Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

Validity Of Claims Made In Weight Management Research by Aphramor - Article Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The research question of the article is ‘validating the claims made in weight management research’. Further review of past literature demonstrates that there are ethical implications to the weight centered approach’s effectiveness and its undesired outcomes. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.3% of users find it useful
Validity Of Claims Made In Weight Management Research by Aphramor
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Validity Of Claims Made In Weight Management Research by Aphramor"

Center for Disease Control’s epidemiological data reveals that mortality risk in severe obesity is not statistically significant and contradictive that obese people live longer than healthy people.
Healthy weight approaches are debated vigorously in scientific circles and there is a lack of representation in previous researches. Apart from that clinical practice accepted standards and ethics of publishing have given a sort of immunity to the subject of weight loss.

  Narrative literature reviews of journal articles are carried out that was published in The Journal of Human Nutrition and Diabetics from 2004 to 2008. Articles on diabetic research were chosen using a purposive sample technique, with weight loss as their main focus from 2004 to 2008 for analysis to assess the validity of the claims made in weight management research.

  The author from the analysis of the diabetic articles found that the research in weight management is dominated by the energy deficit approach even though it has a high rate of long term failure. The evidence from the available sources negates the claims of weight management programs expected success and the complexities and controversies in the supporting evidence are discussed insufficiently in the agenda of this current research.

The findings of the research from the review of diabetic articles focused on weight loss are that,
a. Without sufficient supporting references it is accepted that BMI> 25 is a health risk, indicates poor health and weight loss is an effective remedy for fitness.
b. Claim that Weight loss treatment provides overall health benefits are not specified and are unsubstantiated in those articles.
c. Blood lipids and blood pressure can be regulated through weight loss, the claim also cannot be validated because the article reviewed by the author itself concludes that lipids and lipoproteins changes by only dietary fat’s influence are not possible to identify.
d. Diabetes can be prevented by effective weight management cannot be ascertained from the review of diabetic literature.
e. Weight loss, dieting or energy deficit results in health improvement and fitness and are effective and reliable methods cannot be established because there is no scientific proof, that can be found in the literature, however, it was found that weight loss is not a means for achieving fitness but an end in itself. However from the diabetic articles reviewed it was found that these methods have long term adverse effects on health and fitness.

Article conclusion:
   The author concluded from the review of diabetic articles focused on weight loss that the claims made against the consequences of overweight and obesity and treatment are required to remain healthy are not supported by enough scientific evidence. The claims given for justifying the treatment for obesity that Weight loss is an effective remedy and results in improved health lacks sufficient evidence. Weight loss justification and the treatment do not meet the standards of evidence required for medicine. Also, the author found that there are no discussions on the ethical implications of such treatments, lack of research on alternative approaches centered on non-weight management encourages the regimes of ineffective treatment. The author towards the end of the article recommends an alternative approach such as HAES referring to ‘no-diet or size acceptance approach’ or in simple terms health at every size instead of weight management.

 Good points of the article:
  According to me the good points of the article were that the author laid down the research problem very specifically and dealt with it layer by layer so that it is easy for the reader to understand her point and the research. The purposive sample technique was appropriate for the research. The article was interesting and very in-depth research was carried out using sufficient and supportive evidence. The results arrived were well presented and discussions gave a good analysis and the research has good implications for further research and recommendation health at every size is outstanding.

 Poor points of the article:
Even though the research article had many good points, yet there were few poor points too. The research article lacked the heading conclusion, the author after ‘discussions’ heading, moved on to’ implications for research and practice’, even though it is given in the Abstract section. Due to lack of conclusion heading it makes a reader difficult to know the research conclusions and recommendations and he might get confused. Readers need to read through both discussion and implications section to arrive at a conclusion and what the author recommended. Also, it was a narrative review of diabetic literature, the author did not use any figures or tables which would have been good for raising the readers' interest otherwise article becomes boring and readers lose interest in the middle. Figures and tables are easy to grasp and makes an article more interesting. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(Validity Of Claims Made In Weight Management Research by Aphramor Article, n.d.)
Validity Of Claims Made In Weight Management Research by Aphramor Article. Retrieved from
(Validity Of Claims Made In Weight Management Research by Aphramor Article)
Validity Of Claims Made In Weight Management Research by Aphramor Article.
“Validity Of Claims Made In Weight Management Research by Aphramor Article”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Validity Of Claims Made In Weight Management Research by Aphramor

Total Quality Management of Bank Muscat

I am sincerely indebted to Mr. Majed Ambusaidy, the manager of quality department in Bank Muscat and his assistant, Yasser Al-Raisi, for helping me gather much information for my researching needs.
Any corporation values its customers for they believe that customers are as important as the human capital of the company. Usually, customers dictate the needs and requirements whilst the company develops and provides these needs. In case the customer is not satisfied with the outcome of the product or service rendered, negative implications set in against the enterprise. It may affect not only the customer per se, but it also subjects the entire organization’s reputation at risk. Not to mention the loss incurred as the custo...
72 Pages(18000 words)Case Study

Management Project of Happy Tots Child Care Centre

Scope, time and cost are the restrictions that are acting upon the project management progression. This constraint can also be connected with one of the knowledge areas of Project Management (Bass et al. 2003).
Project Management Plan: For effective project management, the basic step that should be taken is to collect the information that is necessary for developing the project plan and then make flowcharts for the plan (Kenneth, 1999).
Project Scope Management: takes account of the processes required to make certain that the project includes all the work required, and only the work required, to complete the project successfully (Bass et al. 2003).
The project is a database project that will involve the development...
7 Pages(1750 words)Lab Report

Business Management Framework in Educational Organizations

The organizational structure should be present to guarantee clear divisions of authority, responsibility, communication, and control. The second component is the generation of the organization situations for successful implementation such as culture, communications, reward and incentives systems, training, and control (Fonseca 2002).

