Free

The Rape Charge Filed by the Complainant - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The case at bar concerns the rape charge filed by the complainant who is sixteen years old and the niece of the accused, who is 42 years old. The complainant said she was assaulted at least two times over a period of three days while the niece was staying at her uncle's house for a temporary period…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.7% of users find it useful
The Rape Charge Filed by the Complainant
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Rape Charge Filed by the Complainant"

CANADIAN CASE STUDY
R. v. W.(D.), [1991] 1 SCR 742
The case at bar concerns the rape charge filed by the complainant who is sixteen years old and the niece of the accused, who is 42 years old. The complainant said she was assaulted at least two times over a period of three days while the niece was staying at her uncle's house for a temporary period as she is a school dropout, a runaway and had been thrown out of her friends' homes several times already. She did not file a complaint the first time it happened and she even went back to her uncle's house, ostensibly to retrieve back her purse which she had left behind. It is the onus of the Crown to prove a guilt that erases reasonable doubt to overcome the presumption of innocence that should exceed the evidentiary threshold (Fisher, 2011, p. 811). It was only after the second assault that she filed the rape complaint maybe out of spite of her uncle or it might be that she finally mustered enough courage to come out in the open to file the charge. A number of aspects in the case R. v. W. (1991) stand out, of which three are unusual.
Firstly, the case is essentially that of which side to believe because of the lack of usual corroborating testimonies from other witnesses and this case becomes a case of his word pitted against hers. In other words, this case hinges on credibility as to which side seems to be the more truthful, the complainant or the defendant. For the jury, as sole judges, it all boils down to exercising their best judgment based on common sense and any prior everyday experiences as it relates to this particular case. In this regard, it is not quite unusual for rape victims not to file any charges immediately after an incident for various reasons, such as fear of retribution or shame. It is therefore quite understandable why she decided to file a complaint only after a second assault took place. Some victims even take weeks or months before finally deciding to file a complaint, a considerable lapse of time when essential forensic evidence of a crime may have disappeared.

Secondly, it is quite unusual for the trial judge to warn the jury not to start deliberating yet as there might be some corrections pertaining to the first charge filed, when it was agreed by both parties to be essentially correct and fair (error free). What is even more unusual was a short time that elapsed between the main charge and the re-charge, incontrovertible evidence or proof that the judge himself may have entertained some doubts as to the correctness of the first charge and making the re-charge almost as a second thought or an afterthought to rectify something else. This action of the judge put the defendant at a distinct disadvantage as it created doubts on the mind of the jurors as to what constitutes reasonable doubt, on whether to acquit or not. His additional instructions created more confusion instead of clearing things up (Shapiro, 1993, p. 12).
Thirdly and lastly, the exclusion of the third alternative, in which there could possibly be still some reasonable doubt on the evidence presented by the accused in his own defense, had railroaded the case resulting in a guilty verdict by the jury; the way the trial judge made his instructions reduced the case into an either/or proposition. Choosing only between two kinds of options instead of three alternatives had rendered the principle of reasonable doubt useless. An indication of the dilemma is the Supreme Court decision on the appeal was not even a unanimous decision but a divided verdict due to ambiguity (Matthews, 1986, p. 296).
The adage is that it is always better to acquit the guilty than convict the innocent and so this legal principle should be applied in this case because credibility was the core issue and there was reasonable doubt on the guilt of the accused. It is the essence of justice that it be rendered as to leave no reasonable doubt to avoid wrongful convictions (Gould, 2008, p. 132). In cases like these, it is required that the bar of justice be set much higher to avoid a miscarriage of justice.
















References
Fisher, T. (2011, Fall). Constitutionalism and the criminal law: Rethinking criminal trial bifurcation. Abstract. University of Toronto Law Journal, 61(4), 811-843.
Gould, J. B. (2008). The innocence commission: Preventing wrongful convictions and restoring the criminal justice system. New York, NY, USA: New York University Press.
Matthews, A. S. (1986). Freedom, state security and the rule of law: Dilemmas of the apartheid society. Berkeley, CA, USA: University of California Press.
R. v. W.(D.), [1991] 1 SCR 742.
Shapiro, B. J. (1993). Beyond reasonable doubt and probable cause: Historical Perspectives on the Anglo-American law of evidence. Berkeley, CA, USA: University of California Press. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Rape Charge Filed by the Complainant Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
The Rape Charge Filed by the Complainant Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1599290-canadian-case-study-provide-critical-analysis-for-three-aspects-of-the-event-either-positive-or-negative
(The Rape Charge Filed by the Complainant Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
The Rape Charge Filed by the Complainant Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1599290-canadian-case-study-provide-critical-analysis-for-three-aspects-of-the-event-either-positive-or-negative.
“The Rape Charge Filed by the Complainant Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1599290-canadian-case-study-provide-critical-analysis-for-three-aspects-of-the-event-either-positive-or-negative.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Rape Charge Filed by the Complainant

The Relevance of Victim's Volunary to a Charge of Rape

......However where the complainant has voluntarily consumed even substantial quantities of alcohol, but nevertheless remains capable of choosing whether or not to have intercourse, and in drink agrees to do so, this would not be rape.7 Eventually, the charge against Bree was dismissed, but such was the furor over the issue that the issue of intoxication became one of the foremost concerns in legal and academic discourses on rape and consent. IV. Analysing the Two Sides of the Issue Perhaps best articulating the conundrum is Schulhofer (1998: 14-15) in his book entitled Unwanted Sex: The Culture of Intimidation and the Failure of the Law: “‘The law’s willingness to find...
15 Pages(3750 words)Essay

