StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Surpassing the Passive Hero in Waverly by Sir Walter Scott - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The focus of this paper is on the work of Walter Scott. The works of Walter Scott had a profound effect upon the development of the novel as a form, particularly the historical novels. In total, he wrote twenty-seven of them, many of which were some of the most popular works of his time…
Download free paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.5% of users find it useful
Surpassing the Passive Hero in Waverly by Sir Walter Scott
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Surpassing the Passive Hero in Waverly by Sir Walter Scott"

Surpassing the Passive Hero in Waverly by Sir Walter Scott The works of Walter Scott had a profound effect upon the development of the novel as aform, particularly the historical novels. In total he wrote twenty-seven of them, many of which were some of the most popular works of his time. The passage of time has led to many of his ideas seeming to become rather dated and perhaps obsolete, especially regarding the various manifestations of the "hero" that he creates in his novels. In his discussion of the Waverly Novels, Welsh suggests that most of Scott's characters are enduringly passive, rather unsuited for the heroic action that they indulge in. This analysis will suggest that there is more to the heroes within Waverly and its offspring than Welsh gives credit for. Essentially Welsh seems to attempt to debunk the idea that Scott was even a good novelist, let alone a great romantic novelist, within his books. Welsh admits that Waverly is the prototype for the modern novel, but then goes on to argue the various weaknesses within Scott's technique. He suggests that Scott is not a realist, as he seems incapable of drawing a realistic portrayal of life. Neither is he capable of any type of analysis according to Welsh; he argues succinctly that "Scott never criticizes his own society" (Welsh, 1963). Also, Scott is not a very good romantic writer either as he has no full knowledge of the human heart and his characters are "notoriously unemotional" (Welsh, 1963). By way of proving this, Welsh suggests that Waverly's only emotional moment in his very brief attachment to Flora. Further, the hero in Waverly is hardly the stuff of the traditional historical romance. Welsh points out, with a none-too-subtle irony that: . . . . the hero is obviously much more at home as a peacemaker than as a warrior, and it is amusing to watch Waverly racing ahead over the battlefield in order to rescue Hanoverian officers, and then being commended for his distinguished service by the chevalier. (Welsh, 1963) According to Welsh, the hero of Waverly is irredeemably passive and thus incapable of realistically portraying action and an active role within society. The hoer is caught within an intensely moralistic society which essentially stifles him. A true hero, according to Welsh, at least within the modern period, is a man for whom "masculinity meant self-control under the most trying circumstances" (Welsh, 1963). These characteristics he sees more within the insular, inward-looking Talbot rather than in the antics of Fergus rushing around Scotland performing traditionally "heroic" deeds. Part of this passivity, according to Welsh, stems from the fact that Scott's novels often revolve around the relationship between the individual and the state. In Waverly the hero adopts a positively Twentieth Century stance as he paradoxically invites and then resists his own arrest. He is contradictory if incredibly passive, at least in a traditionally "heroic" sense. But does this need to be an "either/or" question or can it be "both/and" Can the hero of Waverly exhibit passivity at one point and action at another and still be believable It would seem that the answer to this is a categorical "yes". Real human beings do not act according to a formulaic design for their character. He is not either a "passive character" or a "hero". He can be passive and active according to the moment. A simple glance at what actually occurs in Waverly belies the simple dichotomies that Welsh sets up in his attempted criticism of the novel. The opening of the novel starts with Waverly taking very real action, both in terms of his physical movements and in his decision making. Waverly is brought up in the family home of his Uncle, near London, but is soon given a commission in the Hanoverian army and is posted to Dundee, in Scotland. If he were purely passive he would not have taken up this commission in the first place. As soon as he arrives in Dundee, Waverly decides to take leave in order to meet the Jacobite friend of his Uncle, Baron Bradwardine, where he meets the beautiful daughter, Rose. This simple plot-line would appear to be the stuff of the traditional historical romance that is now so well known. True, Waverly is not particularly emotional or apparently attached to what he is doing in these various movements and decisions. But neither is he entirely passive, as Welsh would suggest. The mere fact that Waverly does not wear his heart on his sleeve does not necessarily make him totally removed from what is occurring to him. Waverly takes another active decision - both physically and mentally - when he decides to go and see the home life of the rather barbaric Highlanders that visit the Baron's castle. Waverly has thus taken a very long leave from his army duties and is, perhaps predictably, accused of desertion. Again, Scott implies that he must have at least guessed that this would be the probable interpretation of his actions. While Waverly does allow himself to be captured by the Army and then rescued by the Highlanders, he is not merely a passive object being taken from one place to another. He is very much a symbol of something, which is at least part of the reason that the Army and the Highlanders take such an interest in what is, after all, the fate of just one man within a whole war. In a very "modern" manner, Waverly is persuaded to go over to the Jacobite side not for any particular ideological reasons, but because Flora, the Highland Chief's sister, persuades him to. He is caught up with the emotion of the event, rather than any particular rational consideration. In a purely realistic sense, the Hanoverian army has not exactly treated him very fairly or particularly well: it makes sense for Waverly to switch sides. So is are his heroic actions at the Battle of Prestonpans, at the climax of the novel, particularly out of character and thus, as Welsh seems to argue, rather laughable in nature The answer is no. True, Waverly does not gleefully join every fight that is offered to him, but this must be seen as realistic rather than flawed. Soldiers who survive pick their battles carefully, as well as their individual fights. Waverly is merely on e of a type, rather than an irredeemably passive hero. At the end of the novel he chooses to marry the practical, better "wife material" character of Rose rather than the romantic, but far less predictable Flora. Some have suggested that this illustrates a very unheroic action on the part of Waverly, but it can also be argued that this is Scott once again being realistic. Rose would not be a better match for every soldier or hero, but she is the best match for this particular soldier. A formulaic writer would have made Waverly marry Flora, but Scott was far from formulaic. To conclude, while it is true that many of the concerns that are expressed in Waverly are quaint or even irrelevant to modern sensibilities, this does not make the hero necessarily "passive". He does act decisively during the course of the novel, even though he is not always "heroic" in the most traditional sense of the word. ________________________________ Works Cited Welsh, Alexander. The Hero of the Waverly Novels. Princeton University Press, New York: 1963. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Surpassing the Passive Hero in Waverly by Sir Walter Scott Essay, n.d.)
Surpassing the Passive Hero in Waverly by Sir Walter Scott Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1503660-surpassing-the-passive-hero-in-waverly-by-sir-walter-scott
(Surpassing the Passive Hero in Waverly by Sir Walter Scott Essay)
Surpassing the Passive Hero in Waverly by Sir Walter Scott Essay. https://studentshare.org/literature/1503660-surpassing-the-passive-hero-in-waverly-by-sir-walter-scott.
“Surpassing the Passive Hero in Waverly by Sir Walter Scott Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1503660-surpassing-the-passive-hero-in-waverly-by-sir-walter-scott.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Surpassing the Passive Hero in Waverly by Sir Walter Scott

