Functionalist and Intentionalist Explanations of the Rwanda and Holocaust Mass Murders - Essay Example

Comments (1) Cite this document
Summary
In this paper, you will find the full analysis of the mass murder in Rwanda. Further, the analysis compares and evaluates the Holocaust and Rwanda mass murders, as the modern example of genocide. Also, through the comparison of Intenionalist and Functionalist there will be given an explanation of the two mass murders…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.6% of users find it useful
Functionalist and Intentionalist Explanations of the Rwanda and Holocaust Mass Murders
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Functionalist and Intentionalist Explanations of the Rwanda and Holocaust Mass Murders"

Download file to see previous pages The mass murder in Rwanda is a perfect example of the modern time genocide born of ethnic hatred. As compared to the Holocaust genocide, the events unfolding in Rwanda in 1994 gave birth to the systematic slaughter of more than eight hundred thousand Moderate Hutu and Tutsi. This aspect position the Rwandese massacre to being a massacre of the modern phenomenon, absorbed by rationalism, bureaucracy and technology. The massacre of the European Jews, commonly referred to by a majority of scholars as the Holocaust, on the other hand is among the genocides known to the greater percentage of the educated in the society. Between the years 1941 and 1945, European Jews ranging between five and xix million were systematically massacred by the Nazi regime (under the leadership of Adolf Hitler) in collaboration with its allies and other surrogates in the Nazi-occupied territories. Irrespective of the astonishing intensity and scale of the genocide, the prominence of the Holocaust in the recent couple of years has been far from being preordained.
Having given a brief preamble of both the Rwandese and the Holocaust genocides, this paper therefore, gears towards availing an in-depth comparison between the two genocides. In addition, this paper also does evaluate both the functionalist and the intentionalists explanation of the two cases of mass murder based on the principal areas of focus such as uniqueness, precedent and generality in either case as drawn from different theoretical quarters. Comparison and Evaluation of the Holocaust and Rwanda Mass Murders When it comes to the definition of what genocide is, it somehow proves to be challenging. Nevertheless, massacres have over and again been repeated in different parts of the world. The most imperative thing to keep in remembrance is that a mass murder remains to be not only a controversial, but also a contested debate among politicians, historians, academics, fascists and nationalists. Irrespective of the noticeable differences in the context of a mass murder, neither of the sides presents a different opinion or even repudiates the authenticity of the Rwanda and the Holocaust, nor is there sombre rejection over the principle that the Hutus and Adolf Hitler were responsible for the crimes they set off. In this event therefore, it is imperative finding a mechanism of gauging the reality beyond the Rwanda and the Holocaust massacres (Christopher 2004, p.34). As thus, there arise two schools of thought as regards to the historiography of these genocides. These schools of thought are the functionalist and the intentionalist explanations of the genocides. Intenionalist versus Functionalist Explanation of the two Mass Murders Over the past two or so decades, the most heated debate has been revolving around an erudite predisposition by and large referred to as intentionalist and an antagonistic functionalist explanation. Arguably, a great percentage of the interpretation and data so gathered on the Rwanda and the Holocaust massacres relate in one way or the other either in the functionalist or the intentionalist perspectives. To begin with the Holocaust genocide it is even derivable from the word itself, the intenionalists’ explanation lays more accents on the intention that the Nazis had; and from the kick off, it is undeniable that these Nazis had their minds made up to eliminate the European Jews in whichever manner, including carrying a mass slaughter on them. An approach of this kind puts emphasis on the figure of Adolf Hitler and his monomaniacal passion to do away with what he referred to as the Jewish cancer from Germany and Europe as a whole (Tom 2010, p.25). Adolf’s stance of facilitating an elimination of the European Jews is clearly evidenced by the statement he makes when addressing a journalist. He confidently declares that in the event that he assumes power, his first priority ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Functionalist and Intentionalist Explanations of the Rwanda and Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1403401-functionalist-and-intentionalist-explanations-of-the-rwanda-and-holocaust-mass-murders
(Functionalist and Intentionalist Explanations of the Rwanda and Essay)
https://studentshare.org/history/1403401-functionalist-and-intentionalist-explanations-of-the-rwanda-and-holocaust-mass-murders.
“Functionalist and Intentionalist Explanations of the Rwanda and Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1403401-functionalist-and-intentionalist-explanations-of-the-rwanda-and-holocaust-mass-murders.
  • Cited: 1 times
Comments (1)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
ja
jaquelinokeefe added comment 10 months ago
Student rated this paper as
The topic of "Functionalist and Intentionalist Explanations of the Rwanda and Holocaust Mass Murders" was hard to find. I spent hours to find it. Here at StudentShare, I got the finest sample. Many thanks!

