StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

European Union Law: Council Directive 199X/309 on Defective Medicinal Products - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
"European Union Law: Council Directive 199X/309 on Defective Medicinal Products" paper focuses on a Directive imposed liability on a manufacturer of a medicinal product that causes injury or illness and there is no necessity to establish negligence. Compensation has to provide for the pain of wages…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96% of users find it useful
European Union Law: Council Directive 199X/309 on Defective Medicinal Products
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "European Union Law: Council Directive 199X/309 on Defective Medicinal Products"

European Union Law The United Kingdom implemented Council Directive 199X/309 on Defective Medicinal Products (the “Directive”) as the Defective Medicinal Products Act 2004 (“the Act”), with effect from 1st March 2004. It should have been implemented by the 31st December 2003. This Directive imposed a liability on a manufacturer of a medicinal product (the “Product”) that causes injury or illness and there is no necessity to establish negligence. Compensation has to provide for pain, suffering and loss of wages past, present and future. Moreover, it is the duty of the manufacturer to establish that the product did not cause the injury or illness. However, the Act excluded liability for loss of wages and required the victim to establish the liability of the manufacturer. The Directive and the Act were to replace the existing national laws of negligence in relation to the Product. In May 2004, Byrd was prescribed a Product, manufactured by Omnia Pharma PLC (“Omnia”) a company registered in England, for relieving stress. After using for two weeks, Byrd developed suppurating psoriasis as a side effect of this product. This led to frequent absence from work and the resultant dismissal from service. Byrd unsuccessfully attempted suicide due to these developments. The Product continues to be covered by UK patents with the result that Omnia has a monopoly on sales of the Product in the UK. 1 A The doctrine of direct effect, which is applicable to individuals as well as institutions, permits individuals to file a case in national courts if an EU Directive is incorrectly implemented by that Member State. Rights under direct effect have to be honoured without any reference to domestic law. As such the doctrine of direct effect is an intrinsic part of the notion of the supremacy of European Law and no discretion is permitted to the Member States or Community institutions. Regulations always have direct effect but Directives obtain direct effect only on the basis of the merits of each case (direct effect , 2006). The Community law provisions require Member States to compensate any loss caused to individuals due to the non – implementation of a Directive. In the case of Francovich and Others v Italy, the ECJ made it clear that in order to make a Member State liable for the damages caused to an individual as a result of non – implementation of a Directive, three conditions must be fulfilled. First, the underlying objective of the Directive is to provide rights to individuals; second, there should be a description of such rights and their scope must be incorporated in the Directive and third, the damage caused should be due to the failure of the state to implement the Directive (Faccini Dori v Recreb Srl). In Duke v. GEC Reliance, the plaintiff, Mrs. Duke, could not invoke the Equal Treatment Directive since her employer was a private individual (Duke v GEC Reliance Ltd). Similarly, in Paola Faccini Dori v. Recreb srl, the Italian Government failed to implement a Directive that bestowed customers with the right to cancel contracts that were negotiated outside the business premises. Dori who had entered into a contract at a railway station could not seek the right of cancellation under the Directive. The Court had refused to apply the notion of direct effect to individual relationships (Faccini Dori v Recreb Srl). Eventually, the ECJ through its decisions made it clear that there were different rights provided to state employees and private employees. It also held that if the Member States had clearly implemented the Directive in their national laws there would be no possibility for such frustrating situations to transpire, which placed the national courts in an embarrassing position. Therefore, in our problem, the Directive is not directly effective against Omnia, since it is a non ­ – governmental organization. 