Critical Analysis of BMJ article on systemic review of the literature - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The research question formulated seems to explore and expand the knowledge on the subject but not to a substantial level; one reason could be that the question is not much clear and it could have been improved. The investigator was able to highlight the significance of the topic and explain the methodology with its objectives…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.6% of users find it useful
Critical Analysis of BMJ article on systemic review of the literature
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Critical Analysis of BMJ article on systemic review of the literature"

Download file to see previous pages The investigator followed the logical sequence and could comment on the work already done in the area. He was able to discuss on the gaps in the literature.
Though the investigator described the methodology used and completed the study following literature review but the methodology used was not as suggested for this purpose while presenting rationale for this research. The investigator critiqued that the previous reviews were either narrative or quasi-experimental design and could not assess the effectiveness of the isolation measures therefore, he proposed a better review for valid inferences. The best methodology for this purpose is meta-analysis which has been described by Glass as "Meta-analysis refers to the analysis of analyses...the statistical analysis of a large collection of analysis results from individual studies for the purpose of integrating the findings."
Although this research was carried out through a literature review process but in individual studies the investigator focused on the experiences of the patients; their stay in the hospital, course of disease and any other accompanying feature.
The methodology and processes used in the analysis of the data were very well narrated and elaborated by the investigator, which reflects the grasp of the investigator on the subject area. He remained unbiased in the analysis of the literature review as he gave full attention to the errors and the issue of bias involved in these studies at individual level.

8. Credibility:
The evidence of the ownership of the participants in the research could not be explored and validated. An explicit expression regarding this finding was not found.

9. Audability:
The investigator has been successful in keeping the reader with him. He has been able to keep the interest of the reader alive. Although the review is difficult than meta-analysis to follow because the latter has got more scientific components involved especially at the level of analysis which uses some statistically methodology and this way makes the process simpler one.

10. Fittingness:
Yes, findings of the study are generalizable. Out of the final 46 studies, 32 were with the findings, which were similar to the measures taken for MRSA reduction anywhere. Eighteen of these were weak as far as methodology or interpretation of the results was concerned while six were the strongest which were longer time series studies. This way methodology was the central point that contributed much in the strength of any study to be ranked high for more reliable results and generalizability.
11. Confirmability:
Yes, the findings of the study convey the whole message as far as the experience of different players involved, the ownership, the understanding of the reader and application of the research findings. Even though the methodology was not strong for the subject (literature review vs. meta-analysis) but the investigator ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critical Analysis of BMJ article on systemic review of the literature Essay”, n.d.)
Critical Analysis of BMJ article on systemic review of the literature Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1525172-critical-analysis-of-bmj-article-on-systemic-review-of-the-literature
(Critical Analysis of BMJ Article on Systemic Review of the Literature Essay)
Critical Analysis of BMJ Article on Systemic Review of the Literature Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1525172-critical-analysis-of-bmj-article-on-systemic-review-of-the-literature.
“Critical Analysis of BMJ Article on Systemic Review of the Literature Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1525172-critical-analysis-of-bmj-article-on-systemic-review-of-the-literature.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Critical Analysis of BMJ article on systemic review of the literature

Critical Literature Review

...of National Innovation Systems in France and Korea’, Technology Analysis & Strategic Management, Vol. 19, No. 4, pp. 451 – 470 Havas A., Schartinger D. and Weber M. (2010) ‘The impact of foresight on innovation policy-making: recent experiences and future perspectives’, Research Evaluation, 19(2), pp. 91 – 104 Moore M. and Hartley J (2008) ‘Innovations in Governance’, Public Management Review, Vol. 10 Issue 1, pp. 3 – 20 Magalhaes C. and Carmona M. (2006) ‘Innovations in the Management of Public Space: Reshaping and Refocusing Governance’, Planning Theory and Practice, Vol. 7, No. 3, pp. 289 – 303 Lovett G (2009) ‘Ideo collaborative public-sector pilot heads for roll-out’, Design Week,...
6 Pages(1500 words)Literature review

Critical Literature Review

...include: technical and engineering studies, agro foods, chemicals, parachemicals and pharmaceuticals, information technology and electronics.” (OECD, 1998, p. 83). Threats and challenges always come bundled with the adoption of any technology and the information technology is no exception. This critical review will investigate the adoption of ICT by SMEs in general and manufacturing firms of United Kingdom in particular, specially the challenges and threats of ICT faced by these firms. The availability of trained technical manpower to handle the IT infrastructures within SMEs, the security of information and infrastructure and availability of information to all facets of the internationalized businesses...
6 Pages(1500 words)Literature review

