Nobody downloaded yet

Is there any value in E.H. Carr's dictum: 'before you study the history, study the historian' - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
E.H. Carr's dictum: 'before you study the history, study the historian' describes that the facts of history do not come to the readers as intact as it could be because they do not exist in "pure" form, they always come with the interpretation of the user of facts (Tosh 2006)…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.9% of users find it useful
Is there any value in E.H. Carrs dictum: before you study the history, study the historian
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Is there any value in E.H. Carr's dictum: 'before you study the history, study the historian'"

Download file to see previous pages He traced his family background through the great Whig historian, George Otto Trevelyan and by doing so he investigated the origin and development of the Whig tradition. And even though it is not the only interpretation of Queen Anne's reign, it is a valid and, in Trevelyan's hands, a fruitful interpretation (Trevelyan 1949).
Thus to appreciate significance of a history, the reader should know and understand what the historian is doing. Collingwood (1994) states that historians must re-enact in thought what has gone on in the mind of his dramatis personae, so the reader will also re-enact what goes on in the mind of the historian. Thus reading a work of history should be coupled with listening to what is 'bubbly'. If one cannot detect something, there is something wrong with how the history was understood or how it was presented. The facts here were treated like fishes swimming in a vast ocean which is sometimes inaccessible to anyone. What the historian catches will depend partly on chance. His choices on what part of the ocean to fish and what equipment to use will depend on the kind of fish he wants to catch. By that, the historian will get the kind of facts he wants. Thus, history means the interpretation of the historian (Carr 1961).
Another example of how the philosophy of British historian E. H. ...
it was the image of his father which dominated and obsessed his being . . - and even the icy detachment and indifference of Lord Randolph failed to destroy the proud and passionate allegiance of his sonUntil the end he worshipped at the altar of his Unknown Father. (Carter 1965)
It was seen in his writings that Winston Churchill provides a considerable evidence of filial hero-worship. In Thoughts and Adventures, he writes that: the greatest and most powerful influence in my early life was of course my father. . . .1 conceived an intense admiration and affection for him - and, after his death, for his memory, I read industriously almost every word he had ever spoken and learnt by heart large portions of his speeches. Indeed, the workings of Winston Churchill about his father, Randolph could be best understood in this context.
The views of Collingwood on the philosophy of history could expound more the E. H. Carr's dictum. It was told that the history is neither "the past by itself" nor with "the historian's thought about it by itself," but both in their mutual relations. This reflects the two current meanings of the word "history" - the enquiry conducted by the historian and the series of past events into which he enquires. Collingwood argued that the past is meaningless to the historian unless he can understand the thought underlying it. Thus, it could be said that "all history is the history of thought," and "history is the re-enactment in the historian's mind of the thought whose history he is studying." According to Professor Oakeshott, whose point stands near to Collingwood, "history is the historian's experience (Oakeshott 1933).
Carr's dictum mirrored his stance on relativism. ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Is there any value in E.H. Carr's dictum: 'before you study the Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Is There Any Value in E.H. Carr's Dictum: 'Before You Study the Essay)
“Is There Any Value in E.H. Carr's Dictum: 'Before You Study the Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Is there any value in E.H. Carr's dictum: 'before you study the history, study the historian'

E-Commerce - Case Study

...theft in principle is the taking of the identity or impersonating a person in any legal or extra legal transaction before another party. To illustrate in the context of the case on hand: B has impersonated A by using his username password combination to gain access to A’s account in Freegames. A can file a suit against B for identity theft and damages for the tarnished image that A has suffered evolving around the incident. In actuality, it should be B who should pay A for the amount Freegames has collected from A. This position is anchored on the following arguments; it was B who directly benefited from the games that B has procured from Freegames using his username-password combination. It was B who...
17 Pages(4250 words)Essay

E-Marketing Case Study

...?E-MARKETING By: a) There various key stakeholders of HP. These stakeholders include the HP s who have been identified in the case study by Chakraborty and Govind (2008, p. 1) as the young and old, consumers and professional who the Executive Vice President, Personals Systems Group, HP refers to. In addition, Goodby, Silverstein & Partners who are the advertising agency of HP are the other stakeholders of HP. The customers and businesses are recognized as key stakeholders given the emphasis they received in the first HP advertising campaign as observed by Chakraborty and Govind (2008, p. 1). It is only when an organization considers a group as a key stakeholder that they can invest on a...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Labs H, P, & S

...of refraction (Snell’s La): Where: n1 refractive index of air =1 n 2 refractive index of glass. Theoretical refractive index of glass= 1.52 Therefore: Moments of Force (Experiment H) PURPOSE: The purpose of this experiment was to demonstrate the concepts of equilibrium and moments of force. PROCEDURE: The equipment and materials that were used during the experiment included: meter, a 2’ by 4” by 4” wood block, different cans of food, weights, and 2 nails (2-3”). The wooden block was placed on top a level surface and two nails driven in the middle of the block. A meter was placed on the nails at the 50 cm mark of the meter; the meter balanced at this position. Weights were then placed on one side of the meter, and a...
3 Pages(750 words)Lab Report

