StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Subverting the Processes of Peer Review - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The supposed noble stem cell discovery Hwang Woo Suk led should have been so significant that its controversy had become an issue on medicine, ethics, and politics. It had incurred an enormous funding both from public and private sectors in and outside Korea…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.9% of users find it useful
Subverting the Processes of Peer Review
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Subverting the Processes of Peer Review"

Download file to see previous pages Hwang was indeed a brainy researcher. He had efficiently kept his collaborators, manipulating them with their own personal motives. With that, he had managed to maintain his established credibility within the span of his research and prominence.
Hwang was a national hero in South Korea and was rose to fame after claiming a series of remarkable breakthroughs in the field of stem cell research. Despite the notable absence of any of the scientific data needed to probe the validity of his research, Hwang's several claims were well received by the South Korean media and public. They have been so attracted with his claim of immeasurable economic prospect that his research was said to be promising (Wikipedia, 2008). With such renowned standing, he maintained and expands his research team. Building it in a rigid hierarchical structure had made him extremely dominant among his researchers regardless of their titles.
His collaborators worked for his fraud and some had even so consistent with their support despite the arousal of controversies. With their firm determination to back him up, he had managed to publicize his said noble study. Dr. Roh head of Seoul fertility clinic had agreed to collaborate with Hwang despite the anomalous way of obtaining the egg cell from paid donors and two of their junior researchers. When the controversy was exposed he even publicly admits the deed claiming that he was solely responsible and Hwang was unaware of the said anomaly. This was to cover up despite the fact that Hwang himself had distributed egg donation consent forms to his researchers and even personally escorted one to the MizMedi Hospital to take the egg extraction procedure. All these fabrication were for the assured credit on what had been thought as a promising research.
In Hwang's laboratory, every order must be followed having him as a supervisor. Two of his junior researcher had even donated their eggs despite the inconvenience of the procedure. At a point, one of the researcher/donor in her attempt to disclose the fact had retracted her statement due to alleged coercion. Moreover, his team obediently follows when Hwang told them to make it look as if there were 11 stem cells when not even half that number was there. These were with the knowledge that they would have credit on the published discovery. On the contrary, all their efforts in the research would be wasted if they would disclose the fact.
After having acquired a celebrity status in South Korea, Hwang actively sought to establish every possible tie to political and ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Subverting the Processes of Peer Review Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
Subverting the Processes of Peer Review Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1505136-subverting-the-processes-of-peer-review
(Subverting the Processes of Peer Review Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Subverting the Processes of Peer Review Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1505136-subverting-the-processes-of-peer-review.
“Subverting the Processes of Peer Review Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1505136-subverting-the-processes-of-peer-review.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Subverting the Processes of Peer Review

PEER REVIEW

...PEER REVIEW Leadership and management can be differentiated when one of the two aspects is done without the involvement of the other. Leadership can be described as the setting of a new bearing or a vision for a grouping and must be followed (Kellerman, 2001). Contrary, management is the body that controls or directs individuals and/or property in a set according to doctrines or principles that are already established. In the interrelationship of these two aspects, leadership without management offers a vision without a direction on how success can be achieved (Peters, 2000). For this reason, management is an essential combination for any successful leadership. A leader has to ensure that they are able to reach the highest leadership...
1 Pages(250 words)Book Report/Review

Peer Review

...PEER REVIEW DRAFT 1 Are there any additional details that could be included to help you better understand the essay? What is missing or unclear? Details needed for a first time reader to gain deeper understanding of how far the story has come was missing. This detail was very important especially against the backdrop that the writer basis on the previous component of the story to pass a very arguable judgment that the Indians are still not treated well in society today. 2 What part of the essay is most memorable? Why? The most memorable part of the essay is the portion where revelation is made that up to today, not much effort has been made to better the sovereignty of lesser groups by refusing to implement regulations and policies...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Peer review ( critical review)

...Romantic Relationships: A Thematic Analysis Task: Romantic Relationships: A Thematic Analysis Sources have revealed that, there is insufficient literature on romantic relationships at adolescence and early adulthood. Consequently, there have been numerous debates and theories, which have sought to offer their explanations for the nature of romantic relationships at the two phases (Royer, 2009). Accordingly, the study has sought to explore the comparison between romantic relationships at the adolescent stage and during the early adult phase of an individual. The researcher has employed samples amounting to ten participants, who are among his acquaintances. The samples entail equal number of men and women; five men and five women... Relationsh...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Peer review

... use more plausible and better media to record and use in the study. The fizzy photographs were inadequate and failed to arouse any significant emotion from the scene. ANOVA test was appropriate but it failed to validate the hypothesis. The study is also not scientifically presented and lacks essential imperatives of research like literature review, efficacy of variables was not explained and data analysis was merged with results. In all, while the results of the study give important insight into the eyewitness account of the scene of crime, the authenticity of the same cannot be scientifically validated. I would, as such, not cite the study. Recommendations (for publication) Hypothesis should be well defined. Sampling should comprise...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Peer Review

