Neo-Malthusian Population Control - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The Malthusian theory of population holds that at some point in the future, with generational turnovers of humans, will outpace agricultural production. Based on the works of Thomas Malthus, this principle of population expresses cynicism about the future of human life…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.4% of users find it useful
Neo-Malthusian Population Control
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Neo-Malthusian Population Control"

The Malthusian theory of population holds that at some point in the future, with generational turnovers of humans, will outpace agricultural production. Based on the works of Thomas Malthus, this principle of population expresses cynicism about the future of human life. To avoid the Malthusian catastrophe, which results from an unchecked population, there seems to be a number of measures that a group or society can take. These measures usually involve government intervention in procreation as a form of population control. Celibacy, or sexual abstinence, struck Malthus as potentially an effective solution for solving the problem he himself diagnosed with human societies (Gilbert). As we should in contemporary liberal societies, most will find Malthus' conclusions unsettling, not only because of what they describe as in our future, but because of what his findings might justify in terms of government control. The kinds of methods that Neo-Malthusians suggest are necessary to protect the Malthusian catastrophe are undesirable at best and totalitarian at worst. Given this background, there are numerous theorists, from many different fields, who oppose the arguments of Neo-Malthusians by criticizing Thomas Malthus himself.
One criticism is apparent in economist David D. Friedman, who concludes that the prospect of parents having "too many" children is unlikely. His first argument is that although parents may not always be the most rational in deciding to have a child, it is even more difficult for a government, which is the only alternative from having parents decide. Parents are, despite common concerns, rational decision-makers. As the Malthusian catastrophe nears, reasons Friedman, economic effects are felt on fertility. Friedman says, "Consider also the effect of economic conditions on fertility. At the bottom of a depression, with short term income low and long-term prospects-for both parents and children-bleak, birth rates should fall. They do" (Freidman).
Julian Lincoln Simon, another libertarian-leaning economist who specialized in population and natural resources, cites some separate problems with the Neo-Malthusians' arguments. Firstly, his trouble begins with unprecedented levels of education and knowledge among common people. Never before have there been so many educated people to recognize their self-interests in their own social context. Thus, it is far less likely that the global community would near the proposed Malthusian catastrophe, if individuals are intelligent enough to recognize the steps needed to avoid doing so. Secondly, Simon proposes that economic freedom provides an effective stoppage tool to any adverse effect of overpopulation. The world's ability to increase production in response to market pressures (or profitable opportunity) ensures another check on the approach of a Malthusian vision (Simon).
In addition, economist and writer Ester B'serup has criticized the prospect of the Malthusian catastrophe by noting that it is the size of a population (or the demand for a product) that determines methods of agriculture. This is opposes a common interpretation of Malthusian arguments as saying that it is the inverse relationship which happens to be the case. Contrary to prior times, the amount of resources does not shape demand, but it is demand in a market economy that shapes supply. The lessening of poverty in developed nations also ensures that the food supply does not shape populations through starvation and disease. B'serup emphasizes that these factors invariably shape the growth and development of populations (B'serup).
Neo-Malthusians base their claims and recommendations about public policy on classical Malthusian arguments, which remain controversial. It remains unclear the extent to which overpopulation and the exhausting of resources poses a threat to mankind. Therefore, it is unlikely that they can be used to justify overarching policies used to control population growth. Individuals in developed countries will remain unaffected by this growth.
B'serup, Ester. The Conditions of Agricultural Growth: The Economics of Agrarin Change under Population Pressure. New York: Aldine Transaction, 2005.
Freidman, David D. Laissez-Faire in Population: The Least Bad Solution. 1972. 2008 .
Gilbert, Geoffrey. "Introduction." Malthus, Thomas. An essay on the principle of population. Oxford: Oxford World's Classics reprint, 1789. xviii.
Ross, E. B. The Malthus Factor: Poverty, Politics and Population in Capitalist Development. New York: Zed Books, 1998.
Simon, Julian Lincoln. The Ultimate Resource 2. Revised Edition. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1998. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Neo-Malthusian Population Control Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Neo-Malthusian Population Control Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
“Neo-Malthusian Population Control Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Neo-Malthusian Population Control

Population control

...Inserts His/her Inserts Inserts Grade (26, 04, Population Control Introduction With industrialization population of the world has increased many folds. The reason for this increase might be development of medicines and cures for viral diseases. Improvement in health standards in general has also contributed in this population growth. With increasing population the debate on population control has also be increasing. People who oppose population control argue that population growth is vital for economic reasons. Theological reasons are also given birth...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Population and Urbanization - The Malthusian Point of View

