StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

High Court Will Rule on Gay Marriage by Jess Bravin - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "High Court Will Rule on Gay Marriage by Jess Bravin " discusses that generally speaking, many states have overturned the rulings, claiming that it is unconstitutional to essentially punish a lawfully married couple for being gay (Bravin par. 5)…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94% of users find it useful
High Court Will Rule on Gay Marriage by Jess Bravin
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "High Court Will Rule on Gay Marriage by Jess Bravin"

Using the example of Edith Windsor and Thea Spyer, a gay couple who had been together for over forty years, yet when Thea died, Edith was left with taxes that she would not have received had she married a man. This couple stands as the perfect example of how mistreated same-sex couples are, prompting the Supreme Court to hear their pleas for equality. The article comes to an end with a rundown of the various complications that may come as a result of the Supreme Court making a ruling on gay marriage and the fact that the Supreme Court is limited in its power when it comes to state law.

Mark Sherman and Dennis Junius’s article, “Obama Considers Weighing In on Gay Marriage Case” looks at the Obama administration’s decision to urge the Supreme Court to overturn California’s ban on gay marriage. President Obama made his stance clear since the first inaugural address that he support gay marriage and felt that gay couples should not be treated differently under the law. President Obama stated that “his administration would do whatever it could to promote that principle” (Sherman & Junius par. 8). However, these beliefs were primarily personal, and Obama set little in motion for taking the issue to a legal level. Sherman and Junius also point out the many limitations that the Supreme Court has in making a ruling, as well as the other options that proponents of gay marriage have.

The primary similarity between these two separate articles is that they focus on the ongoing battle to legalize gay marriage and allow same-sex couples to make use of the same rights that heterosexual couples receive upon marriage. Homosexuality has been a taboo topic up until a decade ago, and it continues to become more known, and the argument strengthened, as proponents speak up for the rights they believe that everyone deserves, regardless of who they love. In Bravin’s article, we see the steps that have been taken by the gay community and those that support the gay community to get their voices heard by powers that can overturn bans against gay marriage. In Sherman and Junius’s article, the debate has moved beyond what is expected of the Supreme Court and, instead, looks to how our current president can help the cause. The two articles both provide background and methods as to what is currently taking place in this fight for equality.

Another startling similarity is how the two articles focus mainly on the proponents of gay marriage and spend very little time looking at those that are opposed to accepting same-sex couples as legally married. While bias is not necessarily present in either article, all of the authors seem more concerned with a positive fate for same-sex couples and gay marriage supporters. This concern is seen in how the authors, along with providing background into the debates, also offer up additional routes that same-sex couples can take depending on the ruling of the Supreme Court. As a result, it becomes clear that same-sex couples have many avenues to continue their fight, though there seems to be a collective hope that the Supreme Court will find sympathy with those that desire equality with their partners.

A major difference found between the two articles is that the perception of the debate on same-sex marriage shifts from a select few homosexual couples and the Supreme Court, in Bravin’s article, to a much larger public audience, including many people who are not gay but support the importance of love being equal in the article penned by Sherman and Junius.

In this debate, President Obama, with his open views favoring gay marriage, is the individual to that proponents for gay marriage are turning their eyes. Instead of hoping that the Supreme Court and some lawyers will hear them, they now have a single, powerful individual who can stand up for them. The view in Bravin’s article is, in this sense, bleak, with the very little promise that the homosexual population will get their cries heard. Sherman and Junius’s article is more optimistic, and even though they still face the possibility that their cases will not yield the results they want, they have at least shaken up the world with their demand for equality. The topic of homosexuality is no longer taboo, but a reality for millions.

These articles divulging the battle of same-sex marriage focus on the topic of overturning states’ decisions to ban gay marriage, yet each article is from a different perspective. By showing the arguments from different perspectives, we can see the intensity of the fight that same-sex marriage proponents are facing. We can also see to what extent they are willing to go to receive the same rights that heterosexual couples receive, thus gaining the equality that the United States prides itself on. Despite the differences between the two articles, the resounding message is the same: all people deserve equality, and these proponents will not cease their pleas until this goal is met in its entirety. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Gay Marriage Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1469105-gay-marriage
(Gay Marriage Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/english/1469105-gay-marriage.
“Gay Marriage Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1469105-gay-marriage.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF High Court Will Rule on Gay Marriage by Jess Bravin

Education in Pennsylvania

This essay "Education in Pennsylvania " discusses different visions for funding education in Pennsylvania that are expressed by a past governor and the present governor.... Pennsylvania slashed nearly one billion dollars in funding for K-12 and Higher education last year.... ... ... ... Now the current governor wants to take the cuts to public education to a new level....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Falsehood of abortion

The subject of abortion is very controversial.... Persons who are for abortion claim that the country was founded on personal freedoms which include the right of choice – even the choice to abort an unborn child.... ... ... Abortion The subject of abortion is very controversial.... Persons who are for abortion claim that the country was founded on personal freedoms which include the right of choice – even the choice to abort an unborn child....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Role of Online Social Networks in Affecting Daily Life of People

The essay "Role of Online Social Networks in Affecting Daily Life of People" critically analyzes the role of online social networks in affecting people's daily life.... The 21st century has given man numerous gifts.... Life changed completely and permanently with the birth of social media networking....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Family Law and the various areas that are involved in the legal processes

Some of these pertinent subjects that are found to be discussed throughout this researched literature are in realms of: the breakdown of marriage, same sex marriages, welfare of children, domestic violence, gender equality, and a few other points of interest that have a part to play in the role of the family within the UK.... marriage is the main consideration given to this research along with the new laws that have been adapted to include same sex marriages and how they are viewed in the public eye....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Acute Pneumonia and Critical Nursing

On admission he was recorded to have high fever accompanied shaking chills, sharp pleuritic chest pain, headache and sweaty and clammy skin.... This essay stresses that critical care nursing is the special case of nursing that deals with patients facing light threatening problems and it is the critical care nurse whose responsibility is to ensure that the critically ill patient and his or her family receives optimal care....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Florida's Capital Punishment System

This report "Florida's Capital Punishment System" presents the concept of capital punishment that has evolved radically with the passage of years and as the ages have passed, people have grown from accepting capital punishment to being against it regardless of the degree of assault.... ... ... ... Capital punishment is considered a waste of life and also it is said that the receiver of capital punishment dies even before he is given punishment for his sins....
10 Pages (2500 words) Report

Negative Impacts of Separation or Divorce on Children and Adolescents

ccording to Martin and Fabes (2008) children and adolescents whose parents have separated are at a high risk of suffering from emotional distress due to: poor economic status throughout their life; anti-social behaviors which only send them away from their peers, and in the adverse scenario in jail; poor performance in academics, considering that the distress could hamper regular attendance of or concentration in school....
12 Pages (3000 words) Literature review

Why Did George Bush Win the 2004 Election

For example, Bush's evangelical approach in his first term, against stem cell research, abortions, and gay marriages had appeased the religious conservatives.... In this paper "Why Did George Bush Win the 2004 Election?... , the authors attempt to probe the question- What were the factors that led President George W....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us