StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Antigone Written Response - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
CREON AND ANTIGONE: The most often asked question about the play Antigone by Sophocles, one of the three great Greek writers of tragedy, is who is the tragic hero of the play; is it Antigone or is it Creon? According to Aristotle’s concept, a tragic hero is highly placed,…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.9% of users find it useful
Antigone Written Response
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Antigone Written Response"

CREON AND ANTIGONE: The most often asked question about the play Antigone by Sophocles, one of the three great Greek of tragedy, is who is the tragic hero of the play; is it Antigone or is it Creon? According to Aristotle’s concept, a tragic hero is highly placed, highly renowned and prosperous character. He is neither good nor bad and is never perfect. Finally he is responsible for his own down fall. The downfall is from a height so that it assumes somewhat of a high emotional magnitude to create an impact on the audience. Only such a fall from a height with impact of high magnitude will lead the audience to what Aristotle calls “ Catharsis”, or purging away of bad traits in their own character. To quote Poetics by Aristotle: “ Tragedy, then, is an imitation of an action of high importance , complete and of some amplitude ; in language enhanced by distinct and varying beauties ; acted not narrated; by means of pity and fear effecting its purgation of these emotions.” (From Poetics, Eight Great Tragedies, PP 406)
In this play both Antigone as well as Creon, the ruler of Thebes, seemingly qualify to be the tragic hero. As the play is titled Antigone, one tends to assume that she should be the tragic heroine of the play. But she actually fits into only few of the Aristotelian characteristics of a tragic hero. She is a princess. She is not good or bad in the extreme. She is loyal to her brother, polyneices, for whom she wanted to give a decent burial. When Creon the king denies her this right, she questions the authority of the king and that leads to her death. Thus here is a fall from a highly dignified position which may seem to make Antigone the tragic heroine of the play. But her action is will full and is for a noble cause .She knew the consequences of her action and was ready to perish for it. She was doing what she thought was right.
Creon on the other hand has all the characteristics to be an Aristotelian tragic hero. He is not good, nor is he bad. Though his actions lead to the death of Antigone, he never intended to kill her. He was trying to keep the law of his own rule over the Thebans. But beyond this motif, his actions are out of his arrogance and stubbornness. He was so arrogant to think that being the king his was the final word with no responsibility to the people. “No. I am king and responsible only to myself.” says Creon during his argument with his own son, Haemon. (Antigone, line 738, The Theban Plays, PP146). During this argument he refuses to admit the error in his judgment in deciding not to give Polyneices a burial. Polyneices was a rebel and hence Creon decided that his body be left in the battle field to be eaten up by vultures and worms, the harshest punishment of that time, which has no approval of the Gods. At the same time he decided that the dead body of Eteocles, who died in the battle with his own brother, that is Polynecies will be honored and buried. Though he wins the support of the Theban elders for his actions, Teiresias, the blind prophet is warning him that Gods are with Antigone. Instead of listening to the words of wisdom, he arrogantly accuses the prophet to be corrupt. Finally great tragedy falls on him. Antigone kills herself. Creon loses his son and his wife as well. He gets a punishment which is worse than death. He laments his tragic situation thus: “I am nothing. I have no life /Lead me away…. (Lines 1338-39, Ibid PP, 161).Though the audience feel sympathy for him, it was all too late for him. Thus Creon as one who gets doomed because of his own action and defiance of the God’s will is definitely the tragic hero of this play. The chorus closes the play by saying that Gods punish the proud. But the chorus reminds the audience that such punishment brings wisdom too. “This is the law/ That seeing the stricken heart/ Of pride brought down / We learn when we are old.” (Lines, 1350-53, Ibid PP162)
SIGNIFICANCE OF THE FINAL SCENE: The final scene is where Creon comes to know of the consequences of his actions. He wanted to correct himself; but it was late. He had gone out to free Antigone from the cave where she was imprisoned, but by the time he reaches there she had hanged herself. Haemon, Creon’s son who wanted to marry Antigone, stabs himself to death, after an argument with his father. Eurydice, Creon’s wife, after hearing about these tragic happenings kills herself. Creon wails about his mistakes and wrong decisions and expresses guilt over the killing of his own son and wife. He laments how false pride has lead to his own downfall.
The thematic question posed by Sophocles is this: which law is greater; the law of man or that of the God? The play stands by the law of the God, without belittling the greatness of man. (“Wonders are many on earth and the greatest of these is man …. Says, the Chorus. Ibid PP135). The message thus Sophocles gives to the Theban people is to remain alert against the arrogance of their rulers. When the rulers get arrogant the country will get destroyed morally. Sophocles points out at this dangerous trend in the character of the kings in another of his plays, Oedipus the King, the prequel to Antigone. (Antigone is the daughter of Oedipus) There the tragedy is brought about by the arrogance of Oedipus, the king. This lesson is valid not only to the Theban people but to the rulers and the people of the modern world too.
More valid to the modern times is the theme of the right of the individual to reject the attempt by the Government or the society to control his/her freedom to perform his/her personal obligations. Antigone fights such controlling efforts by Creon. While Creon stands for the laws made by men, Antigone stands for much more higher values which can be called divine values. This struggle between personal freedom and the dictates of the State is valid more in the modern social life. The State often sees the citizens as slaves of the laws imposed by it on them. Such situations make the rulers arrogant .They arrogantly deny the rights of the people. This leads to the moral disintegration of the country and its people. This is the lesson Sophocles wants to give to his people and which stands valid even today.
========================
Works Cited:
1) Antigone, Sophocles/ The Theban Plays, Translated by E.F.Watling, Penguin Classics, December 1946.
2) Aristotle: From The Poetics, Translated by L.J. Potts, Eight Great Tragedies, A Mentor Book, Published by The New American Library, New York. 1957. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Antigone Written Response Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words - 1”, n.d.)
Antigone Written Response Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words - 1. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1565226-antigone-written-response
(Antigone Written Response Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words - 1)
Antigone Written Response Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words - 1. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1565226-antigone-written-response.
“Antigone Written Response Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1565226-antigone-written-response.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Antigone Written Response