Date Rape

...?Running Head: Rape Rape [Institute’s Rape METHODOLOGY Aims & Objectives The research should aim to collect a sufficient and relevant amount of data concerning date rape, within the available resources. This data should pertain to one main factor: the frequency of occurrence in different areas and in different socio-economic groups in society. This will bring the researchers one large step closer to determining which factors are correlated with the occurrence of date rape incidents. This is an important aim for the researchers to focus on, as it will help them keep the acquisition of information limited to valid and relevant data. Another aim of the research should be to ensure that the data collected is of high validity as well... will be...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Criminal justice process for a felony criminal charge filed in a state court

...?Running head: CRIMINAL JUSTICE PROCESS FOR A FELONY CRIMINAL CHARGE FILED IN A COURT Criminal Justice Process for a Felony Criminal Charge Filed in a State Court Insert Name Insert Course Title Insert Instructor’s Name July 2011 Criminal justice process for a felony criminal charge filed in a state court Introduction Crime refers to a wrongful act against an individual or society, which is proclaimed by the law, and if committed under certain circumstances, it is punishable by the society. Hence, any act becomes a crime only when the act or action meets the legalities that describe it as such. The concept of crime and criminality is not...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Date Rape

...? Persuasive Essay: Rape and the Need for Prevention Robert Lincoln Kaplan Persuasive Essay: Rape and the Need for Prevention\ Introduction “The man Naomi Hampson lived with was a brutal trophy rapist who was knocking her out before taking pictures as he sexually assaulted her” (Dorman, 2012). Hampson narrates, “the officers said they believed Rob used a drug to sedate me…I felt completely violated – and so stupid” (Dorman, 2012). Hampson further adds, “I hate him for what he did to me – I doubt he ever loved me” (Dorman, 2012). Date rape can occur to any two individuals who know each other or who have consented to a social engagement. While majority of date rape victims...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Floating charge

...FLOATING CHARGE Question: Marina and Mortimer are the sole shareholders and directors of Imitation Furs Ltd. In order to expand their business they applied for a loan from Easy Bank Plc. Easy Bank Plc agreed to grant a loan of ' 500,000 to Imitation Furs Ltd, to be secured by a floating charge over the company's stock in trade. The charge was created on the 1st of July 2007. However, in February 2008 it was discovered that the company's solicitor had failed to register the charge. In April 2008 Marina and Mortimer applied for a further loan of ' 50,000 from Finance Co Ltd. Finance Co Ltd granted the loan to Imitation Furs Ltd to be secured by a floating charge over Imitation Furs Ltd's undertaking. A search at Company's House had... not...
15 Pages(3750 words)Case Study

Rape Myths and Rape Prevention

...Gender Role Conditioning Gender role conditioning might contribute to rape myths where men are conditioned to think that they are the dominant sex and that females are to submit to their will. The "macho" mentality, that fortunately is arguably subsiding as women gain more clout and respect in professional and other circles, could perpetuate the dangerous notion that men are to get their way regardless of the preferences of women. Translated into scenarios involving the bedroom, it could easily breed an atmosphere in which rape is considered acceptable. To be sure, it is the responsibility of society, through parenting and education, to raise young men and women to understand that the genders are equal...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Rape

...Ways in Which Rape Effects Women The act of rape is perhaps one of the most traumatic events that can happen to an individual. Rape is an act of power not an act of sex, “Rape is sexual intercourse that is performed without consent and done mainly by force or deception”(.http://www.med.umich.edu/1libr/wha/wha_rape_crs.htm). Its effects are on a physical, mental and emotional level. The purpose of this essay is to explore the ways in which rape does affect individuals. Rape does not always include violence, but is often the result of intense anger or hatred towards the individual being raped. It is essentially intended to humiliate, demean and harm the victim. In looking at physical results of rape, the victim is often... but not...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Different type of (Rape)(Date rape)(statutory rape) (Acquaintance rape)(Dometic rape

...Types of rape Types of Rape Rape is a social evil which has a long history. Holy Bible says that after the creation of first human Adam, God has created Eve in order to avoid Adam’s loneliness. The attraction between males and females started from there and it continues even now. This attraction is necessary for the sexual activities between males and females which is necessary for the reproduction and enjoyment purpose. Genetically, human is a pleasure seeking animal. So, he uses sex more for enjoyment purposes rather than reproduction purposes. In most of the sex activities, males take the initiative. In order to have sex with the partner, a male uses many tactics. When his attempt for sex fails, he may try to rape his partner... ....
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Date Rape and Date Rape Drugs

...has many violations to charge the perpetrator such as kidnapping, breaking and entering, restraining a victim among others(Curtis, 1997). However in date rape cases, the perpetrator be charged with these criminal offenses. The perpetrator is a trusted party of the victim. His presence in the victim’s property is by mutual consent. The sexual act is usually not the center of the case, but the consent. Consent can only be understood by other parties through the victim’s communication or by an observable indicator in the victim’s actions, deeds, or words. Therefore, the case is based on credibility and “who did what” and “who said what”. The prosecution builds its case in showing the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Criminal justice process for a felony criminal charge filed in a state court

...the parties involved as discussed in the essay below. Investigation Investigation is the preliminary stage in the process. After the victim of a felony files a charge at a state court, the police begin carrying out an extensive investigation with the view to constructing a case. The process of investigation may always require search warrants coupled with warrants of arrest whenever necessary (Porto, 2009). The police investigate the nature of the felony and interview witnesses. This way, they gather adequate evidence and record eyewitness accounts of the crime. Evidence and witnesses are vital in proving the guilt of a suspect. While carrying out the investigations, the police must uphold the rights of...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The Rape Charge Filed by the Complainant for FREE!

Contact Us