StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Critical Analysis of BMJ article on systemic review of the literature - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The research question formulated seems to explore and expand the knowledge on the subject but not to a substantial level; one reason could be that the question is not much clear and it could have been improved. The investigator was able to highlight the significance of the topic and explain the methodology with its objectives…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.3% of users find it useful
Critical Analysis of BMJ article on systemic review of the literature
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Critical Analysis of BMJ article on systemic review of the literature"

Download file to see previous pages The investigator followed the logical sequence and could comment on the work already done in the area. He was able to discuss on the gaps in the literature.
Though the investigator described the methodology used and completed the study following literature review but the methodology used was not as suggested for this purpose while presenting rationale for this research. The investigator critiqued that the previous reviews were either narrative or quasi-experimental design and could not assess the effectiveness of the isolation measures therefore, he proposed a better review for valid inferences. The best methodology for this purpose is meta-analysis which has been described by Glass as "Meta-analysis refers to the analysis of analyses...the statistical analysis of a large collection of analysis results from individual studies for the purpose of integrating the findings."
Although this research was carried out through a literature review process but in individual studies the investigator focused on the experiences of the patients; their stay in the hospital, course of disease and any other accompanying feature.
The methodology and processes used in the analysis of the data were very well narrated and elaborated by the investigator, which reflects the grasp of the investigator on the subject area. He remained unbiased in the analysis of the literature review as he gave full attention to the errors and the issue of bias involved in these studies at individual level.
8. Credibility:
The evidence of the ownership of the participants in the research could not be explored and validated. An explicit expression regarding this finding was not found.
9. Audability:
The investigator has been successful in keeping the reader with him. He has been able to keep the interest of the reader alive. Although the review is difficult than meta-analysis to follow because the latter has got more scientific components involved especially at the level of analysis which uses some statistically methodology and this way makes the process simpler one.
10. Fittingness:
Yes, findings of the study are generalizable. Out of the final 46 studies, 32 were with the findings, which were similar to the measures taken for MRSA reduction anywhere. Eighteen of these were weak as far as methodology or interpretation of the results was concerned while six were the strongest which were longer time series studies. This way methodology was the central point that contributed much in the strength of any study to be ranked high for more reliable results and generalizability.
11. Confirmability:
Yes, the findings of the study convey the whole message as far as the experience of different players involved, the ownership, the understanding of the reader and application of the research findings. Even though the methodology was not strong for the subject (literature review vs. meta-analysis) but the investigator ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critical Analysis of BMJ article on systemic review of the literature Essay”, n.d.)
Critical Analysis of BMJ article on systemic review of the literature Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1525172-critical-analysis-of-bmj-article-on-systemic-review-of-the-literature
(Critical Analysis of BMJ Article on Systemic Review of the Literature Essay)
Critical Analysis of BMJ Article on Systemic Review of the Literature Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1525172-critical-analysis-of-bmj-article-on-systemic-review-of-the-literature.
“Critical Analysis of BMJ Article on Systemic Review of the Literature Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1525172-critical-analysis-of-bmj-article-on-systemic-review-of-the-literature.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Critical Analysis of BMJ article on systemic review of the literature

Critical Literature Review

...?Critical Literature Review. The phenomena of “modernism” and “postmodernism” have been defined in many ways but one of the clearest is that of Sarupand Raja who simply state that the period is one of “enormous and astonishing social change” which “is bound up with the emergence of new ways in which we experience space and time.” (Sarup and Raja: 1996, p. 94) At the start of his book on the self and modernity Giddens uses the analogy of divorce to explain the extra pressures that modernity brings to people. Although traditional society was always subject to unforeseen events and even catastrophes, interpersonal relationships in previous times tended to require more stable and fixed modes of behaviour. The way to behave was more readily...
7 Pages(1750 words)Literature review

