Nobody downloaded yet

Summary response paper - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Student's Full Name: Professor's Name: PHIL 130 (A response paper to a biomedical ethics issue) 24 October 2012 (estimated word count = 1,009) Introduction The scientific studies conducted on animals to obtain crucial data has always raised important and critical moral issues…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.3% of users find it useful
Summary response paper
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Summary response paper"

Download file to see previous pages Moreau, the classic science fiction novel by famed author Herbert George Wells in which animals and humans were grafted into each other in various combinations, producing instead a distinct class of sub-humans. Anything that is considered as cruel, unusual or painful experimentation on animals is now prohibited due to the adoption of these ethical standards as a safeguard against unauthorized experiments. Moral ethics has been around for quite some time; the issues related to it had been discussed in great detail by the ancient Greek philosophers. Ethics today has entered into many areas of human endeavors, such as its increasing adoption by global businesses in the form of corporate social responsibility that has tempered the search for profits under capitalist free markets. Giant strides in medical technologies only fairly recently presented a new set of moral dilemmas, for which people are sometimes not too prepared to deal with, issues like euthanasia, abortion, organ donations, brain death, palliative medicine and the surrogate pregnancy trend in which more women are now willing to rent out their wombs for a fee. In this regard, this paper examines the biomedical issues related to whether animals also have the same rights as people and the propriety of continuing conducting experiments on animals. Discussion In his well-argued article entitled “The Case for the Use of Animals in Biomedical Research” and published in The New England Journal of Medicine back in 1986, Carl Cohen claims that animal experiments should continue because the arguments against them, that the animals have rights which are being violated and all sentient creatures must not suffer pain or any kind of unnecessary or avoidable suffering, are both wrong from a moral perspective. His succinct explanations debunked the two arguments put forward by animal rights advocates on the basis of animals having no rights at all because they have no moral capacity to make any choices or give consent, and secondly, the animals “are not capable of grasping the generality of an ethical premise in a practical syllogism” and it is only humans who can think at a highly abstract level (Cohen 96). With this in mind, he therefore strongly argues in favor of animal experiments for the benefit of science and mankind, in the hope that these experiments will be able to provide benefits for patients with new drug discoveries as well as also sparing humans from being used in biomedical research studies as the subjects themselves, in lieu of animals. A close analysis will show that Prof. Cohen leans towards utilitarianism as his justification. I do not agree nor accept the stance of Prof. Carl Cohen that animals have no rights. The argument he used is that of speciesism, which he did not equate with racism or sexism as it is something entirely different altogether. What he is doing is bordering on casuistry (or hair splitting) and he is likewise equally guilty of the same accusations he had leveled against his critics, mainly that of “drawing an offensive moral conclusion from a deliberately devised verbal parallelism that is utterly specious.” Cohen argued that animal species are not the same and therefore do not have the same rights in an equal measure, but rather that Peter Singer is grossly mistaken to formulate and defend his “principle of equal consideration of interests” ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Summary response paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Summary response paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. Retrieved from
(Summary Response Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
Summary Response Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words.
“Summary Response Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Summary response paper

Fair Work Act 2009 based on the pluralist frame of reference

14 Pages(3500 words)Essay


...Teacher’s ID Summary/ Response Summary In her article “Children need to play, not compete”, Jessica Statsky (n.p) asserts that organized sports for children in between the age of six and twelve puts unrequired physical and psychological pressure on these young children”. According to the writer, the organized sports are injurious as children cannot meet standards set for and by adult sports. Secondly, the games requires physical abilities that are not even developed within this age bracket. Hence, the game patterns can assert harmful impacts on growing bodies by increasing the chance of injuries with lifelong impact. The writer also explains that beside other physical injuries, children...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay


...? CHILDREN NEED TO PLAY, NOT COMPETE Summary: Jessica Statsky in her writing “Children Need to play, Not Compete” emphasized on the fact that the children become a part of the sports like baseball, football in an inappropriate way. They are knowing or unknowing pushed into the sports activities which is not up to their standard and build up a hazardous effect over them which can be detrimental in their overall growth process. Sports, as per Statsky, have been treated as an area to complete rather taking it as learning or any other co curriculum activities. She criticized the organizational committee and the parents to put their children in the competition league which creates a fearfulness, low esteem and physical hazards...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay


...? Summary and Response: Children Need to Play, Not to Compete In the essay “Children Need to Play, Not to Compete” Jessica Statsky focuses on mental and physical impacts of organized competitive sports on children of six to twelve year (O'Connor and Braverman 25-26). She states that organized competitive sports harms children physically and psychologically. In the essay, she uses an example of a child of twelve years child was injured while throwing a curve ball. Though the child has not been injured, but he was mentally affected. Furthermore, children engaged in competitive sports are inclined to win. They consider sports as a matter of victory; children who lose are the victim of depression and...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Kidney Disease and Dialysis

5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Summary response paper

...Marissa Elliott Hamill 05 October A Summary Response Paper to “The Rich get Thinner, The Poor get Fatter” Sabin explores the relationship between the choice of food and health. He quotes the Center for Disease Control and Prevention figures which indicate that the rate of obesity among southerners is as high as 30% (102) and has only happened recently and notes that this is an interesting development considering that the southern states are poorer than the rest of the USA. He attributes this development to the skyrocketing prices of previously cheap healthy foods in comparison to calorie-rich ones. The reason for this is the apparent elevation of traditionally southern fresh produce to...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Response Paper (Summary of World Civilizations: The Global Experience, pp. 475,476; 522-533; 540-542; 566-570) [the online edition of Stearns, Peter N.; Michael B. Adas; Stuart B. Schwartz & Marc Jason Gilbert, eds., World Civilizations: The Global Ex

...World Civilizations: The Global Experience Response to World Civilizations: The Global Experience, pp. 475,476; 522-533; 540-542; 566-570 World Civilization Russia was a great empire that had been established between the year 1450 and 1750. Unlike the Western colonial empires, Russias development implicated only restricted commercial exchange it also fundamentally stopped power steadiness from Europe to Asia. The Russian leaders, radiated off the Tatar domination between the year 1450 and 1480, proceeded on a fairly steady course of expansion (Stearns et al, 2002). Majority of the new territory were Asian, but Russia also attained the leading role in Eastern Europe by the 17th century. The regional sovereignty...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Summary response paper

...Rapid response team EB77 Implementation of a Successful Rapid Response Team: A Multidisciplinary Team Approach Saves Lives The purpose of the committee was to identify critically ill patients and conduct early assessment and intervention, which are likely to minimize the need for cardiopulmonary resuscitation while improving outcomes for patients. According to the committee, a Rapid Response Team (RRT) is likely to improve a patient’s outcome while at the same time, increase family, staff, as well as patient satisfaction (Critical Care Nurse, 1). Therefore, the RRT goal is to prevent deaths recorded on patients who constantly fail outside the critical area. The RRT worked in Durham...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay


... Children Need to Play, Not Compete In “Children Need to Play, Not Compete” Jessica Statsky displayed her deep emotions towards a then prevailing issue, in writing. The masterpiece of writing reveals more and more about children’s competitive sports for and in her course of composition. Prior research revealed that over the past couple of decades, organized sports, specifically for the children, had increased in the United States. All the people, mostly parents and young kids concerned, received this with dire joy. It created room and an opportunity for growing children to develop in fitness as well as nurture young talent. However, shortcomings displayed a different perspective of the whole issue. The entire project was subject... Children...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Summary response paper for FREE!

Contact Us