Symposium Papers Review - Book Report/Review Example

Symposium Papers Review By and al Affiliation Department Donna, E. & Nurgul, A., 2015. The Environmental Impact of Electric Vehicles. December 15-19, 2015. United Kingdom: Kingston-Upon-Hull.This article follows the ASME conference writing style. The layout of the paper takes two columns, with the title of the conference flush top right of the paper followed by the title cantered and the authors. The conference paper also has a number, and the format comprises of the abstract, introduction, and references.

However, the paper the references should be in column form. In this paper, both peer-reviewed and scholarly sources are cited. There is a balance in the use of these sources as it includes conference papers, journal articles, books, and recognized websites. Harvard referencing is not followed in this paper. The sources used are placed under a bibliography and not references. Additionally, Harvard does not require capitalizing the author’s name. This paper does offer an easy to follow argument with regards to the environmental impact of electric vehicles as an alternative to declining fossil fuels and climate change.

CategoryMax ScoreConform to ASME formatting (No/Yes)0Use and appropriateness of information sources25Use of Harvard format style (No / Poor / Yes)10Content and readability20Suggested Review Score: 55Davidson, J. & Johnson, D., 2015. Energy-What Next? December 15-19, 2015. United Kingdom: Kingston-Upon-Hull. The paper follows the ASME formatting concisely from the formatting to layout. The paper has a conference title and number flushed top right, a title and authors aligned centre. The layout of the content includes an abstract, introduction, nomenclature, and references.

The sources included are mostly peer-reviewed with a few from government sites and sources. The sources have been well utilized within the paper to support the argument, and major statistics being from government sources, thus improving content credibility. The paper balances the sources well with most content coming from peer –reviewed articles. Harvard referencing is clearly followed. All sources include the recommended source elements and in the right format. The in-text citations are also in the recommended Harvard reference style.

The paper argument is clear as it evaluates drawbacks in the present forms of energy, and offers solutions that can be implemented in emerging energy technologies to reduce dependence on renewable energy in future.CategoryMax ScoreConform to ASME formatting (No/Yes)30Use and appropriateness of information sources25Use of Harvard format style (No / Poor / Yes)10Content and readability25Suggested Review Score: 90