Critical Literature Review

But one thing which certainly can be implemented is innovation in governance, the way of operating of its public sector organizations. This review critically examines cases of innovation in governance style and differentiates them from private sector product and process innovation. Critical Review Lot has been written on private sector innovations of products and processes but not much on public sector innovation. Governance innovations in public sector require and deserve greater attention as they go beyond the organizational boundaries to involve other public/private sector organizations, leads to a network based decision making leading to a more efficient implementations and tap new pools of resources among existing resources...
6 Pages(1500 words)Literature review

Critical literature review

..., the method of interview was used to serve the objectives of healing relationships with three processes resulted as fostering healing relationships-valuing non-judgmental emotional bond, working in a way to serve the maximum facilitation for patients and displaying a caring attitude towards patients. Critical evaluation of these articles serves the objectives of this literature review. The methods, data, outcomes and theories enlisted in both articles are going to be made part of this process of assessment with a critical look. Have these two articles really served the way for which they were planned? Have these objectives provided something useful towards the process and practice of healing? These are the fundamental questions...
12 Pages(3000 words)Literature review

Critical Article Review

... system work in the United States, what determinant factors constrain it, and how improvements with regards to the shortcomings that have been previously mentioned might be affected within the future. The particular piece in question first references the fact that a case study which will be performed is concentric upon the state of California. Naturally, this choice of tests case analysis is especially important and useful due to the fact that California is the largest state by population and represents perhaps the greatest level of regional diversity that any state within the system has to offer. As such, the article itself increases the level of believability and relevance due to the fact that it has chosen to analyze the most diverse...
5 Pages(1250 words)Article

Article Critical Review

...? Article Critical Review Article Critical Review Introduction The article that this paper will analyse is A Facebook ‘Friend’ Request from the Boss: Too Close for Comfort? by Katherine Karl, Joy Van Eck Peluchette and Jason Fertig. This article seeks to explore ways how employees could react when they get Facebook friend requests from their superiors. The main findings of the article are that some people react negatively, and others positively depending on their thought of why their superior has sent to them the friend request. Summary Making use of most of the information from self-presentation, developmental networks and leader-member exchange (LMX), Peluchette, Karl & Fertig (2013, 291) endeavour to explain how workers may react...
3 Pages(750 words)Literature review

Critical review of article

...Review of “A salutogenic approach to men’s health” Summary “A salutogenic approach to men’s health” by John Macdonald in his book “Environments for Health” discusses the requirement for revamping of men’s healthcare services. In the article Macdonald is concerned with the biased views and policies of healthcare and its providers. He suggests a completely new salutogenic approach to policymaking and giving healthcare to men. He argues that although men are considered the dominant sex, they are also a victim of genderization and stereotypes. For example ‘men are not in touch with their emotions’, ‘men are violent’ and especially ‘men don’t go to the doctor’. This type of stereotyping has had adverse affect on men’s healthcare and alienated...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Article literature review

...Article Literature Review Article Literature Review The article “Advertising Practices for Self-image Projective Products in the New Europe” deals with the question that confronts international advertisers on whether advertising messages should be standardized or localized for markets around the world (Seitz & Johar, 1993). The decision of making advertisements localized is based primarily on cultural factors. According to Douglas and Dubois, as cited by Seitz and Johar, “cultural factors affect advertising in four ways namely: 1) the choice of advertising theme; 2) the connotation or worlds and symbols; 3) the way pictorial conventions are interpreted; and 4) media selection” (1993). To determine the degree of standardization...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Literature Article Review

...Personality Literature Article Review Here Here Here Here Personality Literature Article Review Introduction A 2010 study by DeYoung and colleagues examined the relationship between personality, brain structuring, and the Big Five Personality Inventory. Their experiment was motivated by the desire to examine potential biological correlates of the popular personality test. The authors explain that while personality research has revealed a wealth of information about various aspects of the concept (DeYoung, 2010), little has been revealed about the neurological structures that underlie the formation and influence of individual traits (Jackson, Balota, & Head, 2012). Most of the existing research on personality is based on theorization...
2 Pages(500 words)Article