Antigone

... of moral conflict in this play are the differences between familial and citizen responsibilities and differences between duties to the gods and duties to the state, while the effects of the moral conflict is the loss of loved ones for Creon, due to Antigone’s suicide. The play depicts the conflict between serving the state’s authority and observing one’s family duties. Creon makes a law that prevents Polyneices from having a proper burial, because he is a traitor to Thebes. He declares: Him I decree that none should dare entomb, That none should utter wail or loud lament, But leave his corpse unburied, by the dogs And vultures mangled, foul to look upon. (Sophocles 233-236). Antigone, however, is willing to defy the king, so that she can...
23 Pages(5750 words)Essay

Antigone

...? Literary analysis of Antigone Rough draft Literary analysis: Antigone The story of Antigone is based on prophetic issues and the decision of main protagonists in the play. Antigone and Creon are the main protagonists of the play based on the belief and pride. The play is based on the trust and tradition of the people of Thebes. In fact, the major challenge is on the burial of Polyneices, the challenge is based on the laws to respect. Antigone believes in the laws of the deity which forces them to follow the rites and rituals for proper burial. However, King Creon believes that the laws are made by man and men are the only people who can change the laws. The major challenge affecting both the two protagonists is the personal pride making...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Antigone Written Response

... had proven as his weakness, for in the end he has led to the tragic affairs that would forever taint his rule. Compared with Antigone, Creon is the weaker character. Antigone is a good example of a tragic figure, one which clings to her ideals if she knows they are right and would demand to be heard before she made her own means. Her actions towards the burial of an important person prove how fearless she is. And when it comes to dying, she chose to die with honor. Creon, in contrary, lack the courage it took Antigone to take her own life. That and that alone, is enough proof that Creon is nothing like Antigone. He is nothing like the sort of man a woman could trust decisions in. He failed to discuss his options and saw the fruit...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

ANTIGONE

...Antigone Table of Contents Identification of Specific Values, Beliefs, Character Traits of Antigone Contributing to Her Actions and Leading to HerDeath 3 2. Five Ancient Greek Beliefs, Customs, Views Using Evidence from Antigone 3 3. What the Play Suggests About the Nature of Leadership 3 4. Status of Women in Ancient Greece 3 5. On Antigone- Older or Younger Sister? 4 Works Cited 5 1. Identification of Specific Values, Beliefs, Character Traits of Antigone Contributing to Her Actions and Leading to Her Death She is defiant and loyal to family values, willing to go against the edict of the king in order to bury his dead brother. Facing the King Creon, she continued to be defiant, reasoning with the kind and questioning the morality...
1 Pages(250 words)Book Report/Review

Antigone

Part one The prophecy about the ascension to power by Oedipus comes to pass in the play. Oedipus was to become king by killing his father Laius, which happened on his way to visit the town. The tragedy comes when he ascends to power and marries his mother. The life of Oedipus is complex because it marked with several challenges including being tied and thrown away in order to prevent the prophecy to occur. He is the son of King Laius and Queen Jocasta but later married his mother. The realization of the tragedy of incest leads to death of the queen because she commits suicide after knowing the truth. Oedipus kills his father during a disagreement along the road. In addition he kills Sphinx making him a darling for the people of Th...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Antigone

