StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Comment on Attorney General of Belize v Belize Telecom Ltd - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
From the paper "Comment on Attorney General of Belize v Belize Telecom Ltd " it is clear that the Government-owned shares in Belize, but were gradually sealed off when in 1989, Belize privatized its telecom network and established Belize Telecommunications Limited, which is a corporation…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.1% of users find it useful
Comment on Attorney General of Belize v Belize Telecom Ltd
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Comment on Attorney General of Belize v Belize Telecom Ltd"

Belize privatized its telecom network in 1989. Under the privatization, the government was to gradually seal off its shares and, in the process, retained a special share (Redfem, 2004). According to the company’s constitution, 8 directors would be appointed as per the shareholding in the following manner:
• The special shareholder can appoint 2 of the 8 directors. In this case, the government had a special share which entitled it to appoint two directors.
• Class “B” shareholders comprising private investors could appoint two directors.
• Class “C” shareholders could appoint four directors. The government also owned Class “C” shares.
• A further provision for the election directors was made, stating that if a special shareholder possessed over 37.5% of the share capital in total, it would appoint two of the 4 Class “C” directors.
The government in 2003 completed the privatization process. A law was passed to this effect to enable the completion (Richardson, 2004).
In 2004, Belize Telecommunications bought the special share and the Class “C” shares from the government. To enable Belize Telecommunications to purchase the shares, the government changed its shares into a loan to enable Belize to finance the transaction. Since this was a loan from the government, it needed security from Belize. Belize gave the government a ‘pledge’ on the shares that it had just sold, i.e. the Class “C” shares, but not on the special share until the debt was repaid (Robertson, 2006).
In February 2005, Belize defaulted in the loan repayment and the government’s pledge under the loan agreement was enforced. The government now had more than 37.5% of the class “C” shares but without the special share. Belize now had less than 37.5% of shares. The main issue of the case is whether the directors subject to appointment by the special shareholder with over 37.5% of class “C” shares could be removed. In this instance, there was no shareholder who held both the special share and over 37.5% of class “C” shares.
Belize Telecommunications argued that the two directors were not removable whereas the Attorney General argued otherwise. The argument was that the articles of association regarding the appointment of directors should be made to provide that vacation of office by a director should happen if the shareholding specification that brought him there ceased existing. The Belize Supreme Court’s Chief Justice agreed with the government. With its 37.5% shareholding, the government should be given the power to dismiss the two directors and recruit new ones (Olivelle, 2005).
Analysis
Court Analysis. The Chief Justice in the Belize Supreme Court agreed with the Attorney General that the government may be allowed to remove the directors in question and appoint new ones. The Privy Council’s advice through Lord Hoffman came up with the principles of interpreting the company’s articles of association.
• The interpretation principles apply, whether it is an act of Parliament or a company contract.
• A search for the meaning of the documents should be done by the court, and the documents, in this case, are the contextual facts in mind and articles of association, and should consider their meaning to a reasonable person.
• In a hypothetical situation, it was not relevant, but it was critical to ask what implication and interpretation would be consistent with the constitution of the company.
Lord Hoffman agreed with the Chief Justice that the directors may be removed. Initially, Belize Telecommunications was privatized in order to balance the government’s interests and those of private investors. It was, therefore, not reasonable because there was no shareholder with both the special share and over 37.5% shareholding so that the incumbent directors cannot be removed (Olivelle, 2005).
Author’s Analysis
The Chief Justice’s ruling was in order. The fact that there was no existing shareholder with the special share and 37.5% ordinary shares was not enough given the interpretation and implication of the articles of association regarding the appointment of the two directors and the other facts. The events that occurred regarding the government loan and default of the same were unforeseen by the drafter of the articles of association. Lord Hoffman’s rationale of using the principles of interpretation of a company contract, with the relevant facts and the meaning conveyed to a reasonable person, holds. The Chief Justice was right in allowing the two directors in question to be removed. There was no provision on what should be done if there is no special shareholder with over 37.5% of ordinary shares as was the case. The scenario was unforeseen when the articles of association were being drafted (Olivelle, 2005).
Conclusion
The case dealt with the interpretation of the articles of association of Belize Telecommunications as regards the appointment of directors by the different classes of shareholders. In giving the opinion of the Privy Council, Lord Hoffman had to address the basis upon which a term can be implied in a contract in general terms. This case was a question of implication as a matter of deciding what the articles of association read against the relevant background that would be reasonably understood. 

