Nobody downloaded yet

The Iliad: Achilles in contrast to Hector - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Clients Name Name of Professor Name of Class Date Achilles in contrast to Hector: Homer’s Creation of Sympathy for the Tragic Hero The tragic hero is a figure that is seen at the core of many of the ancient writings that still exist in the current era. The Illiad by Homer is an example of the tragic hero where the protagonists of the story are flawed and their end is the result of those flaws…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.3% of users find it useful
The Iliad: Achilles in contrast to Hector
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample
"The Iliad: Achilles in contrast to Hector"

Download file to see previous pages In examining the characteristics of both Achilles and Hector, the nature of the tragic hero is revealed for both flaws and skills, while not quite meeting the sympathetic characterizations developed by Aristotle. The tragic hero, as it has been recorded through written history, was extensively explored by both Aristotle and Homer. Homer’s sense of the tragic hero is a “sense of morality and fate” which act as the rudimentary qualities. Both Hector and Achilles carry these traits (Mishra 6). Mishra states that “According to Aristotle a tragic hero is a person of exalted position who, on account of some error or flaw, suffers a total reversal of fortune, arousing a feeling of pity or fear” (1). Hector fits into this framework because he commits an error of hubris. His pride leads into battle against Achilles and his arrogance puts his sword into the position to take the kill, destroying the life of the companion of Achilles, Patrocles, rather than Achilles. As his pride leads him to believe that he is strong enough to take the life of Achilles, he erroneously takes the life of someone far inferior to the great warrior and to himself. According to Nussbaum, the tragic hero in the eyes of Aristotle elicits empathy from the reader as the fall of the hero can be related to the tragic ends that occur in daily life. The evocation of the emotions of the reader is created because the hero is good and the audience feels for the injustice of his fall within the work (386). The concept of hubris then comes into play as the tragic hero must not believe in their essential goodness and invulnerability too much as this would be a sign of too much of the wrong kind of pride. This kind of arrogant pride, the belief that one is invulnerable, would be a source of hubris which is a great sin to the Greeks (Nussbaum 387). Therefore he must be less than perfect, yet desire to reach perfection through the righteousness and goodness of his actions. Achilles and Hector do not fully fall into the ranks of the tragic hero as described by Aristotle as Achilles believes himself invulnerable because of the protections put on him by his mother and Hector acts on his belief of his own skills where they are too superior to his opponent, even if unbeknownst to himself. The characterizations created by Homer were well developed and informed the reader of the type of individual character they were reading about which also had a sense of morality that gave applications of meaning to the text as the story was revealed. The characters were distinct, which is one of the reasons that Homer is considered “the first great genius of the Western literary tradition” (Cunningham and Reich 36). It is likely that the Iliad, along with his other most known work the Odyssey, were written from a long history of oral traditions that had passed the stories down to Homer. One of the more brilliant aspects of the poem is the way in which military movement and strategy was made accessible to the average reader by comparing elements of the military to every day concepts. One of these brilliant usages of metaphor and simile can be seen when the “massing of the Greek forces…is likened to a swarm of flies buzzing around pails of milk” ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Iliad: Achilles in contrast to Hector Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1435918-in-the-story-the-iliad-compare-and-contrast
(The Iliad: Achilles in Contrast to Hector Essay)
https://studentshare.org/literature/1435918-in-the-story-the-iliad-compare-and-contrast.
“The Iliad: Achilles in Contrast to Hector Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1435918-in-the-story-the-iliad-compare-and-contrast.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
CHECK THESE SAMPLES - THEY ALSO FIT YOUR TOPIC
The Iliad
...relationships. It may relate to father-son but it may also be an ‘older-younger man’ connection. Homer clearly sees the rule of the father as a desirable situation, but this dominance is not always benign, as evidenced even among the Gods in the relationship between Zeus and Hephaestus (I. 571 pp). Within the Iliad, all men are subject to the laws patriarchy, with the kings enjoying father-son relationships with Gods. Thus ‘Zeus is hard: who before this time promised me and consented…’ that Agamemnon might sack Ilion. Now he is punished ‘in dishonor having lost so many people’ (IX. 19pp). Like a father, Zeus offers or withholds approval. Here we have the example of the stern, exacting father but when Priam morns...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment
Achilles in Homer's Iliad or Socrates in Plato's Apology
...of Lecturer 8th of May, Achilles in Homer's Iliad or Socrates in Plato's Apology Although aesthetics is a major part of literature, it is not all that there is to literature. When one reads a literary piece, one also gets a chance to have a glimpse into what happened at a time in history, particularly the time the literary piece was composed. In essence, Homer's Iliad or Plato's Apology are literary works which reveal to the contemporary reader some of things that happened during the classic age. This is particularly so as this texts have realism strongly embedded in them. By writing about people that existed in their age, the authors of these two works – Homer and Plato respectively –...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
The traits of Hector and Achilles
