Free

Same Sex Marriage - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
In his essay “The case against same-sex marriage crumbles,” Andrew Sullivan has put forth the argument in favor of same-sex marriage, and has proposed that same-sex marriages should be made legal. To prove his point, he has used the so called disadvantages and problems of…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.3% of users find it useful
Same Sex Marriage
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Same Sex Marriage"

Introduction In his essay “The case against same-sex marriage crumbles,” Andrew Sullivan has put forth the argument in favor of same-sex marriage, and has proposed that same-sex marriages should be made legal. To prove his point, he has used the so called disadvantages and problems of heterosexual marriage as his weapons. However, his points completely fail to appeal the reader as they not only show his narrow minded approach but also his inability to see the other side of the situation. Unfortunately for Sullivan, the points that he uses to degrade the heterosexual marriage are the same points which prove why heterosexual marriages are a need and necessity of the society. In an attempt to show the positive aspects of gay marriage, he has ended up disclosing the negative and harmful practices that gay marriage can potentially inculcate in adults.
Weak points in Sullivan’s argument
The first point that is disagreeable in Sullivan’s essay is his comparison of heterosexual people with gays. The point he makes is that gays are asking for the equal status similar to that of the heterosexuals asked for during 1970’s. By this, he means that gays should be included in society without any hesitation and should be treated equally. However, what he fails to understand is that when heterosexuals were asking for equal status, they were asking for equal status ‘and’ respect for the ‘opposite’ and ‘unique’ responsibilities that women were carrying out in their married life. Females were never given importance and respect for their role in the development and growth of their families. Hence, they were asking to be given ‘equal’ status to men. However, in gay marriages there is no such friction as gays cannot fulfill the role of female no matter how feminine a partner is. Hence, comparing gay people’s demand for equal status to the demand of equal status by heterosexuals is absurd.
Secondly, Sullivan talks about the psychological wounds that gay men suffer due to heterosexual marriages they are forced into. However, Sullivan fails to look into the future of same-sex marriage. The same-sex marriage can cause immense psychological problems and deeper wounds on children as child needs both, a father and a mother, for healthy emotional and psychological growth.
Third point that is unacceptable in Sullivan’s argument is his idea of sexual freedom that gays enjoy. Sullivan is saying that sexual freedom is in having sex with anyone and anytime you want to. According to him, more partners mean more freedom. It is difficult to understand how he has come to this conclusion. He says that monogamy creates stress and strain in heterosexual marriage, indicating that if one partner indulges in sexual relationship out of marriage, then other partner feels jealous and does not accept it. However, the point is, this is also applicable in gay marriages. Sullivan is ‘assuming’ that gay people do not harbor any emotional or psychological attachments to their partners the way heterosexual people do. However, every human being, no matter what sexual orientation he is of, develops emotional attachment to his partner. Hence, it is absurd to assume that gay people do not have emotional, physical and psychological attachments with their partners. However, one can find many cases where infidelity has caused stress and strain in gay unions.
Conclusion
The discussion above proves that Sullivan’s attempt to prove gay marriages as happy unions compared to heterosexual marriages has backfired severely and in fact, has convinced the reader that gay marriages are nothing but demand of those people who are not capable of understanding the importance and necessity of commitment and union between male and female and hence, not capable of being a responsible part of the society.
Work Cited
Sullivan, Andrew. The case against same-sex marriage crumbles. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Same Sex Marriage Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words - 1”, n.d.)
Same Sex Marriage Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words - 1. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/gender-sexual-studies/1586941-same-sex-marriage
(Same Sex Marriage Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words - 1)
Same Sex Marriage Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words - 1. https://studentshare.org/gender-sexual-studies/1586941-same-sex-marriage.
“Same Sex Marriage Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/gender-sexual-studies/1586941-same-sex-marriage.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Same Sex Marriage

Legalizing same Sex Marriage

...? Legalizing same Sex Marriage Legalizing same sex marriage has become one of the most controversial debate in the United s of America. There are several arguments to this cause: every citizen has the right to pursue happiness; gay marriage is morally wrong; it is a travesty to the institution of marriage and family. One of the biggest fight in America, is the fight for equality. In the fifties and sixties, black Americans fought for equal rights, and this was one of the longest and most publicized fight since the abolishment of slavery. Today there is a new, tempestuous issue on the horizon— the...
17 Pages(4250 words)Essay

