StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Administrative Discretion - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Public employees constitute the class of people who work at the public sector under the direct control and administration of government. Although, public employees get comparatively attractive remuneration for their services, they are always vulnerable to salary-cut and other compensations in times of national contingencies. Since …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.6% of users find it useful
Administrative Discretion
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Administrative Discretion"

? Administrative Discretion (College) Administrative Discretion Introduction Public employees constitute the of people who work at the public sector under the direct control and administration of government. Although, public employees get comparatively attractive remuneration for their services, they are always vulnerable to salary-cut and other compensations in times of national contingencies. Since the public sector employees play a vital role in the economic growth of a nation, every nation normally formulates special policies for preserving the interests of public employees. However, it seems that various organizational practices and other developments impinge on the worksite interests of public employees. With intent to discuss the issue, this paper will cover the associated terms like administrative discretion, cyber security threats, and statutory protections for public employees. Administrative discretion In the legal context, the term discretion indicates the power to decide or act according to one’s own judgment. Some legal systems like US allow certain discretionary powers to administrative authorities. To illustrate, US law system has framed some broad limits within which an administrative authority can operate. For instance, a statute confers discretion if it is reasonable and is in public interest. To define, the administrative discretion is the expertise of professional expertise and judgment as opposed to strict adherence to regulations or statutes, in making a decision or performing official acts or duties (The Free Dictionary). In other words, when a legal system permits an administrative authority to practice discretion, it is called administrative discretion. The discretionary powers are given to an administrative authority by statute or delegation. It has observed that, generally, broad discretion powers are given to administrative agencies in order to effectively exercise their administrative authority. However, it is held that the discretionary power must not be vague or arbitrary, but it has to be in accordance with legal requirements. US Supreme Court stated that “an administrative agency enjoys wide discretion in ascertaining best way to handle related, yet discrete issues in terms of procedures and priorities” (USLegal). Although, the law imposes certain regulations on the administrative authorities in exercising their discretionary powers, it is often seen that their functions are not in line with law requirements. To illustrate, majority of the authorized persons exercise their discretionary powers to safeguard their selfish interests rather than serving employees’ needs. Kannabiran (2009) points out The Air India v. Nergesh Meerza, A.I.R. (1981) S.C. 1829, a famous Indian case related to wrongful practice of administrative discretion. At the time of the case, an air hostess normal age of retirement was 35 years. However, a regulation of the corporation authorized the managing director to increase the air hostess retirement age up to 45 years. The regulation empowered the managing director to use the provision of discretion on the account of his personal opinion rather than recording specific reasons pertaining to the decision. The regulation lacked specific guidelines and it reflected biased approach and discrimination in the practice of such discretion. In this case, the court held that it clearly indicated a situation of official arbitrariness. Public employees are often affected by the adverse exercise of administrative discretion authority as they are largely employed under administrative agencies. An authority gets the freedom to take action when it is conferred with discretionary power. However, the court can take decisions only in respect of legal validity of those taken actions. Therefore, this provision can be a serious threat to individual liberty especially, public employees’ liberty. Cyber security threats Hackers and spammers are the potential cyber security threats to public employees in this 21st century. In the opinion of Satapathy (2000), nowadays, even strong security measures are unsuccessful to control the unwanted and dreadful cyber activities. Today public employees widely use internet as part of their job. Probably, public employees transfer organizational data using internet facilities such as e-mails. However, recent events suggest than e-mail is not a safe channel for passing confidential data. In 2010, e-mail was widely used as a vector for spreading malicious attacks. For the last few years, e-mails have been widely used to spread Trojans as e-mail attachments. These Trojans enter into personal e-mail accounts and restrict the users from accessing into their accounts. Since public employees use e-mail accounts for official purposes, malicious attacks may adversely affect the safety of such data or information transfers. Every public employee has the legal obligation to ensure the safety of valuable documents which he deals with. Therefore, when malicious attacks threat the safety of valuable documents, it also negatively affects the integrity of the concerned employees. Nowadays, hackers largely use timely topics in order to lure the recipients to open mail and thereby to click on malicious links. Through this practice, hackers get access into personal e-mail accounts so that they can take unfair advantages of others’ valuable documents including official document of public employees. Similarly, it seems that software hackers largely focus on Microsoft properties with intent to check its rapid growth. Evidently, majority of the people use Microsoft products for their compatible features. When hackers produce a series of targeted attack over Microsoft properties, the company may not be able to prevent the malicious attacks effectively. Recently, smartphones are increasingly used for business affairs and hence they have become the focal point for hackers. In short, public employees today widely use modern internet facilities and hence they are more likely to confront with malicious cyber attacks. Statutory protections In olden days, the United States had not given adequate importance on the statutory protection of employees who work in public sector until recently it formulated a number of statutory provisions for public employees with intent to improve their employment policies. Before the formulation of such polices, employers used to terminate their employees without a potential reason. Jain (2007) indicates that the introduction of anti-retaliation provision supported employees in public as well in private sector because these provisions checked employers from terminating their worker without any adequate reason. Generally, employment regulating federal statutes contains such provisions and they mainly work towards the prohibition of employment reprisals. Employees face employment reprisals when they complain about their employer’s breach of statutory duties to a specified public authority. Under such circumstances, the anti-retaliation provision would save the employees from termination. These provisions include the whistleblower provisions in the Occupational Safety and Health Act, the Age Discrimination in Employment Act, and the Fair Labor Standards Act (Government of Canada). These provisions are also beneficial for the employees who have been subjected to retaliation as they also offer compensation for wage losses and seniority. In the view of Krinsky and Reese (2006), the Civil Service Reform Act of 1978 also contributes to public employee protection is United States. Under this provision, the Federal public sector employees get much broader protection if they have disclosed or wish to disclose any government wrongdoing. This type of statutory protection would largely encourage public sector employees to disclose government offense without the fear of termination or retaliation. Conclusion Although discretionary powers are granted to administrative agencies with certain legal restrictions, administrative discretion often seriously encroaches into the interests of the public employees. Similarly, cyber security threats also raise challenges to public employees since they are more likely to use internet facilities. However, different statutory protections ensure the overall safety of public sector employees which in turn would enhance the socio-economic stability of the nation. References Jain, E. (2007). “Realizing the potential of the joint harassment/retaliation claim”. The Yale Law Journal, 117, (1), 120-164. Kannabiran, K. (2009). “Judicial meanderings in patriarchal tickets: Litigating sex discrimination in India. Review of Women’s Studies”. Economic & Political Weekly, XLIV, (44), 88-97. Krinsky, J & Reese, E. (2006). “Forging and sustaining labor-community coalitions: The workfare justice movement in three cities”. Sociological Forum. 21, (4), 623-658. Satapathy, C. (2000). “”Impacts of cyber vandalism on the internet”. Economic and Political Weekly. 35, (13), 1059-1061. USLegal. Discretionary Powers. Retrieved from http://administrativelaw.uslegal.com/administrative-agencies/discretionary-powers/ Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Administrative Discretion Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1425329-adminstrative-discretion
(Administrative Discretion Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1425329-adminstrative-discretion.
“Administrative Discretion Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1425329-adminstrative-discretion.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Administrative Discretion

