Historic Preservation and the Imagined West - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Is it truly the history you come to see or is there a different purpose here? All three cites have grand historic districts. Those consist of Pioneer Square in Seattle, Larimer Square in Denver…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96% of users find it useful
Historic Preservation and the Imagined West
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Historic Preservation and the Imagined West"

Historic Preservation and the Imagined West Historic Preservation and the Imagined West The historic districts of Denver, Seattle, and Albuquerque may not be what they seem. Is it truly the history you come to see or is there a different purpose here? All three cites have grand historic districts. Those consist of Pioneer Square in Seattle, Larimer Square in Denver and Old town in Albuquerque. In the book Historic Preservation and the Imagined West, written by Judy Morley, it is indicated that there may have been another reason for the development of these districts. We will explore that possibility in this paper.
Let us start our exploration in the South. Albuquerque today is one of the fastest growing cities in the west. It sits in the valley between two rivers and much of their history is related to “sitting between two rivers”. It is high desert and is always warm and dry. It is in New Mexico and its original inhabitants were Mexican. There still is a large population of Hispanic people in the Albuquerque area and most of the culture of the city is affected by the Hispanic culture. There is also a large pueblo Indian culture in the Albuquerque area including Southern Ute, Navajo and Apache (McCullah, 2007, pg 30). These cultures have affected the past culture of the city and continue to affect the present culture. As you enter Old Town, you will notice all of these influences immediately.
Old Town in Albuquerque sits at Central and 4th Streets in the city. It took $8 million to make it old enough for a tourist historic district. It was, in fact, the area in which old Hispanic culture began. In fact, back when the city was small, it was very close to the center of town. There are iron fences and gardens just like you would imagine. You can stroll around the area in the shade of the verandas from the buildings. Shopping is readily available and you better bring your wallet because they are very expensive and exclusive in nature. This culture was created from another, older culture. The Hispanics were driven from the area when the renovations began. They were evicted from their homes. The Navajo used to sell all original jewelry off blankets on the streets and the local life was vibrant yet poor. It is a little ironic that the very culture of the people were driven away in order to represent that culture as historic. This writer believes that is what Morley was trying to tell us in her book (Morley, 2006).
Today Old Town is a beautiful place to visit and certainly there are many things to do and much to buy. It is definitely a tourist attraction. The advertisements on the internet are very enticing and make you want to go right away, especially with winter approaching the rest of us. However, it is never mentioned that a few blocks away live the very families that were evicted from these neighborhoods and most live in abject poverty. There are drugs and gangs to deal with. Albuquerque has one of the largest percent of drive by shootings in the United States. We, like so many times, have taken advantage of a poor culture to build our own riches.
A little North of Albuquerque lays Denver Colorado. This city like Albuquerque is growing and is considered part of the Wild West. Their important historic district is Larimer Square. Larimer Square lies on 1st street in the city. At one time this was a dry goods store, the first bank in the west, a bookstore, and the 1st western post office. Today it is shopping, dining, and entertainment. It is lively in the day or night but especially at night. There are 16 renovated 19th century commercial building that are now shops, nightclubs, courtyards and open spaces. Not to long ago, this area was where the homeless went, prostitutes walked, panhandlers worked and alcoholics spent time. All of those people were driven out of the area when the new historic district was built. Again, it was somewhat ironic to have the Wild West driven away so we could build the Wild West.
When we think of the Wild West, we think of saloons and prostitutes, drunks and guns. These things are shown to us everyday in the movies we watch. Of course, everyone is always clean and nice and has just had a bath. Well in the real world that is not the way it is. These people are dirty and homeless and drunk and disorderly and drinking establishments are not pleasant places to go. That is unless it is on Larimer Square in Denver. The restaurants and saloons are lovely and clean and fun. There is one problem though. At night you should not veer to far away from 1st street and you should be on your toes and not wonder around alone (Gendzel, 2008).
Seattle has its Pioneer Square. You can ride downtown by horse and cart on the cobblestone streets of yesteryear. View the historic buildings of the past and the beauty of the area. It is magnificent and while you are there shop in the biggest book store in the country, some of the best shops around and view museums about Seattle’s history. Seattle’s historic district is now known as one of the most cherished historic districts in the states.
Seattle knew by the time that they attempted their transformation of this district that it would make a huge difference in the income for the city. It was well planned prior to setting out to do the work. Their goal was to plan an old American downtown while changing the culture and assumptions about the district. At the time there was a definite nationwide shift in taking a declining real estate market (downtown) and converting it into a tourist attraction. Many people and small business were evicted from the area in order to provide the space for renovation.
In conclusion, yes, there are some truly beautiful historic districts in the United States and three of the most beautiful lie in Albuquerque, Denver, and Seattle. We have a romantic way of looking at the Old West, even though it was in reality a violent and often poor period of our history. Were the historic districts of these towns built on true history? Certainly, that is the question that Morley would ask in her book. Much of the history is still there in all three cases, though it is different than that of the original history.
Would we visit and spend our money in the old towns of the past, without the renovations that have been done? Probably not. We, as Americans, do not want to see the squallier of being poor or the true way a saloon or brothel looks. We visit Old Town, whether it is in Albuquerque, Denver, or Seattle, we visit our dreams of what the Wild West was like and that is the way we like it.
Gendzel, G. (2008) Historic Preservation, A Review: San Jose University
McCullah, T. (2007). Indian Pueblo Cultural Center: Albuquerque; Journal of the West
Vol. 46 Iss 1, p 30
Morley, J., (2006). Historic Preservation And the Imagined West: Albuquerque, Denver,
And Seattle. University Press of Kansas: Kansas City. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Historic Preservation and the Imagined West Essay”, n.d.)
Historic Preservation and the Imagined West Essay. Retrieved from
(Historic Preservation and the Imagined West Essay)
Historic Preservation and the Imagined West Essay.
“Historic Preservation and the Imagined West Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Historic Preservation and the Imagined West

