StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Structure And Anarchy - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
In theory and logic it is relatively easy to show that structure and leadership are more effective than anarchy and consensus in getting things done. In historical experience, however, there is a good argument to be made that movements have made their greatest accomplishments at times when formal leadership and structure have been least important, and anarchy and consensus most prevalent.This paper explores the two arguments to evaluate the strengths and limitations of alternative positions on a set of related issues addressing structure, leadership, majority votes to determine group positions, consensus, working to avoid having leaders or seeing everyone as a leader, group processes, and the…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.7% of users find it useful
Structure And Anarchy
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Structure And Anarchy"

Download file to see previous pages Any organization has a structure and leadership. It is also recognized that an organization is primarily its people. In theoretical discussions it is widely agreed that social movements are not organizations. As Freeman (1978) says," Granted, most movements are not organizations and thus not able to make conscious decisions about their direction. Usually they consist of numerous core groups and a large penumbra of sympathizers. Nonetheless, these core groups serve as the foci of a movement's values and activities and determine much of its deliberate policy". It is here that the crux issue rises. Lacking a resolute structure a social movement always faces instability and the conflict between group maintenance needs and goal achievement needs. The core values of the movement can have a constellation of other values supported by differing groups. These values can be parallel or opposed to core values. The opposing values and their support groups can be in a consensus and form a noticeable opposition. So long as the leadership and the majority that support leadership and movement's core values are able to outnumber and control opposing opinions and groups structure prevails and the movement sails along smoothly with foci values. The instability of movements and opposite values and opinions are particularly strong in movements with democratic values, where the structure is deliberately loosely defined and monitored as too much structure can suppress participation and inhibit eagerness.(Lenin,1901) So social movements offer incentives for order maintenance and also to increase membership. Wilson (1973) identifies four major categories of incentives that an organization can deploy in order to maintain its membership. These are material incentives (money, goods, and other tangible rewards); specific solidarity incentives (status, power, and other intangible benefits that are scarce); collective solidarity incentives (prestige, friendship, fun, and other rewards from being part of a group); and purposive incentives (value fulfillment, or the sense of satisfaction from contributing to a worthwhile cause).Maintenance of consensus becomes a major task of the movement leadership so as to remain on course to foci values.Graeber(2002) defines the consensus process as ," The basic idea of consensus process is that, rather than voting, you try to
come up with proposals acceptable to everyone-or at least, not highly objectionable to anyone: first state the proposal, then ask for 'concerns' and try to address them".
Anarchy
When opposition in a movement becomes splintered with no conclusive or majority based foci value then chaos prevails. "Anarchy means without government, which is different forms of vertically organized, i.e. chaotic included, economic and/or political-administrative ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Structure And Anarchy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Structure And Anarchy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1501044-structure-and-anarchy
(Structure And Anarchy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Structure And Anarchy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1501044-structure-and-anarchy.
“Structure And Anarchy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1501044-structure-and-anarchy.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Structure And Anarchy

Anarchy in the International System

... roles, and the relationships that they have with other states. In essence, these identities are based on interests and this is determined by international interactions and not the structure of the international system. Of importance to note is that, for a peaceful world to be realistic, cooperation must constantly be an option for states to trail, with the assistance of the international institutions which ought to play a part in encouraging and prolonging peace globally(Ward, 1996). Conclusion Anarchy is described as the absence of government or political authority over or between the units in relation to political systems. Anarchy has been used in broad to emphasize on the international system where states are viewed as units...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Wide realist definitions of state and anarchy

The major question therefore is: how do the arising conflicts get resolved? In addressing this question, the realists have defined the state as a sovereign entity that has no competing governmental authority over it, which can enforce promises or protect the country against aggression by other countries. Thus, the concept of realists in relation to State is that as a sovereign entity, it is upon the state to decide how it will deal with both internal and external problems. Further, the realist concept observes that a state exists in a ‘state of nature’, where like humans, states are existing on their own, and must work out how to live with each other in the international arena, since the states as collective entities do not have...
13 Pages(3250 words)Essay

Alexander Wendt Anarchy Theory

Wendt is more with the realists when they say that the state system is in a state of anarchy and that the states are competing for survival. Theorists agree that Wendt's theory has important implications for the advancement of international politics. "Contrary to neorealism's static materialist structuralism, Wendt's social theory bears on the 'tranformative potential' of international politics. His theory claims to reveal the potential for a more cooperative international relations," http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexander_Wendt
International Relations is supposed to have started with the Peace of Westphalia in 1648, from where the modern system of States emerged and since then, various theories have cropped up. Answering a q...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Alexander Wendt and Anarchy

... argues that there is no logic in anarchy. Throughout, he reiterates that an anarchic state should not be logical. According to him self-help and power are institutions and they are not essential features of anarchy. He argues: "there is no logic of anarchy apart from the practice that create and instantiate one structure of identities and interests rather than another." Thus, Wendt says 'anarchy is what states make of it'. Many critics have agreed with his point of view while some disagreed for right reasons. He mainly touches Neorealism, but returns to traditional realism, very often. He also claims that a theory that is far removed from realism is not a working model and he gains significance here. "Realism lays claims to a relevance...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Role of Cooperation in Controlling Anarchy

