Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

Homosexual male couple wants to adopt a child. What will Rousseau, Benedict, and Aquinas argue. What is your view Explain - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
When studying Philosophy and ethics, it is easy to think that the ethics of people who are long dead bear very little relevance to contemporary issues. However influential they were in another time, how can one enter into substantive dialogue with them in our time? This paper…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.8% of users find it useful
Homosexual male couple wants to adopt a child. What will Rousseau, Benedict, and Aquinas argue. What is your view Explain
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Homosexual male couple wants to adopt a child. What will Rousseau, Benedict, and Aquinas argue. What is your view Explain"

March 2, Homosexual Adoption: ical Views on a Contemporary Issue When studying Philosophy and ethics, it is easy to think that the ethics of people who are long dead bear very little relevance to contemporary issues. However influential they were in another time, how can one enter into substantive dialogue with them in our time? This paper will attempt to do so, by imagining the views of Rousseau, Benedict and Aquinas in comparison with my own, in response to a male homosexual couple wanting to adopt a child.
This is an ethical issue because some people feel it is morally wrong or unnatural to be homosexual, or to be romantically coupled with a person of the same gender, and that children need to be protected from such people. Others feel that adults have a right to express sexual preference, that it is a private choice and not a moral issue at all, but that children need a mother and a father which, by definition, a male homosexual couple cannot provide. Still others feel that children need parents to love and guide them, and that sexual preference is not pertinent.
Rousseau claimed that individual freedom comes from sacrificing personal liberty to the “general will”, so that the common interest (not necessarily the majority vote) can be legislated and everyone is protected by the community’s will (Philosophy, et cetara). In the case of conflict, arising from diversity, Rousseau claims that the common interest is what benefits all members, so minority interests are protected from being exploited. Individual rights become collective rights. The general will can never take away individual rights because individual rights are not of practical use to the community or common good (Philosophy, et cetara).
Given this argument, relative to the issue under consideration, it is an individual right to become part of a couple and to raise a family. The general will can only be given an opportunity to overturn this right if two conditions are met. The first is that there is found sufficient and overwhelming evidence that there is danger or developmental threat to children from male homosexual parents. In this event, it can be said to be in the common good to protect the children of the community, who are all innocent and good (Doyle and Smith), from threat. The second condition, which must also be met, along with the first, is that the general will leads to legislation protecting all children of all parents from all threats of any kind. This condition is necessary to meet the requirement of equality under the law. As these conditions do not currently exist, then Rousseau would support the right of the male homosexual couple to adopt the child.
Benedict Spinoza builds on Neo-Platonic thought and Descarte’s definition of “substance” and advocates non-dualism, insisting everything is of one substance. The substance is God, the Absolute. Man is the natural unfolding of God’s nature. Man is identical, in a pantheistic sense, with God ( Therefore the love of man for man is still, in essence, the love of God for God. Homosexuality cannot be immoral because God is not immoral. In the same way, if a male homosexual couple adopts a child and loves the child, and the child loves them as parents, this too is the unity of God’s love. Spinoza would defend their right to adopt, reminding the State of their duty to encourage the men to know God through the rational efforts of raising the child, an expression of God, whom they seek to know.
Thomas Aquinas classified, supported and justified the teachings and rules of the Catholic Church (Hillar, 22). He took, as absolutes, Church religious dogma and supported absolute obedience to its edicts. He would, therefore, have been opposed to a male homosexual couple adopting a child, as it is forbidden by the Catholic Church.
My own opinion, in this matter, is that if a male homosexual couple wants to adopt and parent a child, and they are reasonably certain they have a loving, stable relationship, and are prepared to love the child, then they should have the same rights as any heterosexual couple with a similar desire and intention. I agree with Rousseau that majority and minority must be treated equally and fairly, and that the majority has no right to impose power over the minority, where the common interest is not being threatened. I also like Benedict’s way of seeing everyone as being of one God substance, and that the love of man for man is the love of God for God.
Works Cited
Doyle, Michele Erina and Mark K. Smith. "Jean-Jacques Rousseau on Education." 2007. The Encyclopaedia of Informal Education. Web. 2 March 2012 .
Hillar, Marian. "The Justification of Morals in the Philosophy of Thomas Aquinas." Hillar, M. and H.R. Leuchtag. Ethics and Humanism. Houston: American Humanist Association, 1992. 21-40. Print.
Philosophy, et cetara. "Rousseau and the "General Will"." 20 March 2004. Philosophy, et cetara. Web. 2 March 2012 . "Modern Philosophy - The Philosophy of Bendict Spinoza." 1 June 2010. Web. 2 March 2012 . Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Homosexual male couple wants to adopt a child. What will Rousseau, Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Homosexual Male Couple Wants to Adopt a Child. What Will Rousseau, Essay)
“Homosexual Male Couple Wants to Adopt a Child. What Will Rousseau, Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Homosexual male couple wants to adopt a child. What will Rousseau, Benedict, and Aquinas argue. What is your view Explain

Should Homosexual Couples be Allowed to Adopt

... Should Homosexual couples be allowed to adopt? Homosexual couples are capable of raising healthy children, their life style will not be transcended to them and they will not be psychologically damaged as suggested by the traditional family. Adoption by Homosexual couple is definitely an agreeable fact. This is evident from the number of children in orphanages, who need to be adopted, cared for and loved. What rights do heterosexual couples or other people have to tell same sex couples, that they cannot parent and love a child, just as they do or even better? So, therefore if the same sex couples are in a monogamous relationship, financially stable and most importantly a loving relationship, they should be allowed to adopt a child... are...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper


...view of good. While for Aquinas the highest object of the highest human power, that is intellect, ought to be a ‘cognitive-affective union’, to us who have quite figured the ultimate goodness of physical pleasures derived via things that immediately appeal to the senses, there seems no hope of understanding how Aquinas’ immaterial good may find suitable connection to the extremely material good of the present age. No wonder why the notion of ‘common good’ becomes hardly existent in our time, because the great barrier that separates man’s discernment of natural law by spiritual or metaphysical doctrine and man’s comprehension of the current reality is filled with practicalities of the...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Homosexual Stereotypes

...and heterosexual relationships. Journal of Homosexuality, 12, 1-23. Haldeman, D.C. (2000). The practice and ethics of sexual orientation conversion therapy. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 62(2): 221-227. Kite, M.E. (2004). Individual differences in males' reactions to gay males; Basic and Applied Social Psychology 22: 1222-1239. Metts, Kurdek Dillard, J.P. & Broetzmann, S.M. (2002). The dissolution of gay couples. Journal of Personal and Social Relationships, 8, 265-278. Michael, R.T., Gagnon, J.H., Laumann, E.O., & Kolata, G. (2000). Sex in England. A definitive survey. London: Little, Brown & Company. P.172-186 Peplau, L.A. & Cochran, S.D. (2002). A...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay


... and the common good, can only occur politically. There is no Archimedean resolution to this inherent democratic dilemma. For Rousseau the essence of both "natural freedom" and "civil freedom" was the absence of personal dependence on others. In a society characterized by a healthy civic culture, all constantly adhere to the general will, regardless of their specific interests. This refers to a society where democracy along with a complete totalitarianism is followed. Rousseau possessed the view that only in this manner we can expect complete freedom of democratic sovereignty in Western Europe. This civic culture of conflict-free social solidarity is best facilitated by a relatively undifferentiated political economy. Due... of modern...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Explain your view of the role of television

...on views and perception of current events and political situation around the world. Television documentaries have the power to galvanize people into action. Documentary is one of the most powerful things television does, and sadly it has done so with less and less frequency in recent years. At its worst, television is as bad as its worst critics suggested it might be (Charlton 2001). In some countries television is used by petty dictators to make them appear godlike to an uneducated population; in others the information provided is what the party in power wants believed. Even in the most technologically advanced and well educated countries television is used to sell politicians like soap and deodorant...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Abortion and the Female/Male View

...them by ‘being there’ but their silence is often misunderstood as apathy and indifference towards the plight of female in case there are considerable social problems involved with the birth of the child which may be illegitimate. Shostak describes male abortion pain as the loss of fatherhood and a "wound you cannot see or feel, but it exists" Shostak found: 1. Abortion is a "death experience" and for most men more emotionally trying than they expected 2. The most common post-abortion reaction was helplessness; 3. Men who are not helped to mourn over an abortion are learning how to be even less involved as nurturant parents in the future; and 4. The majority of relationships failed post-abortion....
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Using Your adopt a Business

... Task: Adopt a Business Retailer In any business venture, there is a need to utilize quality business models that aim at increasing profits. These models should be weighed in terms of their profits and losses. Therefore, this paper aims to discuss the various stages of Three-Stage of Service Commission and their implications folds the business and customers. Additionally, the discussion attempts to evaluate other recommendations that a retailer can pursue to boost sales and profits (Jefferson). In an Adopt, a Business Retailer, there are the Three-Stage of Service Commission stages which entail pre-purchase, Service Encounter and Post Encounter. On that note, pre-purchase involve an awareness of the clients such as the products... and...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Homosexual Rights

...and cope with all the perceptions and ridicules from members of the society. Taiwan is one of the first Chinese countries to advocate for homosexual rights when they launched they gay parade in 2003. Whilst some people think that Taiwan may tolerate homosexuality, the reality is that many people in different communities feel humiliated by this practice of homosexuality. Homosexuality will take some time to be accepted by all members of the society though lesbians and gays argue that they have the same rights like other heterosexuals. This is the reason why they are advocating for equal rights since they argue that they have a...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Adopting a Child by Lesbian Couple

...of what their culture dictates regarding marriage. Hence, prompting the social agency to reject Jacqui and Anne’s plea. Besides, according to their narration, there is no prove they will be together until the child attains his or her independence stage (Coghill, 2009). This is because they argue to be living together but no documents to prove their union (Coghill, 2009). Another obstacle is the races’ difference, whereby the adoption agency will be reluctant in letting the couple get the adoptee of their choice (Allen, 2005). Since, this may add up to worsening the child’s state besides the distress or severe experiences, he or she might have...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Homosexual Love

...with "Sapphist" and "Sapphism" around the turn of the twentieth century. The utilization of "Lesbian" in restorative writing got noticeable; by 1925, the expression was recorded as a thing to mean what might as well be called a sodomite. The improvement of restorative information was a noteworthy component in further meanings of the term. Amidst the nineteenth century, therapeutic journalists endeavored to secure approaches to recognize male homosexuality, which was viewed as a huge social issue in most Western social orders. In sorting conduct that showed what was alluded to as "reversal" by German sexologist Magnus Hirschfeld, scientists figured out what was typical sexual conduct for...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Homosexual male couple wants to adopt a child. What will Rousseau, Benedict, and Aquinas argue. What is your view Explain for FREE!

Contact Us