... Part The play opens with Thebe’s civil war that results to the death of two conflicting brothers, Eteocles and Polyneices. Creon takes over the leadership and decrees that Polyneices will be unburried and hence be consumed by prey since he was the cause of the conflict. Their sister Antigone is bold and attempts to bury the body of his brother despite lack of support from her sister Ismene. Her attempt to bury him lands her to prison together with her sister that was accused of having known the plot. The issue of Antigone causes a row between Creon and his son, Haemon. Haemon is in love with Antigone. Creon rules that he will spare Ismene and bury Antigone alive were not for the intervention of Tiresias, the blind prophet. The twist...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Written response

...NEL NODDING ON RELATIONSHIPS s Nel Noddings has played a major role in defining the ethics of care. According to this proponentcaring is a foundation of ethical decision making. Noddings believe that we cannot care if there is no relationship existing amongst us. Noddings believe that a relationship is first created by reception relatedness and engrossment. She argues that relationships involve caring for the needs of each other. This comes through when we develop the sense of reception and start caring about each other. Noddings believe that caring is a basic need in human life and all people deserve caring. The author relates this to the natural instinct of caring that man and women develop in terms of provision of basic needs... NODDING ON ...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Antigone

...Tittle: Wuthering Heights Unit: In the novel Antigone, Sophocles builds two stubborn and strong willed characters. Creon and Antigone are the main characters in this book that seals the fate of one another. The two characters have quest for power and come head to head in the struggle of getting the power. Antigone is a robust girl with respect for all except Creon. She is extremely brave and believes that women and men are equal. She sees women as strong people and should be treated with fairness and equity. On the other hand, Creon appears to be very cruel, selfish and self-centered person. He is a greedy king of Thebes that wants to have much money. He disrespects women especially Antigone that he distastes very much. Creon put Antigone...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Written response task

...February 25, First GMTB Company 12 Park Main Street Michigan, ME 010000 Dear Ms, Smith At first I have known about GMTB Company from the job board called Hot Jobs. I have become familiar with all information stated in the job offer. I was impressed with all qualities and features of your company. The natural gas engineering is my primary qualification, so I decided to apply for the job in GMTB Company. But I had still not enough experience and knowledge to cooperate with your company. But now, after a little time from the first acquaintance with your company I believe that I am the proper type of the candidate that you are looking for. Therefore I want to apply. I wish to be the significant and effective part of your team... 25, First GMTB...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Written response

...Written Response 2 al Affiliation Location: Location of a building is an important aspect of every architectural process and every designer must always be completely aware of all the location-related factors which must be taken into consideration in the design process. The central theme in this reading is on architectural sites. The reading expounds on why it is imperative for every person involved in architectural design and work to appreciate the significance of the site where a building is found. The author is motivated by the fact that the site gives rise to various parameters which directly influence the outcome of an architectural design or project. The reading is also motivated by the need to explore the influence the memories...
1 Pages(250 words)Research Paper

IMF/World Bank Response to Asian Crisis

... IMF/World Bank Response to Asian Crisis Since the first signs of the impending financial crisis appeared in Asian countries financial sectors, one wonders if the International Monetary Funds (IMF) and the World Bank (WB) understood from the outset what was happening, and whether their remedies were timely and appropriate; or, conversely, if prescriptions of IMF and WB made a bad situation worse. One of the underlying causes of earlier financial crises in Central and Latin America and in Africa had been excessive spending by governments. Chronic public sector budget deficits had generated price inflation and trade account imbalances that led to overvalued currencies and the flight of capital. The WB and IMFs conventional prescription...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment

Factors that Influence Tissue Response to Radiation and Evidential Explanations for Them

All biological matter contains inorganic and organic compounds dissolved or suspended in water. This is a protoplasm. The smallest structural and functional component of protoplasm that can exist freely in the cell (Suntharalingam et al, 2005, p. 485). It is just necessary to study the effects of radiation at the cellular level to truly understand the factors that affect biological tissues. Cells are of two types – somatic cells and germ cells. Of these somatic cells have three subtypes – stem cells (cells that generate other cells through differentiation), transit cells (cells that are in the state of being transformed from one type of cell to another) and mature cells (cells that are fully differentiated and are rela...
10 Pages(2500 words)Term Paper

Analysis of Physiological Stress Response Case

Hien Ng's personal history was also significant. He was a chronic smoker and had smoked 20 cigarettes per day for many years. On admission, a general examination of the patient revealed that he was anxious and agitated, but orientated to time and place. His skin was pale and cool to touch. Heart rate was 116 beats per minute and irregular, blood pressure was 140/95mmHg, the temperature was 37.8 C (cool peripheries), respiratory rate was 28 per minute, abdominal pain score was 6/10 and approximate weight was 68kg and height 163cm.

