Nobody downloaded yet

Free Will and Personal Responsibility - Case Study Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
People are given the gift of freewill. But we also know that our culture, education and the values taught to us greatly influence how we make our decisions. In that aspect, can we say that our will is totally free Or is our will always bound be the influences of everything that surrounds us hence we are never free
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.1% of users find it useful
Free Will and Personal Responsibility
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Free Will and Personal Responsibility"

Download file to see previous pages To prove the superman theory, they murdered a fourteen year-old boy named Bobby Franks. Also, they committed the murder of Franks to prove that they were intelligent enough to outsmart the police and create the perfect crime.
However, because of the negligence of leaving behind Leopold's glasses near the dead body, the police was able to prove that they were the perpetrator of the crime. Ultimately, they had been convicted for the crime that they committed.
The defense counsel of Leopold and Loeb presented a closing argument justifying the murder committed against Franks. The main argument of the closing speech is that Leopold and Loeb's act of murdering Franks was a necessary consequence of their background, their upbringing and the principles of Nietzsche. According to the defense counsel, all these factors drove them to killing another person. The combinations of said factors afforded no other result other than the horrific crime committed. As such, Leopold and Loeb could not be held responsible for their actions. Therefore, they should not be punished for killing Franks.
To support this argument the lawyer presented the three points. First, Loeb's and Leopold's upbringing served as a breeding ground for a twisted sense of morality. Loeb was raised by a governess who pushed him too hard on his studies. It was because of the strictness of the governess that Loeb was swayed into rebellion. And the form of rebellion that he took is to read detective stories that were forbidden to him.
Loeb's fascination lead to him to observe that in all these stories, the detective always wins. The detective always figures out the puzzle to the crime. Because of this, he became challenged. He became captivated and obsessed to formulating the perfect crime - one that may not be solved by the brightest detective.
Leopold on the other hand was an intellectual. Because of this, he was accelerated in school. On the downside, he failed to develop this emotional part of his being. He was so smart that he took a liking to Philosophy, particularly the teachings of Nietzsche. And Nietzsche believed that an intelligent man is above the law and morality.
The second thing that the lawyer pointed out is that with the fascination in detective stories, it is but understandable that a highly intellectual person would be challenged to formulate an undetectable crime. They would prove that the detectives do not always win. From the lawyer's point of view, because of this challenge, it was natural that they create the perfect crime. Hence, Loeb cannot be faulted for his creation. The strictness of his governess and the challenge brought by detective stories was to be blamed for his action.
The third point that the lawyer raised for Loeb and Leopold's defense is the teaching of Nietzsche. Nietzsche was strong in his teachings that the intelligent man is not bound by the ordinary rules in morality. Than in fact, the superman is the law by himself. Leopold firmly believe this. And because of which, what else can be the result but a series of acts defying the law and morals
The last defense that the lawyer raised was that of insanity. He claimed that who in their right mind would exchange ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Free Will and Personal Responsibility Case Study”, n.d.)
Free Will and Personal Responsibility Case Study. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1532535-free-will-and-personal-responsibility
(Free Will and Personal Responsibility Case Study)
Free Will and Personal Responsibility Case Study. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1532535-free-will-and-personal-responsibility.
“Free Will and Personal Responsibility Case Study”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1532535-free-will-and-personal-responsibility.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Free Will and Personal Responsibility

Free Will, Determinism and Moral Responsibility

...?(In)Compatabilism: Free Will, Determinism and Moral Responsibility Introduction To all individuals belongs a free will or the unique ability to control their actions. Free will is directly connected to two other vital philosophical concepts: freedom of action and moral accountability. In other words, a person who has free will is able to choose his or her route of action without coercion. Not only human beings, but also animals have a measure of free will that they exercise. This fact adds fire to the discussion since typically, only human beings are thought to possess free will1. This philosophic research study delves into the theories of free will, determinism, and moral responsibility and shows the relationships, exceptions... , external...
13 Pages(3250 words)Term Paper

Humanistic and Existential Aspects of Personality

...and therefore, not fully understandable in terms of general laws. They saw humans as creative, possessing free will, striving for goals and the fulfillment of potentials and strongly craving meaning and significance. Existential approach focuses on the individual’s subjective experiences, free will and ability to responsible for his own existence. It believes in free will and the ability of man to choose the way he wants to live the life. It believes that the meaning of the life can be understood by means of free will and personal responsibility. For example a student passing out of high school has complete choice to...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Human Behavior

