Nobody downloaded yet

Is MacIntyre's Critique of Modern Ethics Convincing - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
This paper seeks to evaluate Macintyre’s critique of modern ethics through an investigation of his works. This paper begins by…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.2% of users find it useful
Is MacIntyres Critique of Modern Ethics Convincing
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Is MacIntyre's Critique of Modern Ethics Convincing"

Download file to see previous pages It continues to point out to the inconsistencies and the groundless nature of major assumptions made in his philosophies. His argument of superiority of certain traditions is also criticized as well as other inconsistencies in his criteria. In After Virtue, when he says “one has to find its moral identity in and through its membership in communities,”1 he rejects the concept of individuality in moral issues. Lastly, this paper explores Hegel’s speculative logic of metaphysics as a contrary philosophy to Macintyre’s.
MacIntyres Critique of Modern Ethics is not convincing. His claims that the ethical theory and practice are incomprehensible is groundless. The recipients of his criticism are the emotive who believe in the doctrine of emotivism. For them, the value upheld and the metaphysical aspects of people are attributes that are derived from own personal preference as opposed to adherence to objective validity. In this case, considering something to be good is not a root of making a rational moral decision, instead that is only based on personal preference. As such, MacIntyres critique is based on three major pillars as proposed by Aristotle (Brodie 1991). The first pillar considers the moral agent in the amateur person, the second one is the moral agent when one already has comprehension of is telos, and lastly, moral considerations that enhance facilitation between stages (MacIntyre 1999). Modernity fails to uphold the second pillar as the normative concept of telos cannot be used as a determinant of good of bad behavior in the society. In this case, the good traits of an individual has to be eliminated, even if it is highly beneficial to the members of the society. This has to happen so that one can adopt new and alternative forms of norms other than the original one. It is only after such a disconnection that one can say that something about that traditional or society is good or one can qualify to understand the ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Is MacIntyre's Critique of Modern Ethics Convincing Essay”, n.d.)
Is MacIntyre's Critique of Modern Ethics Convincing Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1689842-is-macintyres-critique-of-modern-ethics-convincing
(Is MacIntyre'S Critique of Modern Ethics Convincing Essay)
Is MacIntyre'S Critique of Modern Ethics Convincing Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1689842-is-macintyres-critique-of-modern-ethics-convincing.
“Is MacIntyre'S Critique of Modern Ethics Convincing Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1689842-is-macintyres-critique-of-modern-ethics-convincing.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Is MacIntyre's Critique of Modern Ethics Convincing

Ethics Critique

... Can psychological research which explains how human beings make moral judgments help to justify a given judgment or action? If so, how?  Greene (359) argues that human beings make moral judgments without reasoning first. It is only after they have made the judgment that they seek for reasons to justify their actions. Psychological research helps in explaining why people make certain moral judgment. There are certain factors that drive people to make certain moral judgment. If the drivers are well understood, it is possible to justify the moral judgment using psychological research. However, some people will make moral judgment without being driven by anything but out of other factors such as influence. Sometimes, it may... Can psychological...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Critique of code of ethics

...Necessity of the Department of Navy's of Ethic's: The importance of the Department of Navy, of Ethics can be summed up in the words of Donald C. Winter, Secretary of the Navy, "It is essential that all Department of the Navy personnel adhere to the highest standards of integrity and ethical conduct. The American people put their trust in us and none of us can betray that trust." (The Department of Navy Legal Community, Department of the Navy) A written code of ethics serves as a guide in helping to determine what actions are unethical, and what are ethical and prescribed by the code. Thus the navy' s code of ethics serves...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Ethics in Modern Business Management

...Ethics in Management Modern business management requires to hold on numerous challenges with respect to various functions existing in both micro and macro environment. The business environment demands to keep an eye on the way organizations are trying to retrieve the key information about the other organizations'. The recent business trends with respect to the lack of maintaining Integrity of information sharing between the competitors has raised to alarm levels. The organizations are trying to use un lawful ways to intrude into the details of the key features of the products and services of its competitor. The business entities are now highlighting the social responsibility acts to elevate their social...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Theory Critique Feminist and Post Modern

