Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

Garret Hardin Lifeboat Ethics: The case against helping people - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The piece recognized as (Life Boat Ethics: The Case against Helping the Poor) was writing by Garrett Hardin in which he uses several similarities, abstract questioning and honest reasoning to make his case against helping the poor and to counter those theorists who state that…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.2% of users find it useful
Garret Hardin Lifeboat Ethics: The case against helping people
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Garret Hardin Lifeboat Ethics: The case against helping people"

Life Boat Ethics The piece recognized as (Life Boat Ethics: The Case against Helping the Poor) was writing by Garrett Hardin in which he uses several similarities, abstract questioning and honest reasoning to make his case against helping the poor and to counter those theorists who state that the wealthy should help the poor (Hardin 1974). He states that it is not the responsibility of the wealthy nations to help and assist the poor nations. To explain why wealthy nations should not assist the poor nations he uses the example of a life boat and compares it to a wealthy nation. He proposes his hypothesis in quite a persuasive manner to increase the involvement of his audience. In his work he tries to prove that by not helping the poor, wealthy nations will be doing a correct task and will end up helping the poor nations. To support his opinion he gives an example of a life boat consisting of 50 individuals and still has space for another 10 individuals while there are hundreds other in the sea asking for helping and wanting to be saved by the life boat. Hardin states that it is impossible for the life boat and the people who have the life boat to save all of them. The people who are already within the life boat represent those individuals who represent the wealthy nations and those asking for help represent people from poor nations. During the initial stages of his written work, one might perceive that Hardin is being unethical and selfish, but as a reader proceeds, he/she may realize that his opinion may only be the way to save the depleting resources of the earth. Later in his work he states that if all of the individuals who are asking for assistance are added to the lifeboat, the boat will sink. Similarly if wealthy nations start helping all poor nations, the wealthy nations will loose their resources and they will drown along with the poor nations. He further states that the selection of 10 people out of the pool of 100 for help is impossible. He believes that the boat should only hold 50 people for safety purposes. He compares this condition to the condition of the poor; he states that it is very hard for wealthy nations to determine who to help and who not to help so nations should opt for not helping at all. Secondly, he believes that nations should not share its abundant resources with the 10 selected poor countries because the wealthy nation may experience situations when they might be in trouble and the surplus resources may help them during such sessions. Hardin may be wrong in believing that by helping the poor nations, the wealthy nations loose their resources but his ideas do have certain benefits. His ideas may support the notion that if wealthy countries continue to support poor ones, the poor ones will become dependant on them and will not try to take advantages of opportunities. Thus, if poor nations are not helped by the rich nations, the people of poor nations will have to look for other opportunities for survival.
Works Cited
Hardin, Garrett. "Lifeboat Ethics: the Case Against Helping the Poor by Garrett Hardin - The Garrett Hardin Society - Articles." The Garrett Hardin Society. N.p., 1974. Web. 27 Nov. 2012. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Garret Hardin Lifeboat Ethics: The case against helping people Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Garret Hardin Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping People Essay)
“Garret Hardin Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping People Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Garret Hardin Lifeboat Ethics: The case against helping people

Peter Singer and Garrett Hardin On Helping the Poor

... looking outside of their borders, there would be even more aid to spread to the rest of the world. People must get their own houses in order first, and make sure their own needs are provided for, before looking to give aid to others. Works Cited Hardin, Garrett. “Lifeboat Ethics: A Case Against Helping the Poor.” Psychology Today. (1974): n. page. Web. 10 Nov. 2011. . “Home of the 99% of Americans Movement.” SRS Solutions, 2011. Web. 10 Nov 2011. . LoBaido, Anthony C. “Land-Grab Policy Causes Zimbabwe Famine.” WorldNet Daily 20 Nov 2001. n. pag. Web. 10 Nov. 2011. Lifeboat Ethics: The Case...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Governance and International Relations Lifeboat Ethics

...ends meet to ensure that they are on the right path – geared to achieve results which are attainable and positive along the way2. On the same token, this paper gives a good look at the lifeboat ethics which indeed is a way to find out where the resource distribution should be acknowledged and how this would mean sheer value for all the nations in the world. Philosophically, it is quintessential to understand the phenomenon behind the lifeboat ethics. This is a term that was proposed by Garrett Hardin, who was an ecologist in the year 1974. Hardin used this metaphor to describe a situation where a lifeboat consisted of 50...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