Critical article review

... Sociology article review By Lecturer’s and Globalisation now gives a second encounter between the global issues and sociology as interpreted by latest theories of sociology. Ideas brought forth by a group of thinkers lies significantly to their social location, that is, from sociology of knowledge. Contemporary sociological thought therefore bears unique significance to globalisation theories which name the world-as-a-whole, their object of knowledge, including in principle the global south and providing a way of social theory overcoming its most devastating historical limitations. The scope of sociology at its establishment in the 19th century current evolutionary speculation, and later as an academic discipline was unquestionably...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Systemic review

...System Analysis: How Financial Incentives Influence Weight Change System Analysis: How Financial Incentives Influence Weight Change Introduction All over the world, weight has been considered important in determining fitness and beauty, with some cultures favoring heavy weights and others slim people. In a quest to fit in with the expectations of the environment around, one seeks to either gain weight or loose. On the rise, has been the opinion that lighter people, are better looking. More importantly though, there are health concerns that come with the weight of an individual. The biggest concern about weight has not been gain, rather its loss. Health concerns such as obesity, hypertension and arteriosclerosis have not gone to help...
11 Pages(2750 words)Essay

Characteristic of Murder Scenes in Literature

...The following work analyzes two murder scenes, one of which is extracted from chapter forty-five of Perfume, a novel written by Patrick Süskind, and the other from chapter eleven of Thérèse Raquin, one of Emile Zola’s most famous literary works. In Perfume, Grenouille, the main character, murders a young girl in order to extract her scent which forms the ultimate ingredient required to successfully create his exquisite perfume. The enchanting odour of this perfume would serve Grenouille’s goals as it would make him hypnotize people.On the other hand, in Thérèse Raquin,Thérèse ,an adulterous wife, gives her consent to Laurent, her lover, to kill her own husband,Camille,as he’s the osbtacle standing against their mariage... following work...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

Analysis of the Methods of 3 Research Papers about Child Abuse

Research ethics was maintained as the identity of the individuals participating was kept secret. As far as the validity of the study was concerned, the researchers attempted to use content validity in order to get an accurate response. The content validity focused on measuring off the ethnicities and gender percentages within the area and attempting to get a random sample of individuals via the phone. Their approach to random calling allowed for a significant random sample in the study. There were a few issues, however, with this type of approach. Those answering the phone sometimes were not always the desired individual, and not all of the desired people were surveyed. Different replacements did have to be used, and the attempt w...
6 Pages(1500 words)Literature review

Airbus A 380: SWOT and Porters Five Forces Analysis

...INTTRODUCTION This paper is about the European Aero manufacturer, Airbus and its latest offering, the Airbus A 380. Much has been written about theAirbus A 380 and how it is the next generation of aircraft that makes it easier for long haul flights to carry more passengers with fewer or no stops enroute. After the Airbus A 380 was introduced, many called it a revolution in air travel with its emphasis on luxury travel as well as better amenities for economy class travel. In this paper, I look at the Airbus 380 from a critical perspective by analyzing the competition and using tools like SWOT and Porter’s Five Forces. STRATEGIC POSITION In this section, I look at the strategic position of Airbus in the context of the parameters that have...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

Economic Analysis on BMW Cars in the US Car Industry

Mini and the 1-series rapidly grew at a much higher rate through 2008. Since the early days of the new millennium, BMW has been one of the first automakers to utilize flexible factories in which more than one vehicle model could be produced at the same time. This enabled the company to meet shifts in market demand more effectively than BMW’s competitors could. BMW challenges to retain its market position in the international market for luxury cars. Many automakers, such as Hyundai with its Genesis sedan or Nissan's Infiniti brand are increasingly successful in realizing higher margins earned on luxury vehicles. BMW is rated behind luxury brands such as Lexus, Porsche, Mercedes, and Infiniti for these reasons