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Case comment coursework Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1465380-case-comment-coursework
(Case Comment Coursework Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1465380-case-comment-coursework.
“Case Comment Coursework Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1465380-case-comment-coursework.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Comment on Attorney General of Belize v Belize Telecom Ltd

How HR Policies Enhance Employee Productivity

A preliminary survey conducted using interview method on 5 senior agers [2 from large manufacturing organization, 1 from small-medium size telecom organization, 1 each from small size finance and small size service organizations], revealed that the HR managers were involved with routine functions like administration, documentation, training and development and conflict management.... The main research included administering a questionnaire to fifty HR managers [20 from manufacturing with 15 large organizations and 5 Small-Medium; 10 from large telecom organization; 10 each from small finance and service organizations] from 15 organizations....
44 Pages (11000 words) Essay

Life Telecom Corporate Performance

Life telecom, unlike a typical Internet Service Provider, provides its users with a unique forum for communications and entertainment through: wireless internet, national and international telephony traffic and VAS end to end.... Life telecom is a real alternative.... Life telecom, unlike a typical Internet Service Provider, provides its users with a unique forum for communications and entertainment through: wireless internet, national and international telephony traffic and VAS end to end....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Attorney disciplinary board vs. Moothart

The author of the essay "attorney disciplinary board vs.... The attorney sexually harassed the first woman when he made crude sexual comments about her body.... Iowa Supreme Court attorney disciplinary board vs.... These interactions and relationships occurred between 20006 and 2011 and includes allegations of sexual relations, sexual harassment and conflicts of interests as a result of the relationship between the attorney and one of the victims....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Attorney General Alberto Gonzales: The Ethics Triangle

This paper "attorney general Alberto Gonzales: The Ethics Triangle" discusses attorney general Alberto Gonzales that has deviated from ethical behavior.... In this context, the current controversy surrounding United States attorney general, Alberto Gonzales, makes for an interesting case study.... The President appointed Gonzales the United States attorney general on 3 February 2005 (DOJ Web site).... Bush dates back to his three-year term as general Counsel to then-Governor Bush in Texas....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

The Hong Kong Telecom Industry

This discussion, The Hong Kong telecom Industry, outlines that Hong Kong has the most sophisticated, mature and competitive telecommunications markets in the world.... Hong Kong has been the leader in the telecommunication and has a strong market infrastructure.... .... ... ... As the paper outlines, the Office of Telecommunications Authority (OFTA) established in 1993 is the legislative body responsible for regulating the telecommunications industry in Hong Kong....
16 Pages (4000 words) Research Paper

Legal Position of the Cases

st April made by Hardnose ltd.... This study "Legal Position of the Cases" examines two particular cases regarding the application of business law.... The study firstly briefly outlines the facts and background of each case.... Furthermore, the writer would provide a legal analysis along with conclusive recommendations....
20 Pages (5000 words) Case Study

The Belize Barrier Reef

ne of the longest barrier reef systems in the Caribbean and the Atlantic Ocean is off the shores of belize.... This term paper "The belize Barrier Reef" focuses on the home to the teaming ecosystem which involves both land and water creatures.... This section in belize is the only 'true outer barrier system' along with the Mesoamerican barrier reef system which runs along the Mexican the Yucatán, belize, Guatemala, and Honduras....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper

Employment Rights with the Company

In contrast is the decision from the Employment Appeal Tribunal in the case Real Time Civil Engineering ltd v.... .... ... ... Question 1: Global PackagingWhile Aisha has spent her time with Global on fixed contracts, she has wandered dangerously close to acquiring what are known as “employment rights” with the company....
26 Pages (6500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us