Cell Theory

9 Pages(2250 words)Assignment

Technological Advancements in Historic Preservation

...Technological Advancements in Historic Preservation Building preservation is a practice that has existed for many years with many approaches being made in traditional building and construction to ensure that buildings are continuously sustainable. Building preservation enhances buildings in maximizing the usage of existing materials and infrastructures, reducing waste, and preserving the historical identity of older towns and other cities (WBDG). In most cases, sustainability of buildings is initiated through strategic preservation. Historic buildings have been designed with sustainable features that...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper

Digital Preservation

...Digital Preservation policy, procedure and practice in a small archive "As the manager of a small archive you are concerned about establishing policies, procedures and practices to ensure that both born-digital material and analogue items (paper-based and sound recordings) currently being digitized by the archive are future-proofed, that is , created and archived in such a way as to ensure, as far as possible, their long-term survival." Mission and Objectives This note lays down the policy documents for short and long term preservation of digitized items in a small university archive in Hong Kong. The policy document shows the procedures and policies of preservation of such digital...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Historic Preservation And the Imagined West

...Historic Preservation and the Imagined West The cities of Denver, Seattle, and Albuquerque have found that recreating the past in a historical manner may suit the needs of the cities in more than one way. They have recreated their historic districts. Those are Pioneer Square in Seattle, Larimer Square in Denver, and Old town in Albuquerque. The book Historic Preservation and the Imagined West by Judy Morley reviews these districts and what their effect may really be on the local public as well as the tourist business that is created. There was much pain in the...
5 Pages(1250 words)Assignment

Imagined Communities

...of nationalism as the consequence of large historical forces. Particularly, the rise of nationalism to ideological dominance from this perspective is a consequence of a Hegelian process which is understood only in retrospect, the imagining of a community as a nation is not originally self-conscious. Anderson derives the historical origins of nationalism from the rise, decline, and fall of the dynastic empires, namely, Spain, England, Austria, Russia and the Ottoman Empire; and from the opposition of subject peoples, subordinate linguistic groups, and surviving non-European sovereignties. III. Many observers hail Anderson’s position on nationalism. For instance, Jonathan Culler...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Historic Preservation and the Imagined West

...Sur Historic Preservation and the Imagined West How many haven’t marveled at the success some communities have had at not only preserving but revitalizing what was their historic role in the Old West? Unfortunately, according to Dr. Judy Morley, in her book, Historic Preservation and the Imagined West, what many visitors to these sites often see and believe are the result historic preservation efforts are no more real than a Hollywood movie set. Further, what politicians and developers point to as “historic preservation” is often no more real than Frontierland purports to be at Disneyland. Despite this, politicians and developers take their bows and solicit still more money so they can continue their noble efforts. Why... -up call...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Historic Preservation and the Imagined West

...Historic Preservation and the Imagined West Judy Morley, of the book ‘Historic Preservation and the Imagined West’, looks at five preservationprojects in three different cities in the West. The complementary images include Larimer Square and Lower Downtown in Denver, Pike Place Market and Pioneer Square in Seattle and Old Town in Albuquerque. His idea was simple as he believed that the cities can keep the sense of who they are by preserving old buildings. They also do good business as they draw tourists and residents as they may like bricks and mortar history. Larimer...
5 Pages(1250 words)Term Paper

Meeting Held by the Historic Preservation Hearing Officer

...Meeting held by the Historic Preservation Hearing Officer On Tuesday, the 26th of February 2013, the Historic Preservation Hearing Officer held a meeting, which was open to all members of the public. The meeting was scheduled to start at 10:00 at the conference room, number 3B, which is at the 3rd floor of the Phoenix City Hall. During the meeting, the hall was full of attendees, some corporate and others public. The different groups represented included lawyers, the representatives of the area, concerned members of public, business operators and other stakeholders interested in the preservation role played in the city. The meeting started after the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Assignment

Land Preservation

...Land Preservation Affiliation: Response to Chelsea Mahnk I totally agree with your explanations about the issue of land preservation not being dominated by the government in all areas and aspects. The issue of land preservation should be taken to the local people to be handled. The reason many states are not strict on the issue of land preservation is because majority of its population resides in the cities and other urban centers and hence they have no land to conserve as majority of their land is taken up by urban planning departments and projects. Those with land preservation initiatives are those that have agriculture and which supports the state’s economic growth and hence they have incentives to preserve the land... . These are the...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Historic Preservations

... due: Historic Preservations Laurie, John. "Historic Preservation and Cluster Based Economic Development." John Laurie, 10 Dec. 2008.Web. 27 Oct. 2014. historic preservation slows down the rate of economic development in countries. The author argues whether historic preservation slows down economic development due to the amount of funds used to preserve the historic sites as opposed to new developments that can generate money. Research in the past years shows that historic preservation has been thought to bring hindrance in economic development. Recent studies however show that historic preservations do... not hinder economic development but instead can be a powerful economic tool through tourism, entertainment and environmental management (Laurie 38). The book summarizes on the positive impacts historic preservations can make to the economy and different approaches to enhancing the economy through historic preservations. This book can be a useful guide to states and nations that view historic preservations as a hindrance to the growth of their economy. The book was issued six...
3 Pages(750 words)Annotated Bibliography
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Historic Preservation and the Imagined West for FREE!

Contact Us