...? Population and Urbanization: The Malthusian Point of View The entire world is a stage and people mere players on it. This phrase suggests the responsibility of human as co-owners of the world. Issues regarding our existence are a responsibility everyone has to bear. The continuous growth of the population explosion is one of the concerns of human existence since time immemorial. Number itself is not an issue but the ratio of the growing population to the available resources. During the early part of human history the ratio of the population to resources can be considered abundant but the numbers started to increase over the years while the number of...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

History - Malthusian Demographics

...Malthusian Demographics Thomas Malthus a British citizen made a prediction of a possible population catastrophe inwhich he related the rate of population growth and the rate at which recourses are created to satisfy the needs of the ever growing population. In his analysis, he said that the population of the world assumes an exponential growth in a geometric manner while the resources that are created to sustain the population are created in arithmetic manner (Elwell 98). In this regard , he proposed that if the population of the of the world remained unchecked, then a critical point will reach which he referred to as...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Population Growth and Control

...and starvation. Malthus (1798) also argued for population control, through "moral restraint", to avoid this happening. As the population exceeds the amount of available resources, it decreases, since the lack of resources causes mortality to increase. This process keeps the population in check and ensures it doesn't exceed the amount of resources. Over the two hundred years which followed, famine has overtaken numerous individual regions, proponents of this theory state that these famines were examples of Malthusian catastrophes. On a global scale, however, food production has grown faster than population. It has often been argued that...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Neo Pets

...The Case Study of Neo Pets Outline: This paper is a case study on Neopets. In this case study some important questions and answers, which may help inthe growth of the neopets gaming solution are discussed. It was started by two college students, namely, Adam Powell and Donna Williams in the year 1997 and they launched the neopets website in the year 1999. Later a market research company namely Dohring, Inc. bought the concept from them. (Neopets, 2009). The case Study Neo: Answer to Question 1: In the past, we’ve seen many types of children’s products, ranging from Ninja turtles to Hula Hoops that have turned out to be fads. How do you think NeoPets can prevent its concept from becoming a fad? Most...
5 Pages(1250 words)Case Study

Malthusian Reading of Jane Austen

...felt these drives would naturally create an imbalance in population and means of subsistence. Therefore, he proposed that in order to control the population, people need to control birth to prevent uncontrolled population growth. Some of his suggestions included delaying marriage until later in life and even abstinence. Malthus thought if these were not controlled then ultimately this population problem would instigate wars, famine, natural calamities. It is these things nature would be forced to use in order promote death to balance in population. In reading the novels of Jane Austen, there is a...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Proposal


...Neo-Confucianism Neo-Confucianism was a religion of metaphysical, ethical and social Chinese philosophy that had its roots primarily in Confucianism. All the same, quite a few of the metaphysical beliefs were taken from Taoism, while the belief that reality existed and could be comprehended by human beings was implemented with the purpose of going against Chan Buddhism’s own mysticism, which was comprised of contrasting thoughts. Neo-Confucianism was developed during the Song and Ming Dynasties, though its origin can also be traced back to Han Yu and Li Ao and the Tang Dynasty. Neo-Confucianism was developed as a response to Confucianism, Daoism, and Buddhism. Due to...
1 Pages(250 words)Research Paper


...from the rich capital owners to the middle class and low income earners, since businesses and industries create jobs. These jobs, together with the revenue they churn, help pump money into the economy, and thereby leading to more jobs. Because of the above standpoints, the government should let markets be controlled by market forces, so that there is free international trade (Philoguy, 1). How the Opponents of Neo-Liberalism Criticize the Unregulated, Free Markets Promoted By Neoliberals Opponents of neo-liberalism criticize it for its unregulated free markets as is promoted by neoliberals by arguing that free markets deny governments of sources of revenue, since governments are not...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Population Control and Earths Sustainability

...the increasing number. Therefore, the earth is enough to cater for the human population whether there is a decrease or increase in population. Similarly, there have been Neo-Malthusian theories advancing on the fact that an increase in population would cause severe famine and degradation of living conditions. However, what they should know is that whenever there is an increase in population, the resources among other elements that humans require for food and survival also increase, for example, increase in population would prompt an increase in the number cows and food grown. Increase in population...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Population control in India

...Population Control in India Population Control in India The economic situations are becoming harder than before and the use of natural resources such as land stretch beyond limits. There is an urgent need for global population control, especially in India. The existing situation of the population in India puts a lot of pressure on the social amenities such as water, education, and healthcare. The situation has created an enormous gap between the rich and the poor, a factor that is not healthy for a country. Hence, the concept of population control is inevitable as far as India’s future...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Neo-Malthusian Population Control for FREE!

Contact Us