A Comparative Analysis between House Arrest, Electronic Monitoring, and Shock Probation - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The essay aims to address a two-fold objective to wit: to define and discuss house arrest, electronic monitoring, and shock probation, and to compare and contrast house arrest, electronic monitoring, and shock probation and determine their effectiveness…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.3% of users find it useful
A Comparative Analysis between House Arrest, Electronic Monitoring, and Shock Probation
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "A Comparative Analysis between House Arrest, Electronic Monitoring, and Shock Probation"

A Comparative Analysis between House Arrest, Electronic Monitoring, and Shock Probation The essay aims to address a two-fold objective to wit: (1) to define and discuss house arrest, electronic monitoring, and shock probation, and (2) to compare and contrast house arrest, electronic monitoring, and shock probation and determine their effectiveness. A Comparative Analysis between House Arrest, Electronic Monitoring, and Shock Probation Introduction Criminal sanctions are imposed to offenders as part of their criminal responsibility. During the 1800s, the rise of science and the development of positivist criminology have led to the development of more humane probation (Clear, Cole, & Reisig, 2009, p. 66). According to Regoli& Hewitt (2010), probation is defined as a sentencing option in which an offender is released into the community under the supervision of a probation officer (p. 313). The concept of probation started in 1841 when John Augustus became the first probation officer who assisted people convicted of crimes to avoid further criminal behavior. Because of positive results, the state of Massachusetts implemented the probation statewide in 1880. The used of probations was authorized by the federal courts and hired their first probation officers in 1925. Definition and Discussion A. House Arrest House arrest is defined as a court-imposed order in which the offender is legally confined to his or her own residence for a specific amount of time (Siegel& Bartollas, 2011, p. 106). Offenders are not allowed to leave their home except for work, school, and medical treatment matters. Offenders are also required to stay in their homes during evenings and weekends. House arrest ranges from several days to several years, depending on the sentence and degree of criminal liability. House arrest is administered either in probation department or judicial sentence monitored by surveillance officers. In line with these are electronic monitoring, fines, community obligations, etc. that are used in conjunction with house arrest. House arrest is used to punish an offender or to ensure offender’s appearance in a trial and to protect the community. B. Electronic Monitoring Electronic monitoring is used in conjunction with house arrest for individuals who commit more serious offences and to ensure that offenders comply with the house arrest orders. Electronic monitoring refers to the use ofelectronicequipment to verify that the offender is at home or in a community correctional center (Siegel & Bartollas, 2011, p. 107) and initiated in any of the four basic types of systems, namely: active phone line systems, passive phone line systems, remote location monitoring, and global positioning system (GPS). The active phone line systems has continuous signal from offender to the central office unlike passive phone line systems which lack continuous signals and involve random phone calls. Remote location monitoring involves a pager and voice verification method while GPS equipped the offender with a GPS receiver and microprocessor, limiting the distance of the offender to the receiver in only 100 feet. C. Shock Probation Clear, Cole, & Reisig(2009) defined shock probation as a sentence in which the offender is released after a short incarceration and resentenced to probation.It is also called as split probation (p. 78). The principle gives the offender the feeling of incarceration to shock them to abide the law and produce an individual reluctant to commit another crime or probation violation. Comparison and Contrast House arrest and electronic monitoring are both applied after a sentence. Meanwhile, shock probation is implemented during the period of release and until the court act on the case to sentence the offender to probation. House arrest and shock probation are simple and involve only the confinement of offender in the correctional facility while electronic monitoring uses high-technology equipment or gadgets for surveillance. Both house arrest and shock probation keep offender’s family relations intact and these two forms of probation are also applied in less serious cases. On the other hand, electronic monitoring is used in more serious criminal act and surveillance is needed to protect the community. Effectiveness House arrest is viewed as effective in lowering the expenditures of a correctional facility. It also gives opportunity to offenders to keep their jobs and their family relations intact. House arrest is flexible in the sense that it covers particular times of the day and controls particular types of offenders. Officers are able to make more frequent home and community visits in response to violation of house arrest orders. In an electronic monitoring, the issue in lowering recidivism is the main focal point of debate regarding its effectiveness. However, some studies found that electronic monitoring saved money and avoided new construction costs, without widening the net of social control. Electronic monitoring also reduced the likelihood of technical violations and proved to be an effective public safety alternative to prison. Shock probation is viewed as the most effective in limiting prison time, maintaining family ties, reintegrating the offender to the community, and reducing costs and populations of corrections. References Clear, T.R., Cole, G.F. &Reisig, M.D. (2009). The Punishment of Offenders. American Corrections (8th ed.) (p. 65-96) California: Thomson Wadsworth. Regoli, R.M. &Hewitt, J. D. (2010). Corrections in the Community. Exploring Criminal Justice: The Essentials (p. 312-322) Massachusetts: Jones and Bartlett Publishers, LLC. Siegel, L. &Bartollas, C. (2011). Intermediate Sanctions. Corrections Today (p. 98-121) California: Wadsworth, Cengage Learning. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“A Comparative Analysis between House Arrest, Electronic Monitoring, Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(A Comparative Analysis Between House Arrest, Electronic Monitoring, Essay)
“A Comparative Analysis Between House Arrest, Electronic Monitoring, Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF A Comparative Analysis between House Arrest, Electronic Monitoring, and Shock Probation


