StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Film First Before Book - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The paper is about the different impressions from the film and the book. A book is always more complete and accurate since the author is more at liberty to include even the smallest detail possible. Based on personal experience, a film is hard to appreciate when one was able to read the book first, unless the viewer is more into the cinematic aspect of the story…
Download free paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.2% of users find it useful
Film First Before Book
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Film First Before Book"

Film First Before Book A book is always more complete and accurate, since the is more at liberty to include even the smallest detail possible. Based on personal experience, a film is hard to appreciate when one was able to read the book first, unless the viewer is more into the cinematic aspect of the story (Walter 140). Anyone who has read the book and seen the movie “Harry Potter” would be able to attest that there are parts of the book that were not included in the film anymore. This can easily be defended though, because a film or movie lasts only up to 2 hours, while a book can be of any number of pages. This comparison between a book and a film is applicable to the film “Cabeza de Vaca” and the book “Chronicle of the Narvaez Expedition” (Walter 140). “Cabeza de Vaca” is a film regarding an epic subject Alvar Nunez Cabeza de Vaca. For those who already know the history of this Spanish explorer, this film is effective in parts where it portrays a detached observation of people and events. However, there is obvious confusion regarding place, time, and script continuity. For example, the Pacific coast of Mexico seems to be so near Texas, and there are mountains on what is supposed to be the coast of Florida. Compared to the book, it is much less educational of specific events and times. For example, throughout the entire film, de Vaca remains a mysterious and cold figure because it was unable to portray his state of mind besides showing de Vaca’s dreams in a typically movie fashion (Stavans, Augenbraum, and Norton 312). The text “Chronicle of the Narvaez Expedition”, on the other hand, explicitly details his life experiences in the foreign place, and even though some critics say that the famous European ethnocentrism can be traced in de Vaca’s writing, he is able to relay to the readers the important details of the expedition. Through his writings, the readers are exposed to the expedition’s purpose of gaining power, to its failure, to de Vaca’s survival, to his alternate motives for discovering the place. De Vaca’s writing style makes one view the voyage as an anthropological research, giving detailed information as much as possible (Stavans, et al 312). The film also failed to highlight the slight slips of personal contradicting insights that are injected in de Vaca’s writings. This could have been a good way to give the character a complex personality that could have made him more compelling than tedious. For example, in his text, de Vaca objectively talks about a custom of the Native American: “they bury the dead except those who are medicine men” (Nu?n?ez 38). Then a few pages after, de Vaca notes “they drive the diseases away with their breath and their hands and we laughed and took it as a joke” (Nu?n?ez 40). This could have been a good way to emphasize how the Spanish explorer is torn between being critical and amazed by the new world he sees. Although there are parts of the film that tried to capture the greatness of this anti-imperialistic epic and the wonder and terror that the Spanish explorers experienced in this new land, one could still feel it lacking in narrative and adequate information. This may not hold true to every film or movie made because great editing skills could have produced a more educational plot, but one has to understand that films are produced mainly for entertainment purposes and being informative comes only second to this purpose. Watching the film can make a viewer interested in the details of this piece of history, and encourage the individual to read the book. However, reading the text prior to viewing the film can make one more critical of huge gaps in the story. Since no two-hour film can capture the great details a book can give, it is always a good decision to watch the film first before reading the book. Works Cited Echeverria, Nichola, and Cabeza V. A. Nu?n?ez. Cabeza De Vaca. , 1991. Nu?n?ez, Cabeza V. A. The Shipwrecked Men. London: Penguin, 2007. Print. Stavans, Ilan, Harold Augenbraum, and Marcy Norton. "Reviews - Alvar Nunez Cabeza De Vaca: Chronicle of the Narvaez Expedition." Itinerario. 27.3 (2003): 312. Print. Walter, Krista. "Filming the Conquest: Cabeza De Vaca and the Spectacle of History." Literature Film Quarterly. 30.2 (2002): 140. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Film First Before Book Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1409979-film-first-before-book
(Film First Before Book Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/literature/1409979-film-first-before-book.
“Film First Before Book Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1409979-film-first-before-book.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Film First Before Book

Analysis of The Bookseller of Kabul Book by Asne Seierstad

Most individuals and families construct public impressions of themselves somewhat different from reality: they have privacy rights to do so. All people have habits which they practice only when they are conscious that they are entirely unobserved. It is unethical by most standards to publish for profit, information gained by surreptitious means.

Human rights are violated on grounds of sex, skin color, ethnicity, age, economic status, beliefs, and nationality. Every attempt to correct such uncivilized discrimination is worthy of support, which gives the work under review undeniable value. Since free world access to Afghanistan is so restricted, we must assume that the book under review is entirely representative of conte...
11 Pages(2750 words)Book Report/Review

Book Proposal: Visions in Conflict

Because there is no end to the justification for violence, we are participating in a movement for dialogue by bringing together counselors, psychologists and other experts from different traditions (American, African, Christian, Jewish, Muslim, etc.) to address conflict resolution.  