Separation of Powers Exists within the British Political System

Ever since, one of the implicit conditions of this outcome was that the judges should take care not to encroach on the legitimate spheres of discretion of the sovereign political authorities, Crown and Parliament.... It is notable that unlike others entities the Crown is not subject to legal regulation due to the sense of dignity it evokes....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

How Hayek Interprets the Rule of Law

Hayek interprets the rule of law as referring to an ideal condition in which all government actions are bound by general rules that are fixed and announced beforehand.... Hayek's ideal is one that can never be entirely realized in practice, but it does provide him with a… The rules must be general in the sense that they are not aimed at the needs, wants, or activities of particular people....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Impacts of Cyber Vandalism on the Internet

In the paper “Impacts of Cyber Vandalism on the Internet” the author analyzes Administrative Discretion, which indicates the power to decide or act according to one's own judgment.... To define, the Administrative Discretion is the expertise of professional expertise and judgment.... With intent to discuss the issue, this paper will cover the associated terms like Administrative Discretion, cybersecurity threats, and statutory protections for public employees....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Administrative Discretion PA301 wk 5

He connected the influence of capitalism with the existence of culture through religion as he went against the ideals of Karl Marx Administrative Discretion and Max Weber Administrative Discretion and Max Weber Max Weber has been known to beone of the important people to lay down the foundation of social science.... Weber also influenced the concept of Administrative Discretion as he got into several sociological issues.... Administrative Discretion has been linked to bureaucracy....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

The Responsible Administrator: Chapter Nine

In addition, the author notes that if the utilization and misuse of Administrative Discretion is thoroughly evaluated then it results as being another positive relationship between the rule of law and competent public sector management methods ( Sharpe, 2011).... This chapter is crafted with suitable examples of important ethical problems and how… In addition Cooper re-emphasizes the need for an appropriate approach for the public administrative role....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Issues in Measure of Property

The rule of law comprises of clearly outlined policies that involves the rights and laws that govern the citizens.... This rule is associated with… The rule of law and measure of property is objected to sectors like employment, innovation, education, social inclusion, climate and energy. The rule of law cannot be These indicators should be reliable and based on a sound frame work....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Collective bargaining agreement case study

Allocating quality: Collective bargaining agreements and Administrative Discretion over teacher assignment.... Factors such as salaries differ, and Andover, our school, seems to have better terms that suit teachers better.... There is an increase in the… In terms of vacations and holidays, Andover has better terms that point out the specific periods set for holidays....
1 Pages (250 words) Case Study

CONSTITUTION & ADMINISTRATIVE LAW

Moreover, Wade an administrative theorist agrees with the arguments of Dicey and Blackstone albeit at... Dicey writing in 1885 explains it as every act that the executive can lawfully commit without an Act of Parliament.... Conceivably, this explanation confirms… On the other hand, Viscount Radcliffe holds that the powers under royal prerogative are neither discretionary nor arbitrary as some want to He argues that they are indeed acts of necessity, which the government performs in sudden and extreme emergency, especially when it is in the public interest to do so....
4 Pages (1000 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us