...will is questionable, since our genetic and neurological inheritance is in place from conception, and that inheritance will determine our likelihood of being aggressive, deviant, violent, and criminal. He says, “Because we did not choose the factors that affected the formation and structure of our brain, the concepts of free will and personal responsibility begin to sprout question marks” (Eagleman). Since the man that went on a shooting spree had a brain tumor, he, Eagleman argues, didn’t have freedom of choice. His ailment compelled him to commit the crime as it would compel anyone suffering from the same type of tumor. Eagleman seems to set forth the argument that, since we now have...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Personal Responsibility in College Life

...? Personal Responsibility in college life What Personal Responsibility means Though we must all recognize the equal objective importance of the success of a human life, one personal has the special and final responsibility for that success - the person whose like it is – Ronald Dworkin These words of philosopher and scholar Dworkin truly speak about the critical importance of understanding and taking the personal responsibility to assure the success in different facet of life (Brown, 2009). One could not attain success in life until he learns to take the personal...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Personal Responsibility

...?Personal responsibility is a willingness to acknowledge, respect the important standards set for individual behavior and make a deliberateeffort to abide and live by them. This means that when the student does not meet their own goals, they shoulder the blame and not attempt to lay it on other people or external factors. Personal responsibility entails understanding the choices one makes willing to accept the consequences of these choices in view of how they will affect other people (Mergler et al, 2008). Consider two students leaving an exam room; A says “I think I failed that paper, but it is not my fault that teacher never taught us any of the real stuff that was...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Personal Responsibility to Nature

... Personal Responsibility to Nature Living in a country where energy is scare and thus in high demand, oil becomes one of the most ludicrous commodities desired by many—not only by oil companies, but also by peoples in different sectors who can further their self-interests through supporting more oil drilling. The recent oil spill at Gulf of Mexico, however, arouses public awareness on to what extent should we exploit natural resources without causing great environmental and economic harm to the country. Also, it raises the question on how we can individually and collectively pose a positive change to the current situation where the struggle between the natural environment and the commercial sector...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Determinism, free will and moral responsibility

...). Of course, heredity and environment play great role in our actions, but I think that free will can depend on personal moral responsibility. Blatchford asserts that our actions can be predictable. Our nature and heredity determine our acts; this statement fits for famous persons too (Napoleon, Lincoln). In addition to that he claims that his work The Delusion of Free Will "disposes of the claim that man is responsible be cause his will is free" (Blatchford, p. 107).So, we can say that Blatchford is a representative of hard determinism. But there is a question. What about twins who live together and therefore have the...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Free Will and Moral Responsibility

...and responsibility as understood by Hume. The classical understanding reduces the problem of responsibility to merely a problem of free will. This is a massive simplification of Hume's theory of responsibility. Hume also sees intentional action as indicative of the durable principles of the mind. This must be true or else an agent could not be held responsible for their actions. Where (actions) proceed not from some cause in the character and disposition of the person who performed them, they can neither redound to his honour, if good; nor infamy, if evil. (Hume 1910: 386) This claim does not sit easy in itself. For if carried to its...
24 Pages(6000 words)Book Report/Review

Personal Responsibility

...Annotated Bibliography Brown, A. (2009). Personal responsibility: why it matters. New York: Continuum International Publishing Group The book contributes to the debate about the personal responsibility and its implications to the contemporary world. The author insists that the success and failure of any person is in his own hands and he bears the responsibility for his end. The book explains the issue by looking at the philosophical theories and political ideologies. The book is very relevant source for the essay because it mainly focuses upon the topic of personal responsibility and provides significant explanation to basic concept of personal responsibility. The issue has been discusses from philosophical, political and social... and...
2 Pages(500 words)Annotated Bibliography

Personal Responsibility and Individual Accountability

...theme and which designer was well-equipped to handle a peculiar kind of task. On the job, Alan learned a great deal about being responsible, getting things done in an effective and efficient way, to liaise with the remaining team members, to manage his own self, gain interdependence and properly align his working regimes with the time slots which were devoted to his individualized as well as team’s works. (Keigher, 1996) Alan taught me that it was all about passion to do something in a particular field and to have a certain belief that a person can actually do it. He taught me that being responsible does come from within, more so if the destination is in sight. Also motivation is a much...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Case Study on topic Free Will and Personal Responsibility for FREE!

Contact Us