We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Nobody downloaded yet

Historians Can't Speculate - Essay Example

Comments (0)
Summary
This paper "Historians Can't Speculate" focuses on the fact that this is a naïve interpretation of the process of historical research and writing given by a novelist rather than a historian. Morrison’s comment also suggests that greater license can and should be given to the novelist.  …
Download full paper
GRAB THE BEST PAPER
Historians Cant Speculate
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample
Historians Can't Speculate

Download file to see previous pages... Yet when the historical records of an event such as American slavery tend to be biased towards the view of it as just another type of economic enterprise, there is clear value in what might be termed memory or the an attempt to explore what actually occurred using the human imagination as a spur rather than 'actual' historical records. Beloved is a prime example of such an attempt.
Historians are concerned with events which can be assigned to specific time-space locations, events which are (or were) in principle observable or perceivable, whereas imaginary writers . . . are concerned with both these kinds of events and imagined, hypothetical, or invented ones.
It is interesting to note that White's definition provides for an area of coincidence between the work of the historian and the work of the imaginary writer (such as Morrison, who is a novelist) by suggesting that novelists deal with historical events as well as historians, although they may also include the fictional elements that the historian supposedly does not.
As White suggests, it was after the Enlightenment and the French Revolution that history and literature started to part company. By the early 1800's "it became conventional, at least among historians, to identify truth with fact and to regard fiction as the opposite of the truth" (White, p.123) (emphasis added). This might seem almost childishly simplistic to many scholars today, but it can be related to the supposed triumph of the 'rational', often in the form of Science, over the irrational. The word science means "to know" (from the Latin scio, to know) and the only thing that can be "known" is a fact. Fiction was thus "a hindrance to the understanding of reality rather than as a way of apprehending it"(White, p.123). History was thus placed within a hierarchy that placed it indelibly above, and thus superior, to that of mere fiction. Many historians of this era did not seem to consider the fact that the histories which they were writing depended a lot upon which facts were being considered, and that this just as much choice and imagination went into writing them as in fiction. History dealt with facts, and thus the truth, while fiction dealt with non-facts, and thus lies.
It was only during the Twentieth Century that history and fiction started their long journey back towards one another. In the Nineteenth Century historians did not realize that which seems self-evident today: "facts do not speak for themselves, but that the historian speaks for them, speaks on their behalf, and fashions the fragments of the past into a whole whose whole integrity is - in its representation - a purely discursive one" (White, p.125). It is this "fashioning" which makes history resemble the process a fictional writer goes through when she is creating a world of characters.
The historian takes a historical event, for example, the Fall of the Bastille, and gives meaning to it by creating a kaleidoscope through which the event can be seen. The fact that the Bastille fell cannot be disputed; what that falling means can be. Both history and fiction deal with meaning, and thus can be regarded as different techniques with the same end in mind.   ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
CHECK THESE SAMPLES - THEY ALSO FIT YOUR TOPIC
Why Some People Can't Learn English
This paper focuses on the reasons why some people who have migrated to the English speaking countries cannot learn English, despite spending half of their lifetime there. These reasons include factors arising out of the willingness of people, as well as their unwillingness. But, the major reason is the fear of loss of culture.
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
The Greek Historians
This is in the sense that to Greeks history did not have a time line because they considered events that had witnesses still alive as historical events. Individuals like Homer who is well known for his role in detailing the Trojan War are some of the examples of Greek historians who earned their rightful place in history up to today.
5 Pages(1250 words)Book Report/Review
Why Lovers Can't Be Friends
Conlon (2002) asserts that the idea that lovers cannot be friends takes its roots in Plato's thinking that: "1) Each human self is a discrete substance combining essential and unique qualities; 2) All attraction is a desire for union; and 3). The purpose of this union is to share in, possess or otherwise take part in these qualities."
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
History According to Neo-Conservative Historians
In a nutshell, Strauss viewed Hitlers rise as not having resulted from Germanys post- world war one socio-economic predicament- the view held by most experts and historians- but rather as the result of Europes evolution towards liberalized labor
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
How historians make use of other social sciences
For example, one often considers history in context with certain other subject. If one thinks of political history of any nation, it is actually the
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Response to ''why can't Ex-Felons vote
Denying these people the right to vote has been altering the political scenario in the nation. In my opinion, ex-felons should be allowed to vote, as this is the only way they can make known their voice. In the states, where crime is rampant, denial of the right to
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Why we can't wait-martin luther king
Martin Luther King Jr is a renowned leader, clergyman and activist who largely advocated for civil rights in America. He is well recognized for his responsibility in the headway of civil rights by use of nonviolent means, and for this reason, he became an established nationwide icon in the history of modern American liberalism.
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
Why can't we outlaw war
It is one of the biggest challenges facing humanity from the beginning. It changed human culture as well as policies in different countries in the past. Japan for instance changed
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
To what extent do historians own history
It has often been claimed that history is primarily written by the eventual victors. This postulation is seen to be in line with Foner’s postulation that History has and will definitely always be rewritten
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
Public Enemy's Can't truss it
La Rock and Jazzy Jay, “sing a simple song” by Sly and the Family Stone, “hihache” by Lafayette Afro Rock Band, “I’m nin’alu” by Ofra Haza, “dumb girl” by Run-D.M.C., and “get up, get into it, get involved” by James
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper
Let us find you another Essay on topic Historians Can't Speculate for FREE!
Contact us:
+16312120006
Contact Us Now
FREE Mobile Apps:
  • About StudentShare
  • Testimonials
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Free Essays
  • New Essays
  • Essays
  • The Newest Essay Topics
  • Index samples by all dates
Join us:
Contact Us