Two basic theoretical paradigms to business management framework could be identified. The first puts considerable emphasis on structural frameworks to change and involves an issue with organizational design as well as the linkage between organization and environment. This point of view puts less importance upon human activity and the way individuals try to understand or make sense of the wo...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

Household Management by Isabella Beeton

The other virtues that should be adopted by her are: early rising, cleanliness, frugality and economy, choice of acquaintances, care in building friendship, hospitality, a careful conversation with friends, maintaining good temper, to follow fashion in terms of clothing; buying dresses or apparels within the means and status of one’s husband; charity and benevolence; bargaining while purchasing things; maintaining housekeeping account book; hiring competent and honest servants. A guide to the annual wages of domestic servants is also given by the author.
This shows that a woman is in command of all the expenses of her household, which she should spend with care. The bread earner in the Victorian Age was always a man: fa...
14 Pages(3500 words)Article

Difficulty in Operations and Service Management

The unique nature of every service makes the evaluation of quality extremely difficult. Let’s take the case of a doctor. The doctor might be thinking that when he is knowledgeable, is able to provide correct treatment to his patients, has the latest equipment and techniques and the required number of support staff, he is delivering good service. The patients, on the other hand, might be including the friendliness of the doctor and the support staff as well in the list of parameters to call the service as good. If they do not get this, the service quality provided is poor.
The parameters included calling the doctor's service as quality service may also differ from person to person. Some of the patients might be finding e...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment

Scientific Management and Human Relations Approach

For many years, a huge number of experts (Donnelly, pp. 24-33, 2008) have been trying to define the term management; however, analysis has indicated that management is itself a vast terminology that constitutes various aspects of an organization. For some, management is something that involves people. For some experts, management is an art that includes strokes that incline individuals to perform the required tasks in an efficient manner. Due to such a broad scope of management, until now, one can come across various management theories that propose different and diverse methodologies to manage people in an organization, such as classical theory, neo-classical theory, behavioral management theory, etc. As earlier mentioned, this p...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Marketing Research and Its Ethical Principles

Many ethical questions are attached to market research in today’s world. Many ethical violations are taking place to achieve various motives like minimizing research costs through lack of informed consent of participants, violation of rights of the respondents, use of unauthorized information, confidentiality violations, making false statements and promises, etc. this paper will specifically focus on ethical issues about the Rights of the Respondents of marketing research.
Deontology suggests that people should fully comply with their obligations and responsibilities when it comes to ethically analyzing any situation. These obligations and responsibilities of the analyst may be towards a particular person, a group or co...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Management Information System of Linux

As emphasized by GB direct (n.d.) “one of the principal reasons for the growth of open-source software is its affinity with this business model” (par. 8). The support applications specifically come in the form of “helpdesk advice and diagnostic research and direct intervention to diagnose and resolve problems” (GB direct, n.d., par. 24).

The helpdesk application of open source software “backs-up and extends in-house resources when they are approaching their limits” (GB direct, n.d., par. 26). Even unskilled staff or personnel without any technical knowledge of software applications are assisted by the program to back-up relevant files. This support mechanism of open-source software ca...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Understanding of Customer Relationship Management Strategies Pursued by Vodafone PLC

With the increased globalization and competition, it has become very difficult to maintain customer loyalty. The same has been experienced by UK mobile service providers. Customer retention is an acute problem for companies. It has been found that the lack of proper customer relationship management is mainly responsible for this global issue. Vodafone Group Plc, UK’s largest telecommunication company has been selected for undertaking the research to determine the root cause of this problem and to investigate other relevant reasons. A report of 2009 published by the company reveals that there are severe problems related to customer retention. It is well known that the mobile phone industry has boomed over the last eight years...
19 Pages(4750 words)Research Proposal

Training and Development from a Human Resource Management Perspective

The last section will discuss my personal recommendation with regard to specific changes in the use of HR theories and work-related practices. My overall experience during the internship training period was fun and challenging.

During the first week of the training period, I managed to develop useful research survey questionnaires and research aids which enabled me to gather information needed for the development of a training plan for the fitness instructors.

Designing an effective training instruction plan that will address the main concerns of the students is the most challenging part of the internship. Using the ADDIE model, I plan to design a training instruction material by integrating the research sur...
30 Pages(7500 words)Thesis
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Article on topic Validity Of Claims Made In Weight Management Research by Aphramor for FREE!

Contact Us