StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Parental Fitness Assumption - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
This research paper discusses the parental fitness assumption and how it was exercised in several major cases involved child custody. Parental fitness is at the heart of the child custody inquiry, and the notion of ‘fitness’ here is based on the traditional views of heterosexual marriage and self-sacrificing parents as society’s legal groundwork…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.3% of users find it useful
Parental Fitness Assumption
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Parental Fitness Assumption"

? The Parental Fitness Assumption Research Paper Introduction One of the fundamental assumptions of law is the ‘parental rights doctrine’. It states that “in custody disputes between a child’s biological parents and all others (including those who might be considered the ‘psychological parent’), the child’s best interest lies in being raised by a ‘fit’ biological parent” (Cath & Shopper, 2013, 300). Moreover, there is an inherent assumption that biological parents are naturally ‘fit’; hence, it does not have to be established in legal terms or in court. The task of proving the fitness of biological parents is hence carried out by those who challenge it. Therefore, besides a ‘best interests’ judgment, the judge should consider the fitness of those involved. Not like the primary caregiver inquiry, parental fitness, particularly when mental disorder could be involved, the task is usually transferred to those parents who should establish their fitness (Cath & Shopper, 2013). This dilemma is perfectly summed up by West Virginia Supreme Court Chief Justice Starcher, “[i]n my opinion, this case shows that… the stigma of mental illness [is] still a weakness in our court system” (Gopfert, Webster, & Seeman, 2004, 263). This research paper discusses the parental fitness assumption and how it was exercised in several major cases involved child custody. Deciding Child Custody Parental fitness is at the heart of the child custody inquiry, and the notion of ‘fitness’ here is based on the traditional views of heterosexual marriage and self-sacrificing parents as society’s legal groundwork (Nolan & Wardle, 2006). Social workers usually decides about a parent’s fitness and use a specific framework for carrying out parental fitness assessments in cases involving custody, which involves criminal history, substance abuse history, educational history, family history, etc. The description of an ‘unfit’ parent varies by state. A parent could be judged unfit if s/he was not able to properly and adequately care for the child. A mentally ill or alcoholic parent may also be considered unfit (Nolan & Wardle, 2006). The court will usually grant exclusive custody to one parent when the other parent is judged to be unfit, or if both parents are found to be unfit the child will brought to foster care. Proofs of being an unfit parent could be a basis for removing the parental rights to other children although the parent did not maltreat or abandon those children (Casenotes, 2007). The decisive factor is always the child’s best interest. However, in custody cases, favor is granted to adoptive and biological parents. Courts take into consideration issue like the child’s special needs, the involvement of the parent in the child’s development, the parent’s capacity to financially support the child, and the nature of the relationship between the parent and the child (Weisberg, 2008). Trial courts are mandated to evaluate and make correct decisions based on these aspects. There are several major cases that involve parental fitness assumption. In Bailes v. Sours, the biological mother and the stepmother of the child, Michael Sean Sours, fought for custody. The court decided to grant custody to the stepmother on the basis of ‘extraordinary circumstances’, since the child prefers to be with her stepmother and the circumstances, particularly the death of the father, affirm the assumption that the child should stay with his stepmother (Casenotes, 2007). In Troxel v. Granville, the paternal grandparents legally requested rights to visit their granddaughters. The court granted the request, but the mother protested that the decision was unconstitutional (Casenotes, 2007). In Pierce v. Society of Sisters two private schools were granted a restraining order disallowing the implementation of the Oregon Act which obliged the guardians and parents from enrolling their children in public schools. The 14th Amendment protects the right of the guardian or parent to decide where to educate their children (Weisberg, 2008). In Connecticut, judges handling custody cases should ground their judgments in the child’s best interest. Even though a judge will evaluate every case separately, the legal system of Connecticut focuses on the assumption that children are better-off financially, emotionally, psychologically, and socially from both parents’ active presence and involvement (Nolan & Wardle, 2006). In Meyer v. Nebraska the accused was convicted for disobeying the Nebraska law that prohibited the foreign-language teaching to pupils that had not yet finished 8th grade. The 14th Amendment forbids states from formulating laws that limits liberty rights when the law is not sensibly associated with an acceptable state purpose (Cath & Shopper, 2013). And lastly, in the Virginia case of William III and William IV the child’s parents and paternal grandparents fight over visitation rights. The family of the child is whole, with both parents living together. There is no sign of neglect or maltreatment. The parents are deemed ‘fit’, and are able to meet their child’s social, educational, and financial needs. In 1994, the parents informed the grandparents that they were severing their connection or relationship with them (Weisberg, 2008). All of these cases demonstrate that the parental fitness assumption has been largely exercised in important custody cases. However, although the parental fitness assumption is undoubtedly important, it still has negative and positive effects on the family and life of children. One of the negative aspects of the parental fitness assumption is that the child of a non-biological parent who is awarded a share of parental obligations is at risk in several ways (Gopfert et al., 2004). For instance, the establishment of this legal association between the non-biological parent and the child does not settle government benefit concerns. When a non-biological parent is awarded parenting time and power, there could be no legal obligations to the child in question. There are courts that do not oblige the non-biological parent to provide child support (Weisberg, 2008). On the other hand, the positive aspect of the parental fitness assumption is apparent—it is based on the best interest of the child. Judges make sure that they base their decisions on this consideration. The biological parent, particularly the mother, is granted automatic custody based solely on the fact that mothers are selfless (Cath & Shopper, 2013). However, courts largely prefer the presence and involvement of both biological parents. In essence, parental fitness assumption promotes an intact family. Conclusions In child custody cases, the fitness of a parent is the main determining factor. Preference is given to the biological parents. The cases that were briefly discussed demonstrate how some states exercised the parent fitness assumption. There are numerous factors taken into account when determining the fitness of a parent, and judges make sure that they analyze these factors thoroughly and fairly. References Casenotes (2007). Family Law: Keyed to Courses Using Areen and Regan’s Family Law. New York: Aspen Publishers Online. Cath, S. & Shopper, M. (2013). Stepparenting: Creating and Recreating Families in America Today. New York: Routledge. Gopfert, M., Webster, J., Seeman, M. (2004). Parental Psychiatric Disorder: Distressed Parents and Their Families. UK: Cambridge University Press. Nolan, L. & Wardle, L. (2006). Fundamental Principles of Family Law. New York: Wm. S. Hein Publishing. Weisberg, D.K. (2008). Family Law. New York: Aspen Publishers Online. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Parental Fitness Assumption Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1480944-parental-fitness-assumption
(Parental Fitness Assumption Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1480944-parental-fitness-assumption.
“Parental Fitness Assumption Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1480944-parental-fitness-assumption.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Parental Fitness Assumption

