StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Columbus, Smith, and the Beginnings of American Identity - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
In the writings of Christopher Columbus and in the later writings of John Smith one can begin to see an American identity gradually being formed. Obviously, before America became a country unto itself, we can also see how the New World was still subservient to European laws and traditions…
Download free paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.3% of users find it useful
Columbus, Smith, and the Beginnings of American Identity
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Columbus, Smith, and the Beginnings of American Identity"

?Columbus, Smith, and the Beginnings of American Identity In the writings of Christopher Columbus and in the later writings of John Smith one can begin to see an American identity gradually being formed. Obviously, before America became a country unto itself, we can also see how the New World was still subservient to European laws and traditions. Both Columbus and Smith generally viewed their undertakings as being for the glory of England and Spain respectively. In this sense, they were merely servants to the wishes of their rulers. But we can also see that both men undertook their voyages for personal reasons as well. Religion also played a very significant role in shaping early American identity. One of the main goals of both voyages was to convert the heathen nations to Christianity. Also, economics and industry was very important as well and another major reason that Columbus and Smith were supported and sustained by their home countries. This essay will describe how these four things: a pioneering spirit, religion, individualism, and industry are major themes in the writings of both Columbus and Smith as well as show the cultural implications of their narratives and how they may have influenced American identity. From reading Columbus’ “Letter to King Ferdinand of Spain Describing the First Voyage,” we get the sense that Columbus had a pioneering and adventurous spirit. This attribute is comparable to many of America’s pioneers who traveled west; taking up their roots and moving to a relatively unknown and untamed land. One might say that many Americans felt the same way Columbus did and sort of followed in his footsteps. So perhaps Columbus and others like him were responsible for shaping this part of American identity which has characterized American culture. Similarly, from John Smith’s “A General Historie of Virginia,” we can see his pioneering and adventurous attitude as well. Additionally, we get an idea of Smith’s perseverance in the face of hardships. He and his fellow settlers faced starvation, war, dissention, and disease, yet he persisted in staying there and making the colony productive. This persistence in the face of hardships also characterizes American identity and further describes what it means to have a pioneering spirit. Another thing that has greatly influenced American identity is Christianity. From the way they write about Christianity, both Columbus and Smith appear to be devoutly religious. They almost see themselves as missionaries who have a duty to bring Christianity to the heathen nations. Columbus writes that he gave the natives gifts in order “that they might conceive affection for us and, more than that, might become Christians and be inclined to the love and services of Your Highnesses” (2). Spain was, of course, a Catholic nation at this time. In his letter, Columbus shows that he is doing this for God and for his country. So we can see his nationalistic pride as well as devotion to his country’s religious beliefs. America itself was founded on religious (predominantly Christian) beliefs, so one can see how the religion of the first Europeans influenced American values and religion. Converting “savages” to Christianity is a dominant goal for Smith as well. He writes, “The gaining Provinces addeth to the King’s Crown: but the reducing Heathen people to civility and true Religion bringeth honour to the King of Heaven” (4). Again we see the great extent to which religion is connected to the home country and how when both men speak about their countries their religious sentiments usually follow immediately. Both Spain and England were basically inseparable with the Christian religion at this time. In Columbus letter, we can see how his mission is undertaken in service to God and the King of Spain. His voyage would not have been possible without the financial support of the King and Queen; therefore he is indebted to them to do as they wish. Yet we can also see a passion for his individualism and the pride that comes with accomplishing something on his own in the letter. It is entirely possible that Columbus undertook his voyage not only for his country and his religion, but to achieve fame as well. He may have relished the task because of the fame and riches it would bring him. The concept of going out on your own and forging your own path is also an individualist proposition. Basically, the voyage benefited both Columbus personally as well as Spain, and this is why the voyage was commissioned. The individualism that Columbus possessed is also a big part of American culture. We can also see that Smith’s writings show him to be individualistic as well. Although he is a servant to both the King and the business which is financing him, he occasionally disagrees with these entities and doesn’t follow their orders explicitly. His account of one such instance is as follows: “The Salvages being acquainted, that by command from England we durst not hurt them, were much imboldned; that famine and their insolencies did force me to breake our Commission and instructions” (90). Note that Smith did not ask for permission to do this but went ahead and did it. This shows that he has some degree of leniency and possesses the individualistic attitude of leadership in willing to disobey orders in order to do what he thinks is right. Another dominant theme in both of these writings is the concept of economics and industry. This was another reason that both voyages were undertaken. Both countries were interested in discovering precious metals and other resources and also expanding their economic bases. Columbus writes about the immensity of Gold and other precious metals and the benefit this will bring to Spain. He also speaks of other things that will increase trade and add to the Spanish economy. Similarly, Smith writes of the benefit that the New World will have on England’s shipping and fishing industries. He doesn’t place an emphasis on Gold and deplores those who search for it in the New World because he feels like they are wasting their time searching for something that probably isn’t there. Instead, he focuses on making a strong and sustainable community. Of course, economics and industry of the utmost importance to Americans as well. To conclude, we can see how Columbus and Smith’s views of the New World are fairly closely aligned with American culture and identity. They are commissioned by their respective voyages by their homelands but you also get a sense of their desire to be separate and be on their own. However, there is no doubt that European ideals influenced the culture of the New World. After all, America was established mainly by transplanted Europeans and the ideals they brought from their homelands. One can see how these writings may have influenced those who lived in both Spain and England at the time and perhaps certain people identified with their views of the New World and therefore desired to settle there and be a part of something aligned with European ideals but also be separate from them. In regards to understanding these narratives within this context, we can see how they fit in with the literary American tradition and are a precedent and influence to later American events and American literature as well. Additionally, we can see the desires that Columbus and Smith had for the New World and how they are trying to achieve the vision they have for a specific cultural identity. Works Cited Columbus, Christopher. Letter to King Ferdinand of Spain Describing the First Voyage. 1493. Web. 13 July 2011. Smith, John. The Generall Historie of Virginia, New-England, and the Summer Isles. 1580-1631. Web. 13 July 2011. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Columbus, Smith, and the Beginnings of American Identity Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1428034-comparison-of-christopher-columbus-and-john
(Columbus, Smith, and the Beginnings of American Identity Essay)
https://studentshare.org/literature/1428034-comparison-of-christopher-columbus-and-john.
“Columbus, Smith, and the Beginnings of American Identity Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1428034-comparison-of-christopher-columbus-and-john.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Columbus, Smith, and the Beginnings of American Identity