...Book Report Review Article Article I is a well laid out argument that centers around the ‘Disconnectedness’ between the consumer and the producer. It deftly argues that the 20th century has seen a major revolution of the food industry in more ways than one. The days of purchasing the locally grown farm fresh food, cooking at home and maintaining a healthy diet are all a thing of the past because giant corporations have forced themselves into the food markets and presently dominate the whole food industry. The sources are well knitted together, with each idea being explained in a new paragraph without being in anyways redundant. The information or data collected for this write up comprises of both scholarly as well as web related material...
1 Pages(250 words)Book Report/Review

Peer Review

Introduction Breastfeeding in public is a sensitive topic for some. Many are offended when a woman is nursing her toddler in a public place, such as the park or at an airport. There have been many incidents at restaurants and retail stores where nursing mothers were asked to stop breastfeeding or were asked to leave because it was “distracting”or was considered “indecent” for the public eye. Many were told to move to the bathroom, the most unsanitary place for a baby to be feeding.
While some discourage public breastfeeding, doctors encourage mothers to nurse as much as possible. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, approximately 76 percent of mothers start breastfeeding immediately after birth, but on...
2 Pages(500 words)Book Report/Review

Peer review

...Peer Review al Affiliation Peer Review The research touches on a weighty and timely theme that has continued to affect the society particularly in a metropolitan state such as United States. Discrimination in the provision of health services can be fatal to any individuals as it may have a long-lasting impact. Arguably, the topic of the research can be rated as excellent. However, the mode of presentation has clouded out the main item of research and key findings. As a piece of research, it should have clear headlines and subtopic and fluency to enable the learner identify the topic quickly. In this case, the research paper lacks coherence as points are jumbled all over the work without a clear consistency of the flow of thoughts...
1 Pages(250 words)Coursework

Peer review

...Review of “Diabetes and the DIAMONDS Device” Significance The project addresses an important problem because diabetes mellitus, especially Type 2 diabetes, requires close glucose monitoring, in order to provide timely insulin injections. The main aim of the project is to provide a hassle-free, efficient, and effective way of managing diabetes, especially for children who may face the most struggles with having injection shots, at least 4 times a day. If DIAMONDS attains its objective, it can improve the technical ability of diabetic patients in managing their illness. The project can also advance scientific knowledge because it can offer information on the various conditions that may impact the body’s production and use of insulin...
4 Pages(1000 words)Assignment

Peer review

Group Discussion Board BUSI 600 Group Discussion Board: Forum 2 The post presents significant strength in the question from which the hypothesis is derived. Many people do not understand how to effectively derive. A correlation hypothesis is meant to measure the strength of a relationship between two variables. Therefore, the first thing to do when conducting a correlating hypothesis is to identify the main variables. This hypothesis clearly identifies the two variables which are sales and per capita. A relationship between Per capita income and sales is created and the cause effects clearly determined. In addition, other factors that have an influence is sales are identified. These factors as stated include; low interest loans,...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Peer review

...Health Care Provider and Faith Diversity: First Draft Qi Ci Huang Grand Canyon HLT-310V Foundations of Spirituality in Health Care RobertVaughan (Instructor) May 31, 2015 Abstract When providing care to patients who come from a variety of backgrounds with numerous different faiths, understanding basic traits of a patients faith or culture enables providers to give quality health care. However, often times there is a lack of understanding coming from the providers in regards to a patients faith as providers often look at the patients physical body but not their spiritual body. In order to explore the importance of the spiritual body two faiths with opposing views will be analyzed and compared with each other, Christianity... Care Provider and ...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

An Analysis of the Differences in Brain Processes of Males and Females during Language Tasks

Such is the case with the development of cognitive functions and language skills. While the brain may have complexities that we simply haven’t even yet scratched the surface of, seemingly every day there are advancements in our knowledge of brain functions.

MRI’s and various cognitive function tests have shown that males and females use different parts of their brains while performing the exact same language tasks; the biological basis for this is due to the organizing effects of testosterone and estrogen. Females have long been known to be slightly ahead of males as far as language skills at younger ages, but this could also be attributed to the fact that overall females develop earlier than males and reach...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

Infrastructure Application and Review: France

Referring specifically to the country’s water network, Jacobson et al. (1995) notice that ‘although waterworks facilities in France are predominantly government-owned, private firms operate and manage most systems under an array of contracting and leasing arrangements’ (Jacobson et al., 1995, online article). The above study describes the general terms under which the development of infrastructure systems in France is progressing. It should be noticed at this point that in France, the government’s policies regarding the development of infrastructure systems were not always effective – moreover, they were rather limited. Indeed, in a report published by the OECD in 2005, it is noticed that ‘in 19...
9 Pages(2250 words)Case Study

Critical Review of 4 Papers about Education

The author argues in this article that the real problem between races in Great Britain goes beyond individuals that discriminate and hate one another base don race. He argues that institutional racism is a real problem. Part of the problem is that Citizenship Education has been touted as the cure for the nation’s racial strife. The author argues that Citizenship Education does little more than making people feel good because it looks like the government is doing something to address the problem. In reality, the author contends that Citizenship Education acts as a placebo. He argues that it is impossible for the institution to eliminate racism if the institution itself is racist.