...?Probation Use of Probation and its Effect on the Correction System To understand and discuss the effects of probation on the correction system of any nation, at the outset, it is essential to have a clear idea about probation. Probation actually stands for the judgement of behaviour and abilities. In correction system, the offender is subjected to adherence of certain set of codes, regulations and rules under the supervision of a Probation Officer. This might instruct the offenders to discard the firearms and live in the place as directed or even to abide by the curfew in some of the cases. Offenders under probation can...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Electronic Monitoring and Employee Productivity

...such as trade secrets or restricted places, productivity as in employees have to be at the right place at the right time and doing the right things at the right time, reputation as employers do not want company information such as logos to be found at the wrong place that may cause them embarrassment and lastly impact on third parties such that the employer is mandated to do monitor them so as to protect the safety and health of their clients (Kaupins & Minch, 2005, pp1-10). On the other hand there are key ethical considerations that limit employee electronic monitoring. The first one is privacy such that employers need to balance between employee privacy rights and...
4 Pages(1000 words)Assignment

House Arrest: Annotated Bibliography

...? House Arrest: Annotated Bibliography Thesis ment: House arrest and electronic monitoring is an effectivemeans of punishment as an alternative to incarceration. Civic Research Institute. (2010). House Arrest/Home Detention. Probation and Parole Law Reports. A short article considering the right of due process as it applies to a particular case of house arrest that has no broader application. In the case being presented (Gonzalez-Fuentes v. Molina), the Puerto Rico Corrections Administration initially released a number of prisoners into a home release...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Comparative Analysis

...FHM and Cosmopolitan: A Comparative Analysis on Gendered Lifestyle Magazines Gender is commonly defined as a biological difference in the sexes. However, Eckert and McConnell-Ginet (10) maintains that gender is also perceived in terms of sexuality, sexual identity and desire that sexualizes traits and objects associated with masculinity and femininity. Because of this, gender difference is normatively used as a basis of heterosexual pull in literary works such as personality development books and lifestyle magazines. Some are themed according to the gender of the target reader population to specifically accommodate their needs and preferences in terms of individuality, career, relationships and sexuality...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay


...than as a stand-alone sanction. Electronic monitoring allows for long distance surveillance of offenders by either passive or active devices. Passive devices operate via radio transmissions in a wrist or ankle bracelet. Active devices use home telephones and computerized random calls to an offender's residence. Electronic monitoring is a component of many house arrest and ISP programs. Offenders may be sentenced directly to electronic monitoring, but some are placed on this sanction when jail crowding occurs, while others are placed on a monitor after violating a previous...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Electronic Monitoring System Implementation

...Electronic Monitoring System Implementation Table of Contents Executive Summary 2 Background 3 Business Reasons for Monitoring 4 Scope of Electronic Monitoring for business 6 Recommendation 7 Areas of implementation for Electronic Monitoring 7 Conclusion 8 Bibliography 9 Abstract This report presents a detailed analysis of implementation of electronic monitoring technology for measuring the productivity of employees. The uses of information technology are rising in every field of life, especially in business. Information technology is progressing day by day and providing significant advantages regarding the improvement of workers productivity. This research report comprises overview of new technology for electronic monitoring... ,...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

Comparative analysis

...………………………………………………….. D. Infrastructure development (Transportation facilities): Gold Coast and Sunshine Coast…... IV. Findings……………………………………………………………………………………….8 V. Conclusion……………………………………………………………………………………..9 VI. References……………………………………………………………………………………10 VII. Appendices………………………………………………………………………………….11 Comparative analysis I. Introduction Generally saying, behind every tourist hotspot, one can expect the rich history of planning and creativity of a few blessed minds. Worldwide, coastal areas, especially sea coasts with wide beaches attract millions of national and international tourists. As international tourism is blooming, the Gold Coast...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Comparative analysis

...Comparative Analysis Transcript analysis of non-model plants is the method through which many of the contemporary research in plants and various living matter uses to understand the various characteristics in these living products. The method is imperative because it ensures that there is specification of the particular product. An example is the fact that through transcript analysis, there is the assurance of identification of a specific epidermis. The epidermis of plants varies but it is imperative to understand that the normal or scientific microscope does not carry out effective work of determining the difference in plants of a similar species. Transcript...
10 Pages(2500 words)Assignment

Network monitoring and analysis

...LAN and other remotely established networks are prone to different kinds of internal and external threats. Denial of Services (DoS) is one similar threat posed to the networking infrastructure. It can virtually destroy in the entire network and halt the activities. Denial of Service is a malicious online activity that may be performed in number of ways. One very commonly pattern is that of flooding the network. The flooding can come along in the form of targeting the I.P addresses from external sources. Globally Denial of Service makes up for one of the most commonly used method of interpreting and disturbing the already established network transmission and communication (Das & Gulati, 2004¸p. 214). Indiscriminate requests... and other...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Electronic Monitoring/ House Arrest Exercise

... a more in-depth understanding of the concepts of house arrest and electronic monitoring, as forms of nonresidential graduate sanctions. Being immersed in activities that make one imagine assuming the place of offenders provided enhanced opportunities to appreciate the feeling of being free. References Alarid, L. F. (2015). Community-Based Corrections. Cengage Learning. Duhaime, L. (n.d.). Electronic Monitoring Legal Definition. Retrieved from Staples, W., & Decker, S. (2010). Between the home and institutional worlds: Tensions and contradictions in the practice of house arrest. Critical Criminology, Vol. 18, 1-20.... Electronic...
4 Pages(1000 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic A Comparative Analysis between House Arrest, Electronic Monitoring, and Shock Probation for FREE!

Contact Us