Free

Assignment Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
People blindly believe that data is the king. After all, it is just a collection of facts and figures; it is supposed to be objective and without bias, nothing of the aforementioned could be any further from the truth…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.4% of users find it useful
Assignment
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample ""

Give the Kid a Number Briefly summarize the main points of the “Give the Kid a Number” essay.  Perversion of data, that’s the best way to describe it. People blindly believe that data is the king. After all, it is just a collection of facts and figures; it is supposed to be objective and without bias, nothing of the aforementioned could be any further from the truth. Robert Graham (1982) shows in his essay that there are four (flawed) assumptions that people make when they view any data set. These assumptions lead them to believe that if it’s a data set then it must be true, unbiased without any intentional or unintentional influence.
a) Data production is not effected by organizational politics.
b) People will do what they say for the reasons they say it.
c) People behave according to the rules.
d) Data reflects a constant reality (Graham 40).
However, it is not impossible to break free from these flawed assumptions. With the right mindset while analyzing the data can make the difference between choosing two opposite arguments. For instance, knowing the intent of the people that produced the data will keep the reader objective about the so called facts (Graham 43). This approach might easily save the readers from falling victim to data mining or cherry picking. Having a little sense of accounting, finance, business and corporate laws can equip the readers with the right tools before making a decision of investing in the firm.
2) Briefly summarize the main points of the newspaper or magazine article in a few sentences, with particular emphasis on its use of data, and the conclusions, decisions, etc., based on the data.
The article in The Harvard Crimson, Death of Data by Raul Quintana declares that common populace lives in “post-truth” age of politics. This news article is in reference to the upcoming US presidential elections. It has become very easy to distort the facts statistically, as putting the stamp of individual belief on the data doesn’t rid it off the scent of spinning the data (Quintana). Representative Paul Ryan claims that Barrack Obama has doubled the size of the government, when in fact there is no data-matrix to confirm this. Institutes like Office of Management and Budget and Congressional Budget Office, and even Academia are facing criticism of being biased in their data projections or liberal bias. Instead of forming policies based on numerical facts, politicians formulate policies based on pre-existing ideology. What happens is that policies are made before objectively analyzing the data, and then to support the decision, the data is beaten to conform to the policy.
3) How were the data (mis-) used in the article? 
Misinformation and inflammatory rhetoric are the predominant weapons used in twisting the data, and this is being done of regular basis. Data is no longer an objective input in a debate (Quintana). Showing one side of the picture is the most common tool for formulating policies that are based on an ideology. Politicization of data is one of the biggest challenges that the world (victims of policies/general public) is facing.
4) If you were to advise the people involved on better ways of using data in the situation, what would you recommend? 
I would recommend the people to read between the lines. The best way to not get carried away with the ‘political black magic’ is to read more and watch less television. When people watch television, it gets so much easier for the media to influence viewers with data distortion. A whole think tank sits behind those cameras to strategize the data. For instance, even if unbiased data is posted regarding unemployment or massive corporate corruption, merely not highlighting it enough and creating another ‘flashing news’ would be more than enough to misdirect the viewers and throw them off the track. As they say, perception is reality, and media is a master of distorting perception.
Works Cited
Graham, R. J. "Give the Kid a Number": An Essay on the Folly and Consequences of Trusting Your Data." Interfaces 12.3 (1982): 40-44. Print.
Quintana, Raul P. "The Death of Data." The Harvard Crimson. n.p., 5 Sept. 2012. Web. 08 Sept. 2012. .
Copy of the News Article
The Death of Data
By RAUL P. QUINTANA
Published: Wednesday, September 05, 2012
In the midst of convention season, it has become clear that both parties live in a world that none of us can truly recognize. Columnist James Fallows, a former Crimson editor, claims we live in the “post-truth” age of politics.
While upsetting, it is entirely unsurprising that super PACs blatantly disregarded the facts, since their favored candidates can deny any involvement. Yet the parties and even the presidential and vice-presidential candidates themselves have started to publically lie without regard to our political discourse or society as a whole.
Granted, politicians’ distortion of reality is not a new trend. But the de-regulation of campaign finance, escalation of hyper-partisanship, and insatiable public appetite for inflammatory rhetoric have all contributed to an unprecedented disregard for the truth.
Besides honesty and integrity, the irrelevance of truth has particularly severe implications for public policy debates.
Most statistics professors and frustrated Statistics 104 students will tell you that the interpretation of statistical data is an inherently subjective science. Transformations and reinterpretations can create different results from the same data set.
Statistics thus becomes easy to twist in accordance with individual beliefs. Rather than deriving public policy from numerical facts, we have started to derive public policy from pre-existing ideological arguments.
The proliferation of think tanks, policy organizations, and other quantitative-heavy institutions has given rise to a torrent of new research beholden to a specific ideology. Data simply adhere to an existing political narrative rather than providing objective evaluations.
As a result, hyper-partisanship has flourished at the cost of substantive policy debate. We now have partisan conceptions of reality that differ on their most fundamental assertions about the world.
For example, Representative Paul Ryan has recently declared that Barack Obama has doubled the size of government. In reality, no reliable data metric shows a doubling of government under President Obama, or even an increase of more than 10 percent.
Debate, the basis of American governance, can only occur through fundamental agreements about political realities. To substantively debate healthcare, for example, legislators must agree that there is a need for healthcare. However, all of our recent political debates, from the debt ceiling to healthcare reform, have shown two parties so removed from each other that they do not even appear to be debating the same issues.
In theory, policy differences result from differing beliefs on how the government should address a particular issue. It results from a difference of interpretation rather than a difference of construction. Statistics frame these debates by providing the foundation through which legislators can discuss potential solutions.
Yet, data are no longer neutral. Even impartial offices like the Office of Management and Budget and the Congressional Budget Office have come under fire for these underlying tendencies. Academia, one of the few institutions with a mission that explicitly pursues objective truth, constantly faces criticisms of liberal bias.
These destructive accusations have undermined the credibility of statistics as a tool for public policy. Actual policy implications become lost amidst inflammatory rhetoric and misinformation. The entire purpose of these organizations disappears, and data no longer aid debate.
We have entered the age of post-modernity in American politics. Established truths no longer appear relevant. In the face of new evidence, we plug our ears and start shouting accusations in order to drown out the cognitive dissonance.
In this way, we have entered a world of multiple political realities, fortified by the politicization of statistics. To refocus the political debate and create a functioning government, we must re-align these realities and, in doing so, understand the credibility of contrary data.