Inayatullah (1997) provided a theoretical perspective on anarchy and cooperation suggesting that neo-realism tends to rely on a negative interpretation on the theory of spontaneous order. Inyataullah suggests that institutions which emerge spontaneously tend to show some form of design thus design and human reflexivity indicate an overlap of intentions and outcomes. But how would a theory of order or disorder relate to international relations and where in the discourse can we place anarchy and cooperation as necessary concepts to define IR? As Inayatullah suggests, the study of intended actions is an essential part of international relations theory and outcomes of IR focus on ‘values’ underlying theory and practice. Po...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Laws of Nation-States Against Cyber Anarchy

...Laws of Nation s against Cyber anarchy Introduction The regulation cynics make normative and descriptive arguments. Normatively, they claim that since cyberspace transactions take place ‘simultaneously and equally in all national jurisdictions’ (Thierer & Crews 2003: 74) control of information exchanges by any specific jurisdictions unlawfully generates considerable negative spill over implications for other jurisdictions. Descriptively, they argue that the use of geographically founded notions of national regulation and preference of law to a cyberspace activity that is geographically based is utterly useless or will only result in uncertainty (Thierer & Crews 2003). They also argue that the design of cyberspace disqualifies notice...
10 Pages(2500 words)Term Paper

The Federalist Papers: Cohesion Out of Anarchy

...The Federalist Papers: Cohesion Out of Anarchy Among the many issues raised by the federalist papers, one of the primary concerns continually brought up and debated was the need to balance the needs for democracy against the risk of the tyranny of the majority. Federalist No. 51 and the second paragraph of the Declaration of Independence represent part of these concerns. The Federalist Paper No. 51 argues, “In a society under the forms of which the stronger faction can readily unite and oppress the weaker, anarchy may as truly be said to reign as in a state of nature, where the weaker individual is not secured against the violence of the stronger; and as, in the latter state, even the stronger individuals are prompted, by the uncertainty...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Two cheers for anarchy

... on the arguments provided in the book, it can be concluded that protests and movements are not necessarily supported by organizations. Rather, it is the other way round whereby protests and movements enhance the functioning of organizations (Scott 10). Scott also discusses the aspects of structural change in society and the factors that determine such changes. From the book, it can be concluded that structural change is witnessed when there is mass destructions that happen as a result of riots, arson, theft, as well as unorganized demonstrations and mass actions, which threatens the existence and functioning of the institutions that the state has already established. Scott notes that, from an anarchist’s point of view, subordinate members...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Political Economy And the Coming Anarchy

This article also talks about political instability that is brought forth because of poor governance.
He identifies countries such as Sierra Leone, which experiences civil war because of poverty, and poor governance. Furthermore, Kaplan effectively talks about the problems of insecurity in West Africa, and the causes of this insecurity. He identifies poverty as the main cause of insecurity in Western Africa. Kaplan also talks about Turkey and predicts a rise of an Islamic state in Turkey and other places of the world. In this paper, Kaplan is a critique of the Islamic religion, denoting that it is associated with poor people, who are badly urbanized, and they are willing to use violence as a means of achieving their objectiv...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

United Utilities Organizational Structure

He regulated electricity distribution, gas supply, and water and wastewater networks in North West England /United Utilities Taps into Community Spirit, 2006/.
United Utilities was a founder of a telecoms company Your Communications. This company also provides utility consulting and contracting services and an outsourcing business which offers such services as customer management, human resources, finance and accounting /United Utilities, 2006/.

As a result of the sale of electricity and gas supply business in August 2000 United Utilities has no share in the competitive UK generation and supply market. Now United Utilities PLC supplies water and provides wastewater services in the region with the population over 7...
14 Pages(3500 words)Case Study

Family Structure and Academic Achievement

Several recommendations for action are made.
In 1993, Harold Stevenson followed up his 1993 study of achievement among U.S., Japanese, and Taiwanese children (Stevenson et al., 1996). He found that U.S. fifth- and eleventh-graders (first- and fifth-graders in the original study) ranked below Japanese and Chinese students in both math and reading. When the top 10 percent of students were compared in terms of math, U.S. students were still a full standard deviation below the Asian mean.
Data also were gathered in 1993 to judge such things as parental and child satisfaction with achievement levels, and beliefs about the importance of effort versus ability. American parents were the most satisfied with their children's achie...
9 Pages(2250 words)Assignment

Optimal Capital Structure

One of the recent concepts applied in financial management is the effective utilization of resources and choosing the optimal and most appropriate capital structure. In a resource constraint situation, the importance of financial management is especially highlighted as financial strategies are required to get the company or organization pass through several constraints that it may confront in the day to day functioning. The reasons leading to these sources constraint situations could be lack of demand, scarcity of raw materials, labor problems, liquidity control, lack of technological awareness, prejudiced policies about management and finance, etc. If the problem is not taken into consideration during the initial stage itself, th...
6 Pages(1500 words)Coursework

The Major Issues in the Debate Regarding the Existence of an Optimal Capital Structure

