One Dogma of Police Ethics: Gratuities and the Democratic Ethos of Policing - Article Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
ONE DOGMA OF POLICE ETHICS (Gratuities and the Democratic Ethos) Name of Student (author) Name of University Introduction The police profession has developed its own culture over the years. It has its own lingo, practices, ethics and moral principles that its members have to abide by to stay in the force…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.7% of users find it useful
One Dogma of Police Ethics: Gratuities and the Democratic Ethos of Policing
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "One Dogma of Police Ethics: Gratuities and the Democratic Ethos of Policing"

ONE DOGMA OF POLICE ETHICS (Gratuities and the Democratic Ethos) of Introduction The police profession hasdeveloped its own culture over the years. It has its own lingo, practices, ethics and moral principles that its members have to abide by to stay in the force. It is a unique culture characterized by some features, such as the “blue wall of silence” in which police members protect their own when it comes to sticky situations and the attitude towards gratuities. Some of its practices can be quite controversial like justifying the use of deception to catch some criminals through “sting operations” and other kinds of practices in which good behaviors and its bad behaviors can get conflated at times which could be at variance with the law. Some members of the police force can get away with it by strong-arming some witnesses and twisting the facts. However one looks at it, the police force is a necessary social good that a civilized society needs. It is financed through the imposition of taxes and therefore exists due to a common purse. It is a vital social service similar to public education and health care that requires civic scrutiny so that a police force remains a professional force all throughout and carries out its given mandate. This paper re-examines the public discourse on the moral hazards of the acceptance of gratuities offered by certain segments of the general public and how it affects all the police force members. In particular, the paper gives a summary of an article written by Mr. Brandon del Pozo who is a member of the New York Police Department (NYPD) entitled as “One Dogma of Police Ethics: Gratuities and the 'Democratic Ethos' of Policing” which was published in the summer of 2005 by the journal Criminal Justice Ethics. Furthermore, a critique of the same article is given. The acceptance of gratuities can be seen both ways, as one way to enhance community relations between police officers and the civilian populace they are sworn to protect and another way is to see it a roundabout way of giving bribes and pay-offs without running afoul of the law. Discussion The author argues that acceptance of gratuities, although freely offered by citizens, is a dilemma for police force members. In the article, he cites that doing so violates democratic ethos because the police force exists from the taxes imposed on citizens and so everyone should in all cases be afforded the same treatment, based on need and not on the ability to pay a surcharge for such services by giving out gratuities to gain favors from the police, no matter how trifling it is. Acceptance represents a moral hazard of sorts because it requires some reciprocity of some kind. It puts the police member in an awkward position whenever it calls for objective judgment. It can influence his decision-making capability and ultimately his actions with regards to violations. The author further states that police protection should be equally afforded to all citizens, similarly like what the laws of society are intended to be, which is equal protection of everybody. However, police protection is a unique type of social good which incidentally, also has a finite amount to it since police presence cannot be dispensed at all times to everybody because of some limitations, such as in its budget for manpower hiring and equipment. The dilemma in these kind of situations is how to embody the democratic ethos without resorting to socialist methods. A more equitable distribution of police services has to be found, not based on needs or a factor that is somewhat arbitrary that skews police distribution, whether it is preferential or not. The author argued that the use of John Rawls' theory of justice that is based on social contract is more appropriate when trying to solve a dilemma that is as prevalent as that of police gratuities. It helps to re-define the context in which this practice is viewed by most, not intrinsically as evil, but rather, dependent on the context gratuities are given, such as innocently with no strings to it. To critique, this article as written is a bit too wordy for the ideas it tried to convey to a reader. The author is fond of using roundabout ways of saying things, which could have been expressed in simpler ways or shorter sentences. The reader is often stumped on how to interpret some of his assumptions and assertions because the sentences are quite long, sometimes almost the length approximating an entire paragraph. This sentence structure makes reading the article a bit of a chore and it takes a lot of effort to absorb what was being said by the author. There is a real danger of more important ideas being lost on the reader due to this improbable structure. The author makes a good case of saying that acceptance of gratuities freely given and in small trifling amounts do not constitute a wrongful act by itself; it is only the appearance of any impropriety that is a problem. However, police officers are also required or expected to maintain good relations with the local community, and acceptance of gratuities freely given as a sign of its civic friendship is not inherently or intrinsically wrong or immoral. It must be pointed out that all police officers perform their duties under a lot of ambiguities and uncertainties in which officers exercise a lot of discretion and personal decisions during an entire day of tour duty, leading to at times imperfect judgment (del Pozo, 2005, p. 17) because after all, officers are also humans. The environment in which police officers exercise their duties and decision-making capabilities have a lot of gray areas; an example is the use of the appropriate level of force in application of legal violence since they are the only ones tasked to employ it as the law requires to subdue criminals. Conclusion Community policing requires good relationships with the citizens and in this regard, it is absurd to totally ban acceptance of trifling gratuities, as long as these are given with no intention of securing favorable treatment. The view held by Michael Feldberg is too unrealistic or stifling; refusal of gratuities can even be misconstrued as an insult by some people. Furthermore, a theory of John Rawls emphasize that a social contract involves only a satisfactory minimum in terms of police service based on his maximin principle (in which possible gains are maximized while the probable losses are minimized) with regards to the people in a society who have the least in life (ibid. p. 13) whereby author del Pozo termed it as the satisfactory minimum of police protection. As long as this minimum requirement is satisfied, then there will be no arguments on gratuities. The debate on gratuities is engrossing but it does not by itself violate the democratic ethos of the requirements for police services; as Shakespeare said, it is just “much ado about nothing.” Reference del Pozo, B. (2005, Summer-Fall). “One Dogma of Police Ethics: Gratuities and the 'Democratic Ethos' of Policing.” Criminal Justice Ethics, 24(2), 25-46. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“One Dogma of Police Ethics: Gratuities and the Democratic Ethos of Article”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(One Dogma of Police Ethics: Gratuities and the Democratic Ethos of Article)
“One Dogma of Police Ethics: Gratuities and the Democratic Ethos of Article”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF One Dogma of Police Ethics: Gratuities and the Democratic Ethos of Policing