Passive cooling and ventillation

The construction engineers require having insight on the site's climate and whether patterns to successfully employ the passive cooling techniques.... Name: Task: Instructor: Date: passive Cooling and Ventilation Houses protect people from harsh environmental climate whether at home or at work.... The historical design patterns alternatively relied on natural systems of internal environment control, known as passive cooling and ventilation....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Analysis of Phoenix Mars Mission

First & Last Name: Semester: Email Address: SID #: Section (e.... .... TR 11):   HW3 HW4 FINAL Requirements Approved Topic   Cover page   Title Title Abstract   Detailed Outline T.... .... .... T.... ....   Proposal (500 words ~1 pg.... Full paper (3000 words ~10 pg.... Full paper (3000 words ~10 pg....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

The Poem Patriotism by Sir Walter Scott

The author of the paper will begin with the statement that sir walter scott's poem begins with the description of a man who has a deal soul and the reason given for the death of the soul is that man has never taken pride in the native land that he belongs to.... While patriotism may be a dangerous emotion for some, individuals such as sir walter scott would make it the first criteria for having a soul or for being a good person.... Perhaps that is the idea that scott was trying to give and if that is the case then the poem certainly succeeded in passing that idea....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Dred Scott

Dred scott is one such black African slave who fought a war against the legal and social system of nineteenth century America to get his freedom.... Dred scott was another such slave born in the year 1799 in Virginia and was owned by the family of a white southern named Peter Blow.... Here there is some confusion as to who the real Dred scott was.... The name of this slave was Dred scott....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Walter dill Scott's Productivity in the Workplace

This article insists that if an organization wants to solve its issues and analyze its concern, then it has to follow the work and ideologies of walter scott mentioned above or those discussed in his book “Theory of Advertising.... rdquo; According to me, the ideas of walter scott discussed in the article and which are suggested to be necessary for analyzing the issues in the workplace can work if the organization's management implements them.... nbsp; … Walter Dill scott was a professor and one of the first scholars of industrial psychology after he got an education in Germany....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Passive ventilation

passive solar architecture: heating, cooling, ventilation, daylighting, and more using natural flows.... They are usually connected via vertical ducts to the roof terminals.... Warm and moist air is drawn up these duct by the combination of the wind and stack… Dry air is then drawn into the system via background ventilators that are located in habitable rooms....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Zero Carbon Homes: Heat Pumps

This work called "Zero Carbon Homes: Heat Pumps" demonstrates the human impact on the environment.... The author outlines climate change and energy management, residential thermal energy consumption, residential heat pumps.... nbsp;Residential units consume a massive amount of energy....
11 Pages (2750 words) Coursework

Passive Ventilation

the passive cooling entails the entire natural techniques and processes of heat modulation and dissipation without using energy.... the passive ventilation/cooling can be broadly classified into heat dissipation or modulation techniques and preventive techniques.... the passive ventilation system is maintenance-free and consequently economical thus another advantage over methods of ventilation.... This work called "passive Ventilation" describes a building design approach that aims at heat dissipation and heat gain control in a building....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us