2 A It is mandatory for the Member States to implement the treaty principles and the Union’s legislation and the EU requires national governments of the Member States to adopt and implement the European law in their nations appropriately. If the Member States fail to carry out this task, then the EU will approach the ECJ to take appropriate action against that Member State. As such the Commission refers nearly eighty cases to the ECJ per annum on an average. Government agencies, private or public utilities and firms have to apply EU law provisions at national level (Implementation, 2000). Insufficient power to endorse punitive action by the ECJ and lack of enforcing machinery for its decisions has been the drawback of the earlier EC legislation. The introduction of changes to the preliminary ruling system made it possible to overcome this problem by forcing the national courts to enforce ECJ jurisprudence. The Francovich v Italy case established that the EU law had the right to award damages for breach of the European Union law. In that case, the ECJ had ruled that national courts could require the national governments to pay damages to individuals if the government failed to implement EC Directives in an appropriate manner. The ECJ is empowered to impose fines on Member States in cases of violations and breaches of EU law filed by the Commission or other Member States. Thus, violating the European law attracts penalties and the ECJ became more effective in implementing the EC law (European Court of Justice (ECJ), 2000). Consequently, if the Directives are not properly implemented by the Member States, the national courts could compel the national governments to pay damages to the applicants. This was the judgement given by the ECJ in Francovich v. Italy. 3 A Byrd can rely on the indirect effect against the manufacturer Omnia Pharma PLC, since he cannot take action against the same under the direct effect due to the fact that it was a non – governmental organization. Byrd can sue the company for having lost his job and he can also claim damages for the psychological trauma experienced by him. The doctrine of indirect effect enhances the effectiveness of non – implemented or incorrectly implemented directives, which lack direct effect as per the horizontal limitation. This doctrine has come into existence through Von Colson. The ECJ had held in Von Colson that national courts were required to interpret their law with compliance to the wording and purpose of the directive. In other words they have to interpret the directive duly giving it some effect in spite of the absence of proper domestic implementation (Case 14/83 Von Colson and Kamann v Land Nordrhein-Westfalen). In 1991, the ECJ established the Community law’s general principle with regard to the state liability for damages which resulted due to the breach of its obligations, in the famous Francovich case. The breach involved in this case was the non – implementation of a Directive. The ECJ referred to the general principles of the Treaty and the duty of the ECJ which require it to ensure that the law was observed in the interpretation and application of Article 220 (1) EC (Francovich and Bonifaci & others v. Italy ). 4A In the famous Francovich case, the ECJ found the principle of Member State liability in damages to be inherent in the system of the Treaty and necessary to guarantee the full effect of its provisions. The Court also referred to the general principle of Member State loyalty laid down in Art 10 (1) EC Treaty. In our present problem, the UK Government had not implemented the Directive, within the stipulated time. Moreover, the provisions of the act were not in accordance with what had been specified by the Directive. As per the ruling in Francovich, Byrd can sue the UK Government for the loss caused to him due to the improper implementation of the Directive. Byrd can succeed in a claim for damages against the UK Government relying on the Francovich principle. The European integration process was very active in the early 1980s. It was essential to establish common interest of the EU treaty obligations, legislations and common policies. This process of adopting the common legislation and other requirements reflected the core political interests of Member States and resulted in the emergence of a single market programme. The expansion of the scope of the EU law within the territory of the EU was the consequence of the establishment of various EU institutions. Finally, the European Court of Justice became a major voice in the EU. The unequal sharing of resources among Member States and the differences in national legislations has resulted in some very important ECJ judgments. Moreover, some of these decisions have resulted in repealing national sovereignty (Implementation, 2000). References 1. Case 14/83 Von Colson and Kamann v Land Nordrhein-Westfalen, [1984] ECR 1891. 2. direct effect . (2006). Retrieved May 18, 2007, from In Collins Dictionary of Law: http://www.xreferplus.com/entry/5979635 3. Duke v GEC Reliance Ltd, [1988] AC 618. 4. European Court of Justice (ECJ). (2000). Retrieved May 18, 2007, from In Encyclopedia of the European Union: http://www.xreferplus.com/entry/864566 5. Faccini Dori v Recreb Srl, Case C-91/92 [1994] ECR I-3325. 6. Francovich and Bonifaci & others v. Italy , Case C-6. and C-9/90 [1991] ECR I-5357. 7. Implementation. (2000). Retrieved May 18, 2007, from In Encyclopedia of the European Union: http://www.xreferplus.com/entry/864694 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“European Union Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1540883-european-union-law-assignment-attached
(European Union Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1540883-european-union-law-assignment-attached.
“European Union Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1540883-european-union-law-assignment-attached.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF European Union Law: Council Directive 199X/309 on Defective Medicinal Products

