'English Criminal law fails to deal with the drug supplier whose client dies after voluntarily self-injecting or ingesting in a consistent and principled manner Discuss - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The deaths of people from drug use and misuse have led to a long debate on the liability of the drug supplier in the death of the deceased. This debate has been made…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.1% of users find it useful
English Criminal law fails to deal with the drug supplier whose client dies after voluntarily self-injecting or ingesting in a consistent and principled manner Discuss
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample
"'English Criminal law fails to deal with the drug supplier whose client dies after voluntarily self-injecting or ingesting in a consistent and principled manner Discuss"

Download file to see previous pages This is a question English criminal law seems to provide us with inconsistent answers. In some cases such as R v. Kennedy2this has been considered as unlawful act manslaughter, while in other cases, such as R v. Evans3this hasbeen considered as gross negligence manslaughter. It is however rare to have drug supplier charged with murder. According to Mitchel4, it is not possible to charge a drug supplier with murder because their actions do have the mensrea(guilty mind) needed to prove murder. The English criminal law are however clear on that the supply of drugs is unlawful act. The unlawfulness of supplying drugs is specified in the Misuse of Drugs Act 1971. The Misuse of Drugs Act 1971 specifies that it is an offence to be in possession of controlled drugs5; to have the controlled drugs with intention to supply it6; supplying unlawful drug7; and allowing your premise to be used for supplying drugs.8 Therefore, if someone dies from the drug supplier’s unlawful act of supplying drug, the drug supplier should be charged with unlawful act manslaughter.
The criminal law on unlawful manslaughter or constructive manslaughter, requires sufficient prove of unintentionallinkbetween the supplier’s act and the death of the client for the supplier to be held liable9. Therefore, for the supplier to be held liable of manslaughter, it must be proved that the death of the drug user is attributed to the actions of the supplier10. The court needs to determine that were it not for the drug supplier’s act, the deceased could not have died (factual causation). Further to that, the court needs to prove that the act of the supplier was sufficiently significant in the death of the user(legal causation).English courts have failed to apply the principle of causation in a consistent and principled manner in most cases involving involuntary manslaughter11. It seems that, at ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“'English Criminal law fails to deal with the drug supplier whose Essay”, n.d.)
'English Criminal law fails to deal with the drug supplier whose Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1679044-english-criminal-law-fails-to-deal-with-the-drug-supplier-whose-client-dies-after-voluntarily-self-injecting-or-ingesting-in-a-consistent-and-principled-manner-discuss
('English Criminal Law Fails to Deal With the Drug Supplier Whose Essay)
'English Criminal Law Fails to Deal With the Drug Supplier Whose Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1679044-english-criminal-law-fails-to-deal-with-the-drug-supplier-whose-client-dies-after-voluntarily-self-injecting-or-ingesting-in-a-consistent-and-principled-manner-discuss.
“'English Criminal Law Fails to Deal With the Drug Supplier Whose Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1679044-english-criminal-law-fails-to-deal-with-the-drug-supplier-whose-client-dies-after-voluntarily-self-injecting-or-ingesting-in-a-consistent-and-principled-manner-discuss.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
CHECK THESE SAMPLES - THEY ALSO FIT YOUR TOPIC
Criminal Law
...The trial judge had directed the jury with the statement that provocation could be described as an act or sequence of acts that the deceased had done to the accused, which would have made any reasonable person to undergo a sudden and temporary loss of self – control. At the time of assessing the presence or otherwise of provocation, the law takes cognisance of the following features; first, whether there had been sufficient time for the passion to reduce and reason to regain control; second, whether the retaliation against the provocation was reasonable and commensurate to the latter.27 Two major difficulties came to the fore with the decision in R v Duffy. The first of these was whether it was correct...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay
Criminal law
...was the narrowing of the wind- pipe where the tracheotomy tube was inserted. Such a condition is rare, but not an unknown complication arising out of tracheotomy. P had complained of further breathing difficulty and suffered a chest infection after the tracheotomy. The death was caused by the negligence of the hospital staff failing to diagnose and treat P’s respiratory condition. Therefore, we find that John only provided the setting for the death and the “but for” rule would not apply as the doctor’s negligence broke the chain of causation thus causing the death of Tim. This rendered the contribution of John insignificant. The doctor is therefore liable out of his negligence for manslaughter....
