Nobody downloaded yet

Critically assess Hakim's (2006) and McRae's (2003) explanations of women's patterns of participation in the labour force - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Critical Assessment While the 20th century witnessed considerable progress in terms of civil rights, most individuals recognize the country still has significant room to improve. While gay rights may have temporarily grasped the nation’s primary focus, women’s rights still remain a prevalent issue…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.4% of users find it useful
Critically assess Hakims (2006) and McRaes (2003) explanations of womens patterns of participation in the labour force
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample
"Critically assess Hakim's (2006) and McRae's (2003) explanations of women's patterns of participation in the labour force"

Download file to see previous pages Conversely, McRae (2003) argues that women’s position in the workplace must be considered in relation to a variety of disparate social constraints. This essay presents a critical assessment of these explanations of women’s patterns of participation in the labor force. One of the pervading areas of investigation in Hakim (2006) is the extent that there are fundamental differences between men and women that account for their oftentimes divergent patterns in the workplace. For the most part Hakim (2006, p. 280) contends, “They are not fundamental qualitative differences, as often argued in the past in order to entirely exclude women from ‘male’ occupations such as management, the military and the professions.” In this way the research is arguing that there are limited physiological differences that divide men and women in the workforce. Still, the authors indicate that there remain divergent patterns of participation based largely on women’s preferences. The belief that preference theory can account for inequalities in the workplace place is recognized as conflicting with some of the dominant feminist narratives. The author gives a prominent example from modern society, indicating that the gender disparity in certain jobs in the past had been attributed a lack of family-friendly benefits; however, recent research shows that family-friendly benefits did not account for this gender gap. Even though Hakim (2006) makes substantial claims that are supported by empirical evidence, there is also the recognition that the article merely functions to reframe the debate. In this way the research has shifted existential focus to the nature of the job as determining the type of person capable of success in this area. Even as it article argues against the effectiveness of creating family-friendly benefits, it notes that it is the very lack of these benefits that distinguishes male dominant professions from gender neutral professions. Ultimately it appears that the issue is more of an ethical question regarding the extent it is worth restructuring the labor market to enable equal participation by all citizens. While Hakim (2006) makes recourse to preference theory in articulating divergent patterns of gender participation in the labor market, McRae (2003) argues that these divergent patterns should be understood more in terms of social constraints. Specifically, this research implemented an empirical study that examined women’s workplace participation following the first birth of a child. Additionally it followed their workplace and sex role attitudes. The research specifically positions its investigation in contradistinction with Hakim’s explanation that implemented preference theory. In this way, the researchers argue that while preference theory can account for some tendencies in the workplace, it does not go far enough in accounting for workplace disparities. In these regards, the argument is made that preference theory considers women’s labor choices will be able regarding the sort of life style they wish to lead; McRae instead argues that women’s workplace choices, despite their preferences, will oftentimes be restricted by their working capacities. While McRae’s empirical research is established on valid principles, it appears that the divergent conclusion that are reached when compared with Hakim’s perspective is largely linked to the ways that the authors frame the debate. For ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critically assess Hakim's (2006) and McRae's (2003) explanations of Essay”, n.d.)
Critically assess Hakim's (2006) and McRae's (2003) explanations of Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1461283-critically-assess-hakimyies
(Critically Assess Hakim's (2006) and McRae'S (2003) Explanations of Essay)
Critically Assess Hakim's (2006) and McRae'S (2003) Explanations of Essay. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1461283-critically-assess-hakimyies.
“Critically Assess Hakim's (2006) and McRae'S (2003) Explanations of Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1461283-critically-assess-hakimyies.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
CHECK THESE SAMPLES - THEY ALSO FIT YOUR TOPIC
New Right and 1970's - 1990's
...will discuss the social, economic and political issues which contributed to the rise of the New Right in the 1970's and 1980's. It will also discuss the effects it had on the Americans. Economic, social and political factors, which led to, the rise of the New Rights There exists more than one explanation for the rise of the New Rights. Nevertheless, it is unlikely that people could specifically point out the factors that led to the development of the New Rights (Vaguer 16). This is with a regards to the Conservatism era, which could be viewed as a continuation of an already set American tradition. The Conservatism era joins religious, moral and political principles into one thematic...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
S
...;” and those involving direct foreign management or ‘exported management’ such as: “sole direct foreign investment, joint ventures, and international services” (Ibid, pp. 19-27). Recent global developments have provided added venues for international business to enter foreign markets like the cross-border mergers and acquisition which since mid-1980s have been more utilised by MNEs in entering foreign markets (see illustration below) compared with FDI which was popularly used in 1950s-1960’s. (‘International Labour Organization’ n.d.) Moreover, MNE operation today is characterised by intra-firm trade which role is considered critical because it may help MNEs in two ways: cost...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay
Revenue Budget(s)s
...Part 2 The changes in the surplus and deficit are attributed to the change in license system from an old style to a newer system. Part 3 If the number of vehicles failing inspection would increase then this would increase the revenue obtained from the vehicle inspection fees by an additional 15%. Therefore making standards tougher would result in more vehicles failing the inspection and subsequently lead to an increase in revenue. This would be beneficial to the organization. Part 4 a) If the new system is implemented at the beginning of the year, there would be higher deficits in general for that financial year. This is because the cost incurred by the organization in contracting outsiders for the licenses is much higher... 2 The changes in...