Same sex marriage

...is based on prejudice and, as time passes, the concept will become more and more accepted. It, like racial prejudice, will become socially abhorrent (Sullivan, 2000). In addition, the disallowing of gay marriage by legislation violates the Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment.  According to the American Civil Liberties Union, “The law [against same-sex marriage] discriminates on the basis of sex because it makes one's ability to marry depend on one's gender.” The ACLU continues by saying, “Classifications which discriminate on the basis of gender must be substantially related to some important government purpose. Tradition by itself is not an...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Same-Sex Marriage

...? DRAFT COPY FINAL PAPER Same Sex-Marriage Robert George’s and Angela Bolte’s Same-sex marriages have been a hot public issue in America for the pastfew decades. The earliest known gay rights organization is the Society for Human Rights in Chicago that was established in 1924 and launched the first gay rights movement. After that, the Mattachine Society was established in 1950. History reveals that a number of organizations and movements have been launched at state level which support gay rights which include ceremonial marriages, child adoption, domestic partnership registration on public record, domestic partnership...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Same Sex Marriage

...Same Sex Marriage Same Sex Marriage is a highly controversial from whichever angle it is approached, be it from the ethical, moral or religious perspective. Until quite recently in our modern history, homosexuality was not part of the collective social norm. Specifically in the United States, homosexuality was seen by many as taboo as recently as the 1970s. Homosexuality was even seen as dangerous, especially with the rise of the AIDS epidemic in the 1990s. In more contemporary times, homosexuality is becoming more widely accepted. Analogous to other civil rights movements, a shift in societal norms calls to question the laws of the...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Same Sex Marriage

...the homosexual community supported by the pro-gay rights activists who argue for the rights of same-sex citizens to be married just the same as heterosexual marriages; and the religious, social, moral and political authorities who do not support same-sex marriages. The legalization of same-sex marriages is thus an issue of common and urgent concern, and all voices must be heard before making a legal judgment in this situation. In the present situation of homosexual promiscuity especially in the gay community, and the looming threat of AIDS, same...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Same Sex Marriage

...Argumentative Essay on Same Sex Marriage One of the most controversial questions of the day, Same-sex marriage, also called gay marriage, has become a term heatedly debated in the news media and politics. The legitimacy of the same sex marriage as well as the rights of the people who opt for this practice has been central topics of debate and there are numerous points of view and varied conclusions on the topic. The social perspectives, religious convictions, economic arguments, health-related problems, and various related issues etc enhance the scope of the discussions...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Same Sex Marriage

...States. Nowadays it seems as though the administration is promoting Christianity by stating that the Bible declares that God says that marriage was intended for one man together with one woman. If the government would try to please everyone within this nation, it may be a total catastrophe. I suppose that there has been way over concentration on gay marriages, and too little on equal handling (Fisher, R. D., 1994). Gay marriages contradict the self-apparent truth of nature where male and female bodies are calculated for and match each other. Homosexual marriage may undervalue your marriage. An authorization to marry seems to be a lawful document, by...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Debating Same-Sex Marriage

...Same sex marriages This paper will give the solutions on to which the society should undertake in order to solve the social problem of same sex marriages. Recent discussions on marriage between same sex individuals have lead to the emergence of debates about gay marriages. This is because this kind of marriage is referred to as marriage between individuals of the same sex or gender identity. The increase in the spread of HIV in the community is regarded to be due to that fact that matters about sexuality...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Same sex marriage issue

...Same-sex Marriage Issue Same-sex Marriage Issue The article asserts that the marriage of Edith Windsor and Thea Spyer is recognized by the State of New York. However, it expounds on how Windsor was barred by Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) from tax exemption when she claimed the federal estate tax exemption because she was a surviving spouse. According to the article, the denial of the exemption was in connection with the provided definition of marriage and spouse that excluded same-sex partners. According to the Attorney General, as well as the District...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Same Sex Marriage

...Same-Sex Marriage Issue. Homosexual relationships have long been the bone of contention in the Western civilization; though recent liberal trends and democratic ideas influence development of more tolerant view of the issue. The growing number of Western countries legitimate same-sex marriages, entrenching the right of people to engage in homosexual relationships. However, although the compromise is eventually reached concerning same-sex civil unions, approval of gay marriages by the Christian church still sparks rigorous debates. Zerilli (29) states that “the official opinion in many...
7 Pages(1750 words)Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Same Sex Marriage for FREE!

Contact Us