Nobody downloaded yet

In the Court of Appeals of the State of Illinois Melissa Porter vs John Straub - Research Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
This essay focuses on Melissa Porter filed a Petition to Vacate An Original Order of Custody in the District Court for Cook County. This court should find that the District Court erred in calculating child support because the father did not file a Motion for Modification…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93% of users find it useful
In the Court of Appeals of the State of Illinois Melissa Porter vs John Straub
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "In the Court of Appeals of the State of Illinois Melissa Porter vs John Straub"

Download file to see previous pages On November 14, 2011, the District Court ruled in her favor. There was no Motion to Modify Child Support filed by either party. However, the District Court Judge made an Order of Child Support. Pursuant to that Order, the Judge allowed for a deviation from the child support guidelines to accommodate Mr. Straub’s new child, born of his current marriage. There is no Order of Support for that child. There was nothing in the Order addressing unpaid support. STATEMENT OF THE FACTS In October 2011, Melissa Porter sought to regain custody of her son, David, from the child’s father, John Straub. There was an order of Paternity, Custody and Support entered in a Florida court in 2008. Pursuant to that Order, Mr. Straub was ordered to pay $100 per month in child support. His payment history was poor and he was in arrears when Ms. Porter found it necessary to join the Army Reserves to supplement her income in order to properly care for the child. Ms. Porter and Mr. Straub had a verbal agreement that he would care for his son while Ms. Porter completed Basic Training in the Army Reserves. Mr. Straub was ten months in arrears in his child support obligation at the time he began caring for his son in August 2010. Ms. Porter was injured in a training accident while on active duty and spent several months recovering. Upon her return home, she sought the return of the child and Mr. Straub refused. Mr. Straub filed for custody in the Illinois courts. That filing resulted in an Order granting custody to Mr. Straub. Ms. Porter filed for an Order to Vacate that finding and the District Court for Cook County found in her favor, returning her son to her. During the course of those proceedings, the District Court made a support order, allowing a 20% deduction from the Illinois child support guideline amount to accommodate Mr. Straub’s new child of his current marriage. There was no provision for paying the arrearage. There was no inclusion for the income of Mr. Straub’s current spouse when calculating the total net income upon which the support amount should be based, nor was there a finding on the record of the guideline amount upon which the deduction would be based. When Ms. Porter objected, the judge instructed the parties to “take it up on appeal.” Appellant now appeals from the Order Modifying Support. ARGUMENT The facts of the case are not in dispute. All parties were present when the District Court judge modified the child support order to accommodate Mr. Straub’s parental obligation to his new child of his current marriage. The judge deducted 20% from the guideline amount without stating an initial child support guideline amount and the factors at law that allowed him to vary from the statutory guidelines. I. Standard of Review Of the issue presented here on appeal, the standard of review is de novo because there is no dispute as to the facts and the issue is a question of law. In re Marriage of Baumgartner, 393 Ill. App. 3d 297; 912 N.E.2d 783 (2009). See also Einstein v. Nijim, 358 Ill. App. 3d 263, 831 N.E.2d 50 (2005). A judgment is contrary to law “when an opposite conclusion is apparent or when findings appear to be unreasonable, arbitrary, or not based on evidence.” ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“In the Court of Appeals of the State of Illinois Melissa Porter vs Research Paper”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(In the Court of Appeals of the State of Illinois Melissa Porter Vs Research Paper)
“In the Court of Appeals of the State of Illinois Melissa Porter Vs Research Paper”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF In the Court of Appeals of the State of Illinois Melissa Porter vs John Straub

Summit vs. State Supreme Court of Nevada (1985)

...and current case. This testimony was offered by the appellant by stating that the victim had previous knowledge of similar acts that formed a foundation for the current case. Summitt was convicted by the grand jury, and the current case is an appeal on grounds of the rape shield law under FRE 412. Issue The issue before the court in the current case is whether the rape shield law allowed the admission of prior sexual experience of the victim as evidence in the case. The court had to determine whether Summitt could introduce the prior sexual experience of his victim as a basis for his defense in the appeal of his conviction. Rule The rule in this case is...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Court of Appeals of New York

...disturbance in a private residence in Houston, police entered the house of Lawrence and founds him engaged in a consensual sexual act with Garner, an adult and arrested them for engaging in a wayward and indecent act in contravention of the state laws against sodomy between same sex couples. The district court duly convicted them of violating the Homosexual Conduct Statute which prohibited from engaging in deviate sexual intercourse with another individual of the same sex. The petitioners appealed against the ruling and initially managed to convince the three judge panel seated at the Court of Appeals of the Fourteenth district held that the petitioners’...
3 Pages(750 words)Case Study