“Visions in Conflict” has a threefold purpose. The first of these is to express much of the good work being done in the field of conflict resolution and peacebuilding around the world. This is especially relevant in the areas of acknowledgment and understanding of the “other” (including interfaith dialogue); communication through conflict and forgiveness. Second, this compilation aims to open up the field in ord...
8 Pages(2000 words)Book Report/Review

Putins Foreign Policy Changes during His First Presidential Term

Our world, since its ‘origination’ has been a ‘hotbed’ of activity. Activity in the sense, we humans have been showing activeness both mentally and physically, which have transformed our globe from a primitive one to an advanced one. The activities are normally carried out by humans, organizing or segregating themselves into different countries or nations. It is common knowledge that for a country to reach the top echelons, its leader has to be very capable and strong. That is, a capable and strong leader will only be able to provide a better life and future for his/her country and its citizens. From time immemorial, the success or failure of a country depends on the role, the leader plays. The leader is th...
82 Pages(20500 words)Dissertation

Analysis of Isaiah 61:1-11 Book

The focus of this exposition is the book of Isaiah chapter 61: 1-11.  The King James Version of the Bible is used as well as the Judaica Press Complete Tanach Yeshayahu Chapter 61.  The Jewish Publication Society Tanach (1917) is also used.  Lastly, Rashi’s commentary is referred to as well.  It is worthy of mention that both the Jewish and Christian perspectives are explored here and that, in the true essence of research, one is not favored over the other.  Isaiah Ben Amoz was considered a prophet in his time. He was known to predict the deliverance of Jerusalem from the Assyrians. Jerusalem was freed from the control of the Assyrians in 701 B.C. which added to his credibility as a prophet. The whol...
13 Pages(3250 words)Research Proposal

The Purpose of Speech in the Book of Chuang Tzu

We are not able to see the world in its entirety and get separated from Tao, unable to find the way. This position is explained in Chapter II, demonstrating how Dao, the great law, makes things equal. Chapters IV, XI, XIII, and XXII add much to our understanding of the essence of speech. The philosopher also dwells on the significance of silence. In Chapter XXVII the author demonstrates that properly organized speech of the wise serves the great purpose of human education and enlightening. Speech is the major instrument of human communication and cognition, must be used properly.

Speech is very powerful. With its help, humans can narrate events, and draw pictures so vivid and great that listeners are astonished. With th...
10 Pages(2500 words)Term Paper

Mrs. Doubtfire: Analysis of the Film Using Bergsons Essay on Laughter

The story of the movie is rather unusual however it has been well accepted by the public in all countries globally; the success of the film can lead to the development of specific assumptions regarding the quality of comedies produced the last years as well as the characteristics of successful comedies (based on the elements of the film that have been considered as the most successful regarding the laughter caused to the audience). 


In order to understand the potential use of the work of Bergson to the explanation of the sense of ‘comic’ as developed through the particular book, it is necessary to refer primarily to the general characteristics of ‘comic’ as described by Bergson. The ab...
10 Pages(2500 words)Movie Review

The Genre of a Film

By deviating from the purported film genre through the incorporation of surprise elements that deviate from the said genre, the filmmaker can also introduce the element of the unexpected, the surprise twist that can boost the box office prospects of the film. The presentation of elements of different genres requires the audience to reassess the perceptions with which it approaches a film of a particular genre and modifies its interpretation of the text and images of the film.

The genre attributed to a film may play a significant role in the manner in which the text of the film is interpreted. According to James Naremore, “the name of the genre…..functions in much the same way as the name of the author.&rdqu...
12 Pages(3000 words)Term Paper

Analysis of the Book of Job

The job was a man of God who possessed insurmountable faith, so much so that God systematically relinquished from Job all that is good and important, to render a more cleansed and righteous Job with renewed faith. Job discusses many plague-like incidents that all seemed to happen to Job and his family. One of the most powerfully portrayed issues in Job was divine justice.

In the case of the severity of Job’s trials, it is beyond the term understatement to say that what Job went through simply for a test, was supreme overkill. The stipulation placed by God was that he was to be turned over to Satan but just not killed. It seems that God should already know if Job is truly a faithful follower as opposed to putting h...
6 Pages(1500 words)Book Report/Review

Its a Wonderful Life and The Third Man: Messages in Film

The film It’s a Wonderful Life is 1946, World War II, a film by director Frank Capra, starring a beloved American actor, Jimmy Stewart. The film is intended to inspire hope, which might have been sorely lacking in World War II America. The themes of hope, faith, and goodwill are prevalent. Faith is prominent, in that, an angel is sent to guide an earthly human, George Bailey, in his life during a time when the world around him seems to be falling apart. The film begins by establishing the fact that a heavenly hand is needed in the life of the main character, George Bailey (Gehring, Wes, 1988, 135). The segue then is to the young George Bailey, so that the angel, and the audience, can understand who George Bailey is as an adu...
11 Pages(2750 words)Movie Review

Analyzing Film To Kill a Mockingbird

...To Kill a Mockingbird To Kill a Mockingbird To Kill a Mockingbird is a feature film directed by Robert Mulligan. Based on the award-winning novel by Harper Lee, the film was released 2 years after the book in 1962 and made a sensation. It is still considered to be one of the best films in history as it manages to keep spectators engaged even though it is not rich in special effects or posh things. This black and white film is exceptional due to the quality of performance, directors work, editing and superb score. This essay will analyze the film in detail focusing on its relevant elements in order to prove that this film can easily compete with modern blockbusters because it is a masterpiece of cinematography. The cast of the film...
8 Pages(2000 words)Scholarship Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Film First Before Book for FREE!

Contact Us