Importance of Community Policing within Police Organizations policing programs are conducted and implemented. A police section that takes community policing characteristically, designs a program that meets its exclusive local state of affairs. Most police sections, on the other hand, begin by developing unconnected community policing sections that aim at one or more advanced crime covering developments or surroundings. In many circumstances these are the identical communities that cover and community expansion planners have embattled for renewal. The number of locations targeted in any society will depend on a total number of factors, like the level of local obligation to community...
16 Pages(4000 words)Research Paper

Police ethics

...? Police Ethics: A Research Paper goes here Project No. 2 18th April, of your goes here Police Ethics Ethics provide the baseline for the operational behavior of any organization, though every organization observe a customize set of ethics but police department has to have a very considerate set of ethics because it is concerned with public safety and convenience at large. The observation of this ethical code of conduct is even more critical in police investigations where the detective has some extra bit of powers in order to probe into a matter. However, there are well...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay


...? Gratuities to Police Officers Affiliation with more information about affiliation, research grants,conflict of interest and how to contact Gratuities to Police Officers Question 1: Integrity can be perceived as one of the most significant traits that police officers should possess for discharging their duties impartially and efficiently. Therefore, in order to serve the public in an equitable and impartial manner, police organizations need to imbue a respectable work culture that does not tolerate corruption of any nature to win the trust of the public. Thus, to maintain the integrity of their officers,...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Pros and Cons of Police Gratuities

...(Barker 47). He also gives an example of a cook who offered him a free meal in exchange of frequent visits he made to his (cook) establishment. Police officers are routinely obligated to provide such services to the community, and they should not be rewarded at all for providing such services, however; the cook felt a sense of indebtedness to Kania for security services he offered, and the cook’s response was a personal one: a free meal (Barker 51). The problem he noted is that some of his colleagues when offered such gratuities will make it a routine to collect them on a daily basis. This turns out to be the beginning of corrupting the police system. Therefore,...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Pros and Cons of Police Gratuities

...Pros and Cons of Police Gratuities For a long period, the topic of police gratuities has challenged many people. Further evaluations on ethical grounds, moral grounds, and law guidelines to police gratuities can give the necessary answers to allow the practice or not. Police gratuities are gifts, discounts, and favours offered to police officers by members of the public. This paper discusses the pros and cons of giving gratuities to the police. Cons First, provisions of gratuities to police officers lead them to become corrupt. According to Sherman’s theory of “Slippery floor” as quoted on clear water police website, “Acceptance of gratuities lead to acceptance of bribes, which lead to acceptance of payoffs and so on” (Andrews web... of...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Neighbourhood policing, is it real police work

...of neighbourhood policing as the partnership of local police departments in providing teams of police for a community so that a coordinated effort emerges between police community support officers (PCSOs), special constables, volunteers, partners, and wardens in order to target and find solutions for crime issues that are specific to the neighbourhood. The titles for the differing programs and the titles for the teams may change from one location to another. As an example, the Metropolitan Police Department refers to their teams as Safer Neighbourhood Teams. Although they call themselves different names to associate themselves to...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay


...credibility and thereby, likewise makes a difference in establishing ethos. The projected image manifested through the selection of the most appropriate attire during the interview would make either a positive or negative reflection of one’s work behavior and ethics. The physical feature exhibits the kind of professionalism that would be projected to the public if and when the applicant would be admitted to the organization. 7. is the email address the Aaron Gordon should use when he sends an email to a potential employer because the address is more formal and projects an image of professionalism through establishing it coming from a higher educational institution. 8....
1 Pages(250 words)Book Report/Review


...Use of Ethos on UNICEF website Ethos is a rhetoric tool used appeal to ethics, and is a means of convincing the audience of the character or credibility of the persuader. A critical analysis of the UNICEF website in respect of the various photos which are posted exhibit ethos. The visual impression they create is a critical and creative approach towards appealing for support towards children who are subject to catastrophes. Most of the image content on the site focuses on realistic presentation of the messages by depicting the plight of underprivileged children across the world and this constitutes ethos (Hyde 4-13). Stand...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Policing in a Democratic Society

...and threats. But, the real situation is opposite which is largely due to the fact that power is often not exercised in accordance with democratic principles. More attention is focused on reinforcing the crime-fighter image than maintaining order in society. The police do so to create this impression on the public that “they, and they alone, could control” (Walker & Katz, 2012, p. 7). One of the most important principles of democratic policing is to use the authority delegated to the police by the state in the best interests of common people. When power is used by the capitalist class to control the working class or to monopolize their...
4 Pages(1000 words)Assignment

Police Patrol: The Backbone of Policing

...Police Patrol: The Backbone of Policing As seen in the work of Archbold, patrol service is the centre of policing as thepolice in patrol play numerous roles from preventing crime to responding to calls that require their service (2). The methods of patrol services have changed with time, since its onset on patrol on foot to patrols on automobiles. This piece will endeavor to examine how the history of policing has progressed and changed over time. In the beginning, American policing solely relied on the citizens who were responsible for enforcing law. The citizens formed a huge part of the watch groups, what formed the frankpledge system as seen in...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Article on topic One Dogma of Police Ethics: Gratuities and the Democratic Ethos of Policing for FREE!

Contact Us