...Feminist Therapy Of all the kinds of therapies studied, the Feminist Therapy is one that especially focuses on a target clientele with its own generalized characteristics. Although it likewise serves men, the philosophy of the Feminist Therapy is basically premised on women’s socio-cultural issues that cause a lot of emotional and psychological turmoil for women. In sum, Feminist therapy believes that women are innately good, but external forces around her cause her negative effects. It raises awareness that women are usually oppressed by societal expectations usually set forth by men. Thus, Feminist therapy aims to empower women to push their own strengths to the fullest in order to gain the self-respect they need, regardless...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

How convincing is Marxs critique of capitalism

...of the state. The first, he called primary view of the state, is rooted “in the famous aphorism of the Communist Manifesto: The executive of the modern state is but a committee for managing the common affair of the whole bourgeoisie” and political power is “merely the organized power of one class for oppressing another.” The secondary view, according to Milliband, is “that of the state independent from and superior to all social classes, as the dominant force in the society rather than the instrument of the dominant class.” He however concluded that the state remains “the protector of an economically and socially dominant class” (Alavi, 1972: 40). Thus, Marx views the state as a necessary coercive instrument for the...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Business Ethics vs. Success in Modern Business

...Business Ethics vs. Success in Modern Business School Table of Contents ………………………………………………Page No. …………………………………………..3 Chapter 1: Introduction……………………………..4 Background……………………………………..4 Problem Statement……………………………...4 Purpose of the Study……………………………5 Hypothesis statement…………………………,,,6 Study Delimitation……………………………...6 Study Limitation………………………………..6 Definition of terms……………………………...7 References………………………………………8 Business Ethics vs. Success in Modern Business Abstract Business ethics assume a very important role in the contemporary business practices. Although business ethics satisfy the concerns of the critics, yet this satisfaction is...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Article Critique #1--Business Ethics

...The article d ‘Managing to be ethical: Debunking five business ethics myths’ written by Linda Klebe Trevin˜o and Michael E. Brown exposes five myths in business ethics management. The common conception that being ethical is an easy task has been criticised by the paper. The ‘bad apple’ concept which is usually suggested as a reason of unethical business consequences has been referred by the author as a mere myth. The perception that formal code of conducts can ensure ethics has been disproved in the article. It has been pointed out that leadership ethics is merely not about the integrity of the leader. The myth that people are turning...
1 Pages(250 words)Article

Ethics Critique

...Ethics Critique: Question One Psychological research is deeply rooted in examining and understanding why human beings do things the way they do. It focuses on the evaluation and assessment of the human mind and the underlying behaviors that are realized in the process. Human beings exhibit different behaviors and they also reason, act, and portray different emotions at any given point in time. These aspects are influenced by the environment in which an individual human being thrives over time. The growth and development of any given human being forms the basis of psychological research as researchers try to understand the thoughts, actions, and feelings of an individual across his/her life, and the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Moral's in Modern Culture

...in that viewpoint, but the text in 1 Chronicles 20:4-8 can help clear the contradiction. The text in that excerpt briefly describes the same events described in 2 Samuel 21:18-22 but there are no footnotes indicating that the words “the brother of” was absent in the original text (“Bible Gateway passage,” n.d.-a). This impression is applied, therefore, in the interpretation of the verse in second Samuel. With such developments, it is pretty much clear that Elhanan killed Goliath’s brother, and not Goliath. The event of Goliath being slain is well described in the text 1st Samuel that is convincing enough that David killed Goliath. Question 2 In the readings provided, there are two people presented to have killed...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

"After Virtue" by Alasdair MacIntyre

...After Virtue by Alasdair MacIntyre Why do chess, architecture, and farming qualify as practices while tic-tac-toe, bricklaying, andplanting turnips do not? A practice can be described as any complex and coherent kind of socially recognized human activity by which internal goods to that kind of activity are comprehended in an attempt to attain the standard of excellence. Playing chess can be described as a practice as there is an urge to achieve certain kind of analytical skills and strategic competitive and imaginative intensity. In chess playing, the players are not just eager to win on a particular occasion, but they try to excel in whatever the ways that chess demands. Farming qualifies to be a practice as it involves...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Is MacIntyre's Critique of Modern Ethics Convincing for FREE!

Contact Us