The immigration debate - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Our minds have somehow been trained to view these undocumented workers as the bad guys who take jobs away from legal Americans. But a closer scrutiny of the…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.2% of users find it useful
The immigration debate
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The immigration debate"

The Immigration Debate When we think of illegal immigrants, the first thing that enters our mind is underground competition in the workforce. Our minds have somehow been trained to view these undocumented workers as the bad guys who take jobs away from legal Americans. But a closer scrutiny of the situation proves that this fear is not based on any logical explanation. That is because the salary that undocumented workers receive, although lower by about 20 cents per hour, is paid out to people who are willing to be paid to do jobs that regular American high school drop outs are not willing to do. In other words, the undocumented workers may take jobs away from Americans, but these are jobs Americans did not want in the first place. Rather, the illegal immigrants are doing us a favor by accomplishing the tasks that Americans find to menial for their tastes.
In the overall scheme of things, illegal immigrants actually provide a larger benefit to the American economic system by adding at least $10 billion a year to our GDP. A small contribution to an overall GDP of a $10 trillion economy but an increase none the less and in our current national economic state, every little bit helps to ease the burden of inflation on the public. By boosting our GDP, these workers have actually proven that a larger workforce, regardless of employment status, will actually make a difference when it comes to worker output and/or consumer spending ( Said, Carolyn “The Immigration Debate”).
Instead, the illegal immigrants who are working for us should be considered unsung heroes who actually contribute to the system. the Social Security system to be precise . The only problem is that since this batch of employees do not use valid SS numbers, their contributions remain floating within our system. So rather than debating the effects of illegal immigration on the workforce or economy, what we should really be looking at is a way to help make the contribution of these workers a part of the economic system of the country since those contributions are currently located in an economic limbo where it remains useless to everyone concerned.
Works Cited
Said, Carolyn. “The Great Immigration Debate”. News. San Francisco Chronicles. 21 May 2006. Web. 17 Apr. 2012. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“The immigration debate Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 words”, n.d.)
The immigration debate Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 words. Retrieved from
(The Immigration Debate Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 Words)
The Immigration Debate Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 Words.
“The Immigration Debate Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The immigration debate


...? Palestinian vs. Israeli Debate of the of the Concerned July 12, Palestinian vs. Israeli Debate It goes without saying that throughout the history of the Arab-Israel conflict, Israeli’s solution and response to the Palestine issue has been predominantly military. Time and again, Israel has not only responded to the popular Palestinian aspirations with military might, but also the tactics adopted by the Israelis have been brutal and lethal in their approach and ramifications. Since the onset of this conflict Israel has killed a large number of innocent and unarmed men and women, children and the aged. This amounts to a gross violation of the established Military Rules of engagement, UN conventions and the...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper

Analyze the Conventional Wisdom Regarding the Iliegal Immigration Debate

...?Analyze the conventional wisdom regarding the illegal immigration debate The conventional wisdom regarding the illegal immigration debate is based upon the arguments in favor of and against illegal immigration. To be specific, the illegal immigrants, the human rights organizations and activists are in favor of illegal immigration. On the other side, politicians and others in America are against illegal immigration. From a different point of view, both sides have justifiable reasons to put forth their arguments because illegal immigration is an unresolved issue in the American society. Besides, the arguments on illegal immigration deeply influence the development of conventional wisdom on the same subject. Thesis statement... : The...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay


...?DEBATE on “Managers should leave their personal values at home. Their role is to maximize shareholder values” Shareholders of the company are the major source of generating the funds for the company in the form of investments. Company approaches shareholders with the purpose of generating source of investment for the company (Smith, 2003). Therefore it is an essential responsibility of the company managers to maximize the return for its shareholders. The return is given in the form of dividend or in the form of shares (David, 2007). Shareholders invest in the company with the purpose of gaining profits and every profit oriented firm always seeks for maximizing the shareholders value (Roe, 2000). Shareholders value refers...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay


...? Free Trade Free Trade Introduction International trade is term used to refer to the process of exchanging goods as well asservices between two different nations through the process called import and export. The emergence of the concept of international trade took place along with the hot debate of implementation of the police of trade protectionism and free trade. Nations that adopt trade protection policies tend to impose restrictions on the number as well as kind of goods and services that can be imported in a particular nation with the objective of restricting the number of imports. Nations that adopt free trade policies tend to remove or decrease policies that can result in restriction of the number and kind of...
3 Pages(750 words)Coursework

Immigration Debate

...Political Science The immigration debate is complex with few, if any, ‘right’ answers of how to both be pragmatic regarding the costs associated with illegal immigrants and compassionate with regards to the human element involved. The issue lies squarely within the responsibility of the Federal government because individual states and local communities do not have the capability on their own. Many have, however, attempted to deny access to housing, schools, medical treatment and social programs to non-citizens. Some argue that U.S. laws apply to all within its borders, legally or not such as the Fifth Amendment right to due process of law. The laws certainly apply to all when they...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

Illustration of Federalism The Immigration Debate

...Task Illustration of Federalism – The Immigration Debate Why are so many s passing immigration reform measures? Are all of these measures the same? What is a common thread of many of these bills? Many states are passing immigration reform measures because the federal government has not addressed the issue of illegal, immigrants and they continue to stream in all the states. The laws are not the same, but they have some similar legislation such as offering some form of identification other than the driving license, not employing immigrants, and rejecting admissions of immigrants to schools. Briefly describe the key...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

German debate ignores need for educated immigrants THE IMMIGRATION DEBATE / Effect on economy depends on viewpoint

...THE IMMIGRATION DEBATE Back in 1961, Germany and Turkey signed an agreement to bring thousands of Turkish Gastabeiterto work in the coal mines and steel factories. This provided inexpensive labour supply that has helped the Germany’s booming post war economy. Presently, the Turkish are regarded as the largest ethnic minority in the country. A debate on whether to integrate them in the education system is a pressing issue that has seen Chancellor Angela Merkel to be intermittently changing her take on the issue. One day, she is in support the Turks and seemed to embrace immigration but on another day, she condemns it. The cultural and economic problems of integration...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay


...Disciplining Children with Special Needs Disciplining Children with Special Needs Many parents and teachers often have a misconception that with special needs do not require the same standards of discipline with typically developing children. Different authors have expressed their opinion about disciplining children with special needs. Although the majority of the authors agree that, all children need discipline. However, children with special needs deserve the same standards of discipline with typically developing children. This paper will highlight the reasons why it is fair to discipline children with disabilities as typically developing children. According to Nelson et al (2011), all children, irrespective... Children with Special...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment


... ID Number & Speech Presentation on Native American Reparations Recently, Baker published an article on Digital Journal saying that President Barack Obama signed a legislation awarding “$4.5 billion in reparations to the American Indians and Black farmers”. To start my speech presentation, allow me to explain to you what reparations are all about. Basically, the concept of reparation is part of the international law which pertains to the need to restore the damages that the injured parties have encountered as a result of wrongdoings or a violation of the people’s human rights (Goldberg). Reparations can be in the form of restitution. In most cases, restitution can happen by restoring liberty, social status, employment, family... ID Number &...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

AAS 201 Debate: Should we support undocumented immigration

...Undocumented immigration Introduction The term illegal immigration can be defined as trespassing the borders of another country and violating the laws set on immigration in that particular country. The countries that experienced a low economic and social status are the ones where many immigrants originate. The hope for a good economic gain is the major cause of the cases of immigration although there are other causes. The process of illegal immigration is not only achieved by the crossing of the borders. There may be cases where an individual entered the country legally, but later violated the terms of the visa. He or she may overstay...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The immigration debate for FREE!

Contact Us