Having Our Say: The Delaney Sisters First One Hundred Years

This essay explores the contents as well as the representations presented in the book in the form of life history of the Delaney Sisters.... Life History is usually autobiographical, but since most interesting lives touch on various subjects with varying talents, some or most of these lives involve a non-writer....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Analysis of Piagets Theory

Further, similarities and differences will be identified between Erikson's theory and Piaget's theory of child development, with respect to the development of identity.... Jean Piaget (1896-1987), the renowned Swiss developmental psychologist was the first to formulate and establish a theory of children's cognitive development....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Analysis of Poems Assembled with Natural and Elemental References by Emily Dickson

In choosing the following 12 poems centrifugal to elemental and organic imagery, it is hoped that a distinct connection between each of these works can be drawn without depriving them of the author's original meaning.... References to nature and the pieces of the earth which… Choosing poems which are richly assembled with natural and elemental references will together, form a pattern of continuity even in varying authors. The first poem chosen for This piece is fundamentally significant and is named first as it is written in such a way that it capably yet briefly discusses virtually any and all things relevant to life on this earth....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The representation of self in the work of Sylvia Plath

In her very first journal entry, written when she was seventeen, she already shows a sense of her own identity as an invented character: “I think I would like to call myself ‘The girl who wanted to be God'”.... ?? In her Ariel poems which she wrote in 1962, the crevice in her personal life claimed a revision of her self-identity in and through her poems....
27 Pages (6750 words) Essay

New look on Globalization

It is through globalization that we have moved from the ancient world to the modern world.... The fact of changing world and daily development is maintained.... Experts are coming up with innovations to make the work of the human beings easier.... … The coming generation may be having a more advanced economy with a different culture as compared to the current generations....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The U.S Occupation of Japan (1945-1952)

The essay "The U.... .... Occupation of Japan (1945-1952)" focus on the process, objectives and the significance of the occupation process of Japan by the United States.... he essay has two components: the domestic and foreign policies in Japan during the occupation process, and the conclusion.... … Occupation of Japan by the United States was a clear indication of the transformation between the two nations....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

The Basis of a Form of Contractual and Uncontractual Labour: Traditional Slavery

smith notes that some of the Irish were shipped to the new colonies and weren't welcomed by the previous settlers, who were inhospitable, and the ships' captains would often have to return these indentured servants back to England (smith, 1999).... This essay will look at slavery and its differences with indentured servitude....
13 Pages (3250 words) Research Paper

Creating America

In this context, a highly significant fact is that majority of them have fully comprehended the Essence of american Heritage and History.... nbsp; This is an identity that is far superior to the one they used to hitherto have, as denizens of a nondescript region.... This position of enhanced superiority is attributable to the fact that their new identity is the new nationality, which would steadily be recognized in the international landscape....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us