...at the hands of the Trojans and Hector. His hate towards the king seems to have surmounted into an inalienable belief of his rightfulness, so much so that he purports to be guided by Zeus himself: “I don't need that kind of honor, Phoenix. My honor comes from Zeus” (Book 9. 624), suggesting in very simple terms that his position is right and nothing else, “Hate him because I hate him. It's as simple as that.” (Book 9. 632). This hate no doubt is disproportional to the original wrong Agamemnon committed, as Sale points out in his analysis of the Iliad (87), but it does satisfy the code of the warrior with regards to a warrior’s conviction. His resolve is shattered by the death of Patroclus,...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
The Character of Achilles in the Iliad
...that the hero sometimes displays the features that characterize his personality from the positive side, is based on the character’s final preoccupation with wrath. Just as The Iliad starts with the lines that describe the fury of Achilles, in the end Achilles is similarly fraught with wrath. It seems that this wrath lives in him and just seeks the way to express itself. For example, at the beginning of the poem, this feeling of fury and annoyance is directed against the King of the Myrmidons Agamenon, while later, as the story unfolds, it is directed against the son of Priam Hector who is known to have killed Patroclus. It is the death of his faithful friend that makes...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
Discuss the character of Achilles in Homer's Iliad
...to be written of as having questioned the purpose of his life and the reason behind his actions, yet an individual is a rational being. This was during Achilles’ moment of existential crises. This takes place around 1200 BC, a time when no other individual in Western literature had been depicted as having encountered and addressed existential crises. In the same wavelength, while there are other ancient narratives in Western literature such as Ovid, Achilles is the first one to have encountered the problem of existential crises and thereby allowing this encounter to change the course of events in the Iliad. Readers’ Response to Achilles’ Behavior (Hector...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
In the final analysis, Hector is a greater man than Achilles. Discuss
...that Achilles lacks compassion and kindness. What makes Hector a better man is the fact that he seems more human than Achilles. His death in Book 22 is followed by descriptions of his family grieving, which that shows he has more people to love and care for and vice versa. In contrast, Achilles only has his mother, the sea goddess Thetis who comes to his aid and builds on his demi-god like qualities (Mishra, pg.4). He has no other family mentioned in The Iliad. Hector has human qualities such as fear e.g. when Achilles is coming towards him near the walls of Troy, Hector “starts to...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
Homers Achilles
... ic characters that resemble Homer's Achilles. Homer's Achilles was a great hero. When he was born as a mortal, his mother, Thetis, dipped him into the special waters of the river Styx. She did this to make him immortal. Thetis held Achilles by his heel and forgot to wet this heel and this became his weak spot. Achilles was invulnerable except for his unprotected heel. He was a brave warrior whose angry emotions helped him on the battlefields. Homer's Iliad has its first two lines describes Achilles' great anger which propelled him to wreck destruction upon his enemies; 'Sing, goddess, the anger of Peleus' son Achilleus and its devastation, which put pains thousandfold upon the Achians,.......' (Lattimore 59). Archilles' anger... body on...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Compare and contrast Romeo with Hector
...Number] Compare and Contrast Romeo with Hector Homer and Shakespeare are from entirely different times, as are the characters they have written about, Troy’s Hector and Juliet’s Romeo. Both the heroes of their centuries, Hector depicts an entirely different male character, while Romeo is mirroring the complex driven passionate lover who is fighting against fate. Hector is the ultimate epitome of a good son, a good father and a good husband. He is peaceful, considerate and thoughtful and would have been next in line to the throne had it not been for his unfortunate position in defending his land against a war his own brother had started. History has...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
The Iliad
...The Iliad Achilles vs. Hector Despite both of them being the heroic figures of their respective sides-Greek and Trojan armies,Achilles and hector have several differences. It is easy for the pride and glory that both of them possess to hide the differences but keen look into their character. In the Iliad, many characters display heroism yet when it comes down to scrutiny of their characters, their human sides, strengths and weakness set the criteria for distinguishing between two or more heroic character. The same applies for Achilles and hector. From the proceedings of the story, hector is portrayed as the most sympathetic character. The fact that he has a family and fights against the odds impacts the feeling of sympathy... murders...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Compare Achilles and Odysseus based in The Iliad
...Comparison of Achilles and Odysseus based on the Iliad The Iliad works bring about a good story where two of the characters in the poems are analyzed in this essay. The essay provides the comparison and contrast of Achilles who is a son to a goddess and Odysseus who is a smart warrior, in terms of their traits. Most of Achilles’s character can be understood well from their origin. Zeus, who is the king of gods, many years before the beginning of the Trojan War, developed a crush on the sea goddess called Thetis. He then came to learn of a prophecy, which had it that Thetis will bear a son who shall be more powerful than his father. This...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Let us find you another Essay on topic The Iliad: Achilles in contrast to Hector for FREE!
Contact Us