Sociologists regularly criticise Marx and Braverman for being functionalist and determinist (for example, Littler and Salaman, 1982). Braverman notes Marx's dialectical analysis of the historical relations between the material forces and social relations of production…
Download file to see previous pages...
He claims that "he Marx gave primacy to the forces of production in the long sweep of history" (Braverman, 1974, 19-20). Braverman's productive force determinism prevents him penetrating the complexities of the capitalist mentality and the critical importance of the valorization process in the control of labour. Braverman's (1974, pp. 24-25) lack of concern with the valorization process is evident when he writes off Marx's definition of the working class as "the static terms of an algebraic equation", signalling the abandonment of any interest in Marx's political economy.
For instance, the present treatise on capitalist production does not contain a formal definition of 'capital' . Marx would agree with Braverman that the 'accumulation of capital' - the generation of increasing amounts of surplus - "dominates in the mind of the capitalist, into whose hands the control of the labour process has passed" (Braverman, 1974, p. 53). He would also agree with Braverman's (1974, 53) aim to consider "the manner in which the labor process is dominated and shaped by the accumulation of capital". However, as Braverman fails to grasp Marx's definition of capital, he has little to say about how the accumulation of capital controls labour, and focuses solely on the material process of production. Some participants such as Morgan and Hooper recognise "the lack of an adequate theorisation of 'capital' " as a major "lacunae" in Braverman and the labour process debate. Marx says that machines only dominate labour 'technologically' - they impose technical constraints and demands - not that they control every aspect of work. He says that workers are impotent against capital 'even when labour exists autonomously', that is, without supervision or technical constraint. Marx (1976, 994) made quite clear his view that it was "pre-eminently in this sense - which pertains to the valorization process as the authentic aim of capitalist production - that capital as objectified labour (accumulated labour, pre-existent labour and so forth) may be said to confront living labour (immediate labour, etc.)". The workers find themselves not only confronted by material reality, "the workers find themselves confronted by the functions of the capital that lives in the capitalist" (Marx, 1976, 1054), and therefore by accounting. It follows that in Marx's theory it is not so much in detailed control of the labour process that we see the fully developed subsumption of labour in capitalism, but in fully developed systems of accounting. Braverman, by contrast, sees the detailed control of labour as capitalism's defining problem. This explains his view that "capitalists use the most productive instruments of labor and the greatest intensity of labor, but they are always aimed at realizing from the potential inherent in labor power the greatest useful effect of labour, for it is this that will yield him the capitalist the greatest surplus and thus the greatest profit" (Braverman, 1974, 56). By contrast, in Marx's management accounting, and in reality, the capitalist thinks the other way around. Because capital's overriding aim is the greatest return on capital, it invests in machinery
...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
(“Degradation of Work Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1499937-degradation-of-work
(Degradation of Work Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3000 Words)
“Degradation of Work Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1499937-degradation-of-work.
By making rulings in favor of abortion, pornography, and gay marriages, the Supreme Court has led Americans further away from its founding values. It is also apparent that the Supreme Court continues to allow other arms of the government to influence its decisions, especially in matters of political importance.
These hemichannels are each made up from six hemichannel molecules. These gap junctions are significant to the vertebrates as they are used for several physiological processes, for instance correct embryonic development, conducted reaction in microvasculature and harmonized depolarization of the cardiac muscles.
China now releases 13 % of global carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions. This is second to only the United States (23 percent). With the increase in auto usage in China and development in general, this number is increasing speedily. China will soon reach the top position if development tendency persist..
It adds knowledge to the understanding of various fields such as sociology, economics, political science, history, and human geography. The book holds the reputation of being one of the fifty most crucial studies produced in the third quarter of the twentieth century (Wald, 1987).
The thesis degradation of work reaffirmed the venerable discussion of worker-machine relations as a technological essential of capitalism, and set forth two sweeping conclusions about effects of technological changes. The research literature in existence when Braverman described unequivocally contradicted both conclusions.
The publication of Harry Braverman book on the subject of degradation of work in 1974 had an enormous impact on recent changes in organizational form and personal strategies. Baverman’s approach to degradation of work was an essential social critique that claimed massive conversions of work, the organization.
This particular area can be construction technology (e.g. cranes) or medical technology (e.g. cardiograms) or any other area where a practical application of knowledge occurs. But what about the impact of technology on the average worker who technology actually affects?
Workers were rewarded and punished. This approach appeared to work well for organizations with assembly lines and other mechanistic, routinized activities” (McNamara).
The field of management became an interest to most of the thinkers. Theories
Research paper has shown that degradation of GFRP rebars embedded in concrete structures is affected by moisture uptake and elevated temperatures. UV radiations have had effects on gloss and chromatic factors which can be easily avoided. However, moisture content and temperature changes poses a threat in the strength.
The natural ecosystems and regenerating bio-capacity of the earth are undergoing severe degradation, compromising the ability of the planet to sustain life. Environmental degradation involves damaging or destruction of the physical, chemical and biological ecosystems of the earth.
14 Pages(3500 words)Essay
GOT A TRICKY QUESTION? RECEIVE AN ANSWER FROM STUDENTS LIKE YOU!
Let us find you another Essay on topic Degradation of Work for FREE!