The level of capital has been used as a criterion for the classification of a company within its market. Regarding this issue it is noticed by Penrose (1952, 810 in Cooper, 1997, 750) that ‘positive profits can be treated as the criterion of natural selection -- the firms that make profits are selected or 'adopted' by the environment, others are rejected and disappear’On the other hand, Ruhnka (1985, 45) supported that ‘the primary source of capital for most start-up and development stage companies is equity capital raised through limited stock offerings that are exempt from expensive federal and state registration requirements’. In other words, the capital of the firm can be formulated through a series of...
13 Pages(3250 words)Term Paper

Structure of the Legal Profession in the United Kingdom

However, the partition of Ireland in 1922 was a major turning point in the current state of affairs of the UK’s legal system. This event also influenced the religious leanings of each constituent according to the Catholic or Protestant majority as the case may be in each region. (The Legal Profession)
There are basically three constituents in the nation’s legal structure comprising England and Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland. Although England and Wales are two separate constituents, their legal structure is the same. England and Wales also have the same legal jurisdictions. Scotland’s legal scripts are based on the ancient Roman laws. The Scottish parliament can enact and amend legislation on domestic...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

The Work Breakdown Structure and its Advantages in Project Planning

A typical construction project involves a WBS that evolves from an initial task that is successively subdivided into smaller work blocks until the lowest level is reached, indicating a tree-like structure. Subdividing the project breaks down the project work effort into packages that are both manageable and independent. It connotes that the lowest level of the package corresponds to the smallest project work, which requires the shortest completion time periods. As WBS shows the relationship of all elements of a project, a sound basis for cost and schedule control is provided.

Some lists of project activities involved in WBS include budgeting, cost allocation, time allocation and management, and quality assurance. These...
11 Pages(2750 words)Report

Structure of Ford Motor Company

It was only in 1927 when GM overtook Ford in sales that Henry Ford felt the need to innovate Model A that was more in tune with the times (Cattlel, 2000).
Today, Ford Motor Company is the biggest family-controlled auto-manufacturer with number three spots in the list of world’s biggest manufacturers and sellers of vehicles. In, 2007, for the first time in 56 years, Ford was relegated to the third spot from second by the Toyota of Japan. Ford manufactures cars, trucks, and SUVs in the brand range of Ford, Mercury, Lincoln, Volvo, and Mazda. Ford’s s distinctly home-spun variety economy class Mondeo and Mustangs sold the world over, and Lincoln stands for luxury and elegance. Lincoln Motor Company was the first stra...
13 Pages(3250 words)Term Paper

Theory of Justice: Anarchy, State and Utopia

... that such possession is unjust, arbitrary or unfair. On an overall basis therefore, on the question of allowing natural talents to also be factored into the distribution of primary assets, Nozick appears to be correct.                                                             Works Cited: *        Nozick, Robert. "Anarchy, State and Utopia",  Basic Books, 1974 *       Rawls, John. "A Theory of Justice",  Harvard University Press, 2005. He argues against the notion of desert, or the idea that those who are better situated deserve greater advantages, irrespective of whether or not they are also advantageous to others.... of Justice Q4. Rawls argues (pp. 73-4, 103-4) that it is unjust to allow distribution of primary goods on the basis of...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Structure of the Educational System in Morocco and Its Capacity for Addressing the Needs of the Hospitality Industry

...Independent Research Study An investigation into the Structure of the Educational System in Morocco and its Capa for Addressing the Needs and Expectations of the Hospitality Industry in the Country Submitted by : Submitted to : Course : Date : September 29, 2009 Word Count : 3,069 words STATEMENT OF AUTHORSHIP “I confirm that no part of this work, except where clearly quoted and referenced, has been copied from material belonging to any person e.g. from a book, handout, another student. I am aware that it is a breach of GIHE regulations to copy the work of another without clear acknowledgement and that attempting to do so render me liable to disciplinary procedures.” ________________ Table of Contents I. Consultant’s Brief 4...
15 Pages(3750 words)Research Proposal

What to Consider in Structure-Conduct-Performance Model

... for each of the firm. If they both play L then the profits would be half of what they would earn if they do not change. Part B The purpose of this essay is to critically analyze the extent to which the efficiency and equity considerations should be taken into account in the Structure-Conduct-Performance Model when it comes to deciding policies for the mergers between large firms. Firstly, the paper talks briefly about the Structure-Conduct-Performance Model and then moves onto discuss the importance of equity and efficiency in policy making for mergers. Introduction According to the Structure-Conduct-Performance Model, the performance of any industry depends on the firms’ conducts in the industry. The Conduct of the firms in turn depends...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Oligopolistic Market Structure

For instance, in France, the Air France dominates in the airline services in the region but there are still other small firms that provide the same services that still survive in the region, hence, results in the creation of oligopoly.
The emergence of oligopolistic market structure is important to the organizations that benefit from the process in various ways. These importances that are realised are triggered through the existence of different characteristics that the presence and the practice of oligopolistic market structure possess. Consequently, some of the characteristics of oligopolistic market structure include: Interdependence, which is the ability of various organizations that involves in the process of oligopoly,...
6 Pages(1500 words)Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Structure And Anarchy for FREE!

Contact Us