Summary to essay on topic "Honesty, Justice, Due Process, and Crime Control: An Ethical Dilemma"
In considering the ethical issues relevant to the ideas of honesty, justice, due process, and crime control, we are confronted by the radically divergent practicality of concepts that should be harmonious. It would be reasonable to expect, in a civilized society, that we can synthesize these elements without too much problem…
Download file "Honesty, Justice, Due Process, and Crime Control: An Ethical Dilemma" to see previous pages...
Justice is sometimes served by dishonest acts. Similarly, the safety afforded the accused by due process can circumvent crime control and send the message that the punishment for criminal behavior is often escapable through manipulation of the system. This negates the deterrent value of effective law enforcement and implies that if criminals are smart enough, Let us write or edit the essay on your topic "Honesty, Justice, Due Process, and Crime Control: An Ethical Dilemma" with a personal 20% discount.. Try it now they can use the constitutional protections within the criminal justice system to escape punishment. The four elements must be balanced with their attendant ethical issues into a system that delivers justice and crime control without compromising honesty or due process.
There is a difference between honesty and justice, and we will consider a hypothetical situation in which dishonesty can actually serve justice. Honesty is defined as "the characteristic of being fair, truthful, and morally upright" (Encarta, 2005, n.p.) Justice, in terms of its application to the legal system, is characterized by "fairness or reasonableness... [in] the act of applying or upholding the law" (Encarta, 2005, n.p.). Thus, in the definition of both words, we have the idea being fair. Ethically, this can provide a personal dilemma when the unfairness of an individual action results in accomplishing the fairness associated with the successful application of the law. For example, we can posit the example of an un-truthful act on the part of a law enforcement officer that results in the conviction of a guilty person. Let's say that a police investigator has spent months on the surveillance of a drug dealer. He or she knows that the individual is a drug trafficker as a result of watching their behavior over a long period of time. When the time comes for an arrest, the perpetrator has no drugs on his person or in his vehicle; so the officer plants a small amount of heroin in the individual's possession to bolster the evidence needed for the arrest and conviction. Clearly unethical, the officer's actions are neither fair nor morally upright under the strict definition of honesty. Yet, in terms of the service of justice, the guilty drug dealer is convicted and taken off the streets. This is an ethical problem faced by law enforcement daily. It is the application of honesty to justice and, for many in law enforcement, the ends justify the means. In other words, the technically dishonest act of the police investigator results in justice being served because the truly guilty perpetrator is convicted. Under ethical analysis, this is obviously wrong; yet, the inescapable conclusion is that justice has been served.
Due Process and Crime Control
The second set of considerations is related to due process and crime control. The idea of due process is to protect the rights of the accused and assure that there is no rush to judgment without the consideration of all the evidentiary factors in a case. This idea has led to many rules and procedures within the criminal justice system that protect the accused. One of the fundamental tenets of the system is that it is better for the guilty to go free than for the innocent to be punished. As Roger Cossack's article notes, "Blackstone said many years ago
...Download file "Honesty, Justice, Due Process, and Crime Control: An Ethical Dilemma" to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document "Honesty, Justice, Due Process, and Crime Control: An Ethical Dilemma"
(“Honesty, Justice, Due Process, and Crime Control: An Ethical Dilemma Essay”, n.d.)
Honesty, Justice, Due Process, and Crime Control: An Ethical Dilemma Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1523323-honesty-justice-due-process-and-crime-control-an-ethical-dilemma
(Honesty, Justice, Due Process, and Crime Control: An Ethical Dilemma Essay)
Honesty, Justice, Due Process, and Crime Control: An Ethical Dilemma Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1523323-honesty-justice-due-process-and-crime-control-an-ethical-dilemma.
“Honesty, Justice, Due Process, and Crime Control: An Ethical Dilemma Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1523323-honesty-justice-due-process-and-crime-control-an-ethical-dilemma.
Cited: 0 times
CHECK THESE SAMPLES - THEY ALSO FIT YOUR TOPIC "Honesty, Justice, Due Process, and Crime Control: An Ethical Dilemma"
In reality, police institution realizes the necessity to turn over each offender to the judicial confines for appropriate measures of prosecution upon arrest yet, with the acquisition of the suspected criminal, its own jurisdiction becomes frequently led to community-based functions which may either simplify or complicate the situation in conflict for the parties involved (Sykes, 1986).
The researcher states that ethical dilemma requires us to weigh our responsibilities, responsibilities to parents, children, our colleagues. The professional knowledge has a vital role in resolving an ethical dilemma. It is very important that we, as educators understand that the Code of Ethics is only useful if it is part of our every practice.
ince 1964, they have been termed as the major models that guide the operations of the criminal process and act as the ideologies that encompass criminal justice. The have both however been challenged by modern crimes such as pornography and modern rights such as women’s rights
'Justice' means the quality of conforming to principles of reasons, to generally accepted standards of right and wrong, and to the stated terms of laws, rules, agreements, etc in matters affecting persons who could be wronged or unduly favoured.
Justice in simple terms means giving everyone, whatever, should be legally his or hers.
The law is generally composed of the constitution and everything linked with its scope. (Pollock, 2007) When someone is breaking the law that means he or she is conducting a crime, and the person doing so is called a criminal. However, no one can just accuse someone of being a criminal.
Herbert Parker, a professor of law proposes two models to address the problem of crime: crime control model and due process model. Crime Control Model places the main emphasis on rights and freedom of society to receive
The method, according to which both the models work, has also been discussed in the paper. The consequences of both the theories on the general public and the criminals have also been illustrated.
The due process model
In such circumstances, the nursing staff may not be able to save the affected lives while respecting the autonomy of such patients. Such kind of conflict raises the ethical dilemma whether the important is to prefer saving a life or to follow the patient’s will. This
provided in the fifth amendment of the Federal government constitution stipulating that individuals shall not be “deprived of life, liberty, or property without the due process of the law.” In addition, Due Process Clause is provided in the Fourteenth Amendment providing
Ethical Dilemma [Author] [Institution] Introduction Professional ethics tend to exist in all the aspects in which social relationships are involved. In education, there are certain professional ethics that have to be followed by the teachers in class while teaching the whole class collectively.
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
GOT A TRICKY QUESTION? RECEIVE AN ANSWER FROM STUDENTS LIKE YOU!
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Honesty, Justice, Due Process, and Crime Control: An Ethical Dilemma"
with a personal 20% discount.