Critical Literature review

...way, harmonized by the investment in the local communities for justifiable business reasons. It is noteworthy that different corporations implement corporate social responsibility differently due to their varied nature of business. Depending on a business priorities and core values, a corporate social responsibility is manifested in form of incentives and the business processes. Existing literature on corporate social responsibility has associated this practice to ethical ad moral conduct of business. Thus corporate social responsibility is perceived as an obligation not only to the law but also long term aims for the good of the community, which the business serves. In this sense, corporate social responsibility...
6 Pages(1500 words)Literature review

Article literature review

...Article Literature Review Article Literature Review The article “Advertising Practices for Self-image Projective Products in the New Europe” deals with the question that confronts international advertisers on whether advertising messages should be standardized or localized for markets around the world (Seitz & Johar, 1993). The decision of making advertisements localized is based primarily on cultural factors. According to Douglas and Dubois, as cited by Seitz and Johar, “cultural factors affect advertising in four ways namely: 1) the choice of advertising theme; 2) the connotation or worlds and symbols; 3) the way pictorial conventions are interpreted; and 4) media selection” (1993). To determine the degree of standardization... strategy...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Critical review of Literature

...than for others. These factors mean that interventions for alcohol dependency in children and young people have to vary slightly from standard interventions. As a public health topic, alcohol dependency in this age group is important as it can help to normalize certain behaviours (Lembke, 2011), which may further the problem. Alcohol itself is one of the biggest burdens on the NHS, as it can lead to problems with the cardiovascular and digestive systems (Lembke, 2011), as well as causing dementia and related psychiatric problems. The purpose of this research is to explore which interventions for alcohol dependency in the 10-17 age bracket are most appropriate, and should inform policy guidelines on the matter. To do...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper

Literature Article Review

...Article Review: Facebook Profiles and Personality Here Here Here Here Article Review: Facebook Profiles and Personality Introduction A 2010 article by Back and colleagues examines the validity of the personalities projected through personal Facebook profiles. The authors introduce this topic by referring to the large number of people that currently use Facebook (and other online social networks like MySpace). The consequences of this mass participation include the integration of Facebook in everyday social activities, as well as changes to the landscape of communications. A common assumption, by the public and scientific community alike, is that profiles...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper

Literature Article Review

...Personality Literature Article Review Here Here Here Here Personality Literature Article Review Introduction A 2010 study by DeYoung and colleagues examined the relationship between personality, brain structuring, and the Big Five Personality Inventory. Their experiment was motivated by the desire to examine potential biological correlates of the popular personality test. The authors explain that while personality research has revealed a wealth of information about various aspects of the concept (DeYoung, 2010), little has been revealed about the neurological structures that underlie the formation and influence of individual traits...
2 Pages(500 words)Article

Systemic review

...System Analysis: How Financial Incentives Influence Weight Change System Analysis: How Financial Incentives Influence Weight Change Introduction All over the world, weight has been considered important in determining fitness and beauty, with some cultures favoring heavy weights and others slim people. In a quest to fit in with the expectations of the environment around, one seeks to either gain weight or loose. On the rise, has been the opinion that lighter people, are better looking. More importantly though, there are health concerns that come with the weight of an individual. The biggest concern about weight has not been gain, rather its loss. Health concerns such as...
11 Pages(2750 words)Essay

Critical literature review

...Critical Literature Review: Performance Management Introduction Performance Management is a process of continuous and uninterrupted flow of communication among employees and their supervisor so that strategic purpose of the organization is properly communicated to the employees. This helps the employees to become motivated to achieve the purpose and accordingly enhance their performances (Bennett, Lance and Woehr, 2014). Many researchers are of the opinion that sustainable management of employee performances and introducing best practices in this regard, is the key to success for any organization. Best practice in performance management is regarded as using the most professional, standard...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment

Critical literature review

...GLOBALIZATION AND INCOME INEQUALITY al Affiliation Globalization is increasingly associated to inequality, but with normally divergent findings. Many researchers show that globalization activities accentuates inequality in income both within and between nations. This paper presents a detailed review of current literature that links globalization among countries of the world to inequality. The article concludes from the existing literature that the concern of globalization and inequality is real particularly those in developing nations. The paper recommends that there is need for developing nations to unite, adopt policies and contracts that serve their actual cause to...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Critical Analysis of BMJ article on systemic review of the literature for FREE!

Contact Us