Much of the author’s foundati...
10 Pages(2500 words)Assignment

Development and Influences of Peer Sociability

Children’s social development is strongly characterized by peer experiences and friendships during middle childhood. These experiences tend to have a strong influence on children’s cognitive abilities and their social worlds. As children tend to go out of their homes and start mingling with others, whether at school or in the neighborhood, their exposure to the world outside of family increases along with spending more time with a diverse set of friends of the same age.
Adolescence, in other words, replicates and incorporates previously mastered stages of development. Adolescents are characterized by rapid physical growth due to physiological changes; they too tend to expand their social horizons much wider and d...
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment

Pathophysiological Processes Involved in Type Two Diabetes

Changes in lifestyle and behavior, in particular, sedentary jobs combined with lack of exercise and an increase in disposable income combined with lower food prices, have resulted in a veritable explosion of type 2 diabetes. Left untreated, type 2 diabetes can lead to a series of complications and illnesses and a high incidence of premature morbidity. However, over-rich nutrition and the resulting obesity are not the only risk factors as there are different levels of susceptibility to type 2 diabetes in different ethnic groups.

According to statistics released by the World Health Organization (WHO), currently, 180 million people worldwide have diabetes, with 2.9 million deaths per year occurring due to complications cau...
9 Pages(2250 words)Coursework

Critical Review of Goth: Identity, Style and Subculture by Paul Hodkinson

The allure from this standpoint is seen by the author. This report measures mainly the methodology that Hodkinson uses, which is grounded theory research, and the report also examines questions of fixed vs. flexible research. The findings of the research are briefly presented before the current research investigation concludes.

The Goth subculture is founded on principles of viewing some of what society outside this subculture, or mainstream culture, views as abhorrent or negative. There is some fetish tendency in this subculture towards the macabre and death, with face-paint style makeup and mourning clothing being prominent features of belongingness, which are certainly not reflective of mainstream fashion and makeup....
6 Pages(1500 words)Book Report/Review

Word Formation Processes in English

While I have been learning French for years, yet, only basic concepts like the meanings, pronunciations, and basic grammar rules are concerned, I want to understand more about the linguistic aspect, especially the morphological one, of the language. This includes the formation processes of French words and how the French internet languages are different from the traditional word-formation processes. I as well want to discover new information on the computer-mediated languages to improve my informal understanding of both English and French. I am also eager to learn more about the morphological word formation so that I can become a better language teacher.
Linguists categorize words as the small units of syntax within a given l...
12 Pages(3000 words)Assignment

Critical Review of General Electric

... intense pressure from shareholders and stock analysts to produce the returns expected of it, a 4,000% increase in stock value over the 20-year reign of Jack Welch. General Electric today has clearly lost its footing, its firm grip on markets gradually eroded. It has ceased to be the financial juggernaut derived from its engineering expertise by venturing into so many un-related business areas that it has lost its core competencies in the process. Its much vaunted invincible market share has been torn to shreds by its lesser rivals. To better understand what is wrong with General Electric, it is best to re-examine its whole corporate strategy and structure in light of a changed economic environment. There is a debate going whether G.E...
12 Pages(3000 words)Report

Comparative Review of Welfare System

In order to compare the welfare system of the three proposed countries, it is important to first develop a comparative method that would guide in comparing the three states. For the purpose of this paper, a binary comparison would be conducted. The implicit comparison would deal with Britain while the explicit comparison would explore the USA and Canada. Thereby a small N’ study would be used, that is, of three countries.
The three countries selected to share a similarity in the form that these countries are a welfare state. This is when welfare is mainly funded by the state. While the USA and Canada focus on the liberal welfare state, the welfare state of the UK is not quite defined.
The comparison of the welfare...
8 Pages(2000 words)Term Paper

Peer and Self Assessment Strategies

... The following analysis provides a structured and in depth approach to the issue of self and peer analysis within the field of research. Byanalyzing the issue from a multifaceted standpoint, it will be the hope of this author that the strengths and weaknesses that are inherent within the critique and review process can be elucidated to a further extent. Introduction: One of the key aspects of research and scholarly inquiry is with regards to seeking to understand a given issue or present a given approach in a new, novel, and/or effective manner. As a result of this underlying need, researchers tend to craft their approach based upon their own ideas as well as the salient information that they had integrated with throughout the course...
6 Pages(1500 words)Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Subverting the Processes of Peer Review for FREE!

Contact Us