Riggs v.Palmer and Speluncean Explorers - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Riggs and Mrs. Preston approached the court in order to invalidate their late father Francis B. Palmer’s will. The case’s defense consisted of Elmer E. Palmer who was the grandson of Francis B. Palmer…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.2% of users find it useful
Riggs v.Palmer and Speluncean Explorers
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Riggs v.Palmer and Speluncean Explorers"

1. Case Facts Riggs v Palmer represents a probate suit wherein the two plaintiffs Mrs. Riggs and Mrs. Preston approached the court in order to invalidate their late father Francis B. Palmer’s will. The case’s defense consisted of Elmer E. Palmer who was the grandson of Francis B. Palmer. The actual will provided the claimants with small legacies to the estate while Elmer Palmer was left with a large portion of the estate. However till Elmer Palmer came of age the bequeathed estate was to be looked after Elmer’s mother Susan Palmer who was a sister of the claimants. Fearing that his grandfather might change his decision in respect of the will Elmer Palmer murdered his grandfather through poisoning. The plaintiffs presented the argument that the will would allow Elmer to profit from his heinous crime. Elmer would be punished under the statute for murder but his claim to the estate could not be invalidated under the terms of either probate law or criminal law (Dworkin).
In sharp contrast, the Speluncean Explorers case is purely hypothetical in nature and was written by Lon Fuller for the Harvard Law Review in 1949. A team of five entrapped spelunkers is depicted in the Commonwealth of Newgarth who are able to establish radio contact with their rescue team. The spelunkers are told by the engineers that around 10 days would be required for their extraction (Suber) while the spelunkers relate the total food rations they have to the physicians in the rescue team which are deemed insufficient. Radio contact breaks down and resultantly the spelunkers decide to hold a lottery in order to murder one of their members so that others can consume him for survival. The losing member is executed and eaten up. After the rescue the spelunkers are all convicted for murder but there is debate as to the application of murder sentences to the rescued spelunkers (Fuller).
2. Similarities and Differences in Judgments
For Riggs v Palmer the majority opinion clearly stated that the plaintiffs were justified in their claims and the eventual outcome reinforced Judge Robert Earl’s opinion. The decision declared that the tenets of universal laws and universal maxims would be violated if Elmer Palmer was allowed to profit from his crime. It was also related that the legislature could not reasonably be expected to foresee any contingencies when laws were being drafted and so such disdainful behavior ought to be punished. This is similar to the views of Justice Keen in the Speluncean Explorers case where he opines that the statutes of law must be upheld in any circumstances no matter what the circumstances are. The judge clearly states that personal opinions and biases should be left out of official work which is the implementation of the law and not the legislation of the law.
On the other hand, Judge John Clinton Gray disagreed with the ruling opinion in the Riggs v Palmer case by stating that depriving Elmer Palmer of the bequeathed estate would add more to his punishment in the form of murder. The judge felt that in doing so the court was abusing its powers in issuing punishment against an unrelated statute. Moreover the judge felt that the court was taking such a decision to obtain a more “morally pleasing” result. In a similar manner Judge Foster is depicted sympathizing with the spelunkers and opines that by pronouncing such a decision the court is over imposing the law of the Commonwealth of Newgarth in the wilderness where the spelunkers were entrapped. Instead he holds that the law of the wild or “natural law” ought to be applied to the case of the spelunkers and given the circumstances they should be exonerated as they had suffered enough already.
3. Bibliography
Dworkin, Ronald. "The Model of Rules I": Taking Rights Seriously. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1977.
Fuller, Lon L. The Case of the Speluncean Explorers. February 1949. 19 December 2011 .
Suber, Peter. The Case of the Speluncean Explorers: Nine New Opinions. 2011. 19 December 2011 . Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Riggs v.Palmer and Speluncean Explorers Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Riggs v.Palmer and Speluncean Explorers Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from
(Riggs v.Palmer and Speluncean Explorers Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Riggs v.Palmer and Speluncean Explorers Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words.
“Riggs v.Palmer and Speluncean Explorers Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Riggs v.Palmer and Speluncean Explorers

Arnold Palmer Hospital: Managing Operations

...?Arnold Palmer Hospital: Managing Operations Introduction Managing the quality of service is always a challenge among hospital or health care organizations as traditional and prevailing practices often impede or threaten adoption of new or untested systems that may prove to be worthwhile. The management background of Arnold Palmer Hospital provides a refreshing take on the issue. Its Executive Director Kathy Swanson’s improved system about achieving quality health care is beyond question as she was able to implement various techniques to determine problems as well as how to solve them. Empowering the work force towards achievement of goals is employed by Swanson aside from directly being in contact with...
13 Pages(3250 words)Essay

