal decisions. In this case it can be said that judges are law finders rather than being law makers because they have to find law.7 The doctrine of separation of powers stipulates that each branch of the government should not interfere with the mandate and roles of the other branch and each branch should be allowed to operate independently. In this respect, the court system should interfere with the legislature’s role of...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Disciplining judges

...that the structured and formal manner in which a judge’s interdiction makes the entire process significantly bereft of malice and other elements of personalization of the entire process. Partly, this is seen in the fact that not even the Commission has the power to take disciplinary measures on a judge. Secondly, the process is formal and well-elaborated. Particularly, within 21 days of the issuance of its Decision and Recommendation, MJTC should file its original record in the Supreme Court and a copy on the judge being interdicted. Within this time, the judge has 28 days to file a petition in the Supreme Court and MJTC, 21 days to...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay


...In many ways it is easy to interpret the philosophy of positive liberty as a critique of negative liberty - which is as it was formulated. Negative liberty, as it is often characterized by liberalism and those who support this interpretation of freedom, is generally the notion that freedom - which is most commonly recognized as a political ideal to aspire to - is a quality that should be maximized by the individual, and that any system of government is morally obligated to impinge upon this freedom as little as possible or not at all. Positive freedom-based theories point out a very obvious weakness of this position; namely, that one of the activities that most often...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

Judges of colorado state

...policy change resulting in a net returns gain in which, according to the Constitution, voters should approve (Arnold 2). In 1988, the legislature codified the judicial routine commission notion. The legislation formed a statewide commission on judicial performance. This commission oversees the appraisal of county and district court trial judges and assesses the appellate court judges. Due to the formation of this commission, it is likely that some of the judges of the Colorado state will be re-elected. This will be highly based on their performance during their service (Jean 2). The commission follow a certain procedure in assessing judges: reliability;...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay


...Stuart mill, the two kinds of liberty can be limited only by self preservation of society and individuals living in it. In a similar understanding, rightful liberty can be abridged or modified by law and hence laws abridging the natural rights of individual citizens should only be restrained through vigorous constructions within their narrow limits. However, there have been critics of liberty; these opponenents to liberty argued that there should be political order in the society composed of two authorities which are the authority of the government, and the sovereignty of the state. These...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Liberty fighting and killing each other with no mercy. Everybody therefore had to stay and remain in his place of birth without entering into other places. Justice system was also full of impunity with no justice being granted. Many people were accused falsely and even sentenced for imprisonment without any reasonable reasons but due to what was viewed as granting and protecting liberty of all citizens. There are many different cases in these documents that have shown this with that of BUCK v. BELL, 274 U.S. 200 (1927) being a good example (U.S. Supreme Court 2). People were also restricted from moving from one country to the other (immigration). There were strict laws...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Electing Judges

...Electing Judges In partisan election method, those individuals that are running for the position of judge have their ballot papers which even indicate the political party they belong to (Segal 182). In this kind of elections that are various factors that may affect my voting decision. My voting decision will be impacted by identification with the party. This means that my voting decision will be dependent on how the party has performed in the past, this will impact will especially take place if a new face or novice judge is running for the elections. If the judge has already served before, my decision will dependant on how fairly the judge has been...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Religious Liberty

...Religious Liberty of the of the Concerned April 2, Religious Liberty The Supreme Court decision in Edwards v. Aguillard declared that the teaching of creationism in Public Schools was devoid of a clear secular purpose and contrary to the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. The Act under consideration in no way furthered the secular purposes aimed at “protecting academic freedom.” Actually the act endorsed a religious purpose by supporting the existence of a supernatural being responsible for the creation of humanity. In its intent a spirit, the Supreme Court ruling debarred the teaching of theories in Public schools that were least affiliated to a strictly scientific sense of inquiry and amounted...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Do the courts (judges) make policy Should they

..., especially courts of appeal, deal with numerous and countless ambiguous legislations. This means that in the passing of judgment, it may be next to impossible to pinpoint which area exactly the law should be implemented, and how it should be applied (Stone, 2012). In most cases, there is a lot to interpret, which means that judges have to make the call on what exactly to do and when to do it. In my opinion, policies are set by the calls made by the courts (judges), even if they may not want to. By using the two schools of thought that try to explain and dictate the role of judges, I would have to say that the judicial...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Judges Should not Be Granted the Liberty to Make Laws for FREE!

Contact Us