1. Th...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

Analysis of Educational Website

... Analysis of Educational Website Introduction Since antiquity, education remained a major component of human societies; however, until few decades ago, it existed in the society in its traditional and conventional form that involved one-to-one interaction of teachers with their students in classrooms. Since few years, educators and scholars have witnessed rapid advancements in the field of information and technology that has altered almost every sector of the society in a rapid manner, and so the education sector as well. In such advancements, internet has now become one of the most popular platforms for students, teachers, businesspersons, and individuals from every sector to acquire education and information within few clicks and minutes...
7 Pages(1750 words)Article

Analysis of Articles about Climate Change

...Climate change Can we imagine an Earth where there are no green mountains, no deep blue seas and no living creatures? No. But a disaster of such magnitude and dimension is looming over Earth. Humans have identified this threat, defined it and given it a name, global warming. This dangerous proposition is based on the truth that even a 5 % increase in the surface temperature on Earth can wipe out life from this beautiful planet. And the temperature is increasing as never before. It was in 1990s that the world began to hear serious warnings on global warming and climate change. The summary for policy makers prepared as part of the first assessment report by Inter-governmental Panel on Climate Change was the first ever in depth... change Can we ...
6 Pages(1500 words)Literature review

10 Answers about African American Literature

This sentence describes where Linda gets her strength and hopes in achieving her freedom. Her hopes came once again from hearing her father’s voice as she passed through the old meeting house. Bringing this picture up in this part of the story actually emphasizes the soft voices of those who have been enslaved before, that these people did not put down their plans and hopes for freedom even until their death. That is why in this scenario, the whispers of his father’s voice are very effective for her renewed hopes.

2. “The calm, deliberate composure with which he spoke of his late deeds and intentions, the expression of his fiendlike face when excited by enthusiasm, still bearing the stains of the blood...
9 Pages(2250 words)Assignment

Analysis of Employement Law Cases

For instance, Section 82(1) of the Sex Discrimination Act 1975 provides statutory protection to workers who are working under a contract personally to execute any work or labor. It also covers self-employed people2.

Other statutes, such as the Working Time Regulations 19983 and the National Minimum Wages Act 19984, are appliable to workers, in addition to employees5. Hence, all these rights and protections are available to Fred, even if he were to be deemed a self-employed person.

Some of the more important rights bestowed upon employees by the employment law are the right to claim wrongful or unfair dismissal and payment for redundancy. Other legislation, such as the health and safety statute and the insolve...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

Analysis of the Oil Industry

In 2001 alone, the US reported earning from the industry close to two hundred billion US dollars. According to a previous study, the middle east tops the list as the largest exporters of crude oil taking over sixty-six percent of the global production of oil. Europe is the least producers of oil taking only two percent of the market share (Green, 4).
According to the American Association of Petroleum Geologists, the major problem facing the industry is lack of workforce and the increase in demand for oil. The report indicated that by 2030, the world’s oil demand is expected to increase from one hundred and three to one hundred and thirty million barrels per day. Natural gas, on the other hand, will expectedly increase t...
7 Pages(1750 words)Coursework

CNN Inernal and External Analysis

There are quite a few news channels serving the American news-hungry people. When it is not reading the news, CNN offers critiques and insights into news items
Coming to brass tacks, CNN was the first US Cable Channel which offers 24 hours round the clock news. “It operates one of the top 24-hour news channels, reaching more than 100 million US homes. In addition to its flagship channel, the company offers HLN (formerly CNN Headline News), and it has an international division that keeps viewers informed in about 200 other countries.” (Cable news network Inc: Company description, 2010).

Perhaps one of the most conspicuous aspects of CNN is that it has an excellent contact network and reporters on the spo...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Critical Analysis of BMJ article on systemic review of the literature for FREE!

Contact Us