Raul P. Quintana ’14, a Crimson editorial writer, is a history concentrator in Quincy House.
Web URL: http://www.thecrimson.com/article/2012/9/5/harvard-data-politics/ Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words - 42”, n.d.)
Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words - 42. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1602601-assignment
(Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words - 42)
Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words - 42. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1602601-assignment.
“Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words - 42”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1602601-assignment.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Assignment

Activity Based Costing (ABC)

... Activity Based Costing (ABC) is the perfect cure for the problem of overhead allocation within organisations. Critically evaluate this ment.In general, activity based costing (ABC) has been largely described as an alternative method of allocating overhead costs based on logic rather than arbitrarily imputing cost entirely to resulting production output. Historically, ABC started to become popular as an alternative approach to traditional cost accounting about three decades ago, where the latter has become increasingly proving its irrelevance (Emblemsvag, 2010). The increasing automation of production as compared to being labor-intensive, the multiple product lines compared to small number of products being produced... Activity Based Costing...
12 Pages(3000 words)Assignment

International Banking

...?INTERNATIONAL BANKING-LAW AND PRACTICE Task Questions Regulation of Banks 2. Security for secured syndicated loans in an international context NAME OF STUDENT STUDENT NUMBER LAW M591 INSTRUCTOR’S NAME 22ND DECEMBER 2011. Table of Contents Table of Contents 1 1.0REGULATION OF BANKS 2 1.1 Introduction 2 1.2 Banking Regulation Policy Highlights 2 1.3 Main objectives of bank regulation 3 1.4 Disadvantages to the regulation of these businesses because of the behaviours they encourage in the regulated entities and their customers. 8 2.0SECURITY FOR SECURED SYNDICATED LOANS IN AN INTERNATIONAL CONTEXT 10 2.1 Introduction 10 2.2 Overview of Common law and civil law jurisdiction with regard to secure syndicated loans 11 2.3 Different... BANKING-LAW...
18 Pages(4500 words)Assignment

Human sexuality

...? Sociology Sociology Question 1a) If there is one thing that has known variations, it is the things that would draw individuals to each other when starting relationships. Many people believe that as far as relationships are concerned, individuals with shared values or characteristics will most likely be attracted to each other. Others hold the opinion that individuals who are too much alike would not last long as a couple and therefore people tend to look for those that complement them. In quite a number of cases however, individuals are attracted to those people who are different from them since they seek complementary traits in the individual. One thing that you will acknowledge is that as much as these two arguments may look... Sociology...
18 Pages(4500 words)Assignment