From the above history, it is evident that Mr. Ng was admitted to the hospital with acute gastroenteritis with dehydration and exacerbation of chronic gastric ulcers. He was subjected to both a...
15 Pages(3750 words)Case Study

Response of Effective Leaders to Diverse Team Environments

An effective leader is the one who adapts to the changing scenarios in terms of the team he leads and also in terms of the circumstances that the team faces. Herscovitch and Meyer (2002) have confirmed that workplaces are faced with endless change (s), and Paton and McCalman, (2000) have further stated that effective management of that change is an important competency currently required by an organization

Advancement in technology, travel options, communications and liberalization of international business regulations has incorporated numerous possibilities of conditions with diverse natures within the work environment. This trend was found to increase in the early nineties. The transference of a command-driven economy...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

Response to Disaster

...Response to Disaster Response to Disaster Response to disaster is the second stage of disaster management. It comprises of a number of aspects, for instance; evacuation/warning, seek and rescue, assessing damage, offering immediate assistance, continuing assistance, as well as the instantaneous reinstatement of infrastructure (Chien, Davies, Tran 2004 p. 13). The goal of emergency response is to offer direct assistance to sustain life, enhance health and endorse the self-esteem of the affected populace. Such help might vary from offering precise but restricted aid, such as helping refugees with transport, food and temporary shelter, to setting up partial settlement in camps plus other locations. It also might engross initial preservation...
8 Pages(2000 words)Term Paper

Analysis of the Macbeth Play Written by William Shakespeare

...Macbeth Macbeth is a play set up in scot land is written by a great d William Shakespeare. However,it is considered as one of his darkest and most powerful tragedies. The play aims to dramatize the corrosive psychological and political effects which were produced when evil is chosen as a way to fulfill an ambition to gain power. It was the first play by Shakespeare which is categorized as the most studied play which has been made into films, shown in television and even made for basis for the modern plays and films we watch today. Shakespeare work has transcended language, time and even continental barrier; his plays are among the most analyzed and perfumed all over the world. His poems are also taught in classes at every level...
8 Pages(2000 words)Book Report/Review

Lens and Artifact from Letter from Birmingham Jail and Antigone

... of this letter further says that, “it is unfortunate that the demonstrations are taking place in Birmingham but it is more unfortunate that the city’s white power structure left the Negro community with no alternative” (Martin Luther King 458). These is an indication of the civil unrest in the city and MLK does not fear to say that he is responsible and supports the idea of the civil disobedience but it’s a fight for justice for the Negros. MLK is determined to bring justice to the Negros. Similar reproach is portrayed by Antigone when she defies the Kings orders and decides to bury his brother’s body. King Creole had made a decision that Polyneices body not to be buried but her sister Antigone is determined to give his late brother final...
6 Pages(1500 words)Term Paper

Bovine Tuberculosis, Anthelmintic Treatment, Worms and their Effect on the Immune Response to other Pathogens

If a dairy farmer suspects that there are positive TB infection cases in his or her herd, they can conduct a Single intra-dermal Comparative Cervical Tuberculin (SICCT) test to diagnose suspected cases. The SICCT test measures a delayed mode hypersensitivity response to the tuberculin antigen, Purified Protein Derivative (PPD) and is dependent on functional antigen-specific. However, use of SICCT test does not produce confidence levels required to ascertain the success of the tests. The diagnostic sensitivity of the SICCT test is estimated to be between 52-100% with a median value of 80% using the standard interpretation of the test. Factors attributed to the inaccuracy, and the poor sensitivity of the test include among many; the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Oil Spill Response and Cleanup Techniques

This paper will examine, deluge method, chemical method, vacuum, high-pressure washing method and use of microbes. The vacuum method is considered to be the best method since it has fewer effects on the environment.

This technique washes the surface oil to the edges so that it can be collected. The oil that floats on water and also found at the crevices is driven offshore. Normaly, a big pipe with a wide diameter is placed parallel to the shoreline above the oiled area. A flexible perforated header hose is used during the deluge of intertidal shorelines to better conform to their profiles.

“Ambient seawater is pumped through holes in the header pipes and flows down the beach face to the water. On poro...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

The Invisible Gorilla Written by Chabris and Simons

... The Rhetorical Analysis Essay on The Invisible Gorilla The Invisible Gorilla is a book written by Chabris and Simons in order to address two major themes namely gaps that exist in various kinds in cognitive abilities of people and the inability of people to recognize those gaps or believe in their existence. The book is composed of six chapters which analyzes different forms of illusions. Some of the illusions include then illusion of attention, memory, knowledge, cause, confidence and potential. Illusions form an intergral part of the lives of human beings and this paper seeks to establish some of the facts and beliefs that underlie illusions in relation to the Invisible Gorilla. The book is a combination of experimental studies...
6 Pages(1500 words)Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Antigone Written Response for FREE!

Contact Us