CSI and the Post Modern Body - Essay Example

The foundation of CSI is based on the fact that the identity given by the DNA tests undertaken is indisputable and accurately points to the suspect, regardless of the fact that the body could be mutilated. Most significant is the fact that it is impossible to accurately determine the actual gender of the victim, without the application of science. Therefore, the case of identity of the suspect becomes a puzzle to solve, up until the forensic science is applied, which identifies the suspect as a man, who has been living as a woman conducting surgeries and killing the victims (Harrington, 2007).

The strength of the argument presented here is the fact that science is the indisputable basis of presenting an accurate identity of the individuals involved in crime. This is because; through forensic science, where the DNA of the suspects involved can be traced, then the real identity of those involved can be unquestionably noted (Harrington, 2007). Considering that through transsexual surgeries, the gender of an individual can be changed, then, it makes the investigations through detectives more complicated.

This is because, while the investigation could point to the suspect of the crime from a certain gender, then tracing them would be difficult since they can change that. However, through forensic science, the real identity will always remain, as the DNA of an individual can never be changed (Harrington, 2007). Thus, the argument presents science as the basis of providing society with the unbiased truth of identity. The role of the detectives, according to the argument is to expose a true narrative of crime, leaving the rest to science, to determine the identity (Harrington, 2007).

Nevertheless, the weakness depicted by the argument is that of glorifying the role of science in fighting crime, while completely ignoring the role of detectives. This creates a myth that it is possible to deal with any crime with the support of science, while in the real sense this is barely true (Harrington, 2007). The other weakness of the CSI is the presentation of the whites, mostly the middle class as the victims of crime, while in essence, crime faces and affects all indiscriminately.