The issue of immigrants and whether their position is taking away jobs and reducing the wage of native workers has been one of great spectacle and controversy over the years. President Bush's proposal in January 2004 to reform the U.S. immigration system reignited an already strained debate that had been dormant in the aftermath of the September 11 terrorist attacks…
Download file to see previous pages...
The extent that immigrants are taking jobs away from native workers, as well as the impacts they are having on the wages of natives are of great concern and significance, and advocates on opposing sides of the immigration debate are well armed with statistics responding to such issues. The extensive research which has been conducted about the economic impact of immigrants is incredibly complex and much of it has shortcomings. In order to come to a clearer and more knowledgeable understanding on this subject matter, the following questions must be addressed:
By thoroughly discussing these two questions, we can come to a critically more intellectual viewpoint on this subject of interest. The aim of this paper is to discuss all of this, as well as any and all key elements in relation to this issue. This is what will be dissertated in the following.
Academic studies have been done for years in an attempt to assess the extent to which immigration affects the earnings of U.S. workers. Over the past decade, empirical research has found that immigrant earnings growth is remarkably rapid, and surprisingly enough, the cross-section studies find that the relative earnings of immigrants grow so rapidly that after ten to fifteen years immigrants earnings actually do overtake the earnings of native workers. It has been found "The result that, in the long run, immigrants earn more than natives was explained by assuming that immigrants earn more than natives was explained by assuming that immigrants are a relatively select group of individuals whose average 'quality' exceeds that of the typical native worker." (Borjas, 1989). Recent work (Borjas, 1985) raises serious doubts about the validity of the inferences drawn from the cross-section empirical results, considering that cross-section estimates of immigration assimilation are biased if emigration (i.e., return migration) is not randomly distributed across the immigrant population or if the quality of successive immigrant cohorts changed over the sample period.
The most extensive study of this subject released to date, in fact, is an August 2003 report by Pia M. Orrenius and Madeline Zavodny, researchers at the Federal Reserve Banks of Dallas and Atlanta, respectively. Their conclusions were as follows:
For service-related and professional workers, immigration has had little impact on wages. If anything, increases in the number of newly arriving immigrants actually have slightly positive effects.
For manual laborers, increases in the share of newly arrived immigrants have no statistically significant negative impact on wages; but increases in the share of immigrants who adjust their immigration status after they have been in the United States - for example, from student or tourist visas (which do not permit employment) to green cards - have a small negative effect.
The annual wages of low-skilled native workers are about 2.4 percent below where they would be otherwise as a result of the presence of immigrant workers.
There are certainly extremely opposing
...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
(“Immigrants Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1505994-immigrants
(Immigrants Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2500 Words)
“Immigrants Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1505994-immigrants.
In the past, it could have been said that historians were leaning towards getting a story from the point of view of the majority of the people they were studying, leaving out the minority whose point of view and experiences were different from those of the majority, hence the historians’ errors.
For most of these illegal immigrants, they choose to try their luck in the United States of America, which has been branded as the land of “milk and honey” throughout history. America earned the perception as the land of profusion, wealth and incessant opportunities.
Since ancient times, world has experienced a number of episodes of immigration. Immigration is a process where residents of one country move to other country due to multiple reasons to settle there on permanent basis. Immigration plays a vital role in population rise and amalgamation of culture that leads to social, political, and economic enormities that are causing several controversies.
The struggle of immigrants has been the focus of research, literature, art and media: the struggles of immigrants to the US has often been used for social commentary and rationalization of the country's policies particularly in view of the image of the US as the promise land of democracy and liberty.
America has then successfully marketed its model for growth to the entire world. As a nation of multinationals, nearly every American citizen can trace his lineage back to immigrant ancestors. Creating a national identity means sharing the same language; governed by a single government and a little common culture with the same aim and dream for peace and prosperity.
oup of people should not only focus on the coming and going of immigrants but they should also concentrate on understanding their reasons for leaving their homeland, the migration experience they have gone through, their capability to adopt and function in the new environments
With the migration of the Irish Catholics to America, antagonism was aroused by the American Protestants not only on religious ground but also on job competition. An unofficial political party was formed against the Irish Catholics and other immigrants in the mid