Comparing Research Methods

Research provides the theoretical structure for understanding information reported by individual practitioners, and it tests assumptions and observations, and cerates new knowledge.... There is variety of research approaches, and research articles are written to contribute to the… owledge base of the discipline, and the topic tend to be highly specific in nature, which is written for the scholarly community, rather than a general audience....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

Argumentative Research

Every childs development is judged by their intellectual function, their inventiveness, their ego strength, their relatedness to their peers and adults, and capacity to deal with new events that come across their like each day in their social life, and that really depends on… The impact of society on family structure, roles and possessions has turned out to be obvious on the physical, emotional, cultural, social, moral, spiritual, adaptive and religious values in children's life style. The purpose of this dy is to describe the impact of societal issues that may affect children and their up brining; there are many researchers who wrote a lot regarding the impact of social set up on children....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

Technical Communication and Ethics

Therefore, the statement about the ease of operation should be changed, along with the drawing, so that the two agree on the assumption of this reasonable “fitness for a particular purpose” (Product, 2009).... rdquo;… The company has also placed a parental figure in the background of the drawing and included instructions with the drill telling the owner to keep the product away from children....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Residence discussion its pros and cons

This research paper is focused on shared residence discussion; its pros and cons, influence on children's interests and in the research paper the real value of shared residence in judicial and social system.... Shared residence is supposed to endow the child with multi-sided care and support.... hellip; A great interest to shared residence in the UK is explained by desire of justice system to serve for the sake of child's interests....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Blood Transfusions for Jehovahs Witness Children

The insistence of Jehovahs Witness parents on refusing blood transfusions for their children during the course of medical treatment raises a dilemma for the State on the appropriate level of intervention in family and religious life.... The United States has evolved a mature-minor… However, the courts have intervened on numerous occasions to compel a blood transfusion against the parents wishes in critical situations....
13 Pages (3250 words) Research Paper

Sports and Society: Impact of Sport on Cultural Beliefs

porting events, especially those which require rigorous physical activity, have also been linked to changes in the human condition in relation to establishing the psychological desire for fitness (Morris & Maisto, 8).... "Sports and Society: Impact of Sport on Cultural Beliefs" paper states that sporting activities can generate changes in society and enhance human condition; physically and mentally....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

The Current Status of the Sexual Strategies Theory

This paper "The Current Status of the Sexual Strategies Theory" first looks at the history that led to the development of the theory and then evaluates some of the strengths and weaknesses of the theory and discusses some of the further work that needs to be done.... nbsp;… One of the main points is that the evolution of human sexuality is connected to evolutionary biology....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Social Work in Assessing the Needs of Sexually Abused Children

This research “Social Work in Assessing the Needs of Sexually Abused Children” is going to provide a deep insight how social workers can apply the ecological approach in defining the psychological problems of the raped infants and how these necessities can be met by parents, family, and community....
16 Pages (4000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us