1 Pages(250 words)Case Study
Women in 1950-s
Social pressure discouraged those women who wanted to do at least something different from others. All media which were run by men promoted traditional gender roles which forced women to accept the idea of being a housewife as bliss. The publication of The Feminine Mystique by Betty Friedan was a sensation. The book offered a new point of view at female life in the USA. It represented housework as something irrelevant and oppressive. The book was greatly appreciated as well as its writer. Betty Friedan became the leader of the women liberation movement. She organized meetings where women shared their experiences of family life or failure to build a career. Those meetings were important for women because they did not feel alone any...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Women' s right
... gendered analysis shows a clear evidence as to how immigrant and poor women are forced into traditional female roles in low-paying jobs such as nannies, maids, caretakers of the elderly, and at the same time, intentionally denied government subsidies leading to their continuous miserable lives. The onset of troubles facing the women in developing countries is seen by the imposition of structural adjustment policies that require them to pay off their debts. This is further worsened by the belt-tightening measures that have extreme negative impact on the women and as a result, they have no choice to migrate into rich countries such as the United States so as to seek greener pastures. The immigrant women have to settle for low wages... Grace...
1 Pages(250 words)Book Report/Review
All women's week
...Q Ans. I found this assignment challenging because while it is easy to spot the forms of media created solely for women e.g. fashion shows, jewelry exhibitions, makeup tutorials, and cooking classes, it is a little difficult to find something solely produced or created by women. Nevertheless, I read Harry Potter by J.K. Rowling. Q. 2: Ans. I did not cheat at all during the week. However, I must confess that I was inclined to cheat as I was not finding anything solely produced by a woman in the media but just then, Harry Potter Part 6 in the shelf of my room caught my attention as this book qualified as a form of media written solely by a woman. Q. 3: Ans. Yes, I would not have read Harry Potter Part 6 recently had it not been... Ans. I...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment
Women's Rights
..., and abused. They do not feel safe at home, in the streets, workplace or even on public transports. As a result, the women live in fear. They do not live their lives entirely. They need equality and respect. Their rights are discriminated even by their families. It has been on media of parents who rape their daughters. The law is working on such cases (Thomsen 54). Considering acknowledgment of women and their rights, every woman, just as a man has the right of control over their bodies. Throughout the world, girls and women end up forced into cultural practices that are harmful to their health, and cause them so much pain. Some of these practices include female genital...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper
Women's movments
...Women and Peoples’ movements Affiliation Women and Peoples’ movements Women’s’ movements were very vibrant during the 1960s especially in the United States both culturally and politically. Some of the movements were national organizations, campaigns for equal, reproductive rights, and many other reforms. The movements were important as they gave way for women to participate in professions and blue-collar jobs initially associated with masculinity. The movements created the gender balance and open discussions of issues considered private before. However, not all equality as achieved as women still dominate most of the household chores,...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Women's issue
...Gender Wage Gap Women are the primary breadwinners in six out of ten families in America. Apart from this, it is apparent that they earn 75% of every dollar earned by men. Additionally, it is evident that the majority of the women are disproportionately piled in lowest-paying fields in addition to being poorly represented in well-paying fields (Covert, 2015). The issue of gender wage gap can be addressed with much ease through observing a simple plan like the one I will outline below: First, it is crucial for the US government to enforce all organizations as well as offices to treat women 100% in pay, opportunity as well as advancement through coming up with a rule that protects working...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment
S&S Air Company
...S&S AIR COMPANY Internal growth rate= (Return on Asset x Retention ratio Return on Asset x Retention ratio) Return on Asset= 2,029,766/19,986,170=0.10 Retention ratio= 1-dividend pay-out; Dividend pay-out= 610,000/2,029,766=0.3 1-0.3=0.7 IGR= (0.1 X 0.3)/1-(0.1 X 0.3) 0.03/0.97=0.031 3.1% Sustainable Growth Rate= (Net income/ Shareholder’s equity) x (1-retention ratio) (2,029,766/11,435,815) x (1-0.7) 0.18 x 0.3=0.053 5.3% Internal growth rate: This percentage of (5.3%) is the maximum growth S&S Company can grow with external financial aid. Sustainable Growth rate: Refers to the growth rate a S&S Air company can grow...
1 Pages(250 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Let us find you another Essay on topic Critically assess Hakim's (2006) and McRae's (2003) explanations of women's patterns of participation in the labour force for FREE!
Contact Us