Higher Education in Crisis: Whither the University

...?Higher education in crisis: Whither the Introduction Higher education is the goal of most individuals. They see it as a valuable means of establishing successful careers and of landing lucrative jobs in the employment market. Recently however, reports of difficulties in gaining higher education and of establishing rich careers from such an education have become apparent. This paper shall discuss what the university is for and what higher education is for. It shall discuss the role of the intellectual in the 21st century, including the issues and challenges associated with mass higher education. It shall also consider the apparent globalization of western management education. A discussion of the relationship between the labour... education...
10 Pages(2500 words)Assignment

Marketing Communication and Branding

...Marketing Communication and Branding Question 1 Q.1. Communication objectives are the factors which support the organisation to move from the present position to a new and improved position. The objective of marketing communication should be SMART, i.e. ‘Specific, Measurable, Actionable, Realistic, and Time specific’. In relation to the case study, three communication objectives can be stated such as: Increase in the awareness among people by around 35% to 50% within the eight weeks from the day the campaign will commence Introducing a sale or discount and creating 70% awareness a day before the sale/discount begin. Reposition the firm to an up market business news paper from an old news paper. The first objective would... Communication...
4 Pages(750 words)Assignment

Philosophy quizes

...?Na me Philosophy Quizzes SS.R 5-9, 11-12 In the dialogue, Plato reveals that death is the event that releases the soul from its earthly prison, which is the body. For Plato, the soul is the real self --- and is immortal --- and that death and dying is a means to release the person's true being. It means that the body will decompose at death, but the soul is incapable of doing so. 2. The Katha Upanishad, according to Yama's teaching, is the passenger of the chariot, which is the body (1.3.3-4). This is similar to the ideas found in Phaedrus or Parmenides. The need for self-realization is the reason behind birth, thus the need for a chariot, which is the earthly body. Once one's desires are fulfilled and begins to love nothing else...
20 Pages(5000 words)Assignment

Human Resource Management in Practice. Explanation of human`s skills

...? Human Resource Management in Practice Table of Contents Developing the Practitioner 3 Communications and meeting skills 4 Presentation Skills 5 Training and Learning 6 Equality and Diversity 7 Recruitment and Selection 8 Performance Management and Appraisal 9 Absence Management 10 Counselling/mediation-developing skills for the workplace 11 Grievance and Discipline 12 Management of Change 13 Reflective Statement 14 References 20 Developing the Practitioner The competitive environment and the quest for excellence in business organizations has necessitated the need to ensure human resource development. In this regard the role of the practitioner assumes utmost priority in an organization. A practitioner in the area of human... Human Resource...
20 Pages(5000 words)Assignment

A comparative analysis between Franklins Caf and Caffe Nero

...?Organizational Analysis and Behavior Introduction: The aim of this essay paper is to make a comparative analysis between two organizations that havethe same industrial background. In this paper, compare and contrast are being done between the two firms Franklin’s Cafe (a small business) and Caffe Nero (a large multinational business). The analysis is done mainly with respect to the two important topics relevant in the organizations. The topics discussed are done mainly on the basis of the case study that helps to answer question like which one of the two organizations would one prefer to be a customer and an employee. This essay paper not only states which organization one would want to be an employee and a customer, but also... Analysis and ...
17 Pages(4250 words)Assignment

Origin and Evolution of Birds Paper

...?Chul lee Blake Animal Biology 102 November 28, Origin and Evolution of Birds Birds are a truly unique set of animals in the world. For millions of generations, birds have constantly been living on earth. As the evolution theory came to being and many scientists came forth to prove it, the evolution of birds was not left behind. Birds are animals that evolved millions of years ago due to a number of factors in order to resemble the modern day birds (Heilmann 2). As more research is put forth on the origin and the evolution of birds, many results seems to be emanating day by day as new discoveries are made. In the recent years, with enhancement in scientific development, much has been able to be got related to the origin... lee Blake Animal...
11 Pages(2750 words)Assignment

Marketing plan for the healthcare company (nursing home service)

...?Executive Summary  Marketing has always been the most essential functions for all types of businesses and industries including health care industry.World’s population is growing rapidly and so the number of older people. According to researches and studies, the fastest growing demographic are people aged above 80. At the economic level, every shift in demographics brings economic and social challenges with itself. Even in the healthcare systems, the concept of ageing population adds pressure and demands along with itself. At the level of an individual, increased life span brings several challenges with itself. Old aged people have to face certain types of problems when they are at home. At this crucial stage of life, where... Summary ...
15 Pages(3750 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Assignment on topic Assignment for FREE!

Contact Us