Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

A Critical Analysis of R (Smith and West) v Parole Board - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
he criminal cases and proceedings often present with complexities that are ingrained in the structure and nature of the articles and clauses of the constitution and the common law…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.5% of users find it useful
A Critical Analysis of R (Smith and West) v Parole Board
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "A Critical Analysis of R (Smith and West) v Parole Board"

Download file to see previous pages The discussion and analysis of such cases reveals much needed lessons that should be incorporated in the future cases to prevent the mistakes and misjudgments made during the cases under discussion. One such case is R (West and Smith) v Parole1. This paper purports to discuss and analyze this case in order to understand the effects of its implications on criminal and administrative law. Background: in 2005, the Parole Board recalled the released of two prisoners, West and Smith, on the grounds that they had not acted in accordance with their conditions, and had breached the grounds on which they had made parole, posing a risk to the safety of the society at large2. West was a short-term prisoner who had been recalled on the grounds that he had spent one night away from the designated location without notifying his supervisor, and had been allegedly drunk and involved in the breaking down of a door at a girl’s hostel­3. Smith, a long-term prisoner, had been recalled on the pretext that he had proven incapable of fighting his habit of drug abuse on two occasions of his parole even after he had been given a written warning after the first incident4, and since he had been sentenced to prison due to a sexual crime5, his inability to live in accordance with his parole conditions were deemed as a safety risk to the society6. Analysis: The case under discussion presents a complex scenario in that it depends upon variables from the statutes of the common law and the Conventions of the Human Rights Act 19987 both directly and indirectly, and it is, at times, difficult to determine which of the clauses of the said statutes are applicable to the case. For this reason, the discussion and analysis of the case is subsequently divided into two parts; the first part deals with the application and relevance of the statutes of the common law, and the second part would deal with the articles of Convention as they apply to the case. Common Law: this subsection of the analysis would determine whether the pertinent case enjoys the benefit and protection afforded by the common law. The right to an oral hearing is a fundamental right provided by the common law when the Parole Board recalls prisoners released on probation under license due to any reason as deemed appropriate by the parole supervisor and the Parole Board8. The nature of the oral hearing is essentially an interview session, which might be informal in nature as this is considered sufficient9, with the option of presenting witnesses and new evidence in light of new facts or established facts the implications of which might have been changed due to influence of new developments in the case upon probation release of the prisoner10. The prisoner upon recall and once in custody is appraised of the right to file an appeal in order to challenge the Parole Board’s decision of recall11. This appeal is usually and mostly in the form of a written application directed to the Parole Board12. However, the prisoner has to be explicitly informed of his right to request an oral hearing if he feels that his case would be better presented by direct communication with the Board, or if he feels the need to present new evidence or witnesses13. Similarly, it is mandatory upon the Board to arrange an oral hearing if the need for such an arrangement is felt in light of any change in the established facts, or the implications of those facts due to a change in the circumstances of the prisoner upon his release; the need to present witnesses; or if the Board, due to any reason, feels that a fairer ruling would be only possible if the appellant was to engage in oral hearing14. It is generally considered that in many cases the mere use of a written appl ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“A Critical Analysis of R (Smith and West) v Parole Board Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(A Critical Analysis of R (Smith and West) V Parole Board Essay)
“A Critical Analysis of R (Smith and West) V Parole Board Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF A Critical Analysis of R (Smith and West) v Parole Board

Internal and External Environmental Analysis for the Bakery Business

Liberalization of foreign investment and technology policy of the government is supportive of establishing industrial units in the country.

Threat: The UK food regulatory authority is planning to enforce the EC Regulations relating to food labeling. The labeling requirements under the new regulations will affect the food industry as the suppliers will be legally obliged to disclose the GM content of foods to the caterers. Thus business firms in the bakery industry also will be effected through the exclusion of flexible manner of labeling arrangements in the case of flour confectionery involving GM Soya or maize. (Genetically modified and novel foods (labeling) (England) regulations, 2000).

Trend: The new subs...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

The West in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries

In the mid-seventeenth century, the Economy of the West was largely an agricultural one. Many individual houses hold produced agricultural products such as sugar, although there were plantations that produced on a large scale. Silver was also one of the precious items of trade. Merchants traded in silver from Asian countries such as China and India. This trade helped to boost the economy of the West to a large extent. The European merchants risked their lives to establish mines in foreign countries where they usually met resistance that some times resulted in violent confrontations.

