StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

RECRUITMENT & SELECTION ( Human Resource Managment) - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
RECRUITMENT & SELECTION (Human Resource Management) "If a company is considering two job candidates: an internal candidate with years of service and very good performance evaluations; an external candidate who works for a competitor and has valuable experience in new product markets, it has an obligation to hire the internal candidate?…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.8% of users find it useful
RECRUITMENT & SELECTION ( Human Resource Managment)
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "RECRUITMENT & SELECTION ( Human Resource Managment)"

RECRUITMENT & SELECTION (Human Resource Management) "If a company is considering two job candi s: an internal candi with years of service andvery good performance evaluations; an external candidate who works for a competitor and has valuable experience in new product markets, it has an obligation to hire the internal candidate? Do you agree or disagree? Why? Introduction Internal promotions versus external recruitment are a common problem that organizations face. The time tested traditional approach was to train and develop suitable employees to take on new responsibilities.

In the modern world where haste in business processes with the objective of becoming more competitive can be seen in aggressive organizations, tradition has been thrown out of the window and external recruiting has become the rule of the day. (1). In my opinion it is in the traditional approach that the company demonstrates obligation to its own well-being and the well-being of its employees. The Obligation and Benefits of Internal Selection The case presented makes it very clear that the internal candidate has remained a loyal employee to the organization.

The organization has an obligation to its own well-being and the well-being of its employees to recognize loyalty and maintain the loyalty of its employees. (2). Denying this obligation to a talented internal candidate will make employees reconsider their loyalty to the organization to the disadvantage of the organization. Let us look at morale among the employees of the organization in case of external selection. The lack of recognition of performance and loyalty and the possible block to career advancement will lower their morale and act as a de-motivating factor, influencing their performance. (1). Minimizing costs in its business activities is an obligation of an organization.

By opting for the suitable internal candidate the costs involved in easing the new entrant into the job position and organization are removed. In addition, here besides cost advantages, the organization will demonstrate its social obligation through the internal selection. (3). The external candidate may have demonstrated excellent promise in the selection promise, but where is the guarantee that this promise will be lived up to in the actual performance of the job responsibility. (4). The internal candidate has demonstrated not just promise, but actual good performance in the execution of job responsibilities.

The only circumstance where an organization is not obligated to select from internal resources is when the required knowledge and skills for the job responsibility are not available internally, or when the organization would like to introduce change in the corporate culture, or increase diversity in the workforce. (5). This case does not represent such a circumstance, which removes as knowledge and skills are present internally, there is show of wanting to change the corporate culture or increase diversity in the workforce, removing arguments in favor of an obligation to recruit the external candidate.

A final case in favor of the external candidate may be made from the perspective that the modern competitive business encourages organizations to make external selections. Let us examine success story of Deloitte, the multi-national financial services firm, to confirm the veracity of it. In 2001 Deloitte was faced with the requirement of workforce adjustment. Deloitte opted to make this workforce adjustment using its internal talent. The success that Deloitte experienced with this exercise has made the use of internal talent the mainstay of Deloitte in workforce requirements to the delight of its employee and the success enjoyed by Deloitte in the modern financial business world. (5). The case of Deloitte lays to rest even the final argument of competition as an aspect in the modern business world favoring the external candidate.

Conclusion Internal selection should be the obligatory norm of organizations, because of the benefits that are derived by the organization, its workforce, and society at large. There are mitigating circumstances that include the lack of required knowledge, skills, and talent in the organization, or the desire for change in the corporate culture, or increasing the diversity of the workforce that allow an organization to select externally. These mitigating circumstances are absent in this case and the organization should select the internal candidate.

Works Cited 1. Cappelli, Peter. “Hire talent from inside or go outside”. 2011. Microsoft. 28 May 2011. . 2. Trondal, Jarle. An Emergent European Executive Order. Great Clarendon Street, Oxford: Oxford University Press. 2010. 3. Kumar, Raj. Human Resource Management: Strategic Analysis Text and Cases. Uphaar Cinema Market, New Delhi: I.K. International Publishing House Pvt. Ltd. 2011. 4. Fisher, D. Cynthia, Schoenfeldt, F. Lyle & Shaw, B. James. Human Resource Management. Daryaganj, New Delhi: Biztantra. 2008. 5.