E-Business Case Study

...this. These are all value creating activities on the value chain. This has been efficiently defined in its e business platform. 2.1 Solving the Problem of Supplier evaluation and Selection at Wal-mart Planning for the future is an important strategic decision for any organisation if it has to cope with the pressure of competition and expansion. Strategic choices mean finding alternatives solutions to the problems faced by the business unit. The problem of supplier quality management requires seeking solution to customer's loyalty, creation of long-term relationship with suppliers and stakeholders, collaboration with other dealers and not competition, creating an...
16 Pages(4000 words)Case Study

E-Business Case Study

...e-Business The internet that has now emerged and matured, presents a paradigm shift in its very ideation. The infrastructure has acquired a businesscharacter, a transcontinental personality and a vending framework of wide-ranging, business, educational, scientific and personal data. Now its use covers real-time computer conferencing, audio broadcasting, video broadcasting, real time telephony and of course real-time business. E-business in its simplest form can be described as doing business in electronic form. Electronic business is the extensive use of computers, communication technology, networking technology and computerized data to perform business processes. In other words, e-business is any system of suppliers, distributors... the...
16 Pages(4000 words)Essay

E-marketing Case Study

...fixed by companies and nations for themselves marks a growth potential for Real estate and mortgage sector as well, because that means better infrastructure activities and upgrading of the existing facilities. At the same time it is also worthwhile here to mention that the e-Market space is coming up as a formidable alternative, as the customer feels more comfortable to know everything before accepting the services of the company. E-business is more than just e-commerce. It involves business processes spanning the entire value chain: electronic purchasing and supply chain management, processing orders electronically, handling customer service, and...
2 Pages(500 words)Case Study

Case Study or Roger S

...Coordinator. A copy of the “Report of Injury to Employee” must be submitted to Environmental Health and Safety (EH&S) for review and follow-up (Injury and Illness Prevention Program Department Plan, 2006). In cases of emergency, the employee should go to the nearest emergency room facility for immediate treatment, and being the injured worker should inform the employer immediately after the treatment. Otherwise, he should inform his employer of the injury before seeking any medical care. Upon notification, the employee should be provided a first aid treatment in the site if available; otherwise he must be brought to the company clinic for treatment. The examining physician is required...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Study case S

...admitting that they had stopped adding gum strips on the tyres more than a year back. This would ensure its credibility as well as trust among the customers it dealt with by showing responsibility that they valued the people’s lives more than monetary gains from their business. Answer 4 Yes, the company must recall the tyres from the market because gum strips are major safety measures for the tyres. The absence of those strips makes it unsafe for the drivers of the vehicles using these tyres. It would also put the passengers as well as pedestrians’ life at risk as there would be likely more accidents. Answer 5 When Imperial says that Hang Zhem Hai should pay for any recall, they are actually relying...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

EH&S professional case study

...First EH&S professional case study In order to analyze this case study, the scenario can be listed as follows: Liquid – Dangerous when wet, UN1836, Class 8, red-yellow color. NFPA diamond – Red (0): non-flammable, Yellow (2): reacts violently with water, Blue (4): extremely dangerous to health. Surroundings – water spray 20-25 yards away. Nearest populated area – one mile away. Nearest helping squad – fifteen miles away. Now we take a look at what best can be done in this scenario. Priority list - First priority would be to get help. Immediate help can be obtained by getting someone who knows about such circumstances. Since I have just come one mile away from the population zone, I can look... for help from someone in the small town 1 mile away. Next, people specialized for such work must be called to deal with it. This can be done by calling the hazardous material team from 15 miles which is trained under me. Take care no one goes towards the scene. This can be done by being in the vicinity of the accident but also taking full precautions of own self. To do this, I would need to read the instruction of the guide book. Action items - Call the hazardous material team trained in my plant which all necessary equipments. In the meantime, look into the emergency guide and follow the instructions for preventing any damage. Take care that dripping liquid does not flow over to wet ground or does not come in...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

E-Learning Case Study

... of simply be not disclosing to the respondent that they were participating in a research study. References Agostinho, S. (2004). Naturalistic inquiry in e- learning research. International Journal of Qualitative Methods, 4(1): article 2. Retrieved from Anderson, C.A., Lindsay, J.L., & Bushman, B.J. (1999). Research in the psychological laboratory (truth or triviality?) Current Directions in Psychological Science, 8: 3-9 Barlow, D.H. & Hersen, H. (1984). Single case experimental designs. New York: Pergamon.... . There are inherent factors which are mentioned in the eight step verification which are not fulfilled in this empirical study. The...
2 Pages(500 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Is there any value in E.H. Carr's dictum: 'before you study the history, study the historian' for FREE!

Contact Us