The Case Against Evolution

...The Case Against Evolution This essay addresses whether evolution ought to be taught in public schools. In my view, the answer is that there is no valid basis for including evolution in public school curriculums. My arguments are not based on the Culture Wars commonly presented in the mass media. Rather, my arguments are based on the observation that evolution is an unproven concept, as it pertains to the origins of life on Earth, and that it is too often manipulated by people with a political agenda. To this end, this essay will discuss the nature of the evolution argument, why it should not be taught in public schools, and the implications if it were included in public school...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Hardins Argument Concerning Lifeboat Ethics

...Draft of a short essay evaluating Hardin's argument concerning lifeboat ethics In his celebrated article "Lifeboat Ethics: the Case against Helping the Poor", Garrett Hardin comes up with convincing arguments in relation to the tragedy of the commons and he purports that the basic error of spaceship ethics is that it leads to 'the tragedy of the commons'. Hardin puts forward the concept of 'the tragedy of the commons' in the context of the system of private property. According to him, people who own property are aware of their...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Agencies helping homeless people

...Agencies helping homeless people Homeless people can be encountered in any country of the world. The United s of America is not exclusion as well. However, unlike many other nations, Americans strive to support people living on the streets, those who are not able to satisfy their basic needs without outside help. Organizations focused on providing real assistance (housing, food, and clothing) exist in every region of the country. Most of these organizations are non-profit which means that they collect donations from population and cooperate with business units in funds generation and service provision. Homeless people are individuals...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

The Case Against Helping the Poor conquered. This is true economically, with the giving of trade agreements that benefit other countries, and it is also true politically, since charitable donations to these countries can help them to get started. Although the Spaceship Earth metaphor may be unrealistic, as Hardin asserts, it makes much more sense than viewing our planet as a Lifeboat, where we have to either support countries forever or leave them to drown. Works Cited Dorr, Norbert, Susan Lund, and Charles Roxburgh. "The African miracle: how the worlds charity case became its best investment opportunity." Foreign Policy 183 (2010): 80+. Gale Opposing Viewpoints In Context. Web. 2 Aug....
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Case against death penalty

...Case against death penalty Death penalty has attracted a lot of debate from society, with some people arguing against it, while others supporting it. As a form of punishment, some justice systems death penalty punishes a collective number of capital offenders who are guilty. Whereas, the definition of capital offenders differs, many offenders who are guilty of taking the life of others fall into the category of capital offenders. Despite that fact that capital offenders attract capital judgment decisions such as the death penalty, there are strong arguments that people have raised against this practice. Some people view...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Garrett Hardin: The Case Against Helping the Poor

...Garrett Hardin: The Case Against Helping the Poor In his 1974 essay, Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping the Poor, Garrett Hardin argues against any “system of worldwide food sharing” (482). His purpose is to demonstrate the adverse effects of the proposed World Food Bank on population growth and the resulting pressure on resources. Hardin criticizes the ‘spaceship metaphor’ which seeks to assert that every individual on earth has an equal right to an equal share of the available resources. He claims that the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

The Case against Marriage

...The Case against Marriage Marriage has been considered as an important social institution since time immemorial. According to many people, tying the knot is the surest way to ensure social stability, bring up children and avoid sexual anarchy. Thus, changes in the nature of marriage in the form of higher divorce rates and cohabitation without marriage are often portrayed as an indication of social decay. However, Bennett and Ellison claim that due to the changed social situation, it is no more necessary to tie the nuptial knot legally to ensure its stability. In other words, getting into a legal marriage does not increase the stability of the union anymore. The authors claim, “legally...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Will financially aid helping poor people lead to a sustainable future

...that the poor people and countries ought to be helped financially by the wealthy nations and people. This group of people believes that the poor can use the aid to acquire what they lack and also to develop and build their talents that can positively change their countries. In the "Lifeboat Ethics: the Case against Helping the Poor", Garret Hardin advises to against aiding the poor people because the earth can only support a definite number of people. The earth cannot afford the world’s population beyond...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Garret Hardin Lifeboat Ethics: The case against helping people for FREE!

Contact Us