Designer Babies, Scientific and Ethical Considerations - Essay Example

There is an overview of the problem at hand, as any introduction should do before going into details. There is no "random collection of facts", but the examples are relevant and logically linked together.

The scientific considerations are concise and introduce briefly the reader to the methods used. The figures, although not strictly necessary, are there to support the text in a visually pleasing manner. Starting a sentence with a verb may not be common, but it isn't wrong either. However, the incriminated sentence could be re-worded as: "IVF is an assisted reproductive technology (ART) that involves..."

The ethical considerations didn't miss any major points but had to be shortened to fit the essay format. This paper isn't an exhaustive review on the topic, or it would have been far much longer.

The conclusion does make a clear summary of the various aspects of PGD and then broadens the scope once again to make the reader think about the topic once the paper has been read. This is an article about the philosophy of science and should encourage the readers to think for themselves after clearly exposing the problem.

In general, the language used is professional, without any slang, and the punctuation is indeed correct. The grammatical mistake highlighted by the reviewer is a misquote of the paper and should read: "Both techniques combined gave rise to..." All subsequent appreciation of the grammar should therefore be viewed with a critical eye, as there don’t seem to be any mistakes.

From the point highlighted above, it seems reasonable to affirm that the text doesn't need any major changes, except maybe for the sentence starting with a verb Read More