Melissa Richardson

...? Case 2 Talking from the viewpoint of Melissa Richardson, who has been newly assigned with the role of the sales manager for ColorTech Houses, itcan be said that she views the role of a sales manager as one that demand to balance both personal and process based relationships. While discussing in more details, it can be said that she was very well aware of the fact that the role of a sales manager goes much more beyond the job responsibilities of a normal sales executive. She was to some extent aware of the fact that the sales manager needs to supervise the work done by the team members and has to take in to account the review of the progress of each employee in regards to his or her target achievement. She also had the idea... , besides...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

United States Court of Appeals

...In The United s Court of Appeals For the Sixth Circuit United s of America, Plaintiff-Appellee vs. No.____________ George Pickett, Defendant-Appellant X-------------------------------------------X APPELANT’S BRIEF Appeal from the ____________ Order Convicting Defendant of Metal Hunting in a National Park and Illegal Possession of Historic Artifact and ordering Forfeiture of Defendant’s Metal Detector, Artifacts and 2007 Chevrolet Blazer from the Western District Court Of Kentucky at Louisville Statement of the Case This is a case in which Defendant George Pickett appeals from a judgment convicting him of metal hunting in a...
12 Pages(3000 words)Research Paper

State Court System In Indiana

...The Court System In Indiana The Indiana Constitution divides government into three branches: the legislative branch, the executive branch, and the judicial branch. The constitution gives the judicial power of the state to a Supreme Court, a Court of Appeals, circuit courts, and any other courts that the General Assembly sets up (The Trustees of Indiana University, 1999). Trial Courts and appellate courts makes up the two kinds of Indiana state courts. In trial courts, any civil or criminal case can be heard for they have the power to do...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

My Choice Is Illinois State University

...My choice is Illinois State University Life’s journey is dynamic and ever-changing and sometimes, a life-changing event would wake stir one into a realization that time wasted is time unrecovered. That was the lesson learned from my past experiences when my commitment and dedication to school has not always been one’s priority until after my son was born and my passion for a nursing career emerged. When I was in high school, I was not dedicated and focused in academic endeavors; mainly because almost every semester, I transferred to different schools. Personal struggles made it difficult for me to focus on studies and to recognize the relevance of education. In fact, the idea of getting out of school...
2 Pages(500 words)Personal Statement

Rhetorical Appeals

...King, from a Birmingham Jail, uses all these types of appeals, listed above, in order to convince the reader regarding the validity and credibility of his ideas and actions. The same are discussed and highlighted below: Ethos: Ethos is primarily used to indicate and highlight the good character and credibility of the writer. In this letter, Martin Luther King, has very aptly and effectively highlighted his body of work, thus indicating his authority on the subject and successfully justifying his stance on the issue on hand. Example: "I have the honor of serving as president of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference, an organization operating in every southern state, with headquarters in Atlanta,...
2 Pages(500 words)Case Study

The Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals

...The Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals of the affiliation The Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals The controversial issues in the case are evident, and the application of the law should be handled with care. The case has two major sides of consideration. The first concerns the rule of law, which in the State contends that capital murder should be served with punishment equating to execution. This is the only way that the rule of law can be upheld and justice served to the victim of the murderous act. Conversely, it would be absurd to execute an insane individual who has no mental capacity to comprehend his actions or the case for punishment (Kanady, 2006, p....
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Supreme Court Appeals

...Supreme Court Appeals The United s Supreme Court is the highest federal court. The Supreme Court plays a very important role in the growth of United Kingdom law. It has the final say on appeals coming from the federal circuit courts. The justices of The Supreme Court review over seven thousand applications each year; however, they only accept to hear a handful of these cases because of time and resource constraints and because not all cases are of equal merit (Mott 2014, par. 1). The process of getting a case heard by the Supreme Court is rather difficult. As a rule, the applications...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Federal vs State Law

...of some of the state laws were eventually put to light as seen in the case of Adams. Thus, the need to revise such laws that predetermined a suspect’s innocence or guilt was raised. Van Orden v. Perry Thomas Van Orden took Texas to the federal district court on the grounds that the Ten Commandments monument at the state capitol building an unconstitutional in that it violated the First Amendment's establishment clause (Unger 34). According to Orden, the law prohibited the government from passing laws that respected religious establishment. The district court and the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals all ruled against Orden. Their argument...
2 Pages(500 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Research Paper on topic In the Court of Appeals of the State of Illinois Melissa Porter vs John Straub for FREE!

Contact Us