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay
Criminal justice/ criminal law
...and Tokyo Tribunal were both of ad hoc nature.2 It was during the Genocide Convention of the United Nations that the idea of a permanent international criminal tribunal took shape. Draft statutes were consequently prepared by the International Law Commission (ILC), but these efforts were hampered by the difficulty in coming to an accord on how to define aggression. In 1989, Trinidad and Tobago and several other Caribbean and Latin American states and NGOs petitioned for the continuation towards efforts to establish an international criminal tribunal to try drug trafficking cases. In the 1990s, events in Eastern Europe and Africa necessitated the establishment of ad hoc...
16 Pages(4000 words)Essay
Criminal Law
...concerned that Tony might be violent towards them. Question (a) : One night Claire wakes up because she can hear what she thinks is Tony forcing her eldest daughter to have sex with him. She is too scared to do anything immediately. Much later when Tony is asleep Claire goes to the kitchen finds a knife walks into the bedroom and stabs Tony 10 times. Tony dies instantly and Claire then calls the police. The criminal liability of Claire raising all the possible defences can be described as follows: The criminal liability of Claire in the present case is getting involved in murder of her husband. The criminal law always protects the interests of the...
9 Pages(2250 words)Assignment
Criminal Law / Civil Law
..., the federal government of the United States filed the suit. Dr. Stokes (defendant) had a case in which the government (United States of America) was the plaintiff. As such, Dr. Stokes’s case is a criminal case and is dealt with under criminal law. After a jury trial in which Boggs More and Gibson were the circuit judges, Dr. Robert W. Stokes was charged with thirty –one counts of frauds in health care. Actual Charges Filed Against Him Dr. Robert W. Stokes, a licensed and board-certified dermatologist who was operating in Grand Rapids, Michigan, was charged with thirty –one counts of frauds in health care. The federal agents initiated investigative audit Stokes billing practices in 2001into to determine if he was billing Medicare... ?...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Letter to Law Client
...benefits. For instance, some sole proprietors are required to pay the federal tax rate and a self-employment tax, meaning you are being taxed twice; corporations are never allowed to do this. In response to your questions regarding Bubba, there are a few causes for concern here, but a few issues that may still keep you in the clear. First, Bubba is not a regular employee; as you stated, he came down to help out with some extra work. Second, you did not tell Bubba to do this; you gave him different directions. If Bubba is willing to admit to this, then you may safe and the responsibility may fall on him. However, the medical bills are truly an issue-if one person injures another person it is generally required that...
3 Pages(750 words)Personal Statement
Criminal Justice/ Criminal Law
...Criminal Justice/ Criminal Law: Burden of Proof Criminal Justice/ Criminal Law: Burden of Proof Many are the times when peoplehave watched movies and films which dwell on criminal investigations and legal drama. In these films, the different aspects that are required for the prosecution, arraignment in court as well as sentencing of a person are brought forth. But some of the terms that are used in these films are never paid attention to and many just follow the plot. Terms such as criminal evidence, burden of proof, and innocent until proven guilty and beyond any reasonable doubt are seen as part of the...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper
English criminal law fails to deal with the drug supplier whose client dies after voluntarily self injecting or ingesting in a consistent and principled manner
...of death of the users, then a legal causation arises. This material aims at investigating situations when the suppliers of controlled drugs may be held reliable for deaths of users who misuse the drugs. This follows the realization that the English criminal law fails to deal with the drug supplier whose client dies after voluntarily self-injecting or ingesting in the drugs in a consistent and...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay
Principled Negotiation
...Principled Negotiation School The craft of principled negotiation can become a significant communicational tool not only for social workers but for people who simply work with other people. As far as principled negotiation is based on search of compromise between different parties that want to get a benefit from a deal, the most difficult thing in the negotiation is to find the universal solution for a problem that would satisfy all the parties. Dealing with cultural diverse conflict situation it is harder to find the approach to people from other cultures if there is not enough of information about specific features of the cultures. Thus, looking for a...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment
Consistent and inconsistent of client centered theory
...the client has been able to express her motivating attitudes and deep feelings regarding the issue. The client has also been able to explore the attitudes that she possesses and become more aware of why she had reacted in the way that she did in a clear and concise manner. The views that she had previously denied or tried to hide are now more apparent, and thus she can deal with them in a more agreeable manner. After the conscious realization of why she felt fearful and afraid, the client accepts herself more and more completely. Again the client is at liberty to verbalize the feelings or not and, in...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Let us find you another Essay on topic 'English Criminal law fails to deal with the drug supplier whose client dies after voluntarily self-injecting or ingesting in a consistent and principled manner Discuss for FREE!
Contact Us