Reflective Cycle by Gibbs

13 Pages(3250 words)Essay

The Speluncean Explorer's case

...? THE CASE OF THE SPELUNCEAN EXPLORERS (A hypothetical legal case study) of Introduction This paper examinesthe relevant issues in a hypothetical legal case which had involved five members of the Speluncean Society (an explorers club) which forced all the members of the judiciary trying the case, to take a hard look again at the case facts because of the unusual nature of cannibalism among the survivors who were trapped inside a cave they were exploring from an unexpected landslide, which closed their only exit point from the cave. This case brought to the forefront various issues which entailed a vigorous re-examination of the legal underpinnings of...
3 Pages(750 words)Term Paper

Florida v. Harris and Florida v. ardines

...? Critical Thinking Assignment: Florida v. Harris Florida v. Jardines Introduction Consistent in all global legislative systems, legal cases are initially sought out in lower and trial courts. Subsequently, the decisions are appealed and challenged in higher courts such as Supreme Court. Various concurring and dissenting opinions are revealed during the hearings of the cases and all circumstances are carefully accounted for before reaching final conclusion. References to past legal cases are very critical as situations of most of the cases resemble to those in older ones. This paper entails a detailed discussion and critical analysis of two separate legal cases which have mutually similar circumstances....
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Speluncean Explorer Case

...Speluncean Explorer Case Speluncean Explorer Case “The Ukraine has a unified judicial system. Its criminal justice system is based on both the inquisitory and adversary justice principles. While preliminary investigations follow an inquisitory scheme, the adversarial principle dominates when the case goes to trial. The primary criminal justice legislation being adhered to as of December 31, 1993 are the Criminal Code, the Code of Criminal Procedure, and the Law on Judiciary” (Chapkey). The adversarial principle relies on the skill of each advocate representing his partys positions and involves a jury, trying to determine the truth of the case. The jury will hear the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Roe v. Wade or Miranda v. Arizona

...4 November 2009 Miranda v. Arizona Miranda v. Arizona Ernesto Miranda was arrested by Arizona’s police onthe charges of kidnapping and rapping. Miranda, on March 13, 1963, admitted to three crimes. Miranda’s confession statement which was duly signed by him contained a paragraph at the top that it was a voluntary confession, made without any assurance of protection or threats and “with complete familiarity of his legal privileges, including any declaration which he made might be employed against him. Later, Miranda’s admission was allowed into testimony at the trial, and he was sentenced based on his confession at trial. (Cross & Miller, 165). However, some legal professionals were of the impression...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

America's Stone Age Explorers about 13,500 years ago. The theory further holds that the people who had migrated to America were isolated after the melting of glaciers. This caused the disappearance of the land bridge. However, the discovery of enormous ice sheets covering the south in the times of Christopher Columbus flawed this long standing theory on population of America. It is interesting how new developments such as discovery of other Clovis point challenge the previously accepted Clovis theory. The developments include the revelation that the coastline supported life of plants and bears The Clovis point viewpoint is such an important aspect in exploration at that time. It is the discovery of these points dating back to 16,000 B.C and the...
1 Pages(250 words)Movie Review

Loftus and Palmer (1974) Eyewitness Testimony Study

...Topic: Loftus and Palmer (1974) Eyewitness Testimony Study Loftus and Palmer (1974) Eyewitness Testimony Study Introduction Eyewitnesses are also referred to as first hand informants in reflex to past events in an investigation. Most investigations relay on the testimony of an eyewitness to create a vivid scenario of the activities that took course in the time of the events being investigated (Terrell 2008. Pg36). In this case, memory serves as an essential entity in the provision of eyewitness testimonies. This is due to the fact that it palaces the events in the investigation into the imagination of the investigators thus enabling easy analysis of cases and the provision of judgment. The ability to have clear memories is used... to...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Speluncean Explorers

...Case of the Speluncean Explorers Summary of the facts of the case The case involved five explorers who are members of the Speluncean society. They explored a remote cave in the central plateau of the society which then caved in on them following a massive landslide. The five men remained trapped under the massive boulders that blocked the only entrance into the cave. Fortunately, the men had indicated where they would go and soon after they went missing, the government instituted a search party that would try to rescue them from the cave. The efforts by the rescue team were fruitless given the continued landslides and the complex nature of the rescue. In...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Investing: Macien Palmer and Partners

...Case Study: Finance and Accounting Case Study: Finance and Accounting of What should Maciean Palmer and his partners do? In understanding what Macien Palmer and partners should do, it is crucial to understand the different partners’ role in investing. They are required to guide customers in establishing investment opportunities and in making sound investment decisions (Fradin&Fradin, 2011). The question is how the partners will deal with the investment income that they have generated from the various companies that they have invested in. The return of investment from the Cobalt Company will be divided by offering the chief partner of Forte 80 % of the return based on their work. As Palmer was the one who come up with strategies... that...
1 Pages(250 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Riggs v.Palmer and Speluncean Explorers for FREE!

Contact Us