Judicial politics of the EU Court of Justice

The european union (EU) which came into existence on 25th of March, 1957 holds its aim towards promotion of economic activities with a balanced and continuous expansion of activities and accelerated enhancement of standard of living and to build stronger relationship between the states that belong to the union.... council.... In the case, it was proved that the protection of the Parliament under the system is not effective enough as in the case the Commission displayed the shortcomings by taking the council's side with respect to the selection of the appropriate legal base for the regulation in concern....
18 Pages (4500 words) Coursework

Increasing the Duration of Copyright in Literary Works in the United Kingdom

ver the years, the UK has faced several challenges related to copyright owing to the number of sometimes contradictory directives by other european countries as well as international proposals.... The paper "Increasing the Duration of Copyright in Literary Works in the United Kingdom" states that not even the owner of the works stands to gain a particularly high benefit concomitant with the extra 20 years that have been added to the protection period....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

Research Studies in Managment

An important aspect of the political, economic and social programmes of the member states of the european union is full The effects of chronological age - defined in social terms in relation to an individual's chosen or forced behaviour on the grounds of age – has been an issue of political, economic and social relevance since the implementation of the First Action Programme on Ageing, and culminates provisionally with the European Employment Directive.... utside the european union, legislation against age discrimination is in place for example in the United States (Age Discrimination in Employment Act 1967), Canada (legislation in the 1960s), New Zealand (1993 Human Rights Act includes age discrimination), Australia (introduced in 1991-96), and South Africa ...
24 Pages (6000 words) Essay

The Law Regarding the Binding Nature of Directives

A directive has been defined as a legislative act of the european union that places a requirement on member states to achieve a particular result.... "The Law Regarding the Binding Nature of Directives" paper examines the implementation of the directive and discusses whether there has been any breach by the company.... To be able to decide whether a directive is binding it is necessary to understand what a directive is.... A directive will not dictate the means of achieving this and it is therefore open to interpretation....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Commercial Activity: Powers of European Community

The principle of mutual recognition was extensively applied in practice using a series of legal formalities in order to avoid the development of discrimination across the european union.... The basis for the development of the european union was set in practice in 1951 through the creation of the European Coal and Steel Community (ECSC) by the above states; ECSC was established for a specific period of time (for 50 years), i.... On the other hand, the targets set by the european union were also differentiated....
28 Pages (7000 words) Essay

Breach of EU Directive

This directive specified the maximum amount of nibline that could be used in food products.... The council of the EU adopted a directive 2004/222 in October 2004.... In particular, article 4 of this directive had specified that the amount of nibline that could be added to carrot juice was not to exceed 3 mg per litre.... Breach of EU directive ... much harried and desperate Grant made considerable study into the circumstances responsible for her debilitating condition, and discovered that the UK government had failed to implement directive 2004/222....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Smoke Free Work Place and Public Place

To resolve this issue, the courts of law will interpret the laws.... House of Lords Committee on the Constitutional Reform Bill, written evidence from the Secretary of State for Constitutional Affairs and Lord Chancellor 14(2004) stated that the rule of law is the focus of democracy in the UK as well as the shared values of EU member states.... For, the rule of law creates an atmosphere of transparency, fairness, and predictability in the performance of business and contracts as well as personal safety, protection of the individual and property....
9 Pages (2250 words) Term Paper

Concept of Transparency in EU Public Procurement Law: Implications for Legal Reform in Kuwait

he European Procurement Directives are adopted as the primary source for legislation in the countries of the european union, which regulate the purchasing of goods, supplies, and services by national, regional, and local public bodies.... "Concept of Transparency in EU Public Procurement law: Implications for Legal Reform in Kuwait" paper provides guidance to the Kuwaiti legislator when reforming the law for the benefit of the State Treasury, by enhancing the trust of the Public and tenderers in the government procurement procedures....
341 Pages (85250 words) Thesis
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us