Deportation as a Disturbing Solution for Illegal Migration - Essay Example

Deportation is not a good policy for handling illegal immigration‏ The current situation of poverty isalarming in many countries. The sole bread earners of large families find it difficult to make ends meet. As a result of inflation and other obstacles, they indulge in unfair and illegal means to earn easy money. This leads to give rise to a problematic situation in which the wrong doers are reprimanded severely. The intention or need is never looked, the only consideration is the unethical behavior and the violation of law that causes troubles and the wrong doer is punished under the law. One of the ways of getting out from a life of abject poverty is illegal immigration. However poverty is not the only reason, there are many reasons that force people to do this. In the past few years the illegal immigration has increased to a great extent that result in deportation which further makes the situation worse. Deportation refers to the removal of a person from a country based on legal grounds. In USA, it takes place when the federal government orders to remove a non-citizen from the United States (Findlaw). But deportation is not a good policy for handling illegal immigration. It just removes the non-citizens from the land but with their departure the country might lose the work force. There are many causes that force the individuals to opt for illegal immigration because the economic conditions do not allow them to go for a fair and legal mean. So without paying any heed to the consequences and the need to improve the standard of living makes them to overlook the aftermath and they choose to immigrate illegally. Throughout the world, people struggle to get better jobs and economic opportunities for themselves and their families. They succeed in such endeavors since the immigration enforcement possesses many flaws and hence fails to stop them from entering the forbidden lands(Silsby). So this establishes the dire need to improve the living conditions and to find better job opportunities is the driving force behind the illegal immigration. Once the individuals land in the country, they try hard to secure their position as an indispensable being by taking part in the progress of the country. They work in different companies and once they have established their value by working hard they are asked to leave as a result of illegal immigration. Emily Ryo presents a vivid picture of this self-centered act and asserts that while willing to acquire their services pertaining to labor and other hardships, we try to send them the message that their services are no more needed and that they should return to their homelands. This hypocritical approach is equivalent to saying that although we are unwilling to grant you legal status; we are yet very much willing to benefit from your services (Morrison). This gives rise to a new pattern of problems. The families as well as the individuals face problems. Not only has this but the companies benefitting from the labor of the immigrants suffer a loss when they have to let them go under legal issues and laws. There are many reasons that result in deportation. The violation of laws by the immigrants welcomes the officials to look in to the personal information of the immigrants. This further open ways and with this comes the revelation of their illegal immigration. The individuals under the influence of a bad company commit crimes and get arrested. This may result in deportation. A person can be deported for bad behavior, on grounds of conduct, misdemeanors and affecting the cause of peace (Lawyers.com). The fault in paper work can also result in immediate deportation. So if a law of any state is strong and is monitoring every move of its citizen then it becomes difficult for the illegal immigrants to exempt the punishment. The US government has very strict laws for immigrants and it is difficult for the new comers to get citizenship. Those who manage to get it may face other issues like racial discrimination. However there are bright chances of being accepted. But those who fail to get it and come under suspicion and are deported immediately. The US president tried to form lenient actions against the illegal immigrants that were totally rejected by the representatives. This illegal act is considered offensive and considered as the violation of the rights of the US citizens. The Americans who are residing in the country have a right to spend a comfortable life and the job opportunities given by the companies are purely the right of the American citizens. The illegal immigrants by getting the jobs are violating their basic right. This increases the problem of unemployment and makes the living troublesome. Quite a number of democrats in the House of Representatives and some republicans have voted against President Barack Obama’s policy that relates to complying with deferring deportations for immigrants who were brought here as minors (Planas). So under these conditions the leniency was excluded. Many asylum seekers, who find danger in their homeland due to suicide attacks, robbery and murder or due to some other reason that endangers their life, find it an only option to migrate to other country. For this reason there is a proper legal procedure that has to be followed. But in the past few years the population of asylum seekers is increasing in the US that is raising some serious concerns. The president of United States has ordered the congress to supply a huge amount of $4 billion to eradicate the problem (Greenblatt). After being deported the wise thing to do is to take a fresh start and with the limited resources one must seek happiness. In case of hopeless situation a person must wait to return back. A deported person should wait for 5 to 10 years before attempting to enter the United States again in a legal manner (Political Asylum). With improvement in behavior and by legally approaching the superiors one can land safely in another country. However deportation is not the only way to handle illegal immigration. There are many adverse effects of sending an immigrant back depending on the amount of work he has done for the country. There are many illegal immigrants who despite the fact that they have used illegal means to enter but with their intellect, skills and hard work they earn appreciation and make themselves indispensable for the companies. The immigrants from poor countries who have worked as a labor continue to work on the same post in countries where labor force is not easily available. So in case of deportation it sweeps up people who are in the country to work hard. The families who suffer the deportation are deprived of the members who are the only bread earners in the family. It separates families, causing poverty. The process of deportation is very costly. So this result in the expenditure that sometimes proves to be a big amount which if put otherwise would have earned great revenue for the country. No country is safe or is completely free of criminals. There are many criminals who roam freely causing a great trouble for the innocent citizens. There are murderers, assailants, and other gangs who rob people of their property and sometimes take away the lives of innocent people. Comparatively these crimes