The economy of the West grew because of many factors. Sugar, slave trade, and silver played an important role in economic development as we...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

The Necessity of Job Analysis

The importance of job analysis in human resources is to help the management to ascertain and endorse the use of certain activities which take place in employment such as employment procedures such as training, choice of the appropriate employees, reparation as well as evaluation and appraisal. It helps in developing an organized database containing information concerning the job (Singh, P 2008 pp. 82-84).
Job analysis is significant into the employers when selecting the employees who are suitable for a particular position in the organization. In the recruitment process, it is usually possible to make mistakes with regard to employee selection. It enables the management to understand the content of advertisements for vacant po...
7 Pages(1750 words)Coursework

Analysis of OReilly v Mackman Case

Judicial review is a concept which is constitutionally undecided as it on one side, it shores up the rule of law, democracy, and pre-eminence of parliament by facilitating the courts to check the boundaries of government authority and on another side, the courts are open to the decision on the plants based on the fact of separation of authorities that are intimating with the verdicts of democratically elected institutions. Judicial review is not apprehended with the virtues of government assessment but deals with whether the deciding authority has remained within the legal boundaries and whether broad principles of rationality and fairness adhere. The constitutional basis of judicial review is debated as one view holds that it is...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study

Comparative Family Analysis

The second component of this essay will be a comparative analysis with the American family to the Arab family, generally speaking, but also clearly described by Homa Hoodfar, in her book Between Marriage and the Market. This essay will discuss the impact of globalization on different types of families in different societies and cultures. The terms ‘traditional’, ‘modern’ and ‘postmodern’ will be defined, elaborated upon and discussed on a continuum of change. Social change, in the face of globalization, will be discussed in relation to how cultures and families have grown or resisted the forces of globalization. We now turn to an exploration of the types of families in the world and follow...
6 Pages(1500 words)Coursework

Critical Review of Goth: Identity, Style and Subculture by Paul Hodkinson

The allure from this standpoint is seen by the author. This report measures mainly the methodology that Hodkinson uses, which is grounded theory research, and the report also examines questions of fixed vs. flexible research. The findings of the research are briefly presented before the current research investigation concludes.

The Goth subculture is founded on principles of viewing some of what society outside this subculture, or mainstream culture, views as abhorrent or negative. There is some fetish tendency in this subculture towards the macabre and death, with face-paint style makeup and mourning clothing being prominent features of belongingness, which are certainly not reflective of mainstream fashion and makeup....
6 Pages(1500 words)Book Report/Review

Economic Analysis of India

The country’s economy is fast growing with a stable political system that encourages foreign investment although with certain restrictions. The country generally has good energy, transport and communication systems which make the cost of doing business affordably.

The Republic of India found South of Asia is by far the world’s most populous democracy and ranks seventh largest in terms of geographical area (Brown, 1994). India is also the second most highly populated country in the world. The country has a rich culture with four major religions having originally emerged from it; Sikhism, Buddhism, Hinduism, and Jainism. The Indian Republic consists of seven union territories and 28 states and ranks twelfth la...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study

International Affairs v. Liberalism

As a matter of fact, Hoffman’s statement that “international affairs is the nemesis of liberalism” has a grain of truth in it and this is especially so after the 9/11 incident.
There are two schools of thought or perspectives that are used to view international affairs: liberalism and realism. The study of these two perspectives is significant to the idea posed by Stanley Hoffman because they determine the reasons why international affairs, according to him, does not only see eye-to-eye with liberalism but seems to stand on the opposing side of it.
Liberalism can be defined as having four elements: citizens; the legislature; property rights, and; a market-driven economy (Dunne 186). Realism, on the othe...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Analysis of Educational Website

... Analysis of Educational Website Introduction Since antiquity, education remained a major component of human societies; however, until few decades ago, it existed in the society in its traditional and conventional form that involved one-to-one interaction of teachers with their students in classrooms. Since few years, educators and scholars have witnessed rapid advancements in the field of information and technology that has altered almost every sector of the society in a rapid manner, and so the education sector as well. In such advancements, internet has now become one of the most popular platforms for students, teachers, businesspersons, and individuals from every sector to acquire education and information within few clicks and minutes...
7 Pages(1750 words)Article

Analysis of Articles about Climate Change

...Climate change Can we imagine an Earth where there are no green mountains, no deep blue seas and no living creatures? No. But a disaster of such magnitude and dimension is looming over Earth. Humans have identified this threat, defined it and given it a name, global warming. This dangerous proposition is based on the truth that even a 5 % increase in the surface temperature on Earth can wipe out life from this beautiful planet. And the temperature is increasing as never before. It was in 1990s that the world began to hear serious warnings on global warming and climate change. The summary for policy makers prepared as part of the first assessment report by Inter-governmental Panel on Climate Change was the first ever in depth... change Can we ...
6 Pages(1500 words)Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic A Critical Analysis of R (Smith and West) v Parole Board for FREE!

Contact Us