Lepak, David & Gowan, Mary. Human Resource Management: Managing Employees for the Competitive Advantage. Patparganj, Delhi: Dorling Kindersley (India) Pvt. Ltd. 2009.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“RECRUITMENT & SELECTION ( Human Resource Managment) Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/other/1423767-recruitment-selection-human-resource-managment
(RECRUITMENT & SELECTION ( Human Resource Managment) Essay)
https://studentshare.org/other/1423767-recruitment-selection-human-resource-managment.
“RECRUITMENT & SELECTION ( Human Resource Managment) Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/other/1423767-recruitment-selection-human-resource-managment.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF RECRUITMENT & SELECTION ( Human Resource Managment)

Human Resources Management Aspects

This reflective essay focuses on different areas of human resource management that we covered in class, which include equal employment opportunities and affirmative action, human resources planning, recruitment, and selection, human resources development.... hellip; The principal role of human resource management is to increase the efficiency and involvement of employees in the accomplishment of organizational goals and objectives by encouraging them to use their creative abilities, expertise, and talents....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Human Resource Management: Selection and Recruitment Process

The author examines the recruitment and selection process that involves an in-depth analysis of the various steps involved to select the best candidate suitable for the job.... The process is followed by the selection which consists of a series of different processes in choosing the right candidate to fill the vacancy (Taylor, 2008).... However, person specification revolves around the criteria necessary for the selection of a particular candidate (CIPD, 2012) which according to Taylor (2008) are the presence of necessary skills, experience, education and qualification along with the presence of necessary behavioral attributes....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment

IT Professional in Software Service

According to the recruitment policy; they recruit some experienced candidate.... “These occupational case studies are closely related to the organisational case studies that were carried out in a selected number of business functions, during the same time span.... In the WORKS project, business functions are at the core of qualitative empirical re-search, as… In order to study changes in work at the individual level, this report fo-cuses on individual workers within occupational groups linked to key business functions....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The Roles and Purpose of Human Resource Management

It deals entirely responsible for the process of employing, training and all human resource issues affecting employees.... human resource management (HRM) is the unit within an organization that deals with the workforce.... Research has shown that HRM is the heartbeat of any organization; over eighty percent of the company success is attributed from the activities and skills of human resources.... HRM plays an important role in ensuring quality of workforce. The… itment and selection process entails methods and procedures that ensure that only the best workforce is acquired by an organization and in a cost effective manner....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Human Resources Planning or Recruitment and Selection

human resource planning aims at forecasting the labor demand, managing staff number, ensuring that the competencies match the roles assigned and balancing the labor supply and demand in the organization.... In conclusion, human resource planning, recruitment and selection are some of the most crucial processes in an organization for they provide the best employees that ensure success within the company.... The essay "human Resources Planning or Recruitment and Selection" states that all the processes in an organization depend on the efficiency of human resources....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Human Resource Management in Malaysia

This paper analyzes the human resource Management in Malaysia.... The Malaysian Institute of Personnel Management is generally focussed to entice the study of human resource management in Malaysia.... The various training modules include that of public programmes, in-house or corporate training, the professional certificate as well as a diploma in human resource, a professional advanced certificate in industrial relation and training and development along with lecturing opportunities....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

Human Resource Planning - Recruitment and Selection

This paper "human resource Planning - Recruitment and Selection" focuses on the fact that human resource management is one of the most in focus phenomenon in all organizations.... The success of an organization depends on human resource and their quality of output.... nbsp;  Hence we can say that human resource is the means of securing successful strategic performance and as a source of sustainable competitive advantages....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Managing Recruitment and Selection

The line manager, because of their constant visibility in the employee population, is the best resource for the HR manager to seek in order to provide effective policies involving employee management and relationship development.... owever, the HR manager maintains the role of policymaker and compliance manager to human resources rules and regulations, therefore he or she must understand the nature of the employee population and their unique job roles in order to develop policies that will be workable and considered valuable to the employees....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us