have a far more reaching impact than the illegal immigration. So deportation results in the liberty of the criminals because it does not catch the criminals that need to be caught. Although the matter has taken the shape of a political conflict and politicians use it for point scoring, it is depressing to note that the US government deports individuals having American children and in the process deprive children of their biological parents while sending them to foster homes (Wessler). This is the cruel act to take away the mother or father away from children. The children who are innocent are sent to the foster homes. This may result in the traumatic childhood because there is no guarantee of foster parents being nice to the children. Even if the foster parents are nice and sympathetic they can never replace the real parents. This sort of deportation is completely ruthless. Apart from this there is a large amount that is spent on the process of deportation. When an immigrant is served a legal deportation notice, things start to get confusing very quickly (Katherine). First of all, the process can get confusing for the immigrant. The formal hearings and the legal process takes away the energy and time of the court and above all the expenditure adds to the misery. It has been estimated that deporting all illegal immigrants from America would cost more than $285 Billion (Kasperkevic). Many analysts have raised their concerns regarding the expenses. The money spent on the deportation results in loss because in most cases the country willingly and consciously deprives themselves of the hard working individuals. This estimate of the total amount is alarming. If the money is spent on some other work it might bring prosperity but many officials overlook this aspect and become persistent. If the masses continue to show this same behavior it “will overwhelm our legal system, tear apart families, and cost our local and state governments time and money” (Agarwal). Apart from this the trauma and the psychological impact on the families cannot be overlooked. The innocent children who are taken away from their parent are forced to live a life that becomes a misery for them. When parents are deported for any reason, the children may undergo a state of confusion. They may lose trust in their parents by assuming that their parents are criminals. Since such matters are kept confidential, the children are fed with unauthentic explanations which aggravate the loss and in some cases may result in psychological disturbances that may persist into adulthood (Brabeck, Lykes and Hunter 6). This trauma and confusion remains with them forever. They fail to decipher the reason of this sudden and drastic change that completely changes their life. They become the object f mockery by their fellow peers and prefer to live a life in isolation. Apart from this, the burden of whole family lies on any one member mainly the vulnerable being. When families are disintegrated, the stress is felt by all members of the family. The mother is forced to bear the burden of family’s existence. The family may become reserved from the society due to the trauma that is imposed by governmental actions (Dreby 22). There are a few numbers of people who support the illegal immigration based on their ideas about the prosperity of the country. Most Republican politicians base their argument on the Rule of Law which asserts that people who enter a country illegally should not be rewarded for this act by providing them the option of citizenship (Dann). This idea propagates the inhumane behavior towards the illegal immigrants. The law forming agencies take the matter in their hand and make sure that the illegal immigrants are punished. Many put forth their stance in support of the local American citizens who find it hard to find jobs due to these immigrants. Others have based their argument on the idea that as more and more people enter a locality, the job market becomes saturated and therefore it becomes difficult for the locals to earn a living (Hawkins). This apparently looks a valid reason but many overlook the idea that the most of the illegal immigrants are the labor force and they do those jobs that most of the Americans consider filthy. So their departure will make them to do the tasks and they will try to evade the situation. “It will only encourage more illegal immigrants to come here” (Hawkins). By carefully examining the cases one can have an idea about the nature of an individual. So the data collected by observing and examining the personal information of the illegal immigrants, the authorities can decide about the deportation. Those who can serve the country can be kept while those who are indulged in criminal activities or who can affect the property and life of others can be deported. So it can be concluded that deportation is not the only situation to handle illegal immigration. One can thoroughly go through the records and make decisions accordingly. Not every illegal immigrant is considered liable of crimes. The situation and the background should also be examined and then the actions should be taken according to the productivity of an individual. References Agarwal, Nisha. "The Costs of Deportation Are Too High Already." The New York Times. Nytimes.com, 30 Jan. 2014. Web. 2 June 2015. Brabeck, Kalina M., M. Brinton Lykes, and Cristina Hunter. "The Psychosocial Impact of Detention and Deportation on U.S. Migrant Children and Families." American Journal of Orthopsychiatry (2013): 496-505. Print. Dann, Carrie. "Humanity? Practicality? Amnesty? The Arguments for and against Immigration Reform." NBC News. 12 Apr. 2013. Web. 2 June 2015. Dreby, Joanna. "How Today’s Immigration Enforcement Policies Impact Children, Families, and Communities A View from the Ground."AmericanProgress.org 1 Aug. 2012. Web. 2 June 2015. Findlaw "Deportation and Removal - FindLaw." Thomson Reuters. Web. 2 June 2015. Greenblatt, Alan. "Whats Causing The Latest Immigration Crisis? A Brief Explainer." NPR. NPR, 9 July 2014. Web. 2 June 2015. Hawkins, John. "John Hawkins - 5 Reasons Illegal Immigrants Shouldnt Be Given American Citizenship." Townhall.com. 23 Feb. 2010. Web. 2 June 2015. Kasperkevic, Jana. "Deporting All Of Americas Illegal Immigrants Would Cost A Whopping $285 Billion." Business Insider. Business Insider, Inc, 30 Jan. 2012. Web. 2 June 2015. Katherine. "The Deportation Process for US Immigrants." Legal Language Services The Deportation Process for US Immigrants Comments. Legallanguage.com/, 11 Dec. 2010. Web. 2 June 2015. Lawyers.com " Top Reasons You May Receive a Deportation Notice." Deportation Grounds. Lawyers.com, 2015. Web. 2 June 2015. Morrison, Patt. “Why do people cross the border illegally? Its not what you think”. Los Angeles Times, 25 Nov. 2014. Web. 2 June 2015. Planas, Roque. "These Are The Real Reasons Behind Illegal Immigration." The Huffington Post. TheHuffingtonPost.com, 8 Aug. 2015. Web. 2 June 2015. Political Asylum."Grounds Of Deportation For Criminal Convictions." - MassLegalHelp. Masslegalhelp.org. Nov. 2009. Web. 2 June 2015. Silsby, Gillen. "Why People Take the Risk of Illegal Immigration - Futurity." Futurity. 7 Aug. 2013. Web. 2 June 2015. Wessler, Seth. ""Im Here, My Children Are Over There"" ELLE. Elle.com, 27 Aug. 2013. Web. 2 June 2015. Read More