We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Critical Analysis of BMJ article on systemic review of the literature - Essay Example

Comments (0)
The research question formulated seems to explore and expand the knowledge on the subject but not to a substantial level; one reason could be that the question is not much clear and it could have been improved. The investigator was able to highlight the significance of the topic and explain the methodology with its objectives…
Download full paper
Critical Analysis of BMJ article on systemic review of the literature
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample
Critical Analysis of BMJ article on systemic review of the literature

Download file to see previous pages... The investigator followed the logical sequence and could comment on the work already done in the area. He was able to discuss on the gaps in the literature.
Though the investigator described the methodology used and completed the study following literature review but the methodology used was not as suggested for this purpose while presenting rationale for this research. The investigator critiqued that the previous reviews were either narrative or quasi-experimental design and could not assess the effectiveness of the isolation measures therefore, he proposed a better review for valid inferences. The best methodology for this purpose is meta-analysis which has been described by Glass as "Meta-analysis refers to the analysis of analyses...the statistical analysis of a large collection of analysis results from individual studies for the purpose of integrating the findings."
Although this research was carried out through a literature review process but in individual studies the investigator focused on the experiences of the patients; their stay in the hospital, course of disease and any other accompanying feature.
The methodology and processes used in the analysis of the data were very well narrated and elaborated by the investigator, which reflects the grasp of the investigator on the subject area. He remained unbiased in the analysis of the literature review as he gave full attention to the errors and the issue of bias involved in these studies at individual level.

8. Credibility:
The evidence of the ownership of the participants in the research could not be explored and validated. An explicit expression regarding this finding was not found.

9. Audability:
The investigator has been successful in keeping the reader with him. He has been able to keep the interest of the reader alive. Although the review is difficult than meta-analysis to follow because the latter has got more scientific components involved especially at the level of analysis which uses some statistically methodology and this way makes the process simpler one.

10. Fittingness:
Yes, findings of the study are generalizable. Out of the final 46 studies, 32 were with the findings, which were similar to the measures taken for MRSA reduction anywhere. Eighteen of these were weak as far as methodology or interpretation of the results was concerned while six were the strongest which were longer time series studies. This way methodology was the central point that contributed much in the strength of any study to be ranked high for more reliable results and generalizability.
11. Confirmability:
Yes, the findings of the study convey the whole message as far as the experience of different players involved, the ownership, the understanding of the reader and application of the research findings. Even though the methodology was not strong for the subject (literature review vs. meta-analysis) but the investigator ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
Literature Review Analysis
This tried to build the connection of CCCs on the effectiveness of different disinfection alternatives for contact surfaces. Contact surfaces were emphasized to be the integral parts of microbial dissemination among children (Jimenez, Martinez & Chaidez, 2010).
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay
Competitors Analysis Critical Review
Organisations find it difficult to predict trends within the marketing environment. Therefore, they have to have short and long-term strategic plans in place
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay
Critical review of article
He suggests a completely new salutogenic approach to policymaking and giving healthcare to men. He argues that although men are considered the dominant sex, they are also a victim of genderization and stereotypes. For example ‘men are not in touch with their emotions’,
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
Article literature review
According to Douglas and Dubois, as cited by Seitz and Johar, “cultural factors affect advertising in four ways namely: 1) the choice of advertising theme; 2) the connotation or worlds and
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Your own words outline the role of critical appraisal in relation to published research articles, mentioning in your discussion strengths and weakness as well as the utility of critical appraisal as a research tool
Investigating the research methodology of an article, scrutinizing the methods of data collection and analysis used and evaluating how the findings are the presented helps an individual to determine if the conclusions of that article should have
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
xplanatory in nature; it explains what the study/article is about, for instance, it tells the reader that the article is about a control framework that results from strategic lean manufacturing initiative. It should be noted that, the abstract for this article is brief, concise
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
Critical Article Review
main characters, there was Jim, the eleven-year old son of Marion and Collin, who seemed to exhibit anxieties in having to face apparent ridicules from the death of his father due to AIDS. The main argument in the article was that people, who were left with the death of a loved
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Systemic paper review
This paper will research a review of articles that factors the perceived influence to the performance and motivation of nurses. The improvement of nurses’ performance will be done by looking at the relationships between
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
Critical article review
cal thought therefore bears unique significance to globalisation theories which name the world-as-a-whole, their object of knowledge, including in principle the global south and providing a way of social theory overcoming its most devastating historical limitations. The scope
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Systemic review
More importantly though, there are health concerns that come with the weight of an individual. The biggest concern about weight has not been gain, rather its loss. Health concerns such as obesity, hypertension and
11 Pages(2750 words)Essay
Let us find you another Essay on topic Critical Analysis of BMJ article on systemic review of the literature for FREE!
Contact us:
Contact Us Now
FREE Mobile Apps:
  • About StudentShare
  • Testimonials
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Free Essays
  • New Essays
  • Essays
  • The Newest Essay Topics
  • Index samples by all dates
Join us:
Contact Us