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Functionalist and Intentionalist Explanations of the Rwanda and Holocaust Mass Murders

Functionalist and intentionalist explanations of mass murder cases

..., 1992). If Germany was never decimated, which means that its structure was not weakened to the point where the people were hungry for a leader like Hitler, then Nazism could not have happened. A strong country would not abide by a person like Hitler. A weak country would be open to him and his ideas. In this way, the functionalist argument, that the weakening of the country enabled Hitler to happen, intersects with the intentionalist argument, that Hitler took the weakened country and imposed his ideology on the country, and this was the ultimate cause of the Holocaust (Goldhagen, 1996). Rwanda had some similarities to Nazism, but they were not the developed,...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

Holocaust and Rwanda Genocide

...school of thought were referred to as “the twisted road to Auschwitz” camp owing to their insistence that it was the internal power arrangements of the Third Reich that orchestrated the Holocaust. Hence, functionalists/structuralists assert that Holocaust stemmed as part of the functioning of the Nazi state while intentionalists believe that it was Hitler’s intents alone that propelled the Holocaust (Confino2012, p.118). Functionalism also referred to as structuralism and intentionalism represents a historiographical debate centring on the origins of mass murder such as the Holocaust. The two schools of...
13 Pages(3250 words)Essay

Holocaust

...? Elie Wiesel is the Nobel Peace Prize winner of 1986. His book en d “Night”, originally en d “Un di Velt Hot Geshvign” was published in 1956. The book was recently translated into French by Elie's wife, Marion Wiesel, in 2006. However, the English translation of the book has been released way back in 1960, translated by Stella Rodway. The novel is reminiscent of the experiences of the author after surviving and enduring torture during the holocaust. The author narrated his story of being at the Auschwitz and Buchenwald concentration camps with his father. Elie was the sole survivor of those camps and surprisingly enough, his narrations claim that even his father was able to survive an entire year of sheer torture....
5 Pages(1250 words)Dissertation

The Manson Murders

...? The Manson Murders By Due Charles Manson was born on 12 November 1934. He had a historyof committing crimes ranging from petty thefts to burglaries at various stores and gas stations during his childhood. After being in and out and finally being released on March 21, 1967, he had spent more than half of his 32 years in prisons and other institutions. Upon his release, he was granted a permission to move to San Francisco where he moved into an apartment in Berkeley with the help of a prison acquaintance. He got to know Mary Brunner, a 23-year-old graduate of the University of Wisconsin–Madison, and moved in with her. He made her agree to his bringing other women to her resident and soon they were sharing her residence...
5 Pages(1250 words)Term Paper

Holocaust

..., and considerations, it can clearly be determined that the Holocaust and the racial cruelty that he was exhibited within Germany during the years in question is not entirely dissimilar to the racial cruelty, ethnic cleansing, mass murder, and societal upheaval that have occurred in places such as Armenia, Cambodia, Rwanda, Bosnia, and a litany of different states around the globe. In short, the running list of theories that is been provided should not be understood as somehow uniquely German. Rather, these forces can have a powerful impact throughout the globe and to determine the way in which conflict is exhibited and different groups are persecuted for no reason other...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Hotel Rwanda

...Hotel Rwanda . The history of the world in the twentieth century is dotted with genocide. The massacre of the Tutsis by the Hutus in Rwanda in 1994 was one of the most reprehensible of them all, because the world turned a blind eye to it. The 2004 film Hotel Rwanda tells the true story of a deliberate massacre of the Tutsis, an ethnic minority of Rwanda , by the Hutus, and the efforts of one man to save the victims. .Set in Kigalu, the capital of Rwanda during April -May 1994, the movie shows the courage of Paul Rusesabagina, the manager of a luxury hotel, Hotel des Mille Collines, who endeavored to save the victims of the violence against all...
3 Pages(750 words)Movie Review

Functionalist theory

...Functionalist Theory This informative, raptorial, argumentative article about sociology presents numerous facts regarding functionalist theory and how drugs and alcohol affect the lower class and higher class differently in society through out America's history. In order to make this studying even more understandable a brief description of functionalist theory is highlighted in this article. Plus, It's highly shedding light on how society perceived poor people who are addicted to alcohol and drugs and how differently rich people who are addicted to drugs and alcohol are viewed in society as compare to low class, the rate of drugs and alcohols addicts in both the lower and higher class in...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Holocaust

...The Holocaust The horrendous actions of the Third Reich during WWII are well documented. The result ofthe Nazi’s immoral ideologies included occupying much of Europe and the ‘final solution,’ the murder of more than six million Jews (Dawidowicz, 1986: 3). Throughout the history of the world, many countries have conquered others for a variety of motives while oppressing its citizens but what was the motive for systematically exterminating a particular race of people? How could such a passionate hatred of Jews spread through an entire national conscience causing such horrific acts to be perpetrated? Despite popular opinion, the Holocaust didn’t occur because the German people fell into...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Holocaust

...The Holocaust happened for various reasons. Anti-Semitism in Europe helped facilitate a scapegoat for the Versailles Treaty and the economic depression in Germany. Hitler used propaganda to make all the Jews the root of all problems. As a result, Hitler could justify war and territorial gains. The German people readily accepted the necessity to exterminate an enemy. Propaganda allowed the Holocaust to continue. The war also allowed the Holocaust to go on for so long. Since the Diaspora, or scattering of the Jews from current day Israel, Europeans viewed them with distrust. Most of Western Europe and Russia were Christian states during the Middle Ages and after. Those states that were not...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Holocaust and Rwanda Assignment

...Holocaust and Rwanda Accountability is a strong way for the perpetrators to accept their mistake and the wrong they carried out through killing people or commissioning their killing or participation in any way to the genocide or holocaust. This is usually considered the first step towards not only acceptance but reconciliation as well among the communities in order to dissipate the hatred that continues to brew years after the actual genocide took place. This aspect of accountability is why the perpetrators of the violence are taken to court and sentenced if found guilty as explained in Des Forges, (1999). Witnessing is the aspect of stating the events as one observed or was directly...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Functionalist and Intentionalist Explanations of the